222 episodes

Congratulations, you have discovered the greatest and only comedy true crime competition on the internet! Every week our hosts Karl and Vinnie go head-to-head and each make their nominations for the biggest creep in any given category. Then You the listener get to decide the points, and the loser spins the dreaded wheel of consequences. 

The Creep Off The Creep Off

    • True Crime
    • 5.0 • 1 Rating

Congratulations, you have discovered the greatest and only comedy true crime competition on the internet! Every week our hosts Karl and Vinnie go head-to-head and each make their nominations for the biggest creep in any given category. Then You the listener get to decide the points, and the loser spins the dreaded wheel of consequences. 

    A Clockwork Orange Balloon

    A Clockwork Orange Balloon

    In today's episode Karl & Vinnie make their nominations for creepiest gang and we welcome the winner of the results girl competition Danni: In our cop cam segment we watch our Monroe County District Attorney get pulled over for speeding : In the Scum Parade, we meet a teacher/fight promoter, an orange ballon fetishist and a former Major League Baseball player on his way to prisonThe score is currently Vinnie 3 - Karl 2, visit thecreepoff.com to vote and decide this week’s winnerGet your tickets to Hackamania in Las Vegas at Hackamania.com use promo code “Creep” and save 20%Check out the Scum Parade stories: 'Orange balloon' fetish weirdo banned from having them after sick act with decoration - Daily StarAlabama Woman Accused of Trying to Run Down Pedestrians, Assaults Nurse (frontpagedetectives.com)Indianapolis teacher allegedly recorded young students in 'fight club-style' brawls inside classroom: lawsuit (nypost.com)Former MLB player Dustan Mohr is sentenced to nine years in jail for multiple sex crimes against a 13-year-old girl he coached in softball | Daily Mail OnlineWant to support the show? Find us on Patreon, Supercast & Backed.by to get exclusive merch an extra bonus episode every week! Don’t forget you can leave us a voicemail at 585-371-8108

    • 1 hr 41 min
    Bukkake Séance

    Bukkake Séance

    In today's episode Karl & Vinnie make their nominations for creepiest Canadian: This weeks Cop Cam segment we watch a little snitch rat out his mother for meth: In the Scum Parade we meet a determined gas station robber,  a couple who found a hobby and a man who tried to buy himself out of a bestiality charge The score is currently Vinnie 2 - Karl 2, visit thecreepoff.com to vote and decide this week’s winnerCheck out the Scum Parade stories: Man Accused of Trying to Rob Convenience Store With Snake as Weapon (frontpagedetectives.com)Couple accused of creating secret videos of young girls in dressing room at The Woodlands Mall, Hurricane Harbor (click2houston.com)41-year-old man, Kwame Chelsea arrested for having sex with pregnant goat | Pulse GhanaPolice officer allegedly raped 13-month-old who suffered broken bones and severe bruising | Truecrimedaily.comWant to support the show? Find us on Patreon, Supercast & Backed.by to get exclusive merch an extra bonus episode every week! Don’t forget you can leave us a voicemail at 585-371-8108

    • 1 hr 30 min
    Bradley's World

    Bradley's World

    This week Karl & Vinnie celebrate 420 by nominating the creepiest stoner of all time: We begin the voting process for our "results girl competition": On Karl's Cop Cam we meet a guy named Bradley who has the holy spirit tased into him: In the Scum Parade we meet the worst safeway employee ever, an even worse son and a very hungry Spanish politician. Who will be the new results girl? | Patreon: The score is currently Vinnie 1 - Karl 2, visit thecreepoff.com to vote and decide this week’s winnerCheck out the Scum Parade stories: Okla. woman driving stolen Jeep allegedly claimed it was a birthday present from Waffle House customer | Truecrimedaily.comPa. man arrested after his mother is found 'fused to the bed sheets,' covered in feces and maggots | Truecrimedaily.comColorado Safeway employee allegedly masturbated and ejaculated on food items | Truecrimedaily.comGay Spanish Politician With Left-Wing Governing Party Resigns After Photos Circulate Showing Him Eating His Own Feces - The PublicaWant to support the show? Find us on Patreon, Supercast & Backed.by to get exclusive merch an extra bonus episode every week! Don’t forget you can leave us a voicemail anytime at 585-371-8108

    • 1 hr 23 min
    Supplies!

    Supplies!

    In today's episode Karl & Vinnie make their nominations for creepiest April Fool’s Joke and we meet our latest prospective results girl Nurse Beth: We are joined by a concerned parent, who showed us video his 12-year-old daughter took of their drama teacher playing the “Penis Game” with the class. You can watch the video for yourself here https://youtu.be/_wAQlZZlO5sThe score is currently Vinnie 0 - Karl 2, visit thecreepoff.com to vote and decide this week’s winnerCheck out the Scum Parade stories: Man arrested after family member finds child pornography on his laptop, BCSO says (ksat.com)Two women arrested after 'throwing acid over roofer' whose facial burns left him 'unrecognisable' | The Sun'Dead men can't sue': Man allegedly sets up live feed to watch his 'friend' be murdered (local12.com)Teacher, 29, drinks his own urine and bathes in it to help with grief - RSVP LiveWant to support the show? Find us on Patreon, Supercast & Backed.by to get exclusive merch an extra bonus episode every week! Don’t forget you can leave us a voicemail at 585-371-8108

    • 1 hr 27 min
    The Lincoln Project

    The Lincoln Project

    In today's episode Karl & Vinnie are back from Florida and the scum stories really piled up while they were away!The score is currently Vinnie 0 - Karl 2Check out the Scum Parade stories: Dead Body Was in Rochester, New York Water Supply for Nearly 1 Month (people.com)Mum, 35, banned from three care homes for 'bonking elderly residents' to film for X-rated content - Daily StarDuo Busted For Sex In Front Of Popeyes | The Smoking GunIowa: Wild mugshot goes viral as 'arsonist' cuffed after 'setting fire to stranger's porch - US News - News - Daily Express US (the-express.com)Pasco County Christian teacher accused of using AI to create erotic content from student yearbook photos (fox13news.com)Boy, 9, showed no emotion after strangling nine rabbits to death at petting zoo | World News | Metro NewsWoman shot herself in the leg to cover up boyfriend's murder (lawandcrime.com)Parents of Lacey Fletcher, Woman Who 'Melted' Into Maggot-Infested Couch, Sentenced (people.com)Want to support the show? Find us on Patreon, Supercast & Backed.by to get exclusive merch an extra bonus episode every week! Don’t forget you can leave us a voicemail at 585-371-8108

    • 1 hr 38 min
    Pop Rocks & Coke

    Pop Rocks & Coke

    in preparation for WATP live this weekend in Florida, Karl & Vinnie make their nominations for biggest Creep from Tampa Bay! We also meet Red-Head Meg our latest results girl contestant: In our Cop Cam segment we meet the drunkest man ever: In the Scum Parade we learn about a new law, meet the best/worst former cop and a very strict father. Florida Middle Schoolers Arrested for Allegedly Creating Deepfake Nudes of Classmates | WIREDErie County man accused of using a cattle prod to discipline his young children (cleveland19.com)Mississippi cop Michael Green forced detainee to lick up own urine off jail cell floor (nypost.com)Blaise Taylor, former Titans scout, charged in poisoning death of girlfriend, unborn child (wsmv.com)

    • 1 hr 16 min

Customer Reviews

5.0 out of 5
1 Rating

1 Rating

Vincent Geist ,

Pretty good

One of the hosts has the same name as me, so it's pretty good.
(No, but seriously, this is one of the few tolerable true crime shows. It's not obnoxious, and doesn't have drunk women with poor audio quality)

Top Podcasts In True Crime

The Boy in the Water
newsroom.co.nz
The Price of Paradise
Wondery
GUILT
Brevity Studios
The Mushroom Cook
True Crime Australia
Intrigue
BBC Radio 4
Casefile True Crime
Casefile Presents

You Might Also Like

Who Are These Socials?
Karl Hamburger
Who Are These Podcasts?
WhoAreThese.com
SubReddit Surfing
Sub Reddit Surfing
The Dick Show
Dick Masterson
The Biggest Problem in the Universe
Dick Masterson
The Blind Mike Project
Blind Mike