I love this podcast. It takes a case, sometimes a familiar one, and retells it with the help of someone experienced with legal proceedings by deconstructing and evaluating the events of the crime. The ads are tolerable because the volume is controlled which makes for excellent story telling.

Good show, but way too many ads for length of episodes

This was the best podcast 😭😭 please bring it back

I am obsessed with this podcast! So well produced and I have ever heard any of these stories before! So good. When can we get more!!!??

This podcast is not nearly as polished and professional as their Piketon Massacre podcast. Levels are all over the place—volume and quality of sound vary for virtually every speaker. Courtney has a pleasing voice, but she pops her p’s. This seems like a microphone issue, which is weird considering that this isn’t some randos recording in their mom’s basement. Jeff’s vocal fry is like…super annoying? When you take out the ads and the repetitive bits that every episode has, it’s probably only about 20-25 minutes of actual content. With the audio issues I have a hard time binging this pod and can really only get about three episodes in before I have to nope out, but it’s a decent filler pod for when I’m caught up on my favorites.

I’m addicted to true crime shows. This show is great! Unbelievable stories! Great hosts! Great guest speakers! I haven’t stop listening since I found it!

This is an easy listen with a quick summary of some of your fave true crime “love” stories. There are, as many say, way too many ads. Also, I love the women’s investigation facts and how they present them but I feel Jeff is out of place… he sounds almost unsure or as though he always speaks in a questioning tone? It would be a lot more enjoyable with just the female hosts.

I would love to listen to this podcast but cannot deal with the sound leveling issues anymore. The intros are great, then when the guests or experts speak the volume gets very low so I have to turn volume all the way up and suddenly the intro lady is back or a commercial and the sound is blasting and startling. I am positive the sound editor could fix this.

I truly love this group together and think they make a fantastic team. Please keep up the good work!

Sorry, maybe the show gets better later on, but you lost me in the first episode when you referenced and mispronounced “phenergan” as cold medicine. Overall poorly produced, sound like a bunch of friends gossiping over zoom.