65 episodes

Each episode, co-hosts Stephen & Joel take one real-life villain and one fictional villain, discuss their histories, crimes, motives, any connections they may have and decide whether they are redeemable or not with their trusty Bowler Hat Scale. Listener feedback encouraged and addressed on the show.

The Curly Mustache Podcas‪t‬ Stephen "The Roast" Rosenberg, Joel Mengel

    • Comedy
    • 4.9 • 21 Ratings

Each episode, co-hosts Stephen & Joel take one real-life villain and one fictional villain, discuss their histories, crimes, motives, any connections they may have and decide whether they are redeemable or not with their trusty Bowler Hat Scale. Listener feedback encouraged and addressed on the show.

    The Curly Mustache Podcast: Ep. 64 – Ronald Gene Simmons & Billy Lenz

    The Curly Mustache Podcast: Ep. 64 – Ronald Gene Simmons & Billy Lenz

    Hey everyone! Thanks for checking out the newest episode of The Curly Mustache Podcast. Each episode, we take one real-life villain and one fictional villain, discuss their histories, crimes, motives, any connections they may have, and cap off the episode with whether they can be redeemed with our trusty Bowler Hat Scale. This week, in … Continue reading "The Curly Mustache Podcast: Ep. 64 – Ronald Gene Simmons & Billy Lenz"

    • 1 hr 1 min
    The Curly Mustache Podcast: Ep. 63 – Matthew Hopkins & Claude Frollo

    The Curly Mustache Podcast: Ep. 63 – Matthew Hopkins & Claude Frollo

    Hey listeners! Thanks for checking out the newest episode of The Curly Mustache Podcast! Each week, we take one real-life villain and one fictional villain, talk about their histories, crimes, motives, any connections they may have, and then decide whether they could ever be redeemed with our Bowler Hat Scale. In this episode, we talk … Continue reading "The Curly Mustache Podcast: Ep. 63 – Matthew Hopkins & Claude Frollo"

    • 57 min
    The Curly Mustache Podcast: Ep. 62 – George Hassell & Sweeney Todd

    The Curly Mustache Podcast: Ep. 62 – George Hassell & Sweeney Todd

    Hello everyone! Thanks for checking out the newest episode of The Curly Mustache Podcast! Each week, we take one real-life villain and one fictional villain, discuss their histories, crimes, motives, any connections they have, and cap the episode off with whether they can be redeemed with our Bowler Hat Scale. This week, we discuss the … Continue reading "The Curly Mustache Podcast: Ep. 62 – George Hassell & Sweeney Todd"

    • 1 hr
    The Curly Mustache Podcast: Ep. 61 – Danny Rolling & Ghostface

    The Curly Mustache Podcast: Ep. 61 – Danny Rolling & Ghostface

    Hey friends! Thanks for checking out the newest episode of The Curly Mustache Podcast! Each week, we take one real-life villain and one fictional villain, discuss their histories, motives, crimes, any connections they have, and then cap the episode off with whether they can be redeemed with our Bowler Hat Scale. In this episode, we … Continue reading "The Curly Mustache Podcast: Ep. 61 – Danny Rolling & Ghostface"

    • 1 hr 1 min
    The Curly Mustache Podcast: Ep. 60 – Fred & Rose West & Boris & Natasha

    The Curly Mustache Podcast: Ep. 60 – Fred & Rose West & Boris & Natasha

    Hello listeners! Thanks for checking out episode 60 of The Curly Mustache Podcast! Each week, we take one real-life villain and one fictional villain, discuss their histories, crimes, motives, any connections they may have, and whether they can be redeemed with our trusty bowler hat scale. This week, we talk about a couple of villainous … Continue reading "The Curly Mustache Podcast: Ep. 60 – Fred & Rose West & Boris & Natasha"

    • 1 hr 9 min
    The Curly Mustache Podcast: Ep. 59 – Richard Kuklinski & Anton Chigurh

    The Curly Mustache Podcast: Ep. 59 – Richard Kuklinski & Anton Chigurh

    Hello listeners! Thanks for checking out the newest episode of The Curly Mustache Podcast. Each episode, we take one real-life villain and one fictional villain, discuss their histories, crimes, motives, any connections they have, and cap off the episode with whether they can be redeemed with our Bowler Hat Scale. This week, we discuss a … Continue reading "The Curly Mustache Podcast: Ep. 59 – Richard Kuklinski & Anton Chigurh"

    • 1 hr 8 min

Customer Reviews

4.9 out of 5
21 Ratings

21 Ratings

just_jennlynn ,

Amazing Podcast

I love true crime because I’m a weirdo. This is probably one of my new favorite podcasts.

edemoray ,

Finally caught up!

I was recommended to listen to you guys by Jared Murphy, and started at the beginning of Covid closures. I’ve loved it! Kept me entertained while I was home, and continuing to bring laughs to our scary world. I’ve learned a lot of cool stuff, and has led me to researching and learning more about some crazy villains. Keep it up guys, really enjoying each episode!

Honeebunny ,

Come for the True Crime, stay for the chemistry

The chemistry between the three hosts Stephen, Joel, and Ian are fun and informative, but especially so when they rag on another for terrible (wonderful?) accents and impressions, and groany (delectable?) puns. The real life villain vs fictional villain comparisons will have you “ooo” and thirst for more, and they are so good about taking on listener requests. A very interactive podcast where they listen, care and love their audience. I look forward to their episodes!

Top Podcasts In Comedy

Listeners Also Subscribed To