Vinyl Drop

Keith Montena
  • 5.0 (6)
  • MUSIC COMMENTARY
  • UPDATED BIWEEKLY
Vinyl Drop

New episodes every Tuesday diving into the biggest pop music releases—singles, album deep-dives, and the campaigns behind them. From Lady Gaga to Sabrina Carpenter, The Weeknd to Olivia Rodrigo, we’re breaking down the music, the strategy, and the reception. Press play for the facts, but expect some unfiltered opinions along the way.

Episodes

  1. FEB 5

    "Abracadabra", Lady Gaga

    We're breaking down "Abracadabra" by Lady Gaga, the second (technically third) taste of MAYHEM. After premiering during The 2025 Grammys, the track has signaled a leap for and already sparked major conversation. We’re getting into key creatives and collaborators who worked on the song and video, and the team behind it. What is Abracadabra, song and video, about? From the sonic direction to critics' reception, I’m diving deep into where this track sits in Gaga’s discography and why it feels like one of her most defining releases in years. Plus, I'll be discussing claims of her mirroring too much from previous hits. Vinyl Drop covers pop music with an emphasis on new releases, the artists' creative process, collaborators, and their marketing strategy. What do you think of "Abracadabra"? Where does it rank for you? And what should we break down next?

    26 min

  2. JAN 14

    What Went Wrong with Katy Perry's Comeback

    Keith Montena returns this week to discuss "143", Katy Perry’s sixth album, and the missteps that defined her 2024 comeback. After a few underperforming albums, Katy set the stage for a maximalist dance-pop album with Women’s World as the lead single, dubbed a female empowerment anthem. But with producer Dr. Luke’s controversial involvement, an inconsistent rollout, and material that failed to resonate, the era did not live up to expectation. From a pop fan, hear about why "Women's World" faced so much backlash, the history behind WHY collaborators were controversial, and an analysis from a pop fan on Katy Perry's trajectory from "Teenage Dream" to "Witness" and her (lovely!) redemption arc with "Smile", in just under 40 minutes. Vinyl Drop dives into how this comeback went off the rails.

    36 min

  3. 12/17/2024

    "Angel Of My Dreams" by Jade (BEST Pop Song of 2024)

    In 2024, Jade Thirlwall of Little Mix debuted with "Angel Of My Dreams". Her first solo offering after Little Mix, the girl group went on hiatus. Dive into the music, the vision behind the music video, and the creative and marketing decisions that made this debut single unforgettable, and the best pop song of 2024. Also, let's dive into what her album next year may include.

    28 min

  4. 12/03/2024

    Camila Cabello's "CXOXO" & Pop Music in Internet Niches

    Camila Cabello's "CXOXO" album kicked off with a hyper pop-tinged lead single, immediately causing comparisons to Charli XCX. This episode discusses how goalposts in pop music are changing as music becomes more conversational online and less about Top 40 appeal. We explore how Camila’s artistic pivot isn’t about chasing another Señorita or Havana, but about carving a niche within online music stans. Despite high-profile features with Drake and Lil Nas X, slick production from Jasper Harris, and tabloid buzz surrounding Sabrina Carpenter and Shawn Mendes, the album struggles to stick the landing. Is the issue tied to the music itself, the crowded year, albums like "BRAT" in similar lanes, or is something else at play? Tune in as we dissect CXOXO, uncover key moments, and leave you with the tools to form your own verdict.

    43 min

  5. 11/26/2024

    "Disease", Lady Gaga

    Keith Montena is back this week breaking down "Disease" by Lady Gaga, the first taste of the singer's upcoming seventh album. After "Die With A Smile" with Bruno Mars and Joker: Folie á Duex, Lady Gaga returns with the biggest changes to her creative team in nearly 15 years, and an album modeling after dark soundscapes similar to Born This Way. Notably far from 2020's Chromatica. Vinyl Drop discusses pop music with an emphasis on new releases, the artists' creative process, collaborators, and their marketing strategy. I want to hear from you - do you like "Disease"? Did you like the rollout? What should be discussed next?

    36 min

  6. 01/26/2024

    Joanne, Lady Gaga

    (Archive Episode, 2023) Lady Gaga's "Joanne" showcases the singer ditching dance-pop in exchange for country and americana. Hear about the creative process behind the 2016 album, as well as the aftermath of 2013's ARTPOP album and how this shift helped the singer recover. The album marked a commercial resurgence for Lady Gaga with performances at The Super Bowl Half Time Show and Coachella, projects like Five Foot Two and A Star Is Born. Plus, discussions on "The Cure" and puzzled fan reception to her new sound. Also, is Lady Gaga releasing a new album this year? Hear about rumored collaborators for her seventh LP, and if Joanne is the best indicator of her next artistic venture.

    1h 13m

  7. 03/04/2022

    Doll Domination, The Pussycat Dolls

    (Archive Episode 2022) Keith Montena returns this week with previous co-host Ashley Tatum to discuss The Pussycat Dolls. The groups second (and last) era was helmed by collaborators like Polow Da Don, Timbaland, and Darkchild. The album, interestingly, was sculpted by beginning sessions for Nicole Scherzinger's debut solo album "Her Name Is Nicole". Listen to hear about the group's evolving dynamics, why we feel it was always bound to cause some sort of drama, and where the girls are now after reuniting in 2020 with "React".

    1h 10m
  • 7 Episodes

Ratings & Reviews

5
out of 5
6 Ratings

About

New episodes every Tuesday diving into the biggest pop music releases—singles, album deep-dives, and the campaigns behind them. From Lady Gaga to Sabrina Carpenter, The Weeknd to Olivia Rodrigo, we’re breaking down the music, the strategy, and the reception. Press play for the facts, but expect some unfiltered opinions along the way.

Information

  • Creator
    Keith Montena
  • Years Active
    2022 - 2025
  • Episodes
    7
  • Rating
    Clean
  • Show Website
    Vinyl Drop

You Might Also Like

To listen to explicit episodes, sign in.

Stay up to date with this show

Sign in or sign up to follow shows, save episodes, and get the latest updates.
Select a country or region

Africa, Middle East, and India

Asia Pacific

Europe

Latin America and the Caribbean

The United States and Canada