Rory Stewart: The Long History of...
Rory Stewart with a radical take on the concepts that shape our lives.
Good Podcast
11 Nov
Strong thoughts and materials. Good data. Quite Rory centric but I would recommend. Well done Rory.
Rory wrestles with our ignorance.
6 days ago
Rory is undeniably one of the most erudite speakers I’ve encountered, but his persistent inability—or refusal—to acknowledge how others might interpret the same facts differently has long invited accusations of arrogance. This podcast, ostensibly exploring “ignorance everywhere,” does little to dispel that perception. Instead, it feels like an extended essay on his relentless encounters with the ignorance of others, curiously light on any meaningful reflection about his own limitations—aside from a thin veneer of faux humility that seems designed to deflect criticism Are we really to believe that Rory is grappling with his own fallibility alongside everyone else’s? I’m not convinced. His unwavering belief in the righteousness of his intellect seems unshakable. Here is a man who dismisses Johnson as a buffoon, Trump as dangerous, and Brexit as catastrophic. He is utterly convinced of the ignorance of the herd, which leaves one wondering: does he secretly despise democracy itself, for giving so much power to the “uninformed masses”? His arguments, at their core, echo Marxist thinking—an ironic stance for a former Conservative Party leadership candidate, particularly one from a party he and his ilk have arguably left in ruins, paving the way for Labour’s resurgence. Rory critiques not just individuals but entire institutions, yet his attempts to soften this with references to the mysteries of quantum theory feel hollow. By pointing out that even scientists lack a full grasp of their domain, he seems to imply that ignorance is universal—a subtle way of saying it’s not just his critics but everyone who falls short of his lofty standards. Beneath the surface, this episode carries an unsettling message: we are all ignorant, and Rory is here to diagnose our flaws. It’s an argument that resonates with the new left’s intellectual disdain for the masses, though Rory cloaks it in a self-effacing critique of human understanding, including his own. On that narrow point, I agree with him. He is dangerously convinced of his own intellect and strikingly effective at making his worldview persuasive. And yet, his lack of self-awareness and his performative exploration of his limitations make him deeply unsettling. For all of this, I keep listening—not because I find him agreeable, but because his contradictions and blind spots are endlessly fascinating, even if they make my skin crawl.
Excellent
6 days ago
More please
Londoner
17 Aug
Thoughtful and cogent. Although occasionally verbose, an engaging perspective on our obsession with knowledge. A persuasive argument to embrace ignorance without defaulting to Faith. Bravo Rory.
About
Information
- CreatorBBC Radio 4
- Episodes10
- Seasons2
- RatingClean
- Copyright© (C) BBC 2024
- Show Website
You Might Also Like
- PoliticsUpdated weekly
- PoliticsUpdated twice weekly
- PoliticsUpdated weekly
- Daily NewsUpdated daily
- PoliticsUpdated twice weekly
- PoliticsUpdated weekly
- Society & CultureUpdated weekly