This is a great podcast. Well researched, balanced, insightful, and most important, the topic is the focus, not the podcaster.
Don’t worry about the California title, in case you’re thinking this story’s effect stops at the state boundary. California is merely the story host, used to demonstrate all that’s discussed.
Episode ratings:
1 - 5 stars
2 - 3 stars
3 - 3.5 stars
4 - 4.5 stars
5 - 4.5 stars
There’s science, history, story telling, lessons learned, inquisitiveness, and strategy for those who want to understand and make change. The first episode’s history lesson was superbly prepared and discussed, with two phenomenal speakers on the subject.
Episodes 2 and 3 were weaker points for me. It is misleading, if not factually incorrect, to imply that tribal nations are leading and/or leaders in the reintroduction of fire to the landscape. There is zero question that historic tribal entities harnessed fire to procure from and manage landscapes, but these nations are neither leading scientific work nor topping the charts with acres treated (quantity or complexity). I think one has to take caution with the purely/primarily mythic story of fire, especially if the entire story isn’t presented, including cultural change and management/hierarchical tribal system, arson, and differing laws affecting fire use, prosecution, funding strategy, and modern fire history patterns. This is one of two places the podcast fell short and failed to present holistic information to inform listeners.
The other area of concern comes in episode 3, where the podcaster tells the story of the self-titled “Helltown Hotshots.” Here’s another way to describe what we’re told is the heroic story of locals saving the town: unqualified do gooders get incredibly lucky, with geography and weather as much to credit, and fortunately don’t indirectly kill first responders called in to save them from their own arrogant bravado. Now you might say “how dare you!” But I say that once evacuated, stay out. Do not enter evacuation zones or exclusionary fire zones you were never in. These locals broke every tenet of wildland firefighting, and the “firefighter” among them wasn’t willing to use his full name. Now why is that? The podcaster didn’t do enough to highlight the incredible risk, if not stupidity, of these rogue warriors, at the potential expense of the lives of others. Brave and valiant? Maybe. Stupid and lucky? Yes.
These two issues, however, weren’t enough to drop my overall rating. This totality of this podcast is what others attempting to tell the fire story should aim for. Anyone listening can make well informed decisions about understanding, respecting, and living with wildland fire.