In this special edition, David Eisenhower—historian, bestselling author, and grandson of President Dwight D. Eisenhower—steps in as guest host to interview Scott Reich about his new book, One Day in September: Baseball, Brotherhood, and the Birth of the All-Star Game. Their conversation explores the remarkable but largely forgotten story of a charity baseball game played at Fenway Park on September 27, 1917. Featuring legends including Babe Ruth, Ty Cobb, Walter Johnson, Tris Speaker, and "Shoeless" Joe Jackson, the game honored beloved sportswriter Tim Murnane and would ultimately become the precursor to Major League Baseball's modern All-Star Game. But this episode is about much more than baseball. Together, Scott and David examine how a single day in American history reveals larger truths about citizenship, community, generosity, and the power of shared civic experiences. They discuss the role sports once played in bringing Americans together, the influence of early sportswriters in shaping the nation's values, and why recovering forgotten history can help us better understand ourselves today. Blending history, storytelling, and personal reflection, this special Curveball episode is a conversation between two historians about memory, identity, and the enduring lessons hidden in the stories we almost lost. Listeners Will Learn: The conversation focused on the forgotten 1917 baseball exhibition game honoring Tim Murnane. One concept discussed was how storytelling and narrative shape our collective memory. A key theme that emerged was the civic role of baseball in early 20th-century America. The discussion explored how players, owners, and even sportswriters like Murnane wore many hats in the development of baseball. Several points were raised, including the unique democratic experience of early ballparks. The use of sports as a metaphor for American values, such as perseverance, character, and unity, was highlighted. The episode touched on the instinct to gather at scale for community and charity events, something seen as less common today. Scott Reich and David Eisenhower delve into the darkness threading through the "golden age" of baseball: issues of scandal, division, and underlying social tensions.Another topic they discussed was the influence of sports journalism in mythologizing athletes and shaping how we remember their achievements. The notion of exporting American sports like baseball as a tool for peace and understanding between nations was considered. Key Moments: (00:00) One Day in September, by Scott Reich, book launch today (06:39) Guest host David Eisenhower asks Scott Reich about his writing process (10:20) Discussion of Tim Murnane’s love for baseball (11:51) President Dwight Eisenhower on sports and character (17:18) Tim Murnane's list of life advice (19:44) Sports bringing people together (21:07) Building civic connections through sports (26:45) Pre-1919 baseball stories shared between Scott and David (29:19) Tim Murnane’s unique player connections (36:17) Competing styles of baseball (37:42) Discussing America and baseball history