The Cabbage Coins Podcast

Tony Gryckiewicz

A podcast dedicated to the rare coin market, providing education and insights to collectors and new dealers in the hobby.

  1. Ep.40 - John Albanese Grades My Coins - CAC Grading #numismatics #coincollecting #rarecoins

    22 APR

    Ep.40 - John Albanese Grades My Coins - CAC Grading #numismatics #coincollecting #rarecoins

    SummaryJoin Tony Gryckiewicz as he interviews John Albanese, CEO of CAC Grading, to explore the nuances of coin grading, the importance of authenticity, and insights into the numismatic market. This episode offers expert tips for collectors and dealers alike. Action  itemsRotate coins under proper lighting to evaluate surface qualityAvoid cleaning or altering coins to preserve valueLearn from experienced graders and participate in coin shows Keywordscoin grading, CAC Grading, numismatics, coin collecting, coin authentication, grading tips, coin market, coin history, coin tips, coin expert Chapters00:00 Introduction to Cabbage Coins Podcast01:15 John Albanese's Journey into Coin Grading09:14 The Art of Coin Grading and Evaluation17:44 Understanding CAC Stickers and Their Criteria20:10 Analyzing Specific Coins: The 21 High Relief Piece21:07 Evaluating Coin Strikes and Grades22:07 The Importance of Reverse Quality in Grading23:18 Understanding Coin Luster and Planchet Issues25:59 Analyzing Economy Submission Coins26:53 The Intricacies of Confederate Coins27:59 Diving into the 1809 Half Coin29:48 The Impact of Dipping on Coin Value31:26 Assessing the 1861 Dime and Its Marketability32:58 The 1892 Quarter: Beauty and Blotchy Toning35:16 Final Thoughts on Coin Grading and Market Trends41:03 Grading Coins: The Importance of Striking and Luster42:46 Evaluating the 84CC Coin: Luster vs. Abrasion43:42 The 1872 Coin: Originality and Potential Tooling45:55 Understanding Coin Rub and Circulation48:16 The 1917S25 Coin: Striking and Cabinet Friction52:02 Identifying Coin Films and Doctoring Practices55:58 Market Perspectives: CAC vs. Other Grading Services01:00:19 The Joy of Numismatics: Fresh Deals and Historical Coins01:02:11 Thank you Visit the Website for inventory and how to get in touchhttps://cabbagecoins.com/ Where to find Tony and Cabbage Coins:https://cabbagecoins.com/Email: tony@cabbagecoins.comIG: @cabbage_coins Intro Music - "Obverse Fields" by Timothy Gryckiewicz

    1hr 2min
  2. Ep.39 - Part 2 Intro to Pioneer Gold Coins with David McCarthy of Kagin's #numismatics #rarecoins

    15 APR

    Ep.39 - Part 2 Intro to Pioneer Gold Coins with David McCarthy of Kagin's #numismatics #rarecoins

    Join Tony Gryckiewicz as he interviews numismatist David McCarthy about Pioneer Gold Coins, exploring their history, key types, and significance in American numismatics. Perfect for collectors and enthusiasts looking to deepen their understanding of this rare and fascinating niche. Keywords Pioneer Gold Coins, Numismatics, Gold Coin Collecting, California Gold Rush, Private Gold Coins, Coin History, Gold Ingot, 19th Century Coins, Coin Collecting Tips, Rare Coins Key  topics History of Pioneer Gold CoinsTypes of Pioneer Gold Coins and Their SignificanceThe Role of Private Mints and Assay Offices in 19th Century Gold Coin ProductionNotable Coins and Their Stories from the California Gold RushCollecting and Valuing Pioneer Gold Coins Chapters 00:00 Introduction to Pioneer Gold Coins02:11 Cincinnati Mining and Trading Company03:50 The Unique Mass and Kell Coins05:56 The Story of Baldwin & Company07:28 The Controversy of Myers & Company Ingots13:11 The Unique Nature of California Gold Ingots14:00 The Return to Dubosq Coins16:18 The Role of Augustus Humbert21:23 The Rise of Shults & Company24:49 The Gold Coin Scandals of 185127:52 The Emergence of Private Coinage31:37 The Role of the Assay Office33:49 Transition to Modern Minting Practices37:37 The Establishment of the San Francisco Mint39:36 Kellogg & Company: A New Player in Coinage42:21 The Unique Designs of Pioneer Gold44:28 The Legacy of Clark Gruber & Company48:30 The Final Coins of the Gold Rush Era51:54 Getting Started in Pioneer Gold Collecting Resources America's Golden Age: Pioneer Private and Pioneer Gold Coins of the United States - https://www.amazon.com/dp/B09XYZ1234David McCarthy's Profile at Kagan's - https://kagans.com/david-mccarthyCentral States Numismatic Society - https://centralstatescoinclub.org/ Visit the Website for inventory and how to get in touchhttps://cabbagecoins.com/ Tony GryckiewiczOwner - Cabbage CoinsIG: @cabbage_coinsEmail: tony@cabbagecoins.com Intro Music - "Obverse Fields" by Timothy Gryckiewicz

    58 min
  3. Ep.38 - Pioneer Gold Coin Types Part 1 - David McCarthy of Kagin's #numismatics #coincollecting

    8 APR

    Ep.38 - Pioneer Gold Coin Types Part 1 - David McCarthy of Kagin's #numismatics #coincollecting

    In this episode, numismatist David McCarthy joins to explore the fascinating world of pioneer gold coins — their history, types, key figures, and how they fit into the broader collector landscape. Perfect for enthusiasts eager to understand these rare pieces and how to approach collecting them. Main Insights:David McCarthy’s background and expertise is in American numismatics, focusing on pioneer gold coins.The origins of private and semi-official gold coins in the United States, dating back to the late 18th and early 19th centuries.Clarification of terminology: why "territorial gold" is a misnomer, and why "pioneer gold" or "private gold" are more accurate.Key historical figures such as Ephraim Brasher, Templeton Reid, and the Bechtler family, with insights into their coin-making contributions.The significance of early private gold coins like the Brasher doubloon as some of the earliest in North America.How private coins depicted in the discussion, like the California gold rush pieces, reflect the tumult and innovation of their era.The complexities of the market, including rarity, value, and the influence of provenance.Notable examples such as the Moffatt & Company ingots, and their story within the California gold rush.Challenges of authentication, conservation, and valuation in pioneer gold collectibles.Resources for collectors, including recommended literature and tips on working with specialists. Timestamps:00:00 Introduction to Pioneer Gold Coins06:09 Understanding the Misnomer: Territorial vs. Pioneer Gold10:53 The Brasher Doubloon: The First Private Gold Coin15:01 The Value and Rarity of Pioneer Gold Coins22:48 Mormon Gold Coins: A Unique Piece of History28:41 Oregon Gold Coins: The Oregon Exchange Company32:31 Norris, Gregg & Norris: The First California Gold Coins36:50 Miners Bank: The Impact of Fire on Coinage41:08 The Impact of Miners Bank's Fire45:44 Researching California's Gold Economy47:55 Moffat's Transition to the Assay Office48:55 The Rarity of Ormsby Coins51:09 The Mystery of Pacific Company Coins53:10 The Design Influences on California Coins55:07 End of Part 1 Where to find Tony and Cabbage Coins:https://cabbagecoins.com/Email: tony@cabbagecoins.comIG: @cabbage_coins New to the podcast? Click the  "Subscribe" Button Intro Music - "Obverse Fields" by Timothy Gryckiewicz Come to the Central States Numismatics Society Show:April 23-25, 2026Table 1717

    55 min
  4. The Four Horsemen of the Coin-pocalypse with Ben TheCoinGeek, Noah and Owen from Rarity7 and Tony from Cabbage Coins

    1 APR

    The Four Horsemen of the Coin-pocalypse with Ben TheCoinGeek, Noah and Owen from Rarity7 and Tony from Cabbage Coins

    In this episode, four industry experts share their insights on proper conduct at coin shows, negotiation tactics, and the future of grading and market evolution. Whether you're a seasoned collector or just starting out, understanding these etiquette tips and market strategies can significantly improve your experience and success in the coin industry. Main Topics Covered:Most common etiquette mistakes at coin shows and how to avoid themBest practices for buying and selling coins, including negotiation tipsHandling overstated or over-graded coins and future market implicationsThe importance of respectful interactions and security considerationsNegotiation strategies: when to make offers and understanding the perceived valueHow market perception shapes the industry and the role of third-party gradingTips for building long-term relationships and reputation among dealers Chapters:00:00 Introduction to the Coin Show Experience02:55 Understanding Coin Show Etiquette05:24 Dealer and Collector Interactions08:04 The Importance of Respect in Coin Transactions10:56 Navigating the Selling Process at Coin Shows23:48 Understanding Pricing in Coin Collecting26:27 The Emotional Aspect of Inherited Collections27:55 The Importance of Market Knowledge29:45 Creating a Comfortable Environment for Sellers31:11 The Etiquette of Coin Shows35:55 Navigating Price Negotiations39:49 The Ethics of Price Agreements45:41 Lessons from Real Transactions47:47 The Importance of Kindness in Transactions51:09 The Art of Negotiation in Coin Dealing57:31 Understanding Pricing Strategies and Market Dynamics01:01:52 The Future of Coin Grading and Market Trends Resources & Links:Ben TheCoinGeek YouTube Channel:‪@TheCoinGeek‬ https://www.oldpueblocoin.com/ Rarity7 Coins and Currency‪@Rarity7Coins‬ https://www.rarity7.com/ Cabbage Coins ⁨@cabbage_coins⁩  www.cabbagecoins.com

    1hr 11min
  5. Ep.36 - Classic Head Gold with Shannon Rajkitkul of Paradime Coins #numismatics #coincollecting

    25 MAR

    Ep.36 - Classic Head Gold with Shannon Rajkitkul of Paradime Coins #numismatics #coincollecting

    Join us as Shannon Rajkitkul from Paradime Coins shares expert insights into the world of Classic Head Gold coins. Whether you're a collector, investor, or enthusiast, learn how to identify key features, grade coins accurately, and understand market dynamics for this iconic series. Main Topics:Origins and key features of the Classic Head Gold series (1834-1839)How to identify and grade Classic Head coins, focusing on MS61 to MS64+Rarity, market value, and the significance of specific dates like 1838 CharlotteTips for type collectors and building a balanced collectionThe impact of market trends and notable collections like Pogue on pricingHow grading scales evolve and what deltas like "plus" grades mean in practice Key Insights:The differences in design hubs and die varieties within the series, including Script Eight vs. Block Eight stylesImportant visual cues for grading, such as luster, strike quality, and signs of circulation or cleaningThe significance of mint marks, especially for Charlotte (C) and Dahlonega (D), and their collector appealThe market's current hot streak, with a focus on coins graded MS63 and MS64+How pedigree and auction history influence coin values, using Pogue collections as examplesPractical advice for collectors: balancing rarity, condition, and price points Timestamps:00:20 - Introduction to the podcast and Shannon’s background in numismatics01:13 - How Shannon started collecting coins through his grandfather02:17 - Favorite coin series and collecting preferences02:59 - The significance of the Fun Show in Florida03:03 - Preferred US coin series to deal in, especially gold03:23 - Origin of Paradime Coins and market entry04:12 - Focus on Classic Head Gold coins: series overview and highlights04:54 - What makes the 1834 $2.50 classic head special05:58 - Identifying key features: luster and color nuances07:16 - Differences between 1836 Script Eight vs. Block Eight varieties08:17 - Market analysis: value points for grades 61, 62, and 6308:59 - The importance of eye appeal and original surfaces09:54 - Caution in buying MS61 grade coins and what indicators to avoid10:36 - Signs of wear, strike quality, and die cracks to look for12:21 - Understanding "halo" toning and black patches on gold coins13:46 - Differentiating struck vs. circulation wear, strike depth, and how to evaluate strike versus wear15:08 - Handling die crack varieties and their impact on value17:35 - The rarity and desirability of 1837 MS62 examples18:39 - Key market insights on 1837 rarity and auction trends20:26 - How specific dates like 1837 shape the collector’s value proposition21:27 - Choosing between rare dates and common dates in type sets22:45 - The dominance of the 1838 Charlotte in rarity and market interest24:56 - The significance of mint marks like Charlotte on the obverse26:34 - Variability in coin personalities across different years and mints27:24 - The unique appeal of New Orleans minted coins and their undervaluation28:22 - Market trends for $5 Classic Head Gold coins vs. $2.529:25 - Differences in collecting and market dynamics between half eagles and quarter eagles30:28 - How the grading spectrum from AU58 to MS65 impacts pricing34:09 - The importance of eye appeal and surface quality for value36:37 - The process of upgrading coins in collections, grading nuances, and "plus" grades38:04 - Evolving standards in coin grading and how market perception influences value39:39 - The influence of major collections like Pogue on current market prices44:01 - Market depth for different grade ranges and demand for high-grade coins46:25 - Impact of a few major collectors on the series’ price trends47:38 - Selling experience: quick market moves and collector preferences50:01 - The significance of rarity, market demand, and grading for the overall value51:21 - Connecting with Shannon for more insights via Paradime Coins Where to find Tony and Cabbage Coins:https://cabbagecoins.com/Email: tony@cabbagecoins.comIG: @cabbage_coins Where to find Shannon and Paradime Coins:www.paradimecoins.comEmail: shannon@paradimecoins.comIG: @paradimecoins Intro Music - "Obverse Fields" by Timothy Gryckiewicz

    53 min
  6. Ep.35 - How to Select Quality Morgan Silver Dollars with John Baumgart #numismatics #coincollecting

    18 MAR

    Ep.35 - How to Select Quality Morgan Silver Dollars with John Baumgart #numismatics #coincollecting

    Morgan Dollar Collecting: Insights from Expert John BaumgartDiscover expert tips on identifying, grading, and investing in Morgan Dollars. John Baumgart shares decades of experience, revealing how to recognize quality coins, understanding varieties, and the importance of quality photographs in sales. In this episode:The significance of type coins, with focus on the 82S Morgan Dollar MS68How specific minting flaws like wheel marks and die polishing lines reveal a coin's historyThe story behind GSA Carson City dollars and their market impactTips for detecting dipped or cleaned coins using surface inspection techniquesThe importance of variety knowledge, such as the 78-P with deep mirror finish and the 21-S "ugly" coinRecommendations for essential books: Wayne Miller’s Morgan and Peace Dollar and the latest Red Book editionExpert advice on buying high-quality Morgan Dollars and the value of patience and eye for detail Timestamps:00:00 - Introduction and guest background02:09 - The allure of Morgan Dollars and collecting journey02:51 - What makes a perfect type coin? Focus on MS68 82-S04:37 - Recognizing proof-like versus lustrous coins05:41 - Toning characteristics and the GSA Carson City dollars10:01 - Deep mirror proof-like 84-CC and its market value10:51 - Grading insights: what affects coin grades?12:00 - How to identify and sell high-quality Morgans13:07 - The importance of quality photography for sales success14:58 - A detailed look at the 78-P with VAM 14-4 die variety21:13 - The iconic 85-O Morgan Dollar with toning25:43 - Recognizing the rare 21-S "ugly" Morgan Dollar33:44 - Identifying signs of dipping and cleaning37:31 - Collecting the 92 S Morgan Dollar variety48:45 - Die polishing lines versus post-mint cleaning marks50:28 - Recommended reference books for Morgan collectors53:47 - Final advice for collectors: focus on "special" coins Resources & Links:Wayne Miller's Morgan and Peace DollarMorgan Dollar Red Book (Search for the latest edition)VAMworld - John Baumgart’s profile (messydesk) Connect with John Baumgart:Email: john@varslab.com Where to find Tony and Cabbage Coins:https://cabbagecoins.com/Email: tony@cabbagecoins.comIG: @cabbage_coins Note: Always examine coins in person or through high-quality images, and consult resources for variety and grading details before purchasing or selling. Intro Music - "Obverse Fields" by Timothy Gryckiewicz

    56 min
  7. Coin YouTubers Unite! A discussion with TheCoinGeek, Rarity7 and Cabbage Coins #coincollecting

    11 MAR

    Coin YouTubers Unite! A discussion with TheCoinGeek, Rarity7 and Cabbage Coins #coincollecting

    In this engaging collaboration, Tony from Cabbage Coins joins Noah Lehmann-Haupt, Owen Seymour, and Ben TheCoinGeek to discuss the current state and future directions of coin collecting and dealing. They cover market trends, show circuit health, the impact of live streaming platforms, upcoming US Mint releases, and hot topics in numismatics for 2026. Key Topics:The landscape of major coin shows and projections through 2026The rise of live streaming platforms and their effect on the coin marketMarket health and dealer perspectives on recent shows such as Savannah and BaltimoreAnalysis of current popular coin series: Seated dollars, early silver, CAC-approved coins, and the decline of Carson City coinsThe potential of underpriced coin series like Buffalo nickels and trade dollarsInsights into US Mint's 2026 releases, including the semiquincentennialsMarket growth in gold coins versus rare gold and key date gold investmentsOverrated and underrated coin series, with a focus on how market dynamics and collector interest evolveEthical considerations and misrepresentation issues in live streams and online platformsThe influence of market psychology, bubbles, and the importance of informed buying Timestamps:00:00 - Introduction: Industry panel discusses current trends in coin shows and markets02:00 - The future of coin shows: Which regions are underserved?06:37 - Market health insights from major show attendees Owen and Noah10:03 - Buying experiences and dealer perspectives at recent shows16:26 - The impact and risks of live streaming platforms20:05 - Concerns about misrepresentation and ethics in online coin sales33:56 - The role of authentic grading and policing in live streams38:15 - Preview of US Mint's 2026 commemorative and series coins45:00 - Thoughts on modern minting technology and design quality50:35 - Hot series and market trends for 2026: Seated dollars, early busts, and more55:35 - Market analysis: undervalued series and potential investment opportunities58:26 - Gold coins: opportunities amid rising gold prices61:02 - The decline of Carson City coins and focus on other series like buffalo nickels and proof Jeffersons63:49 - The importance of understanding market segmentation and consumer demand66:17 - Final thoughts: The future of numismatics and how collectors can navigate upcoming trends Resources & Links:Cabbage Coinshttps://www.youtube.com/@UCRx-Dzt15Jwr6QBCTO3JXLg www.cabbagecoins.com Ben TheCoinGeek YouTube Channel:https://www.youtube.com/@UCWSftPPYpkOR9gQD0nwtd5A  Rarity7https://www.youtube.com/@UC_Lb7g09sGAwSfXgXz3QSRA https://www.rarity7.com/ Stay tuned for upcoming episodes where we dive deeper into specific series and numismatic trends. Leave your questions below for future Q&A sessions!

    1hr 2min

About

A podcast dedicated to the rare coin market, providing education and insights to collectors and new dealers in the hobby.

You Might Also Like