Not Always Polite

Selene Mayhew

A Canadian true-crime podcast featuring lesser-known Canadian cases. Hosted by Selene Mayhew located in London ON, Canada

  1. 2023-06-03

    Episode 116: The Horrific Murder of Noelle Paquette

    This case begins with two people who were descried in an article as being “Like Paul Bernardo and Karla Homolka, or Michael Rafferty and Terri-Lynne McClintic, who abducted, raped and killed girls, two morally bankrupt, violent people” who found each other on social media. This monstrous pair goes on to Murder a vivacious 27 year old Kindergarten teacher. Listen through to learn more.

    11 min

  2. 2023-04-29

    Episode 115: Did Jeromka “Jerry” Willis Keeshig take his own life?

    This episode contains an update on a previously covered case (Ep. 10) of Tyler McMichael as well as a families story about their son Jerry Keeshig. Jerry's family wants the police to reopen their investigation in the hopes of getting more answers. Update: https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/london/tyler-mcmichael-found-dead-near-dorchester-ont-remembered-for-his-laugh-and-spirit-1.6825942?fbclid=IwAR00icxj6x0wKEFL6wdHRXhGJw_7gJb7jFp9fiVSsUWohVlqqo7RyZjyyOQ Episode Links: https://owensoundhub.org/news/14846-family-wants-investigation-re-opened-recommends-changes.html https://www.bayshorebroadcasting.ca/2023/04/28/family-calling-on-owen-sound-police-to-re-open-investigation-into-jerry-keeshigs-death/?fbclid=IwAR1DE0E7Mh2kA-DkuwuhY87sCxOoN4dalwbh5tgfj37qvh-0NBzKHqaHq7w

    9 min

  3. 2023-04-15

    Episode 114: MURDERED - Pauline Dudley

    17 year old Pauline was last seen by her mother when she left their home to go back to her boyfriends where she had been living for her past year, but she didn’t make it. Listen through to learn more.

    6 min

  4. 2023-03-27

    Episode 113: The Murder of Jeffery Johnson

    31 year old Jeffery Johnson was found dead in the basement of a home he was subleasing from Paul Jaglal. With his mothers persistence, police finally took his disappearance seriously resulting in the discovery of his body 4 days after his death. Listen through to learn more.

    9 min

  5. 2023-03-12

    Episode 112: MISSING/RUNAWAY - Justin Pollari

    In 2001, Justin Pollari ran away. He was 14 years old. Justin has never been seen or heard from since. Listen through to learn more.

    11 min

  6. 2023-02-26

    Episode 111: Sort of Unsolved? The murder of Morris Conte

    In mid 2010, 42 year old Morris Conte was reported missing by his family. Over the next few weeks dismembered body parts started being discovered more than 150 km away. 12 years later, an arrest is finally made but the family still hasn’t received answers to their burning questions. Listen through to learn more.

    5 min

  7. 2023-02-12

    Episode 110: The Unimaginable Murders of Carla and Al Rutherford

    What would cause a 42 year old man to kill his mother and step father in a fiery blaze? Listen through to find out. https://www.thespec.com/news/crime/2019/04/10/dying-words-part-1-the-arson-killings-of-carla-and-alan-rutherford.html

    27 min

  8. 2023-01-28

    Episode 109: The disappearance of Noreen Greenly

    In September 1963 13 year old Noreen Greenley ived in Bowmanville, Ontario. When she didn’t come home after a night hanging out with her friends; her father reported her missing. Listen through to learn about the theories behind her disappearance.

    19 min
See All (115)

Trailer

4.2
out of 5
18 Ratings

About

A Canadian true-crime podcast featuring lesser-known Canadian cases. Hosted by Selene Mayhew located in London ON, Canada

Information

  • Creator
    Selene Mayhew
  • Years Active
    2020 - 2023
  • Episodes
    115
  • Rating
    Explicit
  • Copyright
    © Selene Mayhew
  • Show Website
    Not Always Polite