The Bookish Rewind

Amy and Susan

The Bookish Rewind is like hitting “rewind” on your favorite reads with your two book-obsessed besties. Each episode, we gossip our way through buzzy bestsellers, fresh new releases, and fan-picked gems—sprinkled with inside jokes, dramatic sighs, and the occasional plot rant. Basically, it’s your TBR… unhinged.

  1. 1D AGO

    Episode 14: People We Meet on Vacation

    The Bookish Rewind: People We Meet on Vacation In this engaging conversation, the hosts (Susan & Amy) delve into their reading experiences, focusing on the themes of adaptations, the intricacies of romance novels, and their personal reflections on the book 'People We Meet on Vacation' by Emily Henry. They explore expectations set by titles and the emotional connections characters evoke. The discussion also touches on the pacing of the narrative, the appeal of second chance romances, and what a modern day romcom is. In this conversation, the speakers delve into the complexities of relationships as portrayed in a book they reviewed. They express how the book made them feel while reading, critique character dynamics, and discuss the implications of personal growth and miscommunication. The conversation highlights the struggles of the main character, Poppy, and her relationships, ultimately leading to a broader discussion on expectations versus reality in romantic narratives. Closing with a round of buy it, borrow it, or burn it and "will you think about this book in a month?" Check it out on Goodreads Check it out on Fable Buy it On Amazon Buy it from BAM We do not own rights to this book or any material related to it. The opinions we share, are our own and have been gleaned from reading this book. Keywords The Bookish Rewind, Fiction, Book Review, Podcast, Book Discussion, relationships, character dynamics, plot complexity, literature, TBR, hallmark movies, love, relationships, book discussion, humor, romance, books, reading, adaptations, Stephen King, Dean Koontz, People We Meet on Vacation, Emily Henry, book recommendations, second chance romance, personal growth, friendship, identity crisis, communication, expectations

    1 hr
  2. 2025-12-30

    Episode 10: Kingdom of the Wicked

    The Bookish Rewind: Kingdom of the Wicked - Kingdom of the Wicked #1 In this episode on the pod, we step into a world of curses, demons, and deadly delicious Italian cooking as we share our unfiltered opinions on Kingdom of the Wicked by Kerri Maniscalco. From murder mysteries and magic circles to broody princes of Hell, we break down what worked, what didn’t, and where the story left us wanting more (or less). We chat chemistry, pacing, world-building, and whether this book leans more slow-burn fantasy or prelude to something spicier. Expect hot takes, ranting, and plenty of love-it-or-hate-it moments as we decide if this darkly enchanting series opener cast a spell on us — or left us unconvinced. Light a candle, salt your doorways, and press play — the Wicked are waiting. The Fantasy Foolery Scale 1 - 🐉 “Dragons? Yes. Logic? No.” 2 - 🧝 “Elves, angst, and eyeliner” 3 - 🪄 “Magic system held together with glitter and vibes” 4 - 🧙‍♂️ “World-building so good I got lost” 5 - ✨ “I now live in this fictional realm” Check it out on Goodreads Check it out on Fable Buy it On Amazon Buy it from BAM We do not own rights to this book or any material related to it. The opinions we share, are our own and have been gleaned from reading this book. Keywords The Bookish Rewind, Fiction, Book Review, Podcast, Character Analysis, Plot Twists, Book Discussion, relationships, character dynamics, plot complexity, literature, TBR, fantasy, historical fiction, magic, demons, wicked, kingdom, wrath, hell, eyeliner

    36 min
  3. 2025-12-09

    Episode 9: The Night Circus

    The Bookish Rewind: The Night Circus Step right up and enter Le Cirque des Rêves with us as we dive into Erin Morgenstern’s enchanting and mysterious The Night Circus. In this episode, we unravel the magic behind the black-and-white tents, explore the star-crossed rivalry-turned-romance between Celia and Marco, and debate whether we’d survive as rêveurs or just get lost in the maze of illusions. We break down the storytelling style that reads like a dream you may or may not want to wake up from, gush over our favorite food pairings and discuss our take on the book. Grab your ticket—no admission fee except your imagination—and join us under the striped tent as we review a novel that tries proves magic is real… and sometimes dangerously beautiful. The Fantasy Foolery Scale 1 - 🐉 “Dragons? Yes. Logic? No.” 2 - 🧝 “Elves, angst, and eyeliner” 3 - 🪄 “Magic system held together with glitter and vibes” 4 - 🧙‍♂️ “World-building so good I got lost” 5 - ✨ “I now live in this fictional realm” Check it out on Goodreads Check it out on Fable Buy it On Amazon Buy it from BAM We do not own rights to this book or any material related to it. The opinions we share, are our own and have been gleaned from reading this book. Keywords The Bookish Rewind, Fiction, Book Review, Podcast, Character Analysis, Plot Twists, Book Discussion, relationships, character dynamics, plot complexity, literature, TBR, fantasy, historical fiction, magic

    26 min
  4. 2025-11-20

    Episode 8: Bunny

    The Bookish Rewind: Bunny In this episode of The Bookish Rewind, we dive into 'Bunny' by Mona Awad, a horror thriller with dark academia themes. We discuss our initial impressions, character dynamics, and the unreliable narration that leaves us with more questions than answers. The conversation explores the writing style, pacing, and the setting of a fictional fine arts college, while also speculating on the upcoming sequel and movie adaptation. We share our overwhelming mix of confusion and intrigue about the book, leading to a lively discussion filled with humor and personal reflections. Sassy Thriller Rating Scale 🔪 5 Knives Out of 5 – “I slept with the lights on and questioned my entire existence.” This book had me clutching my pearls, checking my locks, and texting my therapist. A masterpiece of menace. 🔪 4 Knives – “I gasped. Audibly. In public.” Twisty, juicy, and just unhinged enough to make me side-eye strangers. Not perfect, but I’d still recommend it to my enemies. 🔪 3 Knives – “I saw it coming, but I still tripped over it.” Predictable but fun. Like a Lifetime movie with a budget. I didn’t scream, but I did raise an eyebrow. 🔪 2 Knives – “More thriller, less filler, please.” Dragged like a body in the woods. The twist tried, but it didn’t thrive. I finished it out of spite. 🔪 1 Knife – “I was the real victim.” This book committed crimes against suspense. I want my time back and possibly a refund on my trust in humanity. 🗡️ Bonus Rating: The Unhinged Dagger – “What did I just read and why do I want more?” Check it out on Goodreads Check it out on Fable Buy it On Amazon Buy it from BAM We do not own rights to this book or any material related to it. The opinions we share, are our own and have been gleaned from reading this book. Keywords The Bookish Rewind, Fiction, Book Review, Podcast, Character Analysis, Plot Twists, Book Discussion, relationships, character dynamics, plot complexity, literature, TBR, Bunny, Mona Awad, dark academia, unreliable narrator, horror, fantasy

    48 min

About

The Bookish Rewind is like hitting “rewind” on your favorite reads with your two book-obsessed besties. Each episode, we gossip our way through buzzy bestsellers, fresh new releases, and fan-picked gems—sprinkled with inside jokes, dramatic sighs, and the occasional plot rant. Basically, it’s your TBR… unhinged.