The Dr. Junkie Show

Benjamin Boyce

The Dr. Junkie Show is a podcast hosted by addicted person, convicted criminal, prison educator and college educator Ben Boyce. Topics include drugs and those who use them, media, and communication, along with an overall focus on systems of power.

  1. 3d ago

    180: Morality, Monogamy, and Alasdair MacIntyre's "Moral View from Nowhere"

    This week I get person and talk about a recent conversation I found myself in with some new friends at a prison education conference. We talked about morality, utilitarianism, monogamy and feminism, and as our conversation played out, someone overheard it and jumped in, pointing out that we were doing what MacIntyre has described as acting like we are taking a "view from nowhere," which MacIntyre says doesn't exist (and Thomas Nagel agreed, but not until 5 years later in 1986). And they were both right, but I had to think about what the stranger said for a few days before it clicked and I had one of those moments we've all had: "dammit, why didn't I say that?!?"  Sam Harris has done a lot of work explaining why we need not take a "moral view from nowhere" to claim that some things are moral and others are not, but we do have to pull ourselves up by the bootstraps, so to speak, and choose some basic framework for where to start, and since there are so many of us, and since we agree on so little, Harris says we ought to start with things that almost everyone agrees on. As conscious creatures, that means we have to go with the concept of a "good life," or maximizing the well being and minimizing the suffering of conscious creatures. Why? Because we are conscious creatures, and as far as we can tell, all conscious creatures experience both suffering and well-being, and as far as we know all conscious creatures prefer well-being to suffering. Therefore we ought to (from an is--wink, wink, David Hume) work to maximize well-being and to minimize suffering of conscious creatures since we are conscious creatures. Intro/Outro audio from He Said/She Said (1991) and Trainwreck (2023). Image from Fremont St., Las Vegas ;) Support the show

    180: Morality, Monogamy, and Alasdair MacIntyre's "Moral View from Nowhere"

Ratings & Reviews

5
out of 5
3 Ratings

About

The Dr. Junkie Show is a podcast hosted by addicted person, convicted criminal, prison educator and college educator Ben Boyce. Topics include drugs and those who use them, media, and communication, along with an overall focus on systems of power.

You Might Also Like