Why Commissions Didn't Fix Our Sales Problem

What if your sales problem isn't your people — but the system they're stuck in? Mike Carr spent years doing what everyone told him to do: commissions, quotas, performance plans. Every new hire came with the quiet assumption they'd be gone in a few months. He even optimized onboarding to make firing faster.

Then he did the math: it was costing ~$75,000 every time. He called it "Burning the Porsche."

His friend Travis Timmons — who'd been applying Deming's principles — kept nudging him to look at it differently. Mike's first reaction? "This is crazy talk."

In this episode, they walk through what changed, what didn't work at first, and why the biggest shift wasn't the system — it was the psychology. If you've ever felt stuck trying to fix your salespeople, this will change how you think about it.

TRANSCRIPT

0:00:02.2 Andrew Stotz: My name is Andrew Stotz and I'll be your host as we dive deeper into the teachings of Dr. W. Edwards Deming. Today we have an interesting discussion. I'm going to be continuing my discussion with Travis Timmons, who we've been talking about all kinds of things, including offsites, which I've found very, very valuable. I know the listeners have, too. But we're also joined by Michael Carr, who is a business owner who found the teachings of Dr. Deming about 10 years ago and has been trying to implement it ever since. Why don't we kick it off with you, Travis? Tell us a little bit about how you came across Michael and what your relationship's been like over these years.

0:00:43.5 Travis Timmons: Yeah, thanks, Andrew. Great to be here again. Yeah, Mike and I met, I'll say it's probably 14 years ago, something like that. 13, 14 years ago, a business organization he and I were both part of and sat around a table of other business owners working on problems together. And long story short, and part of the problem solving, got to know Mike a little better and had some individual conversations about how Dr. Deming and the Deming approach was having such a positive impact on my business. Might be of interest to some of the things he was working on in his. And encouraged him to attend the Deming two and a half day. But that's kind of how we met, working on business problems together, having some of the same frustrations that even though we're in different industries, the problems seem to look eerily similar across businesses. So, yeah, that's kind of how he and I met and encouraged him to maybe explore Deming and see if it'd have a positive impact on him like it did for us.

0:01:49.2 Andrew Stotz: We were talking before we turned on the microphone about the idea of how do we reach the young man or woman out there who's looking for answers. And we know Deming has a lot of those answers. So I'm really interested to learn more about you, Mike, about not only, of course, your Deming journey, but maybe tell us a little bit about your business and your experience so people can kind of put you in context, in particular where they are and thinking about where you are and where you were.

0:02:17.8 Mike Carr: Sure. Yeah. I came into business about 25 years ago and I did it kind of accidentally where while I was in grad school, I started a campus chapter of Habitat for Humanity and I had more volunteers than I could handle. So over a weekend, I wrote a small piece of software to let people kind of sign up online. This is before the days of SaaS and everything that we're used to today. And that actually took off so quickly that I was supporting it for free, I was giving it away for free to other organizations - nonprofits. And eventually my wife said, this is taking so much of your time, you either need to start charging for it or shut it down and spend some more time with the family. So I quit my full-time job at the time, put all my effort on what became the business, and quickly found myself running a business with no business background or training because my training was in electrical engineering. So I hired my first salesperson and not knowing sort of how traditional business works, I hired the person on salary, fixed salary, and sort of set up a system for her to sell within.

0:03:39.3 Mike Carr: And again, not knowing Deming, not having any business background. And so I kind of accidentally set up sales the way Deming would have recommended because that's just what I thought made sense. Then later on hired a director of sales who had a lot of success in sales, but traditional sales, and he seemed to know what he was talking about. So we completely switched our sales to more of a traditional sales approach based on his recommendation. And that's when problems really started. Because as we're aware on everyone on the call here, the commissions, quotas, and that kind of thing cause a lot of unintended consequences. So at the time that I met Travis in the peer group that we belong to, I was having a lot of issues with sales. I couldn't figure out how to get sales to work. We were hiring and firing people rapidly. And Travis mentioned Deming to me and the Deming two and a half day training which I attended. And I had become so steeped in traditional sales at that time that after the training I literally said, this is crazy talk, this Deming stuff.

0:04:55.4 Mike Carr: It doesn't align at all with traditional sales techniques. But I gave it a shot and over the next year or two we started implementing it. We started trying things. I kept learning about Deming and at some point I realized this is actually the way I was doing it in the beginning when things were actually kind of working back then. So it was funny how I had come full circle from where I had started.

0:05:23.0 Andrew Stotz: And plenty of people that are listening have commission-based salespeople, bonus incentives, all kinds of different things. And they're like, that's the way you do it and the problems that you face are just part of it. And they couldn't see any other way. And it's way too much risk in their mind to even experiment with another way. So what were the problems that you were facing when you talked about I was facing these problems from the way I was compensating my salespeople? I want to make sure that we connect with people who are like... I don't want someone to say, well, that's not me. I want someone to understand exactly the problems that you were facing and then so they can think, okay, yeah, I probably have that problem.

0:06:11.7 Mike Carr: Right. So it was a lot of... So I'll describe sort of the sequence that we would go through. We would hire someone who seemed really qualified. We would give them a day or two of training, we would give them a telephone and a computer, and we would say, "Okay, you've been trained, you have the equipment, go do some hunting and get some sales," and basically leave them alone to go and do that. Of course, they would sort of rapidly fail because they didn't have the support they needed. They didn't have a system to work within. And so we would start applying pressure, we would start messing with compensation and apply incentives, and then we eventually get to a PIP, a performance improvement plan, and then we would eventually let them go and then do all the offboarding and then start from square one. And we did that so many times that we actually started optimizing our process for rapid hiring and firing. At one point, I moved to these thin client PCs so that we didn't even have to send an entire PC to the person.

0:07:25.7 Mike Carr: We could just send the thin client and put their desktop up in the cloud so that when we had to fire them later, it was just a lot quicker to get all your equipment back. So we optimized for that rapid hiring and firing, and we were literally going into most hires with the assumption we're going to fire this person within a couple of months. And so obviously you can imagine the stress that creates for the person we hired, obviously, but also stress on the part of management because we're just constantly failing all the time. Not to mention the business isn't getting revenue and we're missing all the opportunity that we could be capturing. So one day I said to the management team, let's add up how much it costs us to go through this entire cycle beginning to end in terms of man-hours and salary and so forth and missed opportunity. And the number we arrived at was something like $75,000. 75,000 to $100,000 every time we go through the loop. And so to put this in context, I said to the team, this is as if we had gone and bought a Porsche and then just poured gasoline all over it and lit it on fire every time we go through the loop. So I started calling it Burning the Porsche. Let's just burn the Porsche again, guys. And so we got to call it Burning the Porsche. We were optimizing for rapid hire and fire, and obviously stress levels on all sides were just skyrocketing. So those were the problems that we were facing.

0:09:10.0 Andrew Stotz: And I can hear a skeptical person say, oh, you just didn't know about how to train. I know how to train my salespeople, and I put them through this intense training, then I apply all those incentives and it works. What do you say to that?

0:09:27.4 Mike Carr: So, yeah, we tried all of those things. So we gave them piles and piles of written materials, we made training videos, and of course we wanted to hold them accountable for those things. So we had quizzes at the end of each training section, and assuming they passed the quiz, which was five or 10 questions, written questions, we would check the box. And we would later, when they began to fail, we would point back at the checkboxes from the training and say, "Hey, you were trained on this. We checked the box. Why are you not doing the things that you were trained on and the box was checked?" So, yeah, we tried a lot of different varieties of training and different accounta