Polyphonic Press - Classic Album Reviews

Jeremy Boyd & Jon VanDyk
  • 0.0 (0)
  • MUSIC COMMENTARY
  • UPDATED WEEKLY

Polyphonic Press is the show for music fans. Anywhere from the casual listener to the nerdiest of audiophiles. Each week, we review a classic album from a curated list of over one thousand releases, spanning multiples genres. At the top of each show, we have no idea what album we’re going to listen to. So we fire up the Random Album Generator and it gives the album of the week. Join us every Tuesday morning for a new classic album to discover!

  1. Dry by PJ Harvey: The Gritty 1992 Album That Changed Indie Rock

    3 DAYS AGO

    Dry by PJ Harvey: The Gritty 1992 Album That Changed Indie Rock

    Dry (1992) is PJ Harvey’s fierce and arresting debut album—an explosive arrival that instantly set her apart from every other voice in early ’90s alternative rock. Recorded with her original trio (Rob Ellis and Steve Vaughan), the album is raw, unvarnished, and emotionally unfiltered, driven by jagged guitars, stark arrangements, and Harvey’s commanding, shape-shifting vocals. Thematically, Dry plunges into desire, bodily autonomy, vulnerability, and power, often flipping traditional gender roles on their head. Songs like “Dress” expose the expectations placed on women with biting wit, while “Sheela-Na-Gig” merges mythology and sexuality into something both confrontational and darkly humorous. Throughout the album, Harvey wields minimalism like a weapon—the production is rough, the edges deliberately frayed, making every lyric and every tremor in her voice hit with greater force. Despite (or because of) its grit, Dry sounds remarkably self-assured for a debut. It’s visceral, urgent, and unafraid of messy emotions, introducing PJ Harvey as an artist who wouldn’t just push boundaries—she would explode them. Over time, the album has come to be seen as one of the defining statements of ‘90s indie rock and a blueprint for countless artists who followed. Website Support the show on Patreon Contact

    30 min
  2. So by Peter Gabriel: How an Avant-Rock Outsider Made a Pop Classic

    02/12/2025

    So by Peter Gabriel: How an Avant-Rock Outsider Made a Pop Classic

    Peter Gabriel’s So is one of the most iconic art-pop albums of the 1980s, a record that blends emotional vulnerability, ambitious production, and global musical influences into something both personal and cinematic. After years of being known as the “enigmatic” former Genesis frontman—dabbling in experimental textures, avant-rock, and political themes—Gabriel pivoted toward a more accessible yet deeply crafted sound with So. The result was a creative crossroads where pop hooks met worldbeat rhythms, and cutting-edge studio techniques met soulful songwriting. At its heart, So is an album about connection—romantic, spiritual, and human. You can hear it in the yearning “In Your Eyes,” the playful and sensual “Sledgehammer,” the haunted introspection of “Red Rain,” and the grief-stricken storytelling of “Don’t Give Up,” his duet with Kate Bush. The album pairs emotional depth with sonic brilliance: meticulously layered percussion, innovative sampling, and a wide palette of instruments from horns to synthesizers to traditional African rhythms. So also marked Gabriel’s breakthrough into the mainstream, supported by visually groundbreaking music videos—especially “Sledgehammer,” which became a cultural phenomenon thanks to its stop-motion innovation. But the album remains far more than its singles. Its sequencing, flow, and emotional arc make it a cohesive, immersive listen that still feels fresh decades later. In short: So is a rare achievement—an art-rock album that became a pop classic without compromising its intelligence, experimentation, or emotional honesty. If you’re exploring the most enduring albums of the ’80s, this one is essential. Website Support the show on Patreon Contact

    37 min
  3. #1 Record by Big Star: The Blueprint for Power Pop

    25/11/2025

    #1 Record by Big Star: The Blueprint for Power Pop

    Released in 1972, #1 Record is the debut album by Big Star, a band from Memphis, Tennessee that blended British Invasion melodies with Southern soul and jangly guitar pop. Though it wasn’t a commercial success upon release, the album became one of the most influential records in rock history — laying the groundwork for what would later be called power pop. Led by Alex Chilton (formerly of The Box Tops) and Chris Bell, the album is full of shimmering harmonies, chiming guitars, and bittersweet lyrics about youth, love, and longing. Songs like “The Ballad of El Goodo”, “Thirteen”, and “When My Baby’s Beside Me” showcase the band’s knack for melody and emotional depth, while tracks such as “Feel” and “Don’t Lie to Me” add a raw rock edge. Despite glowing reviews, poor distribution from their label, Ardent Records (through Stax), meant #1 Record didn’t reach a wide audience at the time. However, its influence can be heard in countless bands that followed, including R.E.M., The Replacements, Teenage Fanclub, and Wilco. Today, it’s celebrated as a cornerstone of American pop-rock, a perfect mix of heartache and harmony that captures both the innocence and melancholy of early 1970s youth. Website Support the show on Patreon Contact

    27 min
  4. London Calling by The Clash: Punk Rebellion Meets Rock Revolution

    18/11/2025

    London Calling by The Clash: Punk Rebellion Meets Rock Revolution

    A bass-smashing cover. Nineteen tracks that refuse to sit still. And a city’s pulse pressed into vinyl. We spin The Clash’s London Calling and pull apart why this double album still feels urgent, generous, and wildly playable decades later. From the title track’s warning siren to the upbeat surprise of Train in Vain, we follow the thread that ties punk grit to ska bounce, reggae sway, and power-pop shine without losing the band’s core fire. We take you into late-70s Britain—recession, unrest, and a hungry band rehearsing in near squalor—where cross-pollination with Jamaican sound systems and club culture shaped the record’s muscle and movement. You’ll hear how sequencing keeps the double LP lean, why Lost in the Supermarket hits harder as life gets pricier, and how Clampdown proves that urgency and musicianship can coexist. We also unpack the Guy Stevens sessions that chased chaos for feel, the Elvis-referencing cover that nods at lineage while smashing through it, and the band’s decision to price a double album like a single to keep the music accessible. Along the way, we argue for favourite cuts—Brand New Cadillac, Spanish Bombs, Clampdown—track early hip-hop echoes in The Guns of Brixton, and explain how that unlisted closer became a signature. If you love music history, genre-blending, or records that meet the moment, this is a deep, spirited listen that makes the case for London Calling as more than a classic: it’s a living document of rebellion, craft, and community. Subscribe for more classic album dives, share with a friend who needs this record in their life, and leave a review to help other music fans find the show. What are your top three tracks from London Calling? What did you think of this album? Send us a text! Support the show Website Contact Website Support the show on Patreon Contact

    37 min
  5. Skylarking by XTC: Studio Perfection and Pastoral Pop Genius

    11/11/2025

    Skylarking by XTC: Studio Perfection and Pastoral Pop Genius

    Released in 1986, Skylarking stands as one of XTC’s most celebrated and cohesive works—a shimmering, pastoral pop masterpiece that marries the band’s sharp songwriting with lush, orchestral production. Produced by Todd Rundgren, the album was conceived as a conceptual song cycle tracing the arc of an English summer’s day, paralleling the stages of life from youthful innocence to adult disillusionment and beyond. The music is a sun-dappled blend of baroque pop, psychedelia, and classic British songwriting, evoking the melodic sophistication of The Beatles, The Beach Boys, and The Kinks while remaining distinctly XTC in tone and wit. Songs like “Grass” and “Season Cycle” celebrate nature’s rhythms and sensuality, while “Dear God” (originally a B-side, later a U.S. hit) offers biting social commentary and existential questioning. Lyrically, frontman Andy Partridge and bassist Colin Moulding explore themes of love, faith, time, and the bittersweet beauty of everyday life. Rundgren’s layered arrangements give the album a continuous, almost cinematic flow—each track melting into the next like scenes in a pastoral dream. Over time, Skylarking has been reappraised as one of the finest British albums of the 1980s, and many fans regard it as XTC’s crowning achievement—a radiant and wistful meditation on life, nature, and the passage of time. What did you think of this album? Send us a text! Support the show Website Contact Website Support the show on Patreon Contact

    36 min
  6. Eat a Peach by The Allman Brothers Band: Southern Rock’s Bittersweet Triumph

    04/11/2025

    Eat a Peach by The Allman Brothers Band: Southern Rock’s Bittersweet Triumph

    The Allman Brothers Band’s Eat a Peach (1972) is both a celebration of their fiery Southern rock sound and a poignant farewell to founding guitarist Duane Allman, who died in a motorcycle accident during its recording. The album is a hybrid of studio tracks, live performances, and unfinished sessions completed after Duane’s passing, making it both a tribute and a continuation of the band’s momentum. Musically, it captures the group at their creative peak: blending blues, rock, country, and jazz with extended improvisations. The live centerpiece, the 33-minute “Mountain Jam,” showcases the band’s jam-band ethos, while songs like “Melissa” and “Ain’t Wastin’ Time No More” reveal a more reflective, personal side in the wake of tragedy. Studio tracks such as “Blue Sky,” written and sung by Dickey Betts, bring a bright optimism that counterbalances the album’s sense of loss. The title, famously drawn from Duane’s offhand comment that “every time I’m in Georgia, I eat a peach for peace,” adds to the record’s bittersweet aura. Eat a Peach became both a commercial success and a symbolic turning point, solidifying the Allman Brothers as pioneers of Southern rock while memorializing the spirit of a fallen bandmate. What did you think of this album? Send us a text! Support the show Website Contact Website Support the show on Patreon Contact

    32 min
  7. Live Through This by Hole: Catharsis and Riot Grrrl Rage

    28/10/2025

    Live Through This by Hole: Catharsis and Riot Grrrl Rage

    Live Through This (1994) by Hole is a raw, emotionally charged album that captures the turbulent spirit of the 1990s alternative rock scene. Released just a week after the death of Kurt Cobain and only months before the tragic passing of bassist Kristen Pfaff, the record is both deeply personal and culturally resonant. Courtney Love’s fierce vocals cut through layers of punk aggression and melodic grunge, blending rage, vulnerability, and biting wit in equal measure. The album balances abrasive guitar riffs with surprisingly hook-laden choruses, offering anthems that swing between chaotic catharsis and melodic accessibility. Songs like “Miss World” and “Violet” tear into themes of identity, femininity, and self-destruction, while tracks such as “Doll Parts” expose raw longing and fragility. Its lyrics dissect beauty standards, fame, and the dark undercurrents of love and loss, giving the record a confrontational yet deeply human edge. Often hailed as Hole’s defining work, Live Through This stands as one of the most significant feminist statements in rock. It pushed grunge into more emotionally complex territory, resonating with listeners who saw themselves in Love’s unapologetic anger and aching vulnerability. Today, it’s remembered not just as Hole’s breakthrough but as a landmark alternative rock album of the 1990s. Website Support the show on Patreon Contact

    35 min
  8. Scum by Napalm Death: Grindcore’s Explosive Genesis

    21/10/2025

    Scum by Napalm Death: Grindcore’s Explosive Genesis

    Scum by Napalm Death is one of the most important and influential extreme metal albums ever released. Put out in 1987 on Earache Records, it’s widely regarded as the birth point of grindcore—a genre that fused the speed and aggression of hardcore punk with the heaviness and brutality of death and thrash metal. The record is notorious for its breakneck pace, chaotic song structures, and vocals that veer between guttural growls and high-pitched screams. The album is split into two distinct halves, reflecting its unusual recording process. The first side was recorded in 1986 with one lineup, featuring Nik Bullen on bass and vocals, Justin Broadrick on guitar, and Mick Harris on drums. The second side was recorded in 1987 with a nearly completely different lineup—Lee Dorrian on vocals, Jim Whitely on bass, Bill Steer on guitar, and again Mick Harris on drums—cementing Napalm Death as more of a collective than a stable band at that time. Despite the lineup shift, both halves share a relentless energy and uncompromising approach to sound. Scum is also famous for its brevity and intensity: most songs clock in under two minutes, and the album’s most notorious track, “You Suffer,” runs just 1.316 seconds, earning it a Guinness World Record. Its raw production, politically charged lyrics, and uncompromising extremity made it an underground classic, inspiring countless metal and hardcore bands and shaping the blueprint for grindcore as a genre. Website Support the show on Patreon Contact

    31 min
See All (116)

Trailer

About

Polyphonic Press is the show for music fans. Anywhere from the casual listener to the nerdiest of audiophiles. Each week, we review a classic album from a curated list of over one thousand releases, spanning multiples genres. At the top of each show, we have no idea what album we’re going to listen to. So we fire up the Random Album Generator and it gives the album of the week. Join us every Tuesday morning for a new classic album to discover!

Information