301 episodes

We are a pair of normal chicks who love to talk about abnormal things. We're intrigued by things that go bump in the night and the real life monsters who live among us. Join us every week as we creep it real with our style of conversational storytelling. Each episode will have one story of true crime and one of the paranormal variety.
Creep it real, and don't get scared!

A Paranormal Chicks A Paranormal Chicks

    • True Crime
    • 4.4 • 43 Ratings

We are a pair of normal chicks who love to talk about abnormal things. We're intrigued by things that go bump in the night and the real life monsters who live among us. Join us every week as we creep it real with our style of conversational storytelling. Each episode will have one story of true crime and one of the paranormal variety.
Creep it real, and don't get scared!

    EP 161 - NOT YOUR AVERAGE JOE

    EP 161 - NOT YOUR AVERAGE JOE

    In Baltimore, Joe Metheny gets broken up with, and his son gets put into the foster care system. According to Joe, this is the fuel for the killing spree he went on, but is that really true? And how many people did he actually kill? Plus, find out why Joe is sometimes known as “the cannibal”.

    Donna’s story starts at 49:14 – she takes us to Octagon Hall near Franklin, Kentucky. Octagon Hall is not your average house, for one thing, as the name suggests, the two-story house is built with eight si

    • 1 hr 18 min
    Sinister Sightings - EP105

    Sinister Sightings - EP105

    What would you do if there was a guy doing drugs in your pizza restaurant? What about if you went on a class trip to a haunted house? Or if there was a corner of your house you just couldn’t look at? Well, there’s all that and more in this weeks episode of sinister Sightings. These are your real experiences with true crime and the paranormal.

    • 1 hr 10 min
    EP 160 - SMALL TOWN MURDERS

    EP 160 - SMALL TOWN MURDERS

    “Why did you take me from my other family?” What do you do when your son insists he has had another family and can recount details about his past life and his other family? Well if you’re Rachel, you hunt them down and try and re-connect them.

    Kerri’s story starts at 36:41 - It’s set in the small town of Iola, Kansas in 1982 where an uncharacteristically large number of murderers are happening. Bodies are dumped, drowned, stabbed and raped. But just how many of them are Nathanial “Yorkie”

    • 1 hr 16 min
    Sinister Sightings - EP104

    Sinister Sightings - EP104

    There’s a lot going on in this weeks episode of Sinister Sightings, not only do Dolly Parton and Zac Effron feature, but there are also stories of haunted houses and messages from lost loved ones. Sinister Sightings are your real experiences with true crime and the paranormal.

    • 54 min
    EP 159 - THE HART OF THE ISSUE

    EP 159 - THE HART OF THE ISSUE

    Nelson Hart has suffered from seizures for most of his life. On August 4 2002 Hart blames his seizures for not knowing how his two daughters ended up drowning in Gander Lake.

    Donnas story starts at 1:16:31 and takes place in London…. Ohio. Keith and Diane Williams move with their daughter into their dream home, a small cabin in the woods. But soon they start to see strange glowing eyes in the woods beyond.

    • 1 hr 51 min
    Sinister Sightings - EP103

    Sinister Sightings - EP103

    What's worse than a haunted house? Maybe it's the things that your ex get up to once you've broken up? Or maybe it's your kid's creepy imaginary friend? Either way, it's all in this episode of Sinister Sightings, your true crime and true paranormal experiences.

    • 1 hr 13 min

Customer Reviews

4.4 out of 5
43 Ratings

43 Ratings

skairdykat ,

Creeping me sane through the covid-19 pandemic!

I cannot get enough of these two beautiful ladies.
I discovered their podcast in the latter half of 2020 and they’ve kept me entertained throughout the current pandemic with their creepy stories and wonderful wit! I’m working my way through sinister sightings episodes (which are so so good!) then I’m going to start on their other episodes. Which I’m sure are awesome as well!
Creep it real ladies!

cdwag7 ,

Even from across the water

Can not get enough of this podcast! The girls and the community they have formed because of this podcast has made me feel included and I’m free across the water... Love you Donna and Keri you both are amazing x

me25572048 ,

I love this podcast

I absolutely love this podcast. I love their funny friend chat just as much as the stories, I honestly think it’s one of my faves I’ve ever listened to. Keep up the good work, ladies.

Top Podcasts In True Crime

Listeners Also Subscribed To