Cigar Caucus

Sen. Tim Hutchinson

Welcome to The Cigar Caucus, a space for civil discourse hosted by former U.S Senator Tim Hutchinson. With warmth and wit, Tim explores legacy, faith, and friendship, offering a personal glimpse into politics. Join him for thoughtful conversations that shape our lives and nation. Origins of the Cigar Caucus ​ It started a decade ago—not in hearing rooms or campaign offices, but on porches and patios where a handful of us gathered for two simple pleasures: good cigars and good conversation. Politics brought us together, but once the cigars were lit, labels faded. Republicans, Democrats, Libertarians, veterans of campaigns and those who avoided them—we became just friends swapping stories over a slow-burning leaf. ​ We talked about everything from tax policy to SEC football, foreign affairs to the best way to light a Churchill on a windy night. Occasionally we even solved the world’s problems, at least until someone had to leave to pick up grandkids. Then COVID hit. The world shut down, and so did our circle—briefly. But the camaraderie was too strong to lose. We moved to Zoom, lighters flickering on camera, and the surprising thing was this: the group didn’t shrink. It grew. ​ Today the Cigar Caucus stretches from New Hampshire to Florida. The geography changed, but the spirit didn’t. We still disagree, sometimes fiercely, but always with humor, respect, and the understanding that friendship outruns faction. In a divided time, the Cigar Caucus is a quiet rebellion—proof that civil discourse isn’t gone. It’s just enjoying a good cigar.

  1. 5 days ago

    Hope Is an Action: Todd Deatherage on Empathy, Reconciliation, and Mutual Flourishing

    The conversation explores Todd Deatherage’s upbringing in Fifty-Six, Arkansas, and how his small-town roots shaped his life and career. Todd discusses his transition from teaching to politics, his experiences working as a district director, and the lessons he learned while serving as chief of staff to U.S. Senator Tim Hutchinson. He also reflects on his transition to the U.S. Department of State and shares insights from working with Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice. The conversation then turns to decision-making, building consensus, understanding the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, and the founding of the Telos Group. Todd explains the idea of mutual flourishing, discusses leading influential trips to Israel and Palestine, and shares how Telos expanded its work into racial reconciliation. He also offers thoughtful perspectives on confronting despair, cultivating curiosity and empathy, and maintaining hope while addressing deeply complex issues. Takeaways Growing up in a small town can have a lasting influence on a person’s life and career.Todd’s path took him from teaching to politics and eventually to international diplomacy.His time as chief of staff taught him valuable lessons about leadership and decision-making.Working at the State Department provided unique insight into diplomacy and consensus-building.Empathy and understanding are essential when addressing complex conflicts.Curiosity allows us to better understand people with different experiences and perspectives.Hope is an action—not merely an emotion—and can become a powerful force for positive change.Chapters 00:00 Introduction to Todd Deatherage02:18 Growing Up in Fifty-Six, Arkansas04:20 Family Roots and Heritage05:38 Lessons from Growing Up in a Small Town07:25 Imagining a Journey Beyond Fifty-Six08:48 Transition from Teaching to Politics11:09 Interactions with Constituents as District Director13:40 Town Hall Meetings and Memorable Experiences14:49 Becoming Chief of Staff to Senator Tim Hutchinson17:25 Lessons Learned as Chief of Staff23:30 Transition to the U.S. Department of State26:30 Working with Condoleezza Rice27:28 Decision-Making and Consensus28:59 Understanding the Israeli-Palestinian Conflict31:25 The Birth of the Telos Group34:48 The Principle of Mutual Flourishing38:01 Leading Trips to Israel and Palestine41:27 Expanding into Racial Reconciliation45:51 Handling Despair and Discouragement48:44 Cultivating Curiosity and Empathy

  2. 18 Aug

    Beyond the Campaign Trail with Roby Brock

    Roby Brock, a journalist and analyst, shares insights on his upbringing, political attraction, and experiences working with Bill Clinton and Governor Tucker. He also discusses the changes in political campaigns over the years. The conversation covers a wide range of topics, including leadership traits, political campaigns, the impact of social media on the media landscape, and the revitalization of local community newspapers. Roby Brock's career is characterized by a commitment to community building and civic engagement. Takeaways Political attraction and influenceChanges in political campaigns Decisiveness and authenticity are key leadership traits that transcend political affiliations.Understanding where votes are and how to mobilize them is crucial for the success of political campaigns.The rise of social media has transformed the media landscape, leading to the demise of printed newspapers and the proliferation of misinformation.Revitalizing local community newspapers is essential for preserving the fabric of small communities and promoting civic engagement. Chapters 00:00 Early Life and Political Attraction02:56 Changes in Political Campaigns05:48 Working with Bill Clinton09:11 Advanced Work for President Clinton17:31 Working for Governor Tucker20:57 Leadership Traits: Decisiveness and Authenticity24:31 Success Factors in Political Campaigns28:41 Impact of Social Media on the Media Landscape35:58 Revitalizing Local Community Newspapers43:03 Commitment to Community Building and Civic Engagement

  3. 21 Jul

    Bob McEwen: How America Won the Cold War—and What's at Stake Today

    Bob McEwen shares his upbringing in Ohio, his passion for America, and his involvement in the end of the Cold War. He also discusses the impact of socialism and communism, the changes in Congress, and the decline of civility in politics. The conversation covers a range of topics including patriotism, storytelling, economics, faith, education, and the future of the conservative movement. Bob McEwen shares insights on the importance of patriotism, the lost art of storytelling, the impact of economics on society, the role of faith in public service, the state of education, and the future of the conservative movement. Takeaways Ohio's influence on Bob McEwen's upbringingBob McEwen's passion for America and anti-communismThe decline of civility in Congress and the impact of socialism and communism Patriotism and love for one's country are essential for the success and prosperity of a nation.Storytelling is a powerful tool in politics and public communication, helping to make complex topics more relatable and engaging.Understanding economics is crucial for making informed decisions and promoting prosperity in society.Faith plays a significant role in shaping public service and leadership, providing a moral compass for decision-making.The state of education and the need to return control to local districts is a concern for the future of the country.The conservative movement faces challenges and divisions, but truth and freedom remain foundational principles for its success. Chapters 00:00 Ohio: Shaping Years and Similarities03:18 Passion for America and Anti-Communism06:14 The End of the Cold War11:01 Impact of Socialism and Communism18:07 Changes in Congress and Decline of Civility21:32 Patriotism and Anti-Americanism23:20 The Power of Storytelling24:17 Understanding Economics and Free Enterprise30:54 The Role of Faith in Public Service34:20 Challenges in Education and the Conservative Movement

About

Welcome to The Cigar Caucus, a space for civil discourse hosted by former U.S Senator Tim Hutchinson. With warmth and wit, Tim explores legacy, faith, and friendship, offering a personal glimpse into politics. Join him for thoughtful conversations that shape our lives and nation. Origins of the Cigar Caucus ​ It started a decade ago—not in hearing rooms or campaign offices, but on porches and patios where a handful of us gathered for two simple pleasures: good cigars and good conversation. Politics brought us together, but once the cigars were lit, labels faded. Republicans, Democrats, Libertarians, veterans of campaigns and those who avoided them—we became just friends swapping stories over a slow-burning leaf. ​ We talked about everything from tax policy to SEC football, foreign affairs to the best way to light a Churchill on a windy night. Occasionally we even solved the world’s problems, at least until someone had to leave to pick up grandkids. Then COVID hit. The world shut down, and so did our circle—briefly. But the camaraderie was too strong to lose. We moved to Zoom, lighters flickering on camera, and the surprising thing was this: the group didn’t shrink. It grew. ​ Today the Cigar Caucus stretches from New Hampshire to Florida. The geography changed, but the spirit didn’t. We still disagree, sometimes fiercely, but always with humor, respect, and the understanding that friendship outruns faction. In a divided time, the Cigar Caucus is a quiet rebellion—proof that civil discourse isn’t gone. It’s just enjoying a good cigar.