Dueling Scalpels

Abhishek Parmar and Corey Campbell

Two surgeons' authentic takes on random things, and sometimes it's funny.

  1. 4 days ago

    Episode 16. Hernia Mesh: Why Technique Matters and It’s Not as Bad as Mosquitos

    Dr. Abhishek Parmar and Dr. Corey Campbell dig into one of the most misunderstood parts of hernia surgery: mesh. They break down what a hernia actually is, why mesh is usually used, why complications often get blamed on the wrong thing, and how minimally invasive technique changes the risk profile. They also branch into sports hernias, biologic mesh, mesh allergy, and the broader problem of medical myths sticking harder than the facts. Mesh is not as bad as mosquitos.  Key topics  In this episode, Dr. Parmar explains hernias as holes in the abdominal wall and why the tissue is never as strong as it was before the defect formed. Mesh is described as an intentional foreign body that triggers scar tissue, which is the mechanism that helps close and reinforce the defect. The hosts argue that most mesh-related problems are more often tied to technique and patient optimization than to the mesh itself. Dr. Parmar makes the case that chronic pain is a major issue in groin hernia repair, and that suturing can increase nerve injury risk. They compare tissue repair versus minimally invasive mesh repair and discuss why MIS can reduce nerve exposure. The conversation pushes back on the public fear of mesh, noting that bad outcomes are memorable while successful repairs are forgotten. Sports hernia is discussed as a misnomer, often better understood as athletic pubalgia or groin pain in athletes without a true fascial defect. The episode closes by debating biologic vs. bioabsorbable vs. synthetic meshes, highlighting how mesh design has improved over time, especially with macroporous and coated materials, while emphasizing that placement and technique still matter most.  Timestamps  00:00 - Opening banter and guest-style disclaimer jokes  01:50 - Who the hosts would invite as a dream medical guest  03:41 - Why expertise should stay in its lane  06:49 - Today’s topic: hernias and mesh  10:37 - What a hernia is and why mesh is used  11:24 - Why the body reacts to mesh on purpose  12:19 - Why patients compare hernia repair to patching clothing  13:44 - Why groin hernia pain is often the real issue  15:44 - Why chronic pain is usually about nerves and technique  17:52 - The problem with vilifying mesh as the default villain  20:21 - Why mesh got a bad reputation over time  22:55 - Negativity bias and why bad outcomes dominate memory  25:06 - Sports hernia: what it is and what it is not  27:14 - Athletic pubalgia, imaging, and physical therapy first  28:41 - Why some surgeons consider adductor release  31:31 - The sham surgery study and why outcomes can be deceptive  33:32 - What happens if mesh disappeared tomorrow  34:15 - How hernia culture would change without mesh options  39:53 - Rapid-fire opinions on synthetic vs biologic mesh  45:28 - The most important mesh innovation in the last 20 years  46:34 - Coated mesh and why placement matters  48:13 - Robots, mesh placement, and future hernia repair topics  49:25 - Irish goodbye and the end of the episode    Connect with the Hosts:  Abhishek Parmar - LinkedIn Douglas Corey Campbell - X

  2. 1 Sept

    Episode 14. College Football, NIL, and Why the Drama Never Gets Old

    Dr. Abhishek Parmar and Dr. Corey Campbell keep things loose in this episode as they move from podcast housekeeping to a spirited conversation about college football. They dig into why the sport is so entertaining, how NIL has changed the landscape, and why the chaos around rankings, transfers, and conference realignment keeps fans hooked. Abhishek learns it N-I-L and not “nil.” Key topics·       In this episode, Dr. Parmar and Dr. Campbell make the case that college football is uniquely entertaining because it is easy to follow, has fewer games than baseball, and creates higher emotional stakes with fewer data points. ·       Dr. Campbell argues that the sport works because it is a drama machine - full of heroes, villains, and college kids making high-pressure mistakes on a national stage. ·       They discuss how college football functions as a transitional space where young athletes are thrust into adulthood, pressure, and public scrutiny before they are ready. ·       The conversation contrasts college football with the NFL, where the talent level is higher but the outcomes can feel more predictable. ·       They move into NIL, explaining the basic idea that athletes should be able to profit from their name and likeness, while also noting that the system currently feels chaotic and underregulated. ·       They debate possible fixes for the current system, including standardized contracts, transfer rules, and whether a salary cap would make the sport more fair or just entrench the blue bloods. Timestamps00:00 - Podcast intro, compliance jokes, and why physician podcasting is unusual  03:16 - Struggling to find topics and comparing their show to long-running podcasts  05:36 - Why college football is the greatest sport in America  08:52 - Selling college football to non-fans and why fewer games make it easier to follow  09:19 - College kids making mistakes and the appeal of pressure-packed moments  12:08 - Watching young athletes transition into adulthood under public scrutiny  13:55 - College football versus the NFL and why the stakes feel different  17:20 - NIL explained and why it changed the sport  21:11 - Texas Tech as the clearest example of NIL money reshaping a program  24:49 - Should college football use standardized contracts or a residency-style match system?  26:18 - The case for and against a salary cap in college football  27:46 - Transfer portal chaos and the wild west of player movement  30:17 - Nick Saban versus Bear Bryant and what Saban would be like as a surgeon  31:41 - Meeting Nick Saban and the difference between football stakes and surgical stakes  34:56 - Watching kids compete, fail, and rise to the occasion in youth sports  36:19 - Why sports are entertaining: conflict, obstacle, and resolution  39:01 - Conference realignment and why it hurts non-revenue sports  41:58 - Rapid fire: best rivalry, best stadium atmosphere, most hated team  44:04 - Preseason rankings, committee logic, and why rankings still matter  46:21 - Indiana’s surprising ranking and the volatility of preseason expectationsConnect with the Hosts: Abhishek Parmar - LinkedInDouglas Corey Campbell - X

  3. 25 Aug

    Episode 13. “We are Going to Philly.” Leadership in the OR: Vision, Safety, and Managing vs. Leading

    Drs. Corey Campbell and Abhishek Parmar talk about leadership in surgery through the lens of operating room culture, training, and decision-making under pressure. They unpack how surgical leadership differs from management, why clear expectations matter, and how calm, safety-focused communication can shape better outcomes for teams and patients. In this episode, Corey and Abhishek also break down what makes a good OR leader, compare leadership styles, and use real-world examples from aviation, sports, and surgery to show how leaders perform when things go wrong. Key topics We discuss why surgeons are often leaders by default when they enter the operating room, even if they do not think of themselves that way.Corey draws a distinction between leadership and management, arguing that leadership is vision and direction, while management is the technical work of getting people and systems aligned.The conversation explores how toxic teaching can still produce technical skill, but often at the cost of trust, morale, and team performance.Corey describes how better surgical management means setting clear expectations for residents, med students, nurses, and anesthesiology teams before the case starts.Abhishek shares how his approach has shifted toward creating a culture of safety, calm, and predictability so everyone in the room feels comfortable contributing.They use Captain Tammy Joe Schultz and the Southwest Airlines emergency as an example of calm leadership under extreme pressure.They discuss whether yelling in the OR is ever appropriate, settling on the idea that context matters, but personal attacks and humiliation are destructive. Timestamps 00:00 - Cold open 03:01 - Why leadership in surgery is worth talking about 04:09 - Does being a surgeon make you a better leader or a worse one? 05:05 - The “dark side” model of surgical training and anger as fuel 06:53 - Why leadership and management are not the same thing 07:22 - What real management looks like in surgery 09:30 - Abhishek’s early leadership style and why residents said they wanted him “less like Parmar” 11:30 - CEO versus COO: vision versus operations 13:14 - How teams align around a shared vision for a successful operation 14:45 - Examples of excellent OR leadership 15:05 - Building a culture of safety in an intimidating environment 16:37 - Type A versus type B leadership styles in surgery 18:28 - The tradeoffs of being highly meticulous versus relationally trusted 21:06 - Adam Galinsky’s Inspire and the psychology of leadership 22:02 - The Southwest flight emergency and Tammy Joe Schultz’s calm under pressure 23:58 - Visionary, exemplary, mentor: what strong leaders actually do 26:36 - The Costa Concordia captain as the opposite of leadership 29:52 - How surgical leadership changes when things stop going according to plan 31:25 - Why surgery tests leadership more often than routine pilot work 33:00 - Why the pilot analogy breaks down for surgeons 34:49 - Is authoritarian leadership ever appropriate in surgery? 35:05 - Is yelling in the OR ever okay? 37:08 - Parenting, pilots, and why calm communication matters in vulnerable moments 39:49 - When stress, stakes, and incompetence trigger emotion in the OR 41:21 - Nick Saban, Brian Kelly, and what actually makes a great coach or leader 45:07 - Rapid fire: are leaders born or made? 52:48 - Closing jokes and sign-off Connect with the Hosts: Abhishek Parmar - LinkedInDouglas Corey Campbell - X

  4. 18 Aug

    Episode 12. AI in Medicine: Training, Documentation, and the Risks of Overreliance

    This episode of Dueling Scalpels features Dr. Abhishek Parmar and Corey Campbell digging into what AI actually changes in medicine. They focus on where it helps, where it creates risk, and why context, expertise, and accountability still matter. TL:DR: “AI makes you more capable, but it makes you dumber as well.” In this episode: Dr. Parmar and Dr Campbell discuss whether AI makes clinicians more capable or simply more dependent on fast answers.They break down AI use in diagnostics, therapeutics, research, and documentation.Dr. Campbell argues that AI can improve efficiency but may weaken learning, especially for trainees.Dr. Parmar shares how he already uses AI for clinical documentation and why he sees it as a time saver.The two debate whether AI-generated notes, reports, and recommendations create medico-legal risk.They explore which specialties are most exposed to automation, especially radiology and pathologyThey also look at AI-assisted video review in surgery and whether it could help improve performance.The conversation widens into concerns about AI flooding medical research with polished but low-value output. Timestamps (00:00) Opening banter and setting up the episode (01:04) The Odyssey, Greek mythology, and why updates still matter (04:28) Why they wanted to talk about AI in medicine (06:19) Data centers, energy use, and local community costs (10:24) Does AI threaten humanity, or just make people dumber? (11:00) AI, Google, and why easy answers may not stick (12:25) Where AI fits best: diagnostics, therapeutics, and research (13:28) Experience versus machine learning in surgical judgment (15:27) The difference between remembering a task and knowing why to do it (18:24) Using AI for clinical documentation in real practice (20:05) Why medical documentation exists in the first place (21:30) AI-generated police reports and medico-legal concerns (23:02) Final responsibility when AI helps write the note (24:48) Why context and expertise still matter more than raw information (26:11) AI as the internet’s most polished and most unreliable extension (28:21) Which specialties are most at risk from AI (29:50) Self-driving cars and the same accountability problem (31:51) Using AI and video review to score robotic surgery (37:23) Whether AI should be used as a residency gatekeeper (41:37) Rapid fire on AI in medicine, training, and research (44:05) Why good surgeons stay introspective and keep learning (46:21) The disruption from laparoscopic and endovascular transitions (48:03) AI and the risk of flooding research with junk output (51:35) Medical research, truth, and why AI makes that harder (52:46) Closing thoughts Connect with the Hosts: Abhishek Parmar - LinkedInDouglas Corey Campbell - X

  5. 11 Aug

    Episode 11. What's Wrong with Men Today? Exploring Development, Society, and Gender Dynamics

    In this episode, hosts Corey and Abhishek dig into the societal challenges facing men and boys in the 21st century. They cover biological development differences, education gaps, cultural expectations, and the impact of technology on social bonds—highlighting what societal structures could do to support healthier male identities. Key topics: The impact of neurodevelopmental differences between boys and girls, including delayed impulse control in boys and implications for education.The rise of gender disparities in academic performance, especially in the US, with statistics on dropout rates, college enrollment, and postgraduate achievement among Black women versus Black men.The influence of societal expectations and gender roles, including men's diminished sense of purpose as traditional roles evolve.The decline of male friendships and social interactions, partly due to technology and social media reducing meaningful in-person contact.The concept of positive peer pressure and expectations as drivers for self-improvement among men. Timestamps 00:00 - Introducing the episode and the provocative topic of men’s societal struggles 02:00 - Debunking myths about male and female development differences 05:00 - The impact of societal changes on boys’ education and maturation 08:00 - How gender gaps in school performance and expectations are shifting 11:00 - Developmental differences in impulse control and maturity in boys versus girls 14:00 - The influence of social expectations and opportunities on success 17:00 - The rise of women in higher education and the changing landscape for Black men and women 21:00 - The decline of male friendships and its societal implications 27:00 - How technology shifts have reduced human interaction and community building 34:00 - The cultural perception of masculinity and the loss of purpose among men 38:00 - Strategies and ideas for supporting boys and men in a changing world 44:00 - Rapid-fire questions about stereotypes and societal expectations Resources & Links: Atomic Habits by James ClearRichard Reeves - Buy on your local bookstore or onlineThe Center on American Life - Men Friendship SurveyFinnish Education SystemGeorge Gilder on Gender Roles and SocietyThe Stakes of Modern Masculinity - Book or article reference Connect with the Hosts: Abhishek Parmar - LinkedInDouglas Corey Campbell - X

  6. 4 Aug

    Episode 10. Women in Surgery, Generational Shifts, and Future Insights from Dr. Eugenia Kim Page

    Join hosts Dr. Abhishek Barmar and Dr. Corey Douglas Campbell as they continue their discussion with Dr. Jinnie Kim Page, a distinguished board-certified plastic surgeon, for a candid discussion on gender dynamics, surgical artistry, medical training, and the evolving landscape of medicine. This episode offers an illuminating look into the personal and professional journeys shaping the future of healthcare. In this episode: Dr. Jinnie Kim Page's journey from neuroscience to plastic surgeryThe intersection of art, engineering, and medicine in plastic surgeryThe emotional impact of reconstructive vs. cosmetic proceduresHow generational differences influence medical culture and trainingThe challenges of surgical training, including handedness, confidence, and resilienceThe future of general surgery and specialization trendsThe impact of AI, social media, and patient feedback on medical practicePerspectives on work-life balance, gender, and career choice in medicineDiscussions on medical ethics, professionalism, and innovation in the digital age Timestamps: 0:06 — Welcome and the question of talent versus resilience 2:10 — Can surgical skill and confidence be taught? 7:18 — Late bloomers, adversity, and training great surgeons 12:00 — How younger generations may reshape surgical training 19:42 — Is traditional general surgery disappearing? 24:03 — Women in surgery, career flexibility, and work-life balance 28:38 — Rapid-fire: overrated instruments and operating-room preferences 30:44 — Music in the operating room 35:15 — Procedures they’d happily never do again—and advice for residents 36:53 — Plastic surgery myths, liposuction, and the future of the specialty 41:46 — If they weren’t surgeons: alternate careers and closing thoughts   Resources & Links: Spruce AIAtomic Habits by James ClearBrian Johnson's Muscle IntelligenceNate Silver's FiveThirtyEight PodcastMeditations by Marcus AureliusThe Outliers by Malcolm GladwellConnect with Dr. Eugenia Kim Page: Instagram Connect with the Hosts: Abhishek Parmar - LinkedInDouglas Corey Campbell - X

  7. 28 Jul

    Episode 9. Surgical Artistry, Cosmetic Surgery and the Future of Medicine with Dr. Eugenia Kim Page

    Join us as we dive into an engaging chat with Dr. Jinnie Kim Page, a board-certified plastic surgeon with a wealth of experience in reconstructive and cosmetic surgery. We explore her journey from medical school to complex surgeries, her thoughts on surgical artistry, and the evolving landscape of medicine. In this episode: Dr. Page shares her inspiring story of discovering anatomy and falling in love with surgery during med schoolInsights into the artistry of plastic surgery and its visibility to patientsHow patient expectations are managed through communication and shared goalsThe debate over surgical tools and techniques, including microvascular proceduresThe impact of generational differences on training, communication, and professionalismThe future of medical practice in a changing healthcare landscape Timestamps: 00:00 - Introduction to Dr. Jinnie Kim Page and her journey into plastic surgery 02:16 - Transition from neuroscience to anatomy and surgery 04:17 - The intersection of engineering, artistry, and medicine 06:51 - The importance of creativity and troubleshooting in reconstructive surgery 08:19 - Managing patient expectations and the art of aesthetic surgery 12:26 - Training, mentorship, and the evolution of surgical skills 15:33 - Holistic view of plastic surgery: reconstructive vs cosmetic 19:20 - Challenges of transparency and patient reviews in the digital age 23:58 - The future of general surgery and specialized fields like ACS 32:24 - The psychological impact of battling cancer as a surgeon and parent Resources & Links: Spruce AI – AI tool for guest selection and conversation ideasAtomic Habits by James Clear – For personal development insightsBrian Johnson's Optimize – Videos on extending lifespan and healthspan Connect with Dr. Eugenia Kim Page: Instagram Note: This conversation was a deep dive into the complex, evolving world of surgery, highlighting the importance of artistry, resilience, and continuous learning for future surgeons.

About

Two surgeons' authentic takes on random things, and sometimes it's funny.