AFTER SHOW PODCAST

Access our weekly Member’s Only After Show!

£4.99/mo or £49.99/yr after trial

Review That Review with Chelsey and Trey

The Review Queens
  • 0.0 (0)
  • COMEDY
  • UPDATED WEEKLY

A comedy podcast where hosts Chelsey Donn and Trey Gerrald hilariously dissect and debate the wildest, most outrageous reviews across the internet. From 1 Star meltdowns to 5 Star raves, no review is safe! Join the Review Queens for uncensored laughs, surprising insights, and fan-favorite episodes each week.

  1. No Longer Interested + Painful Review

    13/06/2025 · BONUS • SUBSCRIBERS ONLY

    No Longer Interested + Painful Review

    👑 Happy Friday, RoyalSquad! Welcome to the very last After Show Pod. Episode 190 is here—and it’s raw, hilarious, and deeply heartfelt. Chelsey and Trey take one final bow and hold nothing back. Here’s what went down in this emotional finale: 📬 MailChimp Meltdown: Trey reveals the very first unsubscribe from their launch email list—and it came with a shady “no longer interested.” Ouch. 🗣️ Voice Drama Throwback: Chelsey reads a jaw-dropping email from a supposed “fan” who suggested she needed a voiceover artist to replace her voice. Let’s just say… the Queens have thoughts. 🧠 The Impact of Podcasting: From vulnerable moments during creative heartbreak to navigating online feedback and unfiltered opinions, this After Show captures everything that made Review That Review more than just a comedy podcast. 💭 Quote of the Episode: "Please don't be mad at me... but can someone do a voiceover for Chelsey?" – Sarah G 😬 Thank you, RoyalSquad, for riding with us. For the listens, the laughs, and the loyalty. You are the reason we made it to 210 episodes. We love you now and forever. 💖🎤👑

    34 min

  2. 11/06/2025

    210: Finale

    🎙️ Review That Review Episode 210: The Grand Finale👑 The Final Crown: Saying Goodbye After 210 Episodes It’s the end of an era. After 210 episodes of complaints, crowns, and chaos, the Queens are signing off. In this heartfelt and hilarious final episode, Chelsey and Trey reflect on their journey through four years of Review That Review. They answer listener questions, revisit their favorite (and least favorite) moments, and give one last spin on the Meryl-Go-Round. From full-circle emotional callbacks to a spontaneous rendition of the theme song, this final chapter is a love letter to the Queendom. Whether you’ve been here since Episode 1 or just stumbled upon us last week, we are eternally grateful you joined us on this wild ride. Thank you for being part of our story. 💛 ⏰ Timestamps:(00:00:29) Introduction – “It’s Episode 210… and also our final episode.”(00:05:32) How We Really Feel About Ending the Podcast(00:11:40) Reflecting on Our First Reviews(00:18:52) What We’ve Learned + What Surprised Us Most(00:25:47) The Power of Reviews & Listener Impact(00:32:00) What We’re Most Proud Of(00:37:10) Answering Listener Questions(00:45:20) Future Projects & What’s Next(00:52:36) Final Meryl-Go-Round Game(01:01:11) A Thank You to You, Our Royal Queendom(01:05:00) Signing Off... With One Last Crown 👑 🎧 Binge the full archive at: 👉 www.reviewthatreview.com 💥 Stay connected with us: Chelsey: @chelseybd Trey: @treygerrald 🎭 And don’t worry—you haven’t heard the last of us. Be sure to follow us individually for future projects, announcements, and fun surprises. 👀 Enjoyed the episode? Don’t forget to rate and review us on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you listen. Your support helps us grow! 🌟 Prefer to WATCH Your Podcasts? We’ve Got You Covered!If you love seeing reactions, body language, or just enjoy the visual experience of a podcast, we’ve got full video episodes available on YouTube and Spotify! 📺👀 Watching a podcast can sometimes bring out even more humor, insight, and connection. You can see our unfiltered reactions, laugh along with us, and feel like you're right there in the room. Plus, if you're someone who prefers consuming content visually, this is the perfect way to tune in! Watch on YouTube here: Review That Review YouTube ChannelDon’t forget to Subscribe to get notified about new video episodes: Subscribe to YouTube Support the Show: Review The Pod: LoveThePodcast.com/TheReviewQueensDonate: a href="https://www.reviewthatreview.com/donate" rel="noopener noreferrer"...

    1h 33m
  3. Faux Fur Drama + Hostess Cupcake Review

    06/06/2025 · BONUS • SUBSCRIBERS ONLY

    Faux Fur Drama + Hostess Cupcake Review

    👑 Happy Friday, RoyalSquad! Welcome to After Show Pod 189! This week, Chelsey and Trey explore fashion chaos, New York nostalgia, and a deeply suspicious 5 Star Amazon review about, yes, cupcakes. Here’s what went down: 🧁 Cupcake Conspiracy?! A 5 Star Amazon Review claims a pack of 12 Hostess cupcakes arrived intact, on time, and with absolutely no tampering. Sounds normal—until you read it. 🕵️‍♀️ A Little Too Specific... Chelsey and Trey break down the bizarrely detailed assurance that no one injected anything into the frosting. Um... who said they did?! 🧥 Faux Fur Flashbacks: From Craigslist coats to Canal Street chic, Chelsey shares her fuzzy fashion evolution and Trey takes us to a cabaret in a coat with no sleeves. 💭 Quote of the Episode: "I just feel like the more you say it wasn’t tampered with… the more I think it was." – Chelsey 🎧 Tune in for cupcake paranoia, fashion memories, and one extremely sus Hostess review.

    43 min

  4. 04/06/2025

    Monistat - 5 Star Review

    🎙️ Review That Review Episode 209: Monistat – 5 Star Review (??)🍯 Title: 5 Star Yeast Infection Review?! Monistat Gets Crowned?! 👑 Description: This week, the Queens are breaking boundaries—and possibly the internet—with a shockingly positive 5 Star Amazon Review for none other than... Monistat. Yes, the yeast infection treatment. Chelsey bravely takes the lead and walks us through a deeply personal, yet hilariously enthusiastic review that earns both gasps and genuine respect. Before diving into fungal folklore, Trey drops a scorching Lodge A Complaint about stickers on fruit! But the star of the show? A reviewer who turns medical necessity into a glorious tale of victory—complete with awkward metaphors, triumphant conclusions, and a LOT of capital letters. PLUS: A tease of this week’s After Show Pod! ⏰ Timestamps:(00:00:29) Introduction(00:01:19) Lodge A Complaint – Stickers on Fruit(00:06:50) Review Breakdown – 5 Star Review of Monistat(00:24:33) The Verdict(00:27:30) My Royal Highness – Can't Breathe Wheeze!(00:29:08) On This Week’s After Show Pod – Ice Tray Review Enjoyed the episode? Don’t forget to rate and review us on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you listen. Your support helps us grow! 🌟 Prefer to WATCH Your Podcasts? We’ve Got You Covered!If you love seeing reactions, body language, or just enjoy the visual experience of a podcast, we’ve got full video episodes available on YouTube and Spotify! 📺👀 Watching a podcast can sometimes bring out even more humor, insight, and connection. You can see our unfiltered reactions, laugh along with us, and feel like you're right there in the room. Plus, if you're someone who prefers consuming content visually, this is the perfect way to tune in! Watch on YouTube here: Review That Review YouTube ChannelDon’t forget to Subscribe to get notified about new video episodes: Subscribe to YouTube Support the Show: Review The Pod: LoveThePodcast.com/TheReviewQueensDonate: ReviewThatReview.com/DonateJoin Our Patreon: Unlock bonus content, members-only podcast, and more at Patreon.com/reviewthatreview 🎉 Promo Codes: REVIEWQUEEN at clean.emailREVIEW40 at vitable.com.auREVIEWQUEEN at shesbirdie.comREVIEWQUEEN40 at NatalieWeissVoice.comQUEEN15 at SmartPatches.comQUEEN at superchewer.com Stay...

    38 min
  5. Do The Ur-r-r-r-r-urkel! + Penguin Mask Review

    30/05/2025 • SUBSCRIBERS ONLY

    Do The Ur-r-r-r-r-urkel! + Penguin Mask Review

    👑 Happy Friday, RoyalSquad! Welcome to After Show Pod 188! This week, Chelsey and Trey take a nostalgic detour through classic TGIF television before diving beak-first into a 5 Star Review of a… penguin mask? Yup, here’s what went down: 📺 TGIF Throwbacks: The Queens reminisce about Family Matters, Boy Meets World, and how Steve Urkel and The Fonz accidentally hijacked their shows. 🐧 King Penguin Parenting: A 5 Star Amazon Review reveals how one parent uses a giant penguin mask to terrify their children into obedience. Genius? Unhinged? Maybe both. 🧃 Capri Sun Icons & Masked Bedtime Antics: The reviewer’s profile pic is a Capri Sun. Need we say more? 💭 Quote of the Episode: "Whenever they protest bedtime, I whip on the mask. They soon know who is King Penguin." – Randy with an “i” 🎧 Tune in for nostalgia, masked madness, and a new bedtime strategy you didn’t know you needed.

    12 min

  6. 28/05/2025

    Magnolia Bakery - 1 Star Review

    The Queens take a bite out of nostalgia and end up with a mouthful of disappointment. In this episode, Trey presents a scathing 1 Star Yelp Review of NYC’s iconic Magnolia Bakery—specifically the once-revered banana pudding. Is it still worthy of the Sex and the City fame, or has it lost all its flavor? Before the pudding meltdown, Chelsey logs a customer service complaint we all can relate to—being trapped in the purgatory of endless department transfers. Then it’s time for the Review Breakdown, where Chef Earth E. spills the (spoiled?) tea on cupcakes that taste like chemicals, banana pudding made of “whipped air,” and the death of culinary pride. ⏰ Timestamps:(00:01:00) Lodge A Complaint – Endless Customer Service Loops(00:06:48) Review Breakdown – 1 Star Yelp Review of Magnolia Bakery(00:16:09) The Verdict(00:18:00) Magnolia’s Reply Breakdown(00:18:46) My Royal Highness – Perfect Parking Moment(00:22:14) On This Week’s After Show Pod – Penguin Overhead Mask Review Enjoyed the episode? Don’t forget to rate and review us on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you listen. Your support helps us grow! 🌟 Prefer to WATCH Your Podcasts? We’ve Got You Covered!If you love seeing reactions, body language, or just enjoy the visual experience of a podcast, we’ve got full video episodes available on YouTube and Spotify! 📺👀 Watching a podcast can sometimes bring out even more humor, insight, and connection. You can see our unfiltered reactions, laugh along with us, and feel like you're right there in the room. Plus, if you're someone who prefers consuming content visually, this is the perfect way to tune in! Watch on YouTube here: Review That Review YouTube ChannelDon’t forget to Subscribe to get notified about new video episodes: Subscribe to YouTube Support the Show: Review The Pod: LoveThePodcast.com/TheReviewQueensDonate: ReviewThatReview.com/DonateJoin Our Patreon: Unlock bonus content, members-only podcast, and more at Patreon.com/reviewthatreview 🎉 Promo Codes: REVIEWQUEEN at clean.emailREVIEW40 at vitable.com.auREVIEWQUEEN at shesbirdie.comREVIEWQUEEN40 at NatalieWeissVoice.comQUEEN15 at SmartPatches.comQUEEN at superchewer.com Stay Connected: Join the Queendom! Sign up for our mailing list for exclusive updates and content.Leave us a voicemail: 1-850-REVIEW-0 📞 Follow...

    35 min
  7. Parental Tech Support + Spray Bottle Review

    23/05/2025 • SUBSCRIBERS ONLY

    Parental Tech Support + Spray Bottle Review

    👑 Happy Friday, RoyalSquad! Welcome to After Show Pod 187! This week, Chelsey and Trey wade through tech chaos, bathtub hydration, and a spray bottle scandal for the ages. Here’s what went down: 🧴 Stream vs Spray Drama! A 3 Star Amazon Review claims these bottles don’t spray, they stream! But did Chatty Cathy just… not twist the nozzle? 📱 Elder Tech Support Woes: From Zelle to Max.com logins, the Queens recount harrowing (and hilarious) attempts to walk their parents through the modern tech jungle. 🛁 Bathtub Hydration Rituals: Trey drinks gallons of water during baths—like 100+ ounces. Is it extreme, or just brilliant? 💭 Quote of the Episode: "It’s not spraying. It’s only a stream!" – Chatty Cathy (iconic) 🎧 Tune in now for laughter, slight ageism, and an adjustable-nozzle mystery that shakes the RoyalSquad to its core.

    25 min

  8. 21/05/2025

    Neck Massager - 5 Star Review

    Tensions run high as the Queens kvetch about bad drivers in left turn lanes, but the mood quickly softens thanks to a surprise birthday gift from Chelsey to Trey: an electric Shiatsu neck massager! 🎁 While Trey unwraps and tests the massager LIVE on air, Chelsey reads a 5 Star Amazon Review by Jacqueline W., who claims the device is “my new best friend… sorry family.” 💅 With features like heat, deep kneading, and a “Brookstone feel,” this review sends the Queens on a wild ride of satisfaction, skepticism, and vibrating bliss. PLUS: A Royal Highness induction for elevator solitude, and a very relaxed tease for this week’s After Show Pod review. ⏰ Timestamps:00:00 – Intro01:03 – Lodge A Complaint: Signal On, Phone Out, Rage Building06:21 – Review That Review: Shiatsu Massager (Amazon, 5 Stars)10:40 – TREY TURNS ON THE MASSAGER 😳17:20 – The Verdict: Does It Deserve 5 Stars?21:01 – My Royal Highness: The Joy of Riding an Empty Elevator24:12 – This Week’s After Show Preview Enjoyed the episode? Don’t forget to rate and review us on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you listen. Your support helps us grow! 🌟 Prefer to WATCH Your Podcasts? We’ve Got You Covered!If you love seeing reactions, body language, or just enjoy the visual experience of a podcast, we’ve got full video episodes available on YouTube and Spotify! 📺👀 Watching a podcast can sometimes bring out even more humor, insight, and connection. You can see our unfiltered reactions, laugh along with us, and feel like you're right there in the room. Plus, if you're someone who prefers consuming content visually, this is the perfect way to tune in! Watch on YouTube here: Review That Review YouTube ChannelDon’t forget to Subscribe to get notified about new video episodes: Subscribe to YouTube Support the Show: Review The Pod: LoveThePodcast.com/TheReviewQueensDonate: ReviewThatReview.com/DonateJoin Our Patreon: Unlock bonus content, members-only podcast, and more at Patreon.com/reviewthatreview 🎉 Promo Codes: REVIEWQUEEN at clean.emailREVIEW40 at vitable.com.auREVIEWQUEEN at shesbirdie.comREVIEWQUEEN40 at NatalieWeissVoice.comQUEEN15 at SmartPatches.comQUEEN at superchewer.com Stay Connected: Join the Queendom! Sign up for our mailing list...

    32 min
See All (420)

Trailers

About

A comedy podcast where hosts Chelsey Donn and Trey Gerrald hilariously dissect and debate the wildest, most outrageous reviews across the internet. From 1 Star meltdowns to 5 Star raves, no review is safe! Join the Review Queens for uncensored laughs, surprising insights, and fan-favorite episodes each week.

Information