In the final part of this three-part series, Joe Stopulos and Aaron Gunsaulus, a former Christian Reformed pastor from Newton, Iowa, pick up his story at the end of 2024. Aaron had resigned his pastorate, preached his last day on December 31, 2024, and was making his way into the Catholic Church with his wife, Cami. Missed Parts 1 and 2? Find them in the Man Up feed. Highlights from this episode: Why Catholic and not Orthodox: Aaron saw the connection between Isaiah 22 and Matthew 16 on the keys of the kingdom early on. Once he saw the papacy in Scripture, he couldn’t unsee it.The last domino, purgatory: Doctrine was the easy part. Purgatory was his one real struggle until St. Francis de Sales’ The Catholic Controversy explained “baptized for the dead” in 1 Corinthians 15 as suffering offered for the dead. St. Francis de Sales became his confirmation saint.Typology in full color: Aaron already loved seeing the Old Testament fulfilled in the New. The Eucharist and Marian teachings like Mary as the Ark of the Covenant came easily, and Scripture felt new again.“Are we really doing this?”: The day of the Easter Vigil in Cedar Rapids, Aaron, Cami, and their two youngest children made their first confessions and were received into the Church. Aaron says first confession was the moment he looked forward to most, and he still does.The hardest part, Catholic culture: Protestant pastors study their way into the Church. Genuflecting, Catholic vocabulary, and saying “Our Lord” and “Our Lady” take time. His spiritual director still teases him that he talks like a Protestant.The best part, daily Mass and adoration: Adoration felt strange at first. It took experience, not just understanding, to make it part of his rhythm.Nineteen people come home: Friends from his former congregation started asking questions. In October 2025, seventeen of them, plus two reverts, entered the Catholic Church in Newton. That story went viral online.Family: Aaron’s oldest son, now in Des Moines, entered the Church last Easter. Aaron is honest about how hard the decision is for a pastor with six children.Lightning round: Aaron makes the case for Rush as the greatest band ever and for The Lord of the Rings as the greatest story after the Bible, now richer through a Catholic lens.A challenge for every man: Cradle Catholics have been given the pearl of great price. Pull out your Catechism, get to daily Mass or adoration this week, and don’t take the fullness of the faith for granted. Thank you to our sponsors: Construction Professionals: https://cpcustomhomes.com/Iowa Catholic Radio: https://iowacatholicradio.com/Listen to Man Up with Joe Stopulos on the Iowa Catholic Radio Network and at IowaCatholicRadio.com. #ManUp #CatholicConversion #ConversionStory #ComingHome #ProtestantToCatholic #ReformedToCatholic #FormerPastor #Purgatory #Papacy #Eucharist #Adoration #EasterVigil #Confession #StFrancisDeSales #LordOfTheRings #CatholicMen #CatholicDad #CatholicPodcast #IowaCatholicRadio #Iowa #Catholic Listen Live · Program Schedule · Our Stations LINKS You can follow us on Facebook, Instagram, Youtube, Tiktok! More on our website. If you would like to support Iowa Catholic Radio you can donate Here! More from Iowa Catholic Radio: Sunday Dive with Katie PatrizioMan Up! with Joe StopulosCatholic Women Now with Chris Magruder and Julie NelsonThe Uncommon Good with Bo Bonner and Dr. Bud MarrBe Not Afraid with Fr. Fabian Moncada and Fr. Bruce RiebeBe Not Afraid en Español con el P. Fabián MoncadaMaking it Personal with Bishop William JoensenFaith and Family Finance with Gregory WaddleThe Great Men of the Bible with Joe Stopulos Liturgy & Devotions The Daily Gospel Reflection with Fr. Nick SmithThe Daily Mass from St. Francis of AssisiThe Daily Mass from St. Pius XThe Daily Mass from St. TheresaSunday Mass from the Basilica of Saint JohnWant to support your favorite show? Click Here Iowa Catholic Radio - Connecting People to Christ Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.