Do more rap and country

I love this concept and think the hosts are so grumpy and terrific but the editing feels like AI on hyperdrive. It’s ok to have a breath or pause between takes

Genuinely interested in critique. The first episode I listened to of this literally said they had never listened to the music they were critiquing because “they didn’t need to”. They already knew better. There’s more substance in a teaser for an episode of the kardashians than this drivel.

I think they make some good points when they critique artists and their actions, even toxic fan behavior. But they call people who like an artists music idiots. People like what they like and who are they to judge?

Are there any music artists you actually like?

I like the subjects and alternative opinions but the generic prejudices is insanely immature. The little guy literally reminds me of losers that don’t try at anything and mock everyone. Get a personality guy you sound like a drunk sorority girl “like listen to him instead it’s betterrrrr”, boy I could hear you had hand tattoos, man bun, and lms before I googled you and saw you vaping🤣. You can’t attribute a 25year success story to “people just like , go with it…” “it’s total nostalgia” I hate nostalgia baiting and I hate engineered content, like marvel punch lines. But most sales over 20years, maybe have a better view than “sheep”. I’m gunna give em another shot because I wanna hear you guys rip the hipster bands but then you guys put shade on Alice In Chains, Rooster….? That’s a great story about American youth being propagated into the war machine which in this case happens to be his dad… pretty legit, felt, and received.. Find another story this close.

Dudes probably only listen to Jelly Roll

They completely miss the point and delight in critiquing legit musicians. Clearly a couple of bitter failed rock stars.

This show is the breath of fresh air that all the other stale, boring, over rated podcasts should be afraid of.

I’m not sure what this is supposed to be. Is it satire? I’ll admit, I only made it through 15 minutes of the first episode, but based on Cocaine and Rhinestones I was expecting a well researched show that gave solid arguments about why a given band isn’t actually good. I think a well argued case could be put together for any band. I’m a big Beatles fan and I was looking forward to hearing a good take on why they aren’t good, but this just felt like the most basic, unspecific ranting I’ve heard from people in random conversations, who don’t actually know much about music history, which clearly is not the case for Tyler Mahan Coe. Right off the bat they mention that the whole look of the Beatles was crafted by their manager, specifically mentioning their hair. While Epstein did ask them to start wearing suits, the hair was a style John and Paul chose on there own while visiting a friend in France. Epstein had nothing to do with it, and the hair was more essential to the uniqueness of their look than the suits. This is a basic fact that could have been discovered with a simple web search. I’ll give it two stars because their ranting was humorous, but it’s not for me.