The Deductionist Podcast

ben cardall

Look no further, dear listener, for The Deductionist podcast is here to sharpen your deductive skills and blow your mind with its clever insights.Hosted by the charming and enigmatic deductionist himself (HA!) and the Watson of awesomeness! Each episode is a masterclass in observation, deduction, and logic, as they take you on a journey through the mysteries of everyday life.From analyzing crime scenes to decoding the hidden meanings in social interactions, The Deductionist podcast brings a fresh and witty perspective to the art of deduction. With a razor-sharp mind and quick wit...ish, they'll have you hooked from the very first episode.So join us as we explore the secrets of the world around us, and learn how to become a master of deduction like the one and only Deductionist. It's time to uncover the truth and take your deductive skills to the next level. Don't miss a single episode of The Deductionist podcast! Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

  1. 1d ago

    Does NLP Work? What Survives the Evidence

    Bob looks up when he talks. According to NLP, that makes him a liar. Ben Cardall and Bob Pointer give Neuro-Linguistic Programming a fair hearing, keep what holds up and bin what does not. In this episode:- Where NLP came from, and why studying excellent practitioners was a sound idea that got sold as a shortcut- What NLP borrowed from conditioning and cognitive therapy, and why the credit belongs elsewhere- The Meta Model, the part of NLP worth keeping, turned into a three part questioning drill for interviews- Eye accessing cues and representational systems tested, from Christopher Sharpley to Richard Wiseman and Caroline Watt- Three independent evidence reviews of NLP, across psychology, medicine and coaching- Why people swear by NLP anyway, and what Irving Kirsch's expectancy research explains- Where cue reading gets dangerous, and a five question test for any method sold to you next Subscribe, then run the five questions on the last course you paid for. Subscribe to The Deductionist Podcast with Behavioural Intelligence for more Holmesian method applied to the claims you meet every day. Access the free tier or go deeper with exclusive paid challenges: https://www.omniscient-insights.com/axiomhttps://www.omniscient-insights.com/community-home MERCH -- https://the-deductionist.myspreadshop.co.uk/allE-SCAPE GAME -- https://www.youtube.com/@thedeductionistteamEverything else you need -- https://linktr.ee/bencardall Music provided by https://robertjohncollinsmusic.com/` #podcast #nlp #thinking

    Does NLP Work? What Survives the Evidence
  2. Nov 13

    Body Language Pseudoscience? How to Spot the Persuasion

    Thirty seconds into a video about whether body language is pseudoscience, the viewer has heard a criticism, a credential, a concession and a mention of flat earth. No behavioural claim has been tested yet. We play the audio and mark the exact points where evidence gives way to framing, authority or certainty. In this episode: Why opening with the strongest criticism lets the speaker decide how big the objection looksThe order of criticism, credential and concession, and the pratfall effect behind it (Elliot Aronson)How a question about body language pseudoscience becomes a question about why people believe nonsenseWhat a shared “we” and a pair of extreme examples do to an audience before any evidence arrivesAbility, benevolence and integrity, and where each one appears in the audio (Roger Mayer, James Davis and F. David Schoorman)How a curiosity gap holds a viewer in place (George Loewenstein)The question worth asking about body language, which claims are supported, under what conditions, with what confidence Subscribe to The Deductionist Podcast with Behavioural Intelligence for more Holmesian method applied to the claims you meet every day. Access the free tier or go deeper with exclusive paid challenges: https://www.omniscient-insights.com/axiomhttps://www.omniscient-insights.com/community-home MERCH -- https://the-deductionist.myspreadshop.co.uk/allE-SCAPE GAME -- https://www.youtube.com/@thedeductionistteamEverything else you need -- https://linktr.ee/bencardall Music provided by https://robertjohncollinsmusic.com/` #podcast #bodylanguage #thinking

    Body Language Pseudoscience? How to Spot the Persuasion
  3. Nov 6

    How to Hear the Bark in the Boardroom (Groupthink Examples)

    A room where nobody objects looks like agreement. Holmes would call it the dog that did nothing in the night, and former senior detective Bob Pointer has spent a career listening for exactly that kind of silence. Ben Cardall and Bob work through real groupthink examples from boardrooms, police work and jury rooms to show why teams make bad decisions with total confidence, and how a group ends up somewhere none of its members chose. In this episode:- Why silence isn't consent, why a nod tells you nothing, and what to ask when the room goes quiet- How Bob spotted the real power in an office through a glass wall before the manager even walked in- The consensus psychology behind tag questions like "we all agree, don't we?"- Irving Janis, Solomon Asch and pluralistic ignorance, the research behind the best known groupthink examples- What a quick verdict and the choice of foreman tell a detective about a jury room- Who speaks first and who speaks last, and what those bookends of power reveal in any meeting- A protocol for productive dissent built on information rounds, private confidence ratings and red teams that actually get heard If any of these groupthink examples sound like your last meeting, subscribe and tell us in the comments where you stayed quiet. Access the free tier or go deeper with exclusive paid challenges: https://www.omniscient-insights.com/axiomhttps://www.omniscient-insights.com/community-home MERCH -- https://the-deductionist.myspreadshop.co.uk/allE-SCAPE GAME -- https://www.youtube.com/@thedeductionistteamEverything else you need -- https://linktr.ee/bencardall Music provided by https://robertjohncollinsmusic.com/`

    How to Hear the Bark in the Boardroom (Groupthink Examples)
  4. Oct 25

    How to Spot the Sunk Cost Fallacy in an Investigation

    Peter Sutcliffe was interviewed nine times and the accent on a hoax tape counted in his favour. The tape had been played to the nation, and walking away from it would have meant admitting the enquiry had chased the wrong voice. Former senior detective Bob Pointer and private investigator Ben Cardall take the sunk cost fallacy into the incident room and the interview room, on both sides of the table. In this episode:- What the sunk cost fallacy is, and what theatre tickets and Concorde reveal about it- Barry Staw's escalation research and why the most senior person in the room is most at risk- The Yorkshire Ripper enquiry, the Wearside tape and the Byford Report- How investigators rate the same evidence differently depending on their theory- Spotting the sunk cost fallacy in witnesses and subjects who have committed to a story- Why authentic dissent beats a devil's advocate, and Holmes's Norbury protocol- Sincere listening, ORBIT and the premortem as field tools If you have ever defended a theory because of what it cost you, subscribe and tell us in the comments which case you held onto too long. Tags: sunk cost fallacy, escalation of commitment, tunnel vision investigation, confirmation bias, investigative interviewing, behavioural analysis, Yorkshire Ripper investigation, Byford Report, ORBIT interviewing, premortem, Sherlock Holmes deduction, Deductionist podcast Access the free tier or go deeper with exclusive paid challenges: https://www.omniscient-insights.com/axiomhttps://www.omniscient-insights.com/community-home MERCH -- https://the-deductionist.myspreadshop.co.uk/allE-SCAPE GAME -- https://www.youtube.com/@thedeductionistteamEverything else you need -- https://linktr.ee/bencardall Music provided by https://robertjohncollinsmusic.com/` #podcast #ripper #sunkencost

    How to Spot the Sunk Cost Fallacy in an Investigation
  5. Oct 25

    How to Predict Human Behaviour (and When You Can’t)

    Hannah Fry went through every past season of The Traitors looking for statistical patterns, then got recruited as a traitor herself. Maths can predict human behaviour across a crowd with unnerving precision. Point it at one person and the predictions fall apart, for reasons chaos theory explains. In this episode:• Why crowds behave like equations, from Hannah Fry's London riots model to the near repeat burglary effect• How geographic profiling narrows a search without naming a suspect• What the mathematics of love leaves out, and how overfitting fools analysts• Chaos theory done properly, with Edward Lorenz, the butterfly effect and the MusicLab experiment• Why 160 machine learning teams still could not predict human behaviour in individuals• Bayesian reasoning as the bridge from pattern to person, tested on the taxicab problem• The Sally Clark case and the statistical errors that convict the innocent Subscribe for the method behind every case, and learn to predict human behaviour without ever having to guess. Access the free tier or go deeper with exclusive paid challenges: https://www.omniscient-insights.com/axiomhttps://www.omniscient-insights.com/community-home MERCH -- https://the-deductionist.myspreadshop.co.uk/allE-SCAPE GAME -- https://www.youtube.com/@thedeductionistteamEverything else you need -- https://linktr.ee/bencardall Music provided by https://robertjohncollinsmusic.com/` #maths #traitors #behaviour

    How to Predict Human Behaviour (and When You Can’t)
  6. Oct 9

    How Romance Scams Really Work | Forensic Linguist Dr Elisabeth Carter

    The evidence in a romance scam is all there in writing. Every message, every apology, every “be careful, there are scammers on here” sits in the chat log like a frozen crime scene. Dr Elisabeth Carter, criminologist and forensic linguist, reads those crime scenes line by line, by hand, and she joins Ben Cardall and Bob Pointer to show exactly how the crime is built. Most people picture a romance scam as a lonely pensioner and an oil rig sob story. The language shows something far more deliberate: credibility first, rapport second, then a slow transition where the scammer turns vulnerable and the victim offers the money nobody asked for. Elisabeth explains genre mapping (why the exaggeration we tolerate in normal dating, and the countdown clocks we tolerate on Black Friday, make red flags look green), how organised crime groups pass victims between operators to keep them awake, where sextortion enters, and why AI has made the old spelling mistake test useless. Bob brings the reverse order technique from interview practice, Ben brings a super recogniser’s view of deepfake dating profiles, and the live chat brought receipts. You’ll leave with one rule that would stop most romance scam attempts dead in their tracks. Victims of romance fraud get called gullible. The research describes grooming, coercion and abuse. By the end of this episode, you’ll see why. 🎧 Scam Secrets with Dr Elisabeth Carter, Shari Vahl and Alex Wood (BBC Radio 4): https://podcasts.apple.com/gb/podcast/scam-secrets/id1828899532 or search “Scam Secrets” on BBC Sounds🔗 Dr Elisabeth Carter, Kingston University: https://www.kingston.ac.uk/about/staff/dr-elisabeth-carter📖 Elisabeth’s latest book: The Language of Romance Crimes (Cambridge University Press)🚨 Report fraud (England, Wales, NI): https://www.reportfraud.police.uk or 0300 123 2040🚨 Scotland: call Police Scotland on 101 Subscribe if you want to see whether the Real Life Sherlock reputation survives ninety more pages of this. Access the free tier or go deeper with exclusive paid challenges: https://www.omniscient-insights.com/axiomhttps://www.omniscient-insights.com/community-home MERCH -- https://the-deductionist.myspreadshop.co.uk/allE-SCAPE GAME -- https://www.youtube.com/@thedeductionistteamEverything else you need -- https://linktr.ee/bencardall Music provided by https://robertjohncollinsmusic.com/`

    How Romance Scams Really Work | Forensic Linguist Dr Elisabeth Carter
  7. Oct 2

    How to Tell If Someone Is Lying...ish (Microexpressions Won't)

    Spotting lying, we are told is just Somebody freeze framed a grieving parent's face, announced "duping delight" to four million followers, and the comment section returned a verdict before the police did. The lie detection science says that person was running on a coin flip with a ring light. Ben Cardall and former senior detective Bob Pointer take the microexpressions truth apart, then rebuild what the research says about how to tell if someone is lying without guessing. In this episode:- Why watching Lie to Me made viewers worse at recognising honest people- The 2 percent problem: how rarely microexpressions appear, and why they show up on truth tellers too- What the research on murderers' televised pleas found, and why it cannot convict anyone from one clip- The 54 percent wall: 24,483 judges, and why cops, judges and psychiatrists score like students- The 900 million dollar airport programme that never caught a threat- What Ekman got right, including the Othello error most of his fans have never heard of- How to tell if someone is lying with methods that move accuracy: Strategic Use of Evidence, verifiable detail and cognitive load If you have ever been certain about a face, watch this before you decide you know how to tell if someone is lying. Tags: how to tell if someone is lying, lie detection science, microexpressions truth, microexpressions, Paul Ekman, deception detection, true crime analysis, body language myths, Aldert Vrij, strategic use of evidence, investigative interviewing, Deductionist Podcast

    How to Tell If Someone Is Lying...ish (Microexpressions Won't)
  8. Oct 2

    The Real Life Sherlock | Solving Cain's Jawbone Ep 5 | Just Like Everyone

    Many a true word is spoken in jest and only some of them from Sherlock. Except on page eighteen of Cain's Jawbone, where it isn't. One word has been swapped, and I read straight past it three times. This is episode five of my live attempt to solve Cain's Jawbone, the 1934 literary murder puzzle by Torquemada. A hundred pages printed out of order, six murders, six killers, and a solution only a handful of people have ever cracked. Last episode was three ways to hide a body in a sentence. This one opens the second drawer. His toolkit. The anti-proverb, the namesake and the mock-heroic. Three techniques Torquemada uses on pages 11 to 20, and every one of them works by looking completely ordinary. I am not sure that Sherlock would have taken this long to solve it but I am doing the best I can haha My toolkit. The concordance, the anachronism test and stylometry. Three methods built to catch exactly that, borrowed from 13th century friars, a Renaissance forgery hunter, and the statisticians who unmasked J.K. Rowling's pen name. Along the way you'll get the Moses illusion, a garden cricket in full medieval armour, a nickname for Alexander that made me very excited for all of ten minutes, and the line on page eighteen that tells you what the six killers will look like. Then I'll tell you where the solve actually stands. No spoilers. Not now, not when I finish, not ever. If you're solving it yourself, everything here is technique, not answers. Sources mentionedWolfgang Mieder on the anti-proverb (1982)Thomas Erickson and Mark Mattson, the Moses illusion (1981)Alexander Pope, The Rape of the LockHugh of Saint-Cher's Bible concordance (c. 1230)Lorenzo Valla on the Donation of Constantine (1440)Frederick Mosteller and David Wallace, Inference and Disputed Authorship (1964)Patrick Juola and Peter Millican, the Robert Galbraith analysis (2013) If you've spotted something I've missed, tell me in the comments. Spoiler-free, please. I'll check it against the ledger. #cainsjawbone #reallifesherlock #truecrime #puzzle #torquemada #sherlock

    The Real Life Sherlock | Solving Cain's Jawbone Ep 5 | Just Like Everyone
5
out of 5
11 Ratings

About

Look no further, dear listener, for The Deductionist podcast is here to sharpen your deductive skills and blow your mind with its clever insights.Hosted by the charming and enigmatic deductionist himself (HA!) and the Watson of awesomeness! Each episode is a masterclass in observation, deduction, and logic, as they take you on a journey through the mysteries of everyday life.From analyzing crime scenes to decoding the hidden meanings in social interactions, The Deductionist podcast brings a fresh and witty perspective to the art of deduction. With a razor-sharp mind and quick wit...ish, they'll have you hooked from the very first episode.So join us as we explore the secrets of the world around us, and learn how to become a master of deduction like the one and only Deductionist. It's time to uncover the truth and take your deductive skills to the next level. Don't miss a single episode of The Deductionist podcast! Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.