The Cookie Sheets

Mostly Average Joe & Sub Par Kurt
  • 5.0 (3)
  • Wrestling
  • Updated Bimonthly

Joe and Kurt, two idiots who spend more time watching wrestling than anyone should, team up to talk the stories, matches, and fantasy booking of the week.

Episodes

  1. Jun 26

    Episode 295: Oh, Did You Want MORE Wrestling?

    Joe and Kurt are back! This weekend has at least FOUR big events in the wrestling world. They cover NXT’s Great American Bash, WWE’s Night of Champions, TNA’s Slammiversary, and AEW’s Forbidden Door. The post Episode 295: Oh, Did You Want MORE Wrestling? first appeared on MostlyAverageJoe.com.

  2. May 22

    Episode 294: Cookie Sheets ARE the Best

    This week the boys talk Mick Foley to AEW and then get into this weekend’s AEW Double or Nothing PPV. After that, Joe has another new game to spring on Kurt! The post Episode 294: Cookie Sheets ARE the Best first appeared on MostlyAverageJoe.com.

  3. May 8

    Episode 293: Is it a… New Day?

    Joe has Kurt play a new game with the recent WWE releases. Then it’s onto this weekend’s Backlash before discussing the legacy of Ted Turner. The post Episode 293: Is it a… New Day? first appeared on MostlyAverageJoe.com.

  4. Apr 24

    Episode 292: That HHH Stank

    Joe and Kurt are all over this past weekend’s Wrestlemania two night extravaganza. But how much actual wrestling was there? They go by the numbers before diving into the Rhodes-Orton main event. It was uh, something. Then its the rest of the weekend before chatting AEW’s past few weeks. The post Episode 292: That HHH Stank first appeared on MostlyAverageJoe.com.

  5. Apr 10

    Episode 291: It’s Vegas, Babyyyy

    Joe and Kurt start the show by diving into this weekend’s AEW Dynasty PPV. Then, it’s a new segment called Real Slams, Fake Bets – all about the two night Mania card. The post Episode 291: It’s Vegas, Babyyyy first appeared on MostlyAverageJoe.com.

  6. Mar 20

    Episode 290: Still Not Interested

    Joe and Kurt are back, and they’ve watched some wrestling. First up for discussion are the Mania card changes in the last few weeks. Is Orton challenging Rhodes uh, better than what it was going to be? Then it’s all about Revolution’s returns and the ending to the FORTY-SIX MINUTE death match. The post Episode 290: Still Not Interested first appeared on MostlyAverageJoe.com.

  7. Feb 6

    Episode 289: I Wasted a FuboTV Trial on THIS??

    Joe has a list of grievances with the 2026 Royal Rumble event. A. LIST. Get ready to hear it. Also, AEW has some newcomers. Who will have the most imapct? The post Episode 289: I Wasted a FuboTV Trial on THIS?? first appeared on MostlyAverageJoe.com.

  8. Jan 23

    Episode 288: Rumbly in Our Tumblies

    This week it’s all about the upcoming Royal Rumble event. Who will win? What surprises will we see? Which wrestler has the best odds? But first… chocolate talk? The post Episode 288: Rumbly in Our Tumblies first appeared on MostlyAverageJoe.com.

  9. Jan 9

    Episode 287: 2025 Sheety Awards

    Joe and Kurt are back in 2026! Joe plays “pick a number” with Kurt before the idiots dive into their best and worst of 2025. The post Episode 287: 2025 Sheety Awards first appeared on MostlyAverageJoe.com.

  10. 12/19/2025

    Episode 286: The Time to Quit Is Now

    Joe and Kurt are here to discuss all the ins and outs of John Cena’s last match, a submission loss to GUNTHER. Was it the right call? Then it’s about AEW’s upcoming World’s End PPV and Sports Illustrated’s end of year wrestling awards. The post Episode 286: The Time to Quit Is Now first appeared on MostlyAverageJoe.com.

  • 10 Episodes

5
out of 5
3 Ratings

About

Joe and Kurt, two idiots who spend more time watching wrestling than anyone should, team up to talk the stories, matches, and fantasy booking of the week.

Information

  • Creator
    Mostly Average Joe & Sub Par Kurt
  • Years Active
    2017 - 2026
  • Episodes
    10
  • Rating
    Explicit
  • Copyright
    © 2017 MostlyAverageJoe
  • Show Website
    The Cookie Sheets