The Buckeye Weekly Podcast

Buckeye Insiders Network

Tony Gerdeman and Tom Orr discuss Ohio State football, Ohio State football recruiting, and share insights and analysis from inside the Buckeye beat. You can also find them at BuckeyeInsiders.com. 

  1. 2h ago

    BONUS: Juck on Bucks with Tony Gerdeman on the Ohio State Staff, Decision Making

    What went wrong with Ohio State football in 2026, and what changes does Ryan Day need to make to get the Buckeyes back into national championship contention? In this episode of Juck on Bucks, Juck Miletti is joined by Tony Gerdeman of BuckeyeInsiders.com for an in-depth discussion about Ohio State's disappointing season, Ryan Day's coaching staff, questionable personnel decisions, and what needs to happen this offseason. Following Ohio State's 28-19 victory over Northwestern, Juck and Tony examine why the Buckeyes have struggled against elite competition despite having one of the most expensive coaching staffs and rosters in college football. Is Ryan Day getting enough out of the talent he has? And how much of the blame belongs to his assistant coaches? The discussion begins with Ohio State's special teams problems, including the firing of Robby Discher and the continued lack of aggression in the kicking game. Juck and Tony also take a closer look at offensive coordinator Arthur Smith, defensive coordinator Matt Patricia, and the unusual dynamic Ryan Day faces with two former NFL head coaches running his offense and defense. Could their experience and stature make it more difficult for Day to demand changes? The conversation then turns to Ohio State's assistant coaches, including Tyler Bowen, Keenan Bailey, Carlos Locklyn, Cortez Hankton, Billy Fessler, and Larry Johnson. Who deserves another season, and which position groups might benefit from new leadership? They also discuss the development of true freshmen Chris Henry Jr. and Legend Bey, the lack of opportunities for several highly regarded young players, and whether Ohio State's coaching staff has been too quick to bench freshmen after mistakes. Finally, Juck and Tony look ahead to Nebraska and Michigan, discussing whether the Buckeyes can finish strong and how much interest remains among Ohio State fans following three losses. Topics include: Why Ohio State's win over Northwestern shouldn't erase concerns about the program. The firing of special teams coordinator Robby Discher. Why Ohio State's special teams continue making costly mistakes. Matt Patricia's defensive scheme and whether Ohio State should use more four-man fronts. The impact of losing starting quarterback Julian Sayin. Why the 2002 and 2014 national championship teams were fortunate to have experienced backup quarterbacks. How Ohio State's difficult schedule exposed problems that might otherwise have been overlooked. The relationship between Ryan Day and former NFL head coaches Arthur Smith and Matt Patricia. Which Ohio State assistant coaches should return in 2027? Why Tyler Bowen could be facing an uncertain future. Questions surrounding Keenan Bailey, Carlos Locklyn, Billy Fessler, and Larry Johnson. Cortez Hankton's recruiting performance and the future of Ohio State's receiver room. Why Chris Henry Jr.'s freshman season hasn't met expectations. Whether Ohio State should give Legend Bey more opportunities despite maturity concerns. Why Kari Wilder and other talented freshmen haven't played more. Ohio State's confusing offensive line and defensive line rotations. Can the Buckeyes regain momentum against Nebraska and Michigan? 00:00 – Welcome to Juck on Bucks: Ohio State's disappointing season and playoff hopes 01:30 – Michigan's disastrous season under Kyle Whittingham 03:00 – Why the final two regular-season games are so important for Ohio State 04:15 – What changes does Ryan Day need to make this offseason? 06:41 – Tony Gerdeman joins Juck Miletti 06:55 – Did firing Robby Discher help Ohio State beat Northwestern? 07:41 – Why Ohio State's special teams continue to struggle under Ryan Day 09:42 – What Ohio State's win over Northwestern really tells us about the Buckeyes 11:57 – Did Matt Patricia finally get more aggressive with his defensive line? 13:00 – Why Ohio State's defensive approach against Nebraska could look different 14:40 – How much has losing Julian Sayin changed Ohio State's season? 15:29 – Why the 2014 national champions benefited from Cardale Jones' experience 17:00 – Comparing Ohio State's quarterback depth in 2002, 2014, and 2026 18:19 – Would Ohio State have beaten USC or Oregon with Julian Sayin? 19:30 – Why Ohio State's difficult schedule exposed major problems 21:47 – How roster turnover and injuries complicate Ryan Day's decisions 23:00 – Which Ohio State assistant coaches should be worried about their jobs? 25:06 – Ryan Day's relationship with Arthur Smith and Matt Patricia 27:00 – Juck evaluates Ohio State's offensive and defensive assistant coaches 30:26 – Why recruiting and player development remain critical at quarterback 31:30 – Does Matt Patricia's NFL defensive system work in college football? 32:45 – Why Tyler Bowen's future remains uncertain 34:15 – Should Ohio State make coaching changes before Signing Day? 36:20 – Larry Johnson's future and the impact of potential coaching changes on recruiting 37:09 – Is Cortez Hankton doing enough as Ohio State's wide receivers coach? 39:02 – Why Ohio State could pursue an experienced No. 1 receiver in the transfer portal 40:01 – Why so many Ohio State players have failed to meet expectations 41:30 – What Ohio State needs from its talented freshman class 43:02 – Chris Henry Jr.'s drops, development, and freshman receiving statistics 45:00 – Why Chris Henry Jr. shouldn't be compared directly to Jeremiah Smith 46:09 – Should Ohio State be playing Legend Bey more? 47:30 – Are the Buckeyes too quick to bench young players for mistakes? 49:08 – Tony explains why Ohio State needs to give its freshmen more opportunities 51:00 – Why limiting Legend Bey's playing time could hurt Ohio State's future 53:49 – Juck argues Ohio State needs a different approach to developing young players 54:50 – Why the Buckeyes risk losing talented freshmen to the transfer portal 56:00 – Confusing personnel decisions involving Ohio State's offensive and defensive lines 57:24 – Can Ohio State finish strong against Nebraska and Michigan? 58:30 – Why fan engagement has declined during a disappointing season 59:44 – Final thoughts with Tony Gerdeman and Buckeye Insiders Join Buckeye Insiders! Get exclusive Ohio State football coverage, insider reporting, recruiting analysis, premium message board discussions, and more at: https://BuckeyeInsiders.com

  2. 6h ago

    Michigan Monday: The Oregon Fail

    How bad has Michigan football gotten? After suffering a 31-7 loss to Oregon, the Wolverines are running out of answers, running out of time, and potentially running out of patience with head coach Kyle Whittingham. In this edition of Michigan Monday on the Buckeye Weekly Podcast, Tony Gerdeman and Tom Orr break down Michigan's latest embarrassment, a game that was never as close as the scoreboard suggested. Michigan managed just six completed passes for 71 yards against Oregon, its lowest number of completions in a game since the infamous 13-13 tie against Ohio State in 1992. Neither Tommy Carr nor Bryce Underwood could get the passing game going, and the constant quarterback rotation only highlighted the Wolverines' offensive problems. Has Michigan's quarterback situation somehow gotten even worse? Tony and Tom discuss why Michigan's offensive line remains a disaster, whether firing offensive coordinator Jason Beck made matters worse, and how the Wolverines have reached the point where even a seven-point deficit feels insurmountable. And Michigan's defense, which has carried the team throughout much of the season, finally showed some serious cracks. Oregon quarterback Dylan Raiola threw for 341 yards and four touchdowns as the Ducks repeatedly exploited Michigan's secondary with explosive plays. Even a simple third-and-19 checkdown turned into a 49-yard touchdown against a defense that seemed to have forgotten how to tackle. Meanwhile, questions continue to grow about Kyle Whittingham's future in Ann Arbor. His conservative fourth-down decisions, questionable game management, and inability to generate offense have Michigan fans wondering whether another coaching change could be coming. With undefeated UCLA and Ohio State remaining on the schedule, Michigan now faces the possibility of finishing 5-7 and missing a bowl game entirely. Could Michigan's miserable season get even worse? 00:00 – Welcome to Michigan Monday: Even Michigan fans are tired of watching Michigan 00:26 – Should Michigan give Kyle Whittingham more time? 01:44 – Oregon dominates Michigan 31-7 in a game that was never close 02:59 – Savion Hiter's 70-yard touchdown and Michigan's ineffective running game 04:00 – Why Michigan's quarterback rotation isn't solving anything 04:40 – The offensive line injuries that continue crippling Michigan 05:00 – Michigan's passing game reaches a historic low 05:54 – Just six completions against Oregon, matching Michigan's lowest total since 1992 06:33 – Has Bryce Underwood gotten worse since being benched? 07:15 – Tommy Carr struggles and Andrew Marsh's uncertain future 08:13 – Could Andrew Marsh leave Michigan through the transfer portal? 09:40 – Is Michigan football even less entertaining than the Rich Rodriguez years? 10:02 – Why Michigan's offensive line makes the quarterback situation almost impossible 11:00 – Kyle Whittingham's questionable decisions and conservative game management 12:03 – Is Whittingham mentally checked out, or are fans reading too much into his behavior? 13:00 – Could Michigan unveil trick plays against Ohio State? 15:14 – Has Kyle Whittingham failed to restore competence to Michigan football? 16:00 – Oregon exposes Michigan's defense with explosive passing plays 17:00 – The disastrous third-and-19 screen that went for a 49-yard touchdown 18:02 – Dylan Raiola's impressive throws and Michigan's problems in the secondary 19:35 – Does Michigan's defense have enough left to carry the team? 20:30 – Why Michigan is a good defense attached to a terrible offense 21:50 – Can a defense survive when its offense provides no help? 22:59 – Could Michigan shock undefeated UCLA and salvage its season? 24:15 – Does Michigan have any offensive creativity left? 24:56 – Are Tony and Tom finally tired of Michigan football? 25:14 – Looking ahead to Ohio State–Michigan Week and Buckeye Insiders coverage Join Buckeye Insiders! Get exclusive Ohio State football coverage, insider reporting, recruiting analysis, premium message board discussions, and more at: https://BuckeyeInsiders.com Join Tony Gerdeman, Tom Orr, and the Buckeye Insiders community for daily Ohio State football coverage and discussion. We're already preparing for Ohio State–Michigan Week, with game previews, matchup breakdowns, predictions, rivalry history, and plenty of Michigan Monday coverage. Watch more Buckeye Weekly episodes at: https://www.youtube.com/@BuckeyeInsiders Join the conversation!

  3. 11h ago

    Ten Things We Learned Rewatching Ohio State's Win Over Northwestern

    What did we learn from rewatching Ohio State's 28-19 win over Northwestern? Is Luke Fahey developing into a more reliable quarterback? Has Jeremiah Smith officially become the greatest receiver in Big Ten history? And is Ohio State's defensive line finally starting to play up to its potential? In this episode of the Buckeye Weekly Podcast, Tony Gerdeman and Tom Orr go back through the television broadcast of Ohio State's victory over Northwestern and share 10 takeaways that stood out on a second viewing. 00:00 – Welcome to Buckeye Weekly: Rewatching Ohio State's win over Northwestern 01:04 – Takeaway No. 1: Jeremiah Smith makes Big Ten receiving history 02:33 – Smith ties the conference record with 17 career 100-yard receiving games 02:55 – Takeaway No. 2: Luke Fahey's height isn't the problem people thought it would be 03:56 – Fahey's improvement and his impressive touchdown throw to Isaiah West 06:25 – How Fahey compares to C.J. Stroud and Justin Fields through three starts 06:43 – Takeaway No. 3: Isaiah West is making a case for a bigger role 08:29 – West's strong performance, late fumble, and receiving touchdown 09:26 – Takeaway No. 4: Kenyatta Jackson delivers despite limited playing time 10:25 – Takeaway No. 5: Qua Russaw and Ohio State's defensive line are improving 11:30 – Eddrick Houston's physical play and potential targeting concerns 13:10 – Ohio State's defensive linemen dominate the tackle statistics 14:49 – Zion Grady's improvement and the Buckeyes' growing pass rush 15:00 – Takeaway No. 6: Ohio State finally takes the easy yards with Jeremiah Smith 16:10 – Why easy completions can help Luke Fahey and the entire offense 16:45 – Takeaway No. 7: Jeremiah Smith's unbelievable sideline catch 17:53 – Did the officials make the right call overturning the incompletion? 19:42 – Takeaway No. 8: Ohio State nearly gave away a comfortable finish 21:31 – The late fumble, Northwestern's touchdown, and Ohio State's missed interceptions 22:00 – Takeaway No. 9: Ohio State's secondary still needs to finish plays 22:30 – Takeaway No. 10: A surprisingly refreshing television broadcast 24:00 – Tony and Tom discuss the broadcast crew and Ohio State's upcoming games 25:00 – Brandon Inniss returns punts but doesn't play on offense 26:30 – Final thoughts and the road ahead against Nebraska and Michigan Join Buckeye Insiders! Get exclusive Ohio State football coverage, insider reporting, recruiting analysis, detailed film breakdowns, and premium message board discussions at: https://BuckeyeInsiders.com Join Tony Gerdeman, Tom Orr, and the Buckeye Insiders team for daily Ohio State football coverage and analysis. Watch more Ohio State coverage on YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@BuckeyeInsiders Join the conversation!

  4. 18h ago

    BREAKING: RB Nigel Newkirk Commits to Ohio State

    BOOM! Ohio State has flipped running back Nigel Newkirk from Alabama! The Buckeyes have landed another important commitment in their 2027 recruiting class, adding talented Gainesville, Georgia running back Nigel Newkirk to a class that already includes Daylon Gordon. In this breaking news edition of the Buckeye Weekly Podcast, Tony Gerdeman is joined by Juck Miletti to discuss Newkirk's commitment, what makes him an exciting prospect, and how Ohio State managed to turn things around after missing out on David Gabriel Georges. So what exactly is Ohio State getting in Nigel Newkirk? Juck breaks down Newkirk's impressive vision, patience, acceleration, ability to follow his blocks, and willingness to run physically despite his relatively modest frame. Tony and Juck also discuss how Newkirk compares to fellow running back commit Daylon Gordon and whether the two freshmen could contribute immediately in 2027. But the bigger story might be what happens to Ohio State's current running back room. With questions surrounding the futures of Bo Jackson and several other Buckeye running backs, how aggressively will Ryan Day and Mark Pantoni pursue an experienced transfer portal addition? Tony and Juck discuss possible portal targets, including Duke's Nate Sheppard and Rutgers' Antwan Raymond, while examining how NIL, roster management, and the need for more explosive plays could reshape Ohio State's backfield. 00:00 – BOOM! Nigel Newkirk flips from Alabama to Ohio State! 00:42 – Ohio State adds Newkirk to its 2027 recruiting class alongside Daylon Gordon 01:15 – Why Juck Miletti wanted Newkirk after the Buckeyes missed on David Gabriel Georges 01:45 – Breaking down Nigel Newkirk's running style and strengths 02:15 – Newkirk's vision, patience, acceleration, and physicality 02:45 – Where Newkirk needs to improve and how he compares to Daylon Gordon 03:35 – Why Alabama originally secured his commitment 04:05 – Newkirk's return from injury and Ohio State's renewed evaluation 04:35 – The remarkable road trip from Georgia to Columbus that preceded his commitment 05:25 – Why Ohio State's interest became increasingly clear 05:50 – Can Newkirk or Gordon contribute immediately in 2027? 06:56 – How much size will Ohio State's incoming running backs need to add? 07:30 – Could Ohio State completely reshape its running back room? 08:16 – The transfer portal and potential running back targets 08:40 – Duke's Nate Sheppard and his explosive production 09:27 – Why Ohio State may pursue a high-level portal running back 10:00 – Bo Jackson's future and the Buckeyes' lack of explosive rushing plays 10:45 – Could Rutgers running back Antwan Raymond be an option? 11:40 – Why the running back transfer market is different from other positions 12:00 – What Nigel Newkirk's commitment means for Ohio State moving forward 12:25 – Final thoughts and Buckeye Insiders recruiting coverage Join Buckeye Insiders! Get exclusive Ohio State football recruiting coverage, insider reporting, premium message board discussions, and analysis from Tony Gerdeman, Juck Miletti, and the entire Buckeye Insiders team at: https://BuckeyeInsiders.com Follow the latest developments in Ohio State's 2027 recruiting class, transfer portal targets, roster decisions, and more. Watch more Buckeye Weekly episodes and breaking Ohio State recruiting news: https://www.youtube.com/@BuckeyeInsiders

  5. 1d ago

    BONUS: Juck's First Thoughts From Ohio State's 28-19 Win Over Northwestern

    Ohio State is back in the win column! The Buckeyes defeated Northwestern 28-19 at Ohio Stadium, snapping their two-game losing streak and giving freshman quarterback Luke Fahey his first career victory. But was this the kind of performance Ohio State fans were hoping to see? Buckeye Insiders' Juck Miletti reports live from the field at Ohio Stadium to break down the good, the bad, and the downright strange from the Buckeyes' victory over Northwestern. One of the biggest developments was Ohio State finally making Jeremiah Smith the centerpiece of its passing attack. After questions all week about his lack of involvement against Oregon, Smith was targeted 17 times, finishing with 11 receptions for 117 yards and a touchdown. Juck discusses whether Ohio State has finally figured out how to feature its best offensive weapon and what the performance could mean for Smith's Heisman Trophy campaign. There were also encouraging performances from running backs Bo Jackson and Isaiah West, a reshuffled offensive line that performed well, and a defensive line that finally generated consistent pressure. Kenyatta Jackson recorded two sacks, Qua Russaw added another, and the Buckeyes finished with five sacks overall. But there were still plenty of concerns. Ohio State's special teams produced another costly mistake despite the firing of coordinator Robby Discher. Freshman receiver Chris Henry Jr. continued to struggle with dropped passes, and questions remain about why promising young players like Legend Bey, Cincere Johnson, and Khary Wilder aren't seeing more action. Juck breaks down all of it while looking ahead to Ohio State's final two regular-season games against Nebraska and Michigan. Topics include: Luke Fahey earns his first career victory as Ohio State's starting quarterback. Jeremiah Smith's huge performance: 11 catches, 117 yards, and a touchdown. Why the Buckeyes finally made Smith the focal point of the offense. Ohio State's surprisingly limited offensive possessions in the first half. Can Ohio State still reach the Big Ten Championship Game? Why the offensive line looked better with another new combination. Bo Jackson rushes for 114 yards on 20 carries. Isaiah West gets more opportunities and makes an impact before a costly late fumble. Another special teams mistake following Robby Discher's firing. Why Legend Bey still isn't returning kickoffs. Bey's impressive reception and his confrontation afterward. Chris Henry Jr.'s continued struggles with dropped passes. Why Ohio State needs to see more from its young receivers. Kenyatta Jackson, Qua Russaw, and the Buckeyes' five-sack performance. Why Juck wants to see more of Cincere Johnson and Khary Wilder. What the Buckeyes need to improve before facing Nebraska and Michigan.

4.5
out of 5
420 Ratings

About

Tony Gerdeman and Tom Orr discuss Ohio State football, Ohio State football recruiting, and share insights and analysis from inside the Buckeye beat. You can also find them at BuckeyeInsiders.com. 

You Might Also Like