380 episodes

If you dig murder and heavy metal mixed with a dose of mayhem, then this is the podcast for you! Hosts Pete Altieri, Chris Shawback, and Joey Cashman use their own brand of humor to provide a unique listening experience on a variety of dark subjects such as serial killers, true crime, mobsters, and more. The guys take turns sharing their metal knowledge and feature a band in the metal segment, plus other guests who tell hilarious stories of mayhem, Killer Cage Matches, karaoke destruction, and much more!

Murder Metal Mayhem Pete Altieri, Chris Shawback, and Joey Cashman

    • Comedy
    • 4.4 • 34 Ratings

If you dig murder and heavy metal mixed with a dose of mayhem, then this is the podcast for you! Hosts Pete Altieri, Chris Shawback, and Joey Cashman use their own brand of humor to provide a unique listening experience on a variety of dark subjects such as serial killers, true crime, mobsters, and more. The guys take turns sharing their metal knowledge and feature a band in the metal segment, plus other guests who tell hilarious stories of mayhem, Killer Cage Matches, karaoke destruction, and much more!

    Bonus Episode - God's Misfits Cult

    Bonus Episode - God's Misfits Cult

    Pete, Chris, and Joey tear up a bonus episode, this time with a discussion on a current true crime story about God's Misfits. They are an extreme right wing religious cult that is based in Oklahoma and are allegedly responsible for the brutal murder of two women, Veronica Butler and Jillian Kelley, over a child custody dispute. Five of them have been arrested so far and some have admitted their involvement in this devious plan.

    Get your copy of Jeff's true crime book, "Beyond the Headlines", and advance order one today from Wild Blue Press!

    Order mech, join the 666 Club, and more at Murder Metal Mayhem. You can also sign up for the 666 Club on our Patreon page.

    Subscribe to our YouTube channel so you don't miss any of the content, including the new 666 Seconds of MURDER videos. Check out the new Throwing the Horns heavy metal channel for all the killer episodes, plus band interviews, and more!

    We also have Instagram and Threads - so keep in touch with Murder Metal Mayhem even more!

    Order any of Pete's books on his website with a great online store. You can order his latest book, "Creation of Chaos: Volume IV", a short story collection.

    Follow Joey's Goremonger page for updates on his music and his distro, FTA Records.

    Spreading like a case of the clap in a trailer park!

    • 25 min
    Bonus Episode - Triple Six Fix

    Bonus Episode - Triple Six Fix

    Pete, Chris, and Joey hammer out a great bonus episode on the insane 1980 lottery scandal known as the Triple Six Fix. When the daily numbers landed on 666, the State of Pennsylvania figured out that lottery announcer, Nick Perry, and seven others attemped to scam millions. The plan they came up with was brilliant and stupid at the same time!

    Get your copy of Jeff's true crime book, "Beyond the Headlines", and advance order one today from Wild Blue Press!

    Order mech, join the 666 Club, and more at Murder Metal Mayhem. You can also sign up for the 666 Club on our Patreon page.

    Subscribe to our YouTube channel so you don't miss any of the content, including the new 666 Seconds of MURDER videos. Check out the new Throwing the Horns heavy metal channel for all the killer episodes, plus band interviews, and more!

    We also have Instagram and Threads - so keep in touch with Murder Metal Mayhem even more!

    Order any of Pete's books on his website with a great online store. You can order his latest book, "Creation of Chaos: Volume IV", a short story collection.

    Follow Joey's Goremonger page for updates on his music and his distro, FTA Records.

    Spreading like a case of the clap in a trailer park!

    • 40 min
    Episode 259 - Patrick Kearney: The Trashbag Killer

    Episode 259 - Patrick Kearney: The Trashbag Killer

    Pete, Chris, and Joey crush another episosde with a feature on Patrick Kearney, known as the Trashbag Killer. His murderous ways from 1962 to 1977 in Southern California left at least 21 victims discarded on the freeways. They're joined by Jeff Ignatowski to discuss this gruesome true crime story.

    Pete has the horns with a feature on Necrot, plus the guys do a Killer Cage Match, mayhem from Chris, and much more!

    Music by Necrot, Laceration, and Claustrophobia.

    Get your copy of Jeff's true crime book, "Beyond the Headlines", and advance order one today from Wild Blue Press!

    Order mech, join the 666 Club, and more at Murder Metal Mayhem. You can also sign up for the 666 Club on our Patreon page.

    Subscribe to our YouTube channel so you don't miss any of the content, including the new 666 Seconds of MURDER videos. Check out the new Throwing the Horns heavy metal channel for all the killer episodes, plus band interviews, and more!

    We also have Instagram and Threads - so keep in touch with Murder Metal Mayhem even more!

    Order any of Pete's books on his website with a great online store. You can order his latest book, "Creation of Chaos: Volume IV", a short story collection.

    Follow Joey's Goremonger page for updates on his music and his distro, FTA Records.

    Spreading like a case of the clap in a trailer park!

    • 2 hr 3 min
    Episode 258 - Bruce McArthur: Pushing Up Daisies

    Episode 258 - Bruce McArthur: Pushing Up Daisies

    Pete, Chris, and Joey tear another episode to shreds with a feature on the disturbing case of Bruce McArthur. His 8 murders in Toronto shocked the world when it was discovered he buried the remains in large planters he installed as a landscaper! They're joined by their Canadian co-host, Shane Borczuch, for the conversation into the crimes.

    Joey has the horns and leads the discussion into Anal Blast, plus the guys deal a new Killer Cage Match, mayhem stories from Pete and Joey, the announcement of the new Throwing the Horns podcast, plus much more!

    Music by Anal Blast, Replicant, and Graceless.

    Get your copy of Jeff's true crime book, "Beyond the Headlines", and advance order one today from Wild Blue Press!

    Order mech, join the 666 Club, and more at Murder Metal Mayhem. You can also sign up for the 666 Club on our Patreon page.

    Subscribe to our YouTube channel so you don't miss any of the content, including the new 666 Seconds of MURDER videos. Check out the new Throwing the Horns heavy metal channel for all the killer episodes, plus band interviews, and more!

    We also have Instagram and Threads - so keep in touch with Murder Metal Mayhem even more!

    Order any of Pete's books on his website with a great online store. You can order his latest book, "Creation of Chaos: Volume IV", a short story collection.

    Follow Joey's Goremonger page for updates on his music and his distro, FTA Records.

    Spreading like a case of the clap in a trailer park!

    • 2 hr 11 min
    Bonus Episode - Interview with Morgue Mike

    Bonus Episode - Interview with Morgue Mike

    Pete sits down to interview a man with 20 years of experience working in a morgue, who is a long-time listener and 666 Club Member. We're calling him "Morgue Mike" to keep his anonymity due to the sensitive nature of his job as a  Forensic Pathologist Assistant.

    They discuss Mike's unlikely inspiration for wanting to get into the field, the education and training he's had, his job duties in the morgue including autopsies, the Harvard Morgue Scandal where allegedly the manager and his wife sold parts of donated bodies for five years, and much more.

    It's a darkly interesting conversation between these two guys who have an interest in heavy metal and true crime!

    Order mech, join the 666 Club, and more at Murder Metal Mayhem. You can also sign up for the 666 Club on our Patreon page.

    Subscribe to our YouTube channel so you don't miss any of the content, including the new 666 Seconds of MURDER videos. Check out the new 666 Seconds of METAL channel for all the killer episodes, plus band interviews, and more!

    We also have Instagram and Threads - so keep in touch with Murder Metal Mayhem even more!

    Order any of Pete's books on his website with a great online store. You can order his latest book, "Creation of Chaos: Volume IV", a short story collection.

    Follow Joey's Goremonger page for updates on his music and his distro, FTA Records.

    Spreading like a case of the clap in a trailer park!

    • 30 min
    Episode 257 - Elyse Pahler: The Slayer Murder

    Episode 257 - Elyse Pahler: The Slayer Murder

    Pete, Chris, and Joey tear apart another episode with a feature on the 1995 case of Elyse Pahler and the Slayer Murder. The guys celebrate their 6-year anniversary with this story about three teenage metalheads who performed a human sacrifice so their band would score a record deal.

    Chris ha the horns in the metal segment and leads the charge with a discussion on The Omnific, plus the guys do a new Killer Cage Match, mayhem stories from Chris and Pete, and lots more of the usual insanity!  

    Music by Suffer, Corpse Molester Cult, and The Omnific.

    Get your copy of The Profiler from Scorpion Lair Games today on Kickstarter!

    Order mech, join the 666 Club, and more at Murder Metal Mayhem. You can also sign up for the 666 Club on our Patreon page.

    Subscribe to our YouTube channel so you don't miss any of the content, including the new 666 Seconds of MURDER videos. Check out the new 666 Seconds of METAL channel for all the killer episodes, plus band interviews, and more!

    We also have Instagram and Threads - so keep in touch with Murder Metal Mayhem even more!

    Order any of Pete's books on his website with a great online store. You can order his latest book, "Creation of Chaos: Volume IV", a short story collection.

    Follow Joey's Goremonger page for updates on his music and his distro, FTA Records.

    Spreading like a case of the clap in a trailer park!

    • 1 hr 58 min

Customer Reviews

4.4 out of 5
34 Ratings

34 Ratings

Mayhem 115 ,

Great podcast

This is a cool podcast. I enjoy it all but especially the music section. It nice to hear about the new thrash metal coming out and the local scene. The Mayhem part always leaves me laughing. I can confirm that the stories about Bags in the Frankenstein episode are pretty accurate and a great tribute to a funny guy that lived his life.

J22792 ,

Posers Be Gone!!!

Tell CK to chill out I was driving down wildman and I swear that wild SOB put a cinderblock right through my windshield. I guess next time I have the balls to drive down wildman I better be playing some heavier metal.

Chris Benoit's Dong ,

Rip Off

Not bad but it is most definitely a rip off of Death Metal Detectives. Check them out if you like this but want more metal, hilarious comedy, and more “karaoke”. Team Goosehammer forever!

Top Podcasts In Comedy

The Joe Rogan Experience
Joe Rogan
KILL TONY
DEATHSQUAD.TV & Studio71
SmartLess
Jason Bateman, Sean Hayes, Will Arnett
Call Her Daddy
Alex Cooper
This Past Weekend w/ Theo Von
Theo Von
Wiser Than Me with Julia Louis-Dreyfus
Lemonada Media

You Might Also Like

Morbid
Morbid Network | Wondery
Last Podcast On The Left
The Last Podcast Network
Crime Junkie
audiochuck
True Crime All The Time
Emash Digital / Wondery
Timesuck with Dan Cummins
Dan Cummins
Small Town Murder
James Pietragallo, Jimmie Whisman