I'm lucky enough to be joined on this The Jabot episode by Saira Mohamed, the Agnes Roddy Robb Chair in Jurisprudence, Ethics, and Social Responsibility and a professor of law at the University of California, Berkeley. She's the author of What a Country Owes Its Soldiers. After the get-to-know question, we get into the nitty-gritty of her argument. Mohamed argues that a government owes service members the same duties it owes everyone under its control, including protection from unnecessary dangers and from illegal orders. We talk about the Feres Doctrine, the myth of the volunteer, exploitation, legal remedies and readiness. Key Takeaways Mohamed argues that a country owes its soldiers the same duties it owes every person under its authority and control. Military service is necessarily dangerous, but she says that doesn't make every danger necessary, and the government owes a duty to avoid the unnecessary ones. The Feres Doctrine, read broadly, bars service members and their survivors from suing for injuries sustained in service, which Mohamed calls a very strange rule. "They signed up for it" falls short, she says, because service members can't simply quit and can be prosecuted for leaving. Mohamed sees cultural change, understanding soldiers as people and not instruments, as the step that comes before any legal fix. About the Guest Saira Mohamed is the Agnes Roddy Robb Chair in Jurisprudence, Ethics, and Social Responsibility and a professor of law at the University of California, Berkeley, where she teaches and writes about criminal law and human rights. Her interest in war and mass violence took her from international affairs to law school. She is the author of What a Country Owes Its Soldiers, published by Harvard University Press. Links and Resources What a Country Owes Its Soldiers by Saira Mohamed (Harvard University Press): https://www.hup.harvard.edu/books/9780674301641 Keywords JAB Podcast, Kathryn Rubino, Above the Law, Saira Mohamed, What a Country Owes Its Soldiers, Feres Doctrine, military law, rights of service members, illegal orders, Uniform Code of Military Justice, all-volunteer military, civil-military relations, military readiness, cannon fodder, human rights law, Berkeley Law, legal industry, legal professionals, law professor interview, legal podcast Episode Highlights [00:00:00 - 00:04:16] Saira Mohamed explains how an interest in war and mass violence led her to law school, and why Perspectives on Legal Thought still shapes her work. [00:04:16 - 00:05:19] Her short answer to the title question: a country owes soldiers the duties it owes every person under its control. [00:05:19 - 00:06:23] The Feres Doctrine, and how broadly it has been read to bar suits over injuries sustained in service. [00:06:23 - 00:07:45] Why dangerous service doesn't make every danger necessary, from helicopter maintenance to illegal orders. [00:07:45 - 00:11:44] Why the all-volunteer military doesn't settle the question, from service contracts to desertion prosecutions. [00:11:44 - 00:13:27] Who serves today, and what the "warrior caste" description says about the public's distance from the military. [00:13:27 - 00:17:37] Sacrifice versus exploitation, and why "cannon fodder" still describes how service members are treated. [00:17:37 - 00:20:46] Remedies: opening up Feres for some claims and using the UCMJ crime of oppression. [00:20:46 - 00:24:34] Civil-military relations, and why seeing soldiers as people supports healthy ones. [00:24:34 - 00:27:24] The readiness question: why treating troops as people and keeping operations lawful go hand in hand with readiness.