![](/assets/artwork/1x1-42817eea7ade52607a760cbee00d1495.gif)
65 episodes
![](/assets/artwork/1x1-42817eea7ade52607a760cbee00d1495.gif)
Rewind the Love Podcast rewindthelove
-
- TV & Film
-
-
4.2 • 78 Ratings
-
A reality nostalgia podcast recapping VH1's Celebreality competition shows.
-
I Love New York S2E1 - Little People, Big D*cks
We're back in the New York groove! Things get off to an interesting start as twenty "new" contestants (read: Great Value versions of S1 guys) have come to compete for the love of our Queen Tiffany.
Support the show and get access to our bonus episodes donating to our Patreon account: www.patreon.com/rewindthelovepod
Follow along with us by watching “I Love New York“ on Hulu. Also, don't forget to rate/review/subscribe/tell all your friends about us!
RtL Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/rewindlovepod/
RtL Twitter & Instagram: @rewindlovepod
Theme: “disco diva 30,” Colin Willsher (via Storyblocks) -
I Love New York S2E2 - Wet Ass Presents
As the guys' swimming skills are put to the test as they have to cross a pond to deliver a present to New York, we learn that some of them are willing to lie, cheat, and steal to win her love.
Support the show and get access to our bonus episodes donating to our Patreon account: www.patreon.com/rewindthelovepod
Follow along with us by watching “I Love New York“ on Hulu. Also, don't forget to rate/review/subscribe/tell all your friends about us!
RtL Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/rewindlovepod/
RtL Twitter & Instagram: @rewindlovepod
Theme: “disco diva 30,” Colin Willsher (via Storyblocks) -
I Love New York S2E4 - Bad Boys Club
Support the show and get access to our bonus episodes donating to our Patreon account: www.patreon.com/rewindthelovepod
Don't forget to rate/review/subscribe/tell all your friends about us!
RtL Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/rewindlovepod/
RtL Twitter & Instagram: @rewindlovepod
Theme: “disco diva 30,” Colin Willsher (via Storyblocks) -
I Love New York S2E5 - Pricks
What We’re Watching: 0:03:17 - 0:14:12
Feelings Corner: 0:19:04-0:33:33
Support the show and get access to our bonus episodes donating to our Patreon account: www.patreon.com/rewindthelovepod
Follow along with us by watching “I Love New York“ on Hulu. Also, don't forget to rate/review/subscribe/tell all your friends about us!
RtL Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/rewindlovepod/
RtL Twitter & Instagram: @rewindlovepod
Theme: “disco diva 30,” Colin Willsher (via Storyblocks) -
I Love New York S2E6 - DONE DONE
One Mo Chance Trailer: 0:22:12-0:25:42
FOL & ILNY All-Stars: 0:25:42-0:35:35
Support the show and get access to our bonus episodes donating to our Patreon account: www.patreon.com/rewindthelovepod
Follow along with us by watching “I Love New York“ on Hulu. Also, don't forget to rate/review/subscribe/tell all your friends about us!
RtL Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/rewindlovepod/
RtL Twitter & Instagram: @rewindlovepod
Theme: “disco diva 30,” Colin Willsher (via Storyblocks) -
Rock of Love S1E1 - It's Hard Out Here for a Pimp
Time for a completely new franchise! Mike and Sonia reacquaint themselves with Bret Michaels, Big John, and the 25 ladies who put the "hot" and/or "mess" in "hot mess" competing for Bret's heart on the inaugural season of Rock of Love.
Support the show and get access to our bonus episodes donating to our Patreon account: www.patreon.com/rewindthelovepod
Follow along with us by watching “Charm School“ on Amazon Prime, Hulu, or Tubi. Also, don't forget to rate/review/subscribe/tell all your friends about us!
RtL Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/rewindlovepod/
RtL Twitter & Instagram: @rewindlovepod
Theme: “I Want You,” Paul Mitchell Beebe (via Storyblocks)
Customer Reviews
My Favorite Podcast
This has become my comfort podcast that I listen to over and over again. Mike and Sonia are so fun and enjoyable to listen to and they have some great guests (Alvin, Huey, Troy, and Sarah Hunt are my faves!) I love the early 2000’s reality show era and their commentary on it is great.
Come back!
This podcast is so entertaining. I love how they dissect the episodes. This show is funny and I like the dynamic between the two hosts and their guests! I hope they release new episodes.
Good podcast, but only in doses
Listen, I wanted to give this podcast 5 stars. They cover some of my favorite shows from the Celebreality era of VH1. Yes, they’re mostly entertaining. They are pretty thorough. But what makes me go down two stars is one of the cohost, Sonia. She interrupts constantly, she talks over her husband Mike all the time, she is rude and dismissive of his commentary (which btw, is usually more entertaining than hers!). I’ll give an example. She’ll give her commentary, then Mike comes in and gives his (all while she’s still trying to talk over him mind you) and she’ll get this condescending tone and just be like “okay?” to pretty much anything that he says. That or a long pause and a rude “anyway”. I can’t stand it. I have to turn off the podcast sometimes because of it. What a shame, because like I said, their content is pretty good and I actually do wish they’d come back to finish reviewing more of the Of Love era shows and seasons. TLDR; Podcast is entertaining, one of the hosts makes it somewhat unbearable to listen to at times.