Narativ with Zev Shalev (Audio)

Zev Shalev

Uncover the hidden forces shaping our world. Zev applies his skills gained as a journalist and news executive for 30 years to give viewers and listeners an unparalleled view of events changing our world.  Narativ is Where Truth Lives. www.narativ.org

  1. 4d ago

    ELECTION ROUNDUP WITH SCOTT MACFARLANE

    Four days out, MeidasTouch’s chief Washington correspondent told Narativ Live to read the money and the plane, not the polls. Scott MacFarlane came back from Michigan with a measure of this election that no poll prints. He told Zev Shalev on Friday to watch “where the surrogates and the money are going,” because that is “a much better read than polls ever will be.” MacFarlane reads the plane first. Trump has flown to South Carolina twice in two weeks, to Kansas and Iowa, and on Monday, MacFarlane said, he lands in Louisiana, where Sen. Bill Cassidy finished third in May’s primary and nobody polls the seat. Democrats send their money the other way: their Senate Majority PAC put $1.2 million behind Scott Colom against Sen. Cindy Hyde-Smith in Mississippi, and the Republicans’ Senate Leadership Fund answered with seven figures. “If they’re putting money into Mississippi, they’re seeing something polls can’t show,” MacFarlane said. The Democrats he talks to feel “optimism and nausea,” and trust the polls “about as much as they trust thin ice on a warm winter day.” MacFarlane called the Republicans Trump is flying to save “endangered Republicans”; Shalev said they are becoming an endangered species. One, by MacFarlane’s count, has put daylight between herself and Trump: Rep. Ashley Hinson in Iowa, and even her criticism is “muted” and “mushy.” Michigan, where he spent the week: tariffs are the issue, MacFarlane said, and in the Lansing district the Iran war is too. Rep. Tom Barrett, a Republican, voted twice this summer to pull U.S. forces out of Iran and told MacFarlane he “caught all kinds of hell” for it. Michigan’s 10th, 7th and 4th districts are, in his count, “the margin Democrats need to pull even.” Shalev’s read: the House most likely flips; the Senate is “still very much too hard to call.” The Senate race there has, MacFarlane said, “naked Islamophobia being uncorked in” it; Republican Mike Rogers is betting on a divide between Democrat Abdul El-Sayed and Detroit’s voters, and MacFarlane is “not seeing that work.” Shalev said the Islamophobia is backfiring. MacFarlane saved Alaska for last. Trump had Attorney General Todd Blanche’s Justice Department sue to stop the state certifying the result if Sen. Dan Sullivan loses; Alaska’s own election officials asked the federal judge to throw it out. Shalev called the suit a first. MacFarlane called it “ballot stacking crap” and said the administration “is quickly losing credibility with all of the courts.” MacFarlane anchors the MeidasTouch Network’s election night on YouTube from the first poll closings in Indiana and Kentucky. His Substack, MacFarlane Reports, runs daily until then. This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.narativ.org/subscribe

    ELECTION ROUNDUP WITH SCOTT MACFARLANE
  2. 4d ago

    NEW ANALYSIS: Trump Moves Past Betraying Ukraine to Aiding Russia

    Sergey Lavrov landed in Atlanta on Friday morning for the G20 foreign ministers’ meeting. A day earlier Russia flew a jet drone into the platform at Dnipro’s main railway station as a train boarded and killed at least 14 people; CNN counted 15. Those two facts opened Narativ Live, and by the end of it Sean Wiswesser and Olga Lautman, a Russia analyst, had said it plainly. “This is not America isolationist policy,” Lautman said. “This is America siding with Russia.” Zev Shalev went a step further: this is no longer betrayal, it is Trump aiding and abetting Russia. Wiswesser ran a CIA station, and put the first number on it: Patriot interceptor deliveries to Ukraine are down to one quarter of January’s rate, by his count, “and it’s costing lives.” Pentagon chief Pete Hegseth had neither approved nor rejected the transfers Europe already paid for, the Washington Post reported Oct. 19; Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky asked him Monday to “unblock the deliveries.” Starshield, the military Starlink, was speed-capped in mid-October with no notice: a terminal moving faster than 100 mph loses its link. Lautman blamed the Pentagon, not Elon Musk, and Musk agrees: the limits, he said Oct. 24, are “decided by the US military and ultimately POTUS.” Hegseth denies any directive. Whoever’s hand is on the switch, the switch does the same thing. Trump signed Sen. Lindsey Graham’s sanctions law on Sept. 18 and waived every provision of it on Oct. 16, in an order with no end date that never uses the word Ukraine. On Oct. 9 the Treasury licensed Russian diesel; the first tanker, the Agioi Fanendes, was due in New Jersey on Nov. 7 and now sits “for orders,” after Gov. Mikie Sherrill called the deal illegal on Thursday and said she is looking for ways to stop it. “Congress needs to take action,” Wiswesser said. “Why aren’t they acting to enforce the law?” Lautman counted one Republican who has acted, Sen. Thom Tillis, the only one to sign the Oct. 24 letter to banks and ports. Wiswesser’s book, Tradecraft, Tactics, and Dirty Tricks: Russian Intelligence and Putin’s Secret War (Naval Institute Press), is out now and, he said, topped Audible’s espionage releases last month; he told the audience the proudest boast today should be “I am a Ukrainian.” On Friday Reuters reported that Pentagon officials privately urged Lithuania, Latvia and Estonia to tone down their warnings about Russia; the Pentagon’s policy chief advised one Baltic official against “poking” Moscow, and Estonia says nothing of the kind came through official channels. Lautman’s version: the Pentagon told allies to shut up and stop poking Russia. In the same weeks drones hit at least three merchant ships off Bulgaria and Romania and more than 20 sailors were lost; Romania blamed Russia for one, the Khoryv, sunk off Constanța on Oct. 23. “This is war,” Lautman said. “You hit ships with drones and you sink the ships.” Russia bombed a train station, and Romania says a Russian drone sank a merchant ship in NATO waters, in the same two weeks Washington licensed its diesel, waived its sanctions and asked the neighbors to keep quiet. Narativ reported on Oct. 20 that Russia is being paid before the talks. This week the payment went from money to cover. A House that flips on Tuesday makes any Trump-Putin deal hard to get through Congress; as Shalev put it, voters can change the outcome of this war by how they vote. The Kremlin wants its Abu Dhabi round of talks after Nov. 4, and Nov. 3 sets the price. The Agioi Fanendes, idling with no port confirmed, will show which way the shipowners bet first. Thank you Dani Smart, Amy Gabrielle, Caro Henry, John Mahoney, Lalisa, and many others for tuning into my live video with Olga Lautman and Sean Wiswesser! Join me for my next live video in the app. This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.narativ.org/subscribe

    NEW ANALYSIS: Trump Moves Past Betraying Ukraine to Aiding Russia
  3. 6d ago

    Bucha Mayor Trolls Trump's Diesel Deal With Putin

    The mayor of Bucha has an answer to Donald Trump's diesel deal with Vladimir Putin. He posted a photo of himself holding a jerry can of diesel and asked everyone to fill one and ship it to the United States, so Ukraine can outsupply Putin and save Americans billions. Jacob Kaarsbo saw the post on the mayor's phone on Monday, after the two laid flowers at the Bucha memorial. The former Danish intelligence officer joined Narativ Live from Kyiv on Wednesday, four days after driving in from Copenhagen with a convoy of 11 cars for the Ukrainian army. One blew its engine on the road. Cars for Ukraine, the Danish group behind the convoys, passes 1,000 vehicles next month. Kaarsbo's reading of the diesel deal: Russia has no diesel to spare. It has an export ban in force and has been importing diesel through South Korea. The deal is "smoke and mirrors," he said, a route to getting sanctions lifted. Zev Shalev went further: it puts Russian oil back into the open market and legitimizes the shadow fleet. The anger in Kyiv is real and mostly unspoken, Kaarsbo said. "They feel the betrayal." A senior Ukrainian officer told him on Wednesday, through a translator, that Ukraine and Denmark have to fight Russian fascism together. Then he laughed and added: and American fascism too. Kaarsbo named Putin's war crime: the deportation of Ukrainian children, which Putin has bragged about. Trump, he said, is threatening sanctions on the International Criminal Court that prosecutes such crimes. "Donald Trump sides with him." Why now? Danish pundits say Trump wants cheaper diesel before the midterms. Kaarsbo called that "b******t." He expects Trump to try to hold power whatever the result; Denver Riggleman has warned the machinery to annul a defeat is already in the works. Shalev offered two scenarios: Russia helps the GOP win, or a Nixon ending if the vote collapses far enough that the party tells him to go. Kaarsbo said he predicted this in his book: Putin manipulates Trump through a "treasonous web" of finances. The Financial Times showed this weekend how the Russians got into the Alaska gas deal; Shalev named the route: Don Jr.'s hunting companion, a man tied to Putin's bodyguards. On Starlink, Kaarsbo said Europe has the satellite technology and must scale it. While Musk was throttling Ukraine's connection, someone sabotaged Starlink antennas in Bulgaria, Poland and Lithuania. "Classical GRU stuff," he said. He woke at 3 a.m. Monday to the air defense battery next to his hotel. The one place in the city with real destruction is a marketplace with no military target in sight, struck again and again. The students were drinking in the park the next night. His last word: Ukraine is doing well on the front line and innovating faster than Russia. Build it up from Europe and Canada and it can end the war without the Americans. Shalev: Carney already has a plan with Zelensky. SourcesNarativ Live, Oct. 28, 2026, live from Kyiv with Jacob Kaarsbo (the replay)Jacob Kaarsbo, Intel Brief, "Live from Kyiv Q&A Special," Oct. 27, 2026: https://jacobkaarsbo.substack.com/p/live-from-kyiv-q-and-a-specialKyiv Post, Oct. 27, 2026, Treasury weighs lifting sanctions on the Russian Direct Investment Fund (NYT): https://www.kyivpost.com/post/88359CNBC, Oct. 24, 2026, Starlink restored, Musk admits throttle: https://www.cnbc.com/2026/10/24/ukraine-starlink-starshield-service-restored.html This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.narativ.org/subscribe

    Bucha Mayor Trolls Trump's Diesel Deal With Putin
  4. Oct 28

    BREAKING NEWS: EISENKOT DECLARES VICTORY IN ISRAELI ELECTIONS

    Polls closed in Israel at 10 p.m. local time, which is 4 p.m. in New York. Within the hour the three main channels put the bloc led by Gadi Eisenkot at 52 seats and Netanyahu's at 50, with the Arab lists at 17 or 18, the most they have ever held. Zev went live on Narativ at 7:30 p.m. and read the night the other way from the wires: "A lot of the reporting out there is going to say that exit polls indicate a deadlock. I don't believe that's the case." The reason was the speech. Eisenkot stood up at his headquarters and said, "We made history." He called the outgoing government "the coalition of the fiasco" and said the voters "voted against Bibi Netanyahu as the Prime Minister of the State of Israel." He ruled out another election: "In elections with such a high turnout, it would be a mistake to go out for a second round." "Netanyahu, do not dare use the security of Israel for your needs." He promised a Zionist government and said, "It is the end of the era of them and us." Zev heard a former chief of staff putting the military on notice: the soldiers answer to an interim prime minister now, and Netanyahu was warned not to use them to protect himself. That matters in the White House, because Trump has been saying he goes back to war with Iran next week alongside his best friend, and his best friend just lost power. "With one of them gone, it's really interesting how it's going to fall apart for Trump." Lev Parnas joined from a car in Florida. "Two down. Bolsonaro and Bibi, and Trump's next," he said. He was cautious about the next 30 days: calls were already being placed to Israel from the Trump administration, and Netanyahu would push back hard. Lev's precedent was Orban, who rumbled about staying until the power of the people was too strong. Zev's was Lula: saying it is over is what ends the rigging conversation. Both men put the Arab vote at the center. Turnout reached 77.7%, and the Arab turnout ran higher, because those voters wanted the Oct. 7 inquiry Netanyahu never allowed. Seventeen seats for parties that used to stay home is what makes Eisenkot's coalition and breaks Netanyahu's. The consequence runs past Israel. Netanyahu helped install Trump in 2016 as part of the alliance Narativ calls the enemies of democracy, and the money followed: a billion dollars under Bibi's oversight through Jared Kushner, the Gaza waterfront plans, the Epstein network that tied Netanyahu to Putin. Lev wanted the new government's first act to be aid into Gaza and an end to the bombing. The official count takes days, and Netanyahu has not spoken. Likud's 24 seats make it the largest party and still leave him nowhere to build. Eisenkot declared victory, told Bibi to retire, and told the army whose orders to follow. The count decides whether Israel heard him. This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.narativ.org/subscribe

    BREAKING NEWS: EISENKOT DECLARES VICTORY IN ISRAELI ELECTIONS
  5. Oct 27

    Democrats Tie Trump To Epstein But Have Not Made The Case (Yet)

    The House Judiciary Democrats put a case in writing Monday: Donald Trump as a participant in Jeffrey Epstein's crimes, and Todd Blanche covering it up. On Narativ Live, Ellie Leonard, who reads the Epstein files page by page, and Zev Shalev agreed on the aim and doubted the work. Leonard called the report "a big buildup to a best-of album." The Katie Johnson story, the Jane Doe stories and the Maxwell proffer were already public, she said, and "it just wasn't good enough at this late stage in the game." Shalev said the point of the document is a special counsel in a new Congress, and launching one against a sitting president "is about as serious as you can get." "Don't fail this." Both read the Blanche interview the same way. Blanche flew to a Florida prison in July 2025, Maxwell raised Jane three times, and he cut her off each time; the FBI had built him a slide deck of prominent names the night before, and Jane was on it. Leonard typed her own transcript of the tapes. By her count Blanche asked about Trump far less than about Bill Clinton, Bill Gates, Reid Hoffman and Bill Barr, Maxwell called Trump "a total gentleman," and that short exchange, in her reading, is what got Maxwell moved. She put the dates together: the birthday letter Wall Street Journal reporters published, the Situation Room meeting the same day, the proffer one week later, the move to Bryan, Texas, one week after that. Shalev held the line: obstruction "may be true, but we don't know," and the report does not say who sent Blanche the deck or who compiled it. Leonard's own leads sit where the report did not look. Hundreds of pages of handwritten FBI notes are unsearchable, so nothing in them was scrubbed. A whistleblower says documents under case number 31E-HQ-C1461253 are withheld from Congress, and someone at the Justice Department leaked Jane Doe 4's notes, unredacted, to conservative media. She counts 43 on-the-record accusations of sexual assault against Trump. There are no foreign-language files in the release. Shalev's lead is money. Paolo Zampolli, Trump's "my friend Paolo" in Beatrice Keul's account, arranged visas for models, sold fake passports through the United Nations and sold Trump Soho condos, and was a special envoy until last week; the report mentions him only as the visa guy. Nothing in the files predates 2008, the year Shalev says Epstein helped crash the market. A special counsel scoped to sex crimes alone would repeat the Mueller mistake, and one that reports to the attorney general cannot work. Leonard added the shield: executive privilege, which only the Supreme Court can override. Shalev said on air that he gave Raskin's office material from Narativ's Zampolli reporting and introduced one witness, and that this is not an endorsement of the report. The Keul allegation, he said, is the new thing in it, and the question now is who in Congress writes the special counsel's mission. This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.narativ.org/subscribe

    Democrats Tie Trump To Epstein But Have Not Made The Case (Yet)
  6. Oct 26

    LULA BEATS TRUMP’S MAN — AND SERBIA’S STRONGMAN FALLS THE SAME NIGHT

    Brazil’s electoral court called it at 9:12 PM Brasília time. With 99.76 percent of sections counted, Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva took 51.75 percent — 64,066,539 votes — to Flávio Bolsonaro’s 48.25 percent, 59,724,015. A margin of 4.3 million. A fourth term. And, as Zev put it from the desk Sunday night, the end of “the most sustained campaign a US administration has ever run to pick Brazil’s president.” Three weeks ago this was Flávio’s to lose. He beat Lula in the first round on October 4 by 2.2 million votes. Trump called it “a very tight but great victory.” Prediction markets had him at 78 percent as polls opened Sunday morning. The polls said 51–49. The polls were right. How the night went Polls were due to close at 4 PM Eastern. At 4:11, Supreme Court Justice Cristiano Zanin ordered every station in the country to stay open two more hours after both campaigns asked for time — Lula’s coalition citing bus service cut in São Paulo and Salvador, Flávio’s citing weather. The electoral court froze the count at 4:20 with a quarter of one percent in. It restarted at six. Lula led the first boxes. Flávio passed him at about 15 percent counted and held the lead through 45. Then the South and Southeast — the regions Flávio was supposed to own — came in, and Lula went from nothing to two million ahead. “Squeaked away with quite a resounding victory,” Zev said on air. “I say squeak and resounding in the same sentence. It doesn’t always fit.” Turnout was 80.79 percent of 158.7 million registered voters. What Brazil voted against Reuters reported Saturday, on ten current and former US officials, that Trump’s team spent eighteen months working to return the Bolsonaros to power: Magnitsky sanctions on Alexandre de Moraes, the justice who convicted Jair Bolsonaro of plotting a coup; visas revoked for the justices who sat with him; tariffs on Brazilian goods with the father’s prosecution named as the reason; a terrorist designation for Brazil’s gangs announced the day after Flávio met Deputy Secretary of State Christopher Landau in May. Eduardo Bolsonaro worked the State Department from Washington. Lula told voters for months that Washington was trying to pick their president. Zev’s read Sunday night went further: that the Trump administration’s hand showed in the first round, and that the second round was the one Brazil got to decide for itself. “Trump will try and make it seem like he had nothing to do with all of this,” he said. “He was caught in the cookie jar.” Flávio had promised amnesty for his father, who is serving 27 years. He admitted taking about $12 million from banker Daniel Vorcaro to fund a film about him and is under investigation for corruption, money laundering and tax evasion. Brazil read all of that and still gave him 48 percent. Not a landslide. A decision. Serbia, the same night Aleksandar Vučić conceded Serbia’s parliamentary election ninety minutes after polls closed in Belgrade — fourteen years of one-man rule, gone to a leaderless Students’ List with no politicians on it. By his own party’s projection the students take 135 to 140 of 250 seats to his 105, roughly 2.2 million votes to 1.7 million, on turnout near 70 percent — the highest since Milošević fell in 2000. He blamed independent media, unnamed European governments and “an American deep state.” Putin had endorsed him. The movement began under a concrete canopy at the Novi Sad railway station that collapsed in November 2024 and killed sixteen people. Dijana Hrka, who lost her son there, told N1 from the Belgrade crowd: “I have been waiting for this moment for two years.” And in Venezuela, María Corina Machado slipped back into the country Sunday after a year outside it — the story Narativ led with at 1:30 PM, before Brazil took the night. The pattern Orbán fell in April after sixteen years. Vučić fell Sunday after fourteen. Brazil kept Trump’s man out. Three ballots in one year on the same model — Putin’s endorsement, Trump’s friendship, the courts and the broadcaster in one set of hands — and the model lost all three. Israel votes next. The United States votes November 3. Zev’s note to the chat as the Brazil numbers settled: the tactic that showed up in São Paulo Sunday — the buses that didn’t run — travels. “Plan extra hours when you go to the polls on the 3rd.” Trump phoned Lula before the vote and wished him luck. His State Department declined, in writing, to say it would respect the result. Now it has one. Watch the full breaking news broadcast above. Subscribe free — The Narativ in your inbox every day. Know Sooner: narativ.org This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.narativ.org/subscribe

    LULA BEATS TRUMP’S MAN — AND SERBIA’S STRONGMAN FALLS THE SAME NIGHT
  7. Oct 23

    Russia Is Sinking Ships To Provoke a NATO Reaction

    A Russian drone sank the cargo ship Khoryv 13 miles off Constanța, Romania, on Friday morning. One sailor dead, three missing. Olga Lautman counts seven ships hit in the Black Sea in two weeks and 31 sailors dead or missing. "This used to start world wars," she said on Narativ Live. Europe is shifting forces to the Black Sea, she said. It is barely news. Ukraine, Romania and Bulgaria have asked NATO to guard the lanes; Zev Shalev called it an act of war and NATO's job, pending an American sign-off. On Starlink, four views. Lautman's view: Starshield, the military version, sits on a Pentagon contract Europe pays for, so the order came from Trump to the Pentagon and nobody needed Musk. "This is on Trump. This is not Musk." Lev Parnas said the question is the trick. "Who cares if it's Musk, Trump. The bottom line, it's not working." Oleksandr Bolbirer, who writes Voice of Ukraine from Kyiv, said some units have service back and some do not. "On top, it's sunshine. If you look on the bottom, there's still some fog out there." Shalev's point: whoever flipped the switch, Ukraine's drones have flown blind for nine days, while Jared Kushner told Zelensky not to hit refineries. They split again on why Russia is hitting Kyiv so hard now. Bolbirer thinks Moscow is sprinting before the American vote: "They're not going to have as many chances as they have today." Lautman disagreed flat. Russia's turn on Kyiv began the day Trump took office, she said, and "the Russians don't give a flying s**t about American elections." Shalev read both as one argument: Russia moves when American power changes hands, and it does in 12 days. Parnas called Bolbirer's view "Ukrainian hope." Nobody disputed the rest: cluster munitions over Kyiv, eight regions' power stations hit in 24 hours, a heating season begun on the 15th with the pipes still cold, Bolbirer's daughter barely in school. "They are erasing us," Bolbirer said. "But we want to live." On Nov. 3, Parnas says his sources have Trump and Speaker Johnson agreeing not to convene the new Congress, "almost a done deal." Lautman expects Democrats to be seated, by an uprising in American streets if need be, and then expects little: a subpoena to Musk goes nowhere without a Justice Department to enforce it. What comes after splits them too. Lautman: the Trump–Xi meeting on the 18th produces nothing, Putin is China's client, and no one can sign away Ukrainian land without a referendum. Bolbirer: dictators do not read rules, and if the big powers sit down together, "who's going to come in?" Parnas: the next front is energy, Russian gas back to fill the hole Iran's strikes on Qatar opened, and he does not trust Germany or France through a winter. Lautman trusts the eastern flank whatever Germany does. Shalev: it is one movement, capturing democracies one at a time, and what Bolbirer lives under could reach America in months; a big enough vote on Nov. 3 is the first answer, and Trump cannot face Xi for a country that just voted against him. This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.narativ.org/subscribe

    Russia Is Sinking Ships To Provoke a NATO Reaction
4.7
out of 5
180 Ratings

About

Uncover the hidden forces shaping our world. Zev applies his skills gained as a journalist and news executive for 30 years to give viewers and listeners an unparalleled view of events changing our world.  Narativ is Where Truth Lives. www.narativ.org

You Might Also Like