I just recently discovered this podcast earlier this week, and i’ve already listened to majority of the episodes! I don’t know what it is about their voices but it’s so comforting to listen to and it’s clear they do their research before discussing topics.

I love this podcast. It feels like I’m sitting down and just hanging out with some friends. I love how personable it is as well! It’s really great 😁

the light hearted banter and causality to this podcast makes it unique compared to other supernatural/crime podcasts. i always look forward to going on a drive just so i can listen to the next episode. can’t wait to see what y’all come up with next!!

It’s 18 minutes and I’m still waiting for the meat of the episode. 🥱 It’s 24 minutes now and I give up.

Hi, I just recently started listening this week. I love the vibe you both send out, and the stories I enjoy all of them! I love the topics. I was just listening to a podcast that was about the water park in Jersey and I saw the comments that Nikki wrote :/ so I just wanted to show some love to you both. Kath sending you much love! Don’t let them get you down. I listen to you guys while I’m at work all day lol. I do medical bulking and it gets stressful especially with Covid. You both make my day so much more enjoyable thank you for that! I’m trying my best to catch up to the current podcasts lol but I am enjoying every single one on my way to that. I have to admit sometimes I literally start busting up laughing on some things and my coworkers are like wth. Lol it’s like I’m part of the conversation you guys have it’s so easy to dive in and I have shared your podcasts with some friends they love it too lol. Anyways just wanted to show love and support for you both ;) Thank you again for these podcasts, please don’t stop lol hope you all have a great weekend.

I started listening around the time they started making them. Until COVID happened and I assumed one of them died because guess why. I didn’t know they started up till I was showing my brother about a week ago. It was so exiting when I saw they started making them again. I tried to listen to other podcast that are spooky and also scary but never liked them and don’t know why. But by far the best podcast ever.

I have listened to every single episode you guys have made and I loved every single one of them! I really like that you guys switch it up with different focuses of each episode! I was seriously so thrilled when you guys did the twilight episode. I was listening in my car nodding along in agreement and laughing at the comments you guys made about the series. I also very much hate the CGI baby, with a burning passion lol. Keep doing what you’re doing because you guys are awesome :)

I love how real these people are, in other podcast I’ve tried to watch they have been too fake. The stories are very interesting to me and I love how it feels like I’m in a conversation. 10 outta 10 recommend!

I love this podcast!

The woman says “like” and “uhm” SO much it’s hard to follow along or trust she’s well-researched. I made it about 40 minutes into the episode on Kids Who Kill and gave up. It just got super annoying. The guy spoke well but also did not seem well-researched. (Ex: time requirement/waiting period before Missing Persons report can be filed, neither were sure on this or if it was different in certain states or localities, most require NO wait period. Seriously, ever heard of The First 48? Goodness gracious. This is a dangerous thing to not know and to publish incorrect information on it as well with literally no research at all, is really just kind of upsetting.)