Third Opinion Podcast

Pamela Garron
  • 4.2 (17)
  • News Commentary
  • Weekly

Discussions on issues around antisemitism and the State of Israel.

  1. 6d ago

    Israel at a Crossroads: The War, the Elections and Rising Antisemitism

    Show recorded on October 26, 2026: Claims that Israel committed genocide continued to dominate international discourse as Third Opinion examined the war in Gaza, rising antisemitism and the challenges facing Israel. Recorded ahead of Israel's elections, the episode explored the country's political crossroads, including debate over Haredi men serving in the Israel Defense Forces (IDF) and the ultra-Orthodox parties' positions on military service. In an interview, Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu argued that diplomacy would not work with Hamas and that the only way to deal with the terrorist organization was to destroy it. He also attributed much of the worldwide anti-Israel sentiment to artificial intelligence and its role in spreading misinformation. Christian Lebanese activist, lecturer and author Brigitte Gabriel addressed the history of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, discussing the period when Egypt controlled Gaza and Jordan controlled the West Bank, as well as the founding of the Palestine Liberation Organization (PLO) and the subsequent conflict over Israel's legitimacy and prospects for peace. Gedaliah Blum of the Heartland Institute examined the international criticism directed at Israel and questioned the world's response to the war in Gaza, including the failure of other countries to help evacuate civilians to safety while Hamas operated in the territory. The program also featured Bill Maher's commentary on Jew-hatred and the inconsistencies in how antisemitism was addressed across the political spectrum, from the far right to the far left. Conservative columnist Chloe Trapanotto and British-Israeli commentator Eylon Levy challenged allegations of genocide and apartheid, arguing that the conflict was a war rather than a campaign of genocide. The discussion also examined Hamas's control over images released from Gaza and the influence of those images on international public opinion. Mike reviewed the week's major international and U.S. headlines, highlighting the stories shaping the debate over Israel, antisemitism and the future of the Middle East.

    Israel at a Crossroads: The War, the Elections and Rising Antisemitism

  2. Oct 22

    From Florida to Europe: Israel and the Issues Facing the Jewish Community

    Show recorded on October 20, 2026: Mike explored debates surrounding Israel, antisemitism and politics. He featured "Nicholas the Zionist" challenging Mehdi Hasan's remarks on Israel and Gaza, examined questions surrounding who knew about the October 7 attacks and discussed Florida's midterm elections and the U.S. Senate race.  Internationally, Mike covered an antisemitism conference in Ireland where hotel reservations were reportedly canceled over attendees' support for the IDF, and a controversy in Reggio Emilia, Italy, where the mayor reversed an anti-Israel declaration targeting a gathering of American and Israeli Jewish early childhood educators and apologized. The episode also featured Joseph Cohen of the Israeli Advocacy Movement answering questions about Gaza, Hamas and Israel's military response in an interview with a young Palestinian woman. Thank you for listening, subscribing and sharing the Third Opinion Podcast.

    From Florida to Europe: Israel and the Issues Facing the Jewish Community

  3. Oct 16 ·  Video

    Mamdani, Antisemitism and the Future of Israel

    Recorded on October 15, 2026: This episode examined Mayor Mamdani's claim to want to help Jews fight antisemitism but has lobbied accusations against Israel, including his claims of genocide in Gaza before the war began. Mike also explored the complex history of Israel, Gaza and the Palestinians. He discussed why a two-state solution faces significant obstacles and why many Arab countries have been reluctant to accept Palestinian refugees. Through clips featuring a former Miami Beach mayor and Bill Maher, he examined arguments challenging the genocide accusation and explaining why Israel will continue to exist. Mike closed the episode with a positive development: Paraguay's vice president reaffirmed his country's commitment to its relationship with Israel, declaring that it would not abandon that partnership despite potential political costs. Thank you for listening, sharing and subscribing to The Third Opinion Podcast

    Mamdani, Antisemitism and the Future of Israel

  4. Oct 5

    The Rising Tide: Understanding Modern Antisemitism

    Prerecorded for the week of October 5, 2026: Antisemitism isn't simply a historical problem — it is a present-day threat that is changing how Jews live, worship, educate their children and participate in public life. In this special episode, Mike examined the rising tide of antisemitism, what is driving it and what can be done to fight it. This special episode asks difficult questions about where modern antisemitism comes from, why it continues to spread and how education, community and a deeper understanding of Jewish history can help confront it. How we can move beyond simply remembering what happened to ensuring that Jewish communities can live openly, safely and proudly today? Although Jews make up only about 2% of the U.S. population, they are victims of a disproportionate share of religiously motivated hate crimes - a staggering 91% of American Jews report feeling unsafe because of the rise in antisemitism and Jewish communities are spending approximately $1 billion each year on security. The episode also explored the increasingly blurred line between criticism of Israel, anti-Zionism and antisemitism, examining its growing presence on the radical right while also asking how antisemitism manifests in other ideological spaces. Can teaching the Holocaust prevent antisemitism? Only 29 states currently require Holocaust education, while troubling numbers of young Americans demonstrate a lack of basic understanding about the Holocaust. Perhaps the deeper problem is how we teach the Holocaust;  too often, education focuses on what was done to Jews while giving too little attention to the antisemitism that made the Holocaust possible. In trying to make Holocaust education universally accessible, have we inadvertently erased what makes Jewish history and antisemitism unique? Thank you for listening, sharing and subscribing to The Third Opinion Podcast

    The Rising Tide: Understanding Modern Antisemitism

  5. Oct 2

    The Genocide Accusation Against Israel

    Prerecorded for the week of September 28, 2026: In this special episode of The Third Opinion Podcast, Mike took an in-depth look at the accusation that Israel is committing genocide in Gaza and examined the history and implications of the blood libel accusation against Israel and Jews.   The episode argued that discussions of the Israel-Hamas war often focus overwhelmingly on Israel's actions while giving insufficient attention to Hamas's conduct, including its use of civilian areas and the consequences of fighting from within the civilian population. Mike questioned the reliability of casualty figures and other information coming out of Gaza, arguing that the lack of independent and varied sources can make it difficult for the public to understand what is actually happening on the ground.   A central focus of the episode was the legal definition of genocide and, specifically, the question of intent: does Israel's conduct demonstrate an intent to destroy the Palestinian people as a group, or are the civilian deaths tragic casualties of an ongoing war? Israel's humanitarian aid, warnings and evacuation measures and the difficult reality of protecting civilians in a conflict where Hamas operates within densely populated areas points to their intent.   Understanding the actions of both sides is essential to evaluating the competing claims surrounding the war. The special episode ultimately asked listeners to look beyond headlines and emotionally charged accusations and consider the evidence, definitions, sources and context behind the claim of genocide. Thank you for listening, sharing and subscribin to The Third Opinion Podcast

    The Genocide Accusation Against Israel

  6. Sep 24

    Macklemore to NAZA: Art, War and Antisemitism

    Recorded on September 22, 2026: Laureen and Mike discuss the growing intersection of entertainment, politics, Israel and antisemitism, beginning with the controversy surrounding Ed Sheeran's Loop Tour, scheduled to come to Raymond James Stadium on November 7. Macklemore was removed from the U.S. leg of the tour after making pro-Palestinian comments, including saying "Free Palestine" during his opening set at MetLife Stadium. The controversy involved New England Patriots and Gillette Stadium owner Robert Kraft, who has said Macklemore's past comments and actions crossed a line.  The conversation then turns to NAZA, the documentary by Israeli filmmakers that won the Special Jury Prize at the Venice Film Festival after receiving a record-setting 25-minute standing ovation. The film features anonymous testimonies from 24 Israeli military and intelligence personnel and makes allegations about Israel's targeting practices in Gaza, including the use of AI-assisted systems. The filmmakers' use of anonymous sources has become a major point of controversy: the IDF has rejected the film's allegations and questioned whether the anonymous sources and their accounts can be independently verified. Israeli officials have also sharply condemned the film, with some calling for the filmmakers' citizenship to be revoked. Laureen and Mike also examine the continuing rise in antisemitism and incidents of anti-Jewish violence, particularly in Britain and elsewhere, and debate the extent to which criticism of Israel and Benjamin Netanyahu has contributed to antisemitism in the United States. They discuss differing views within the Jewish community and the difficulty of separating criticism of Israeli government policy from hostility toward Jews. Finally, the discussion turns to the war involving Iran and the Trump administration's approach to the conflict, including questions about the impact of economic sanctions, the administration's stated objectives and what the next phase of the conflict could look like. The episode closes by questioning whether the administration has articulated a clear path toward ending the conflict and what continued military and economic pressure could mean for both Iran and the United States. Thank you for listening, sharing and subscribing to The Third Opinion Podcast

    Macklemore to NAZA: Art, War and Antisemitism

  7. Sep 17

    From Gaza to Iran: Where Does This End?

    Recorded on September 15, 2026: The podcast focused on the increasingly strained relationship between Britain, Israel and the Jewish community, including Britain's decision to impose sanctions related to Israeli settlements in the West Bank. Mike and Laureeen also examined Bill Maher's argument that the war in Gaza should not be characterized as genocide, but rather as an unfortunate consequence of war and his view that the increasingly casual use of the term "genocide" is contributing to rising antisemitism. The episode also took an in-depth look at the ongoing war involving Iran. With the ceasefire having ended, hostilities have resumed, with Israel and Iran exchanging strikes and each side offering competing accounts of the conflict and its consequences. The discussion considers the continued cycle of retaliation and, ultimately, the question that remains difficult to answer: how will this conflict end? Thank you for listening, sharing and subscribing to The Third Opinion Podcast

    From Gaza to Iran: Where Does This End?

  8. Sep 10

    Florida Politics, Israel and a Nation on Alert

    Recorded on September 7, 2026: The episode opens with a Rosh Hashanah greeting and a thoughtful explanation from Laureen about the meaning and purpose of blowing the shofar. The conversation then turns to American politics, the midterm elections, and the debate over whether Israel is losing support among younger voters and Democrats because of its conduct during the war.   Mike and Laureen examine Florida's Senate race, including Angie Nixon's recent Democratic primary victory and her membership in the Democratic Socialists of America. They also discuss questions surrounding Senator Ashley Moody and her involvement as attorney general in the Hope Florida settlement.    The discussion turns to New York City and the controversy surrounding Mayor Zohran Mamdani as the country approaches the 25th anniversary of 9/11. The episode raises broader questions about the ongoing Israel-Hamas war, whether either side can ultimately achieve its objectives, and whether the United States and Israel are prepared for another major attack—including the possibility of a cyberattack.    Thank you for listening, sharing and subscribing to The Third Opinion Podcast

    Florida Politics, Israel and a Nation on Alert
See All (336)

Ratings & Reviews

4.2
out of 5
17 Ratings

About

Discussions on issues around antisemitism and the State of Israel.

Information

You Might Also Like