JUSTUS with Jack & Gonzo

Jack D’Aurora and John Gonzales

Social justice means applying the law equally to all people. But in practice, that doesn’t always happen. We’re business and trial lawyers with over 60 years experience of practice. Together, we practice law, we seek social justice, and we reveal the conflict between the two. And in this podcast, we bring together guests from a variety of backgrounds to discuss the current issues surrounding social justice and the inequity between these issues and their relation to the legal system. Join with us, so that it’s not Just Us.

  1. Nov 11

    141. The downside of data centers

    Today, we’re joined by Molly Bryden and Ali Smith, both of whom are with Policy Matters Ohio. Molly is a climate and sustainability researcher, and Ali leads the work and wages team. Our discussion focuses on the rapid growth of data centers in Ohio and the policy, economic, environmental and community concerns associated with that expansion. Ohio lacks a comprehensive regulatory framework governing data center development, leaving many communities uncertain about the impacts and benefits of these projects. Supporters of data centers often cite economic development, tax revenue and construction employment. Large hyperscale data centers can create hundreds or even thousands of temporary construction jobs over development periods ranging from 18 months to several years, but the number of permanent positions is much lower. Estimates suggest Ohio currently has roughly 8,000 to 10,000 permanent data center jobs spread across about 200 sites, with most facilities employing between 60 and 100 workers. These jobs generally offer strong wages and benefits, but critics argue they do not justify the extensive tax incentives provided to developers. The conversation emphasizes the growing role of artificial intelligence in driving demand for hyperscale facilities, which consume enormous amounts of electricity and water. One proposed facility in Piketon is expected to require more electricity than all Ohio households combined. Increased electricity demand is contributing to rising energy costs across the region, with residential electric bills increasing significantly over the past decade even as household electricity consumption has declined. Water use is another major concern. Data centers rely heavily on water for cooling systems and may consume billions of gallons annually. Molly and Ali warn that inadequate regulation could threaten water quality, increase costs, and strain future water supplies. Molly and Ali also voice concern about wastewater disposal and the environmental effects of cooling processes. Additional issues include noise pollution, air quality impacts, natural gas-powered on-site generation facilities, and limited community input in siting decisions. While renewable energy could help address some concerns, regulatory barriers and reliability requirements have limited its adoption. Molly and Ali advocate for stronger state policies, including better reporting requirements, community engagement, transparency, limits on tax incentives, environmental safeguards and long-term planning. They point to states such as Virginia and New York as examples of jurisdictions experimenting with stronger oversight and regulatory approaches. See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.

  2. Nov 2

    140. Police shootings, ethics and accountability

    Roughly 1000 people are killed by police annually. Today we welcome Penn State public policy professor Ben Jones to discuss the moral foundations of policing authority, over-policing, and what accountability should look like. The discussion begins with the Ta’Kiya Young shooting in 2023 in Blendon Township, Ohio, where the situation quickly escalated unnecessarily. The officer who shot and killed Young was acquitted and later resigned. Gonzo points out that civil litigation and financial incentives (including insurance) often drive reform more than criminal prosecutions, which are rare. Ben explains the gaps between ethics and the law and cites three ethical principles for evaluating the use of force: just purpose, proportionality and necessity. Officers should choose the least harmful option (e.g., not shooting at moving vehicles), which was not the case with the Young shooting. Ben, Jack and Gonzo explore when use of force is legitimate, de-escalation training and decentralization, and the challenges that come with providing adequate training for some 18,000 law enforcement agencies nationwide. Ben discusses research concerning the consequences of high-profile controversial police killings. In the aftermath of those incidents, violent crime often goes up, which can't be fully explained by just a reduction in policing. Some incidents can be avoided through better policy, better training and better tactics. Ben talks of evidence-based de-escalation training that reduces shootings. When de-escalation is employed, not only are there fewer injuries to suspects and people in the community, there are fewer injuries to officers as well. As Ben sees it, reforms are often framed as a zero-sum game, where a reduction in the use of force by police will mean police will be less safe. That's not actually the case, because reforms can help keep officers safer. Listen to the conversation. See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.

    140. Police shootings, ethics and accountability
  3. Oct 19

    139. Ohio's plan for funding public schools is broken

    We’re joined by Bailey Culp of the Ohio Federation of Teachers and Hannah Haubert of Policy Matters Ohio. We discuss why rural districts struggle and what it would take to fix the state’s funding system, which was declared unconstitutional in the DeRolf decision. Bailey and Hannah explain that traditional public schools rely heavily on local property taxes plus state funds and that the state’s share of funding education has fallen from about 47% to roughly 32.2%. The decrease in state funding has resulted in school districts pushing for more local levies and competing for funds with other entities like libraries. Under the Fair School Funding Plan, passed in 2021, the legislature calculates the cost of education for the school districts and each district’s funding capacity, but the Plan has not been fully phased in. State lawmakers have calculated the cost of education based on costs that existed in 2022 and have calculated local funding capacity to rise with property valuations, which hasn’t always happened. In addition, lawmakers have also failed to account for the costs of certain programs, such as children with special needs and English learners. The result is that many districts, mostly rural, find themselves with large funding gaps. The education voucher program has expanded and now exceeds $1 billion annually. Education vouchers mean less money for public education. What about the lottery/sports gaming revenue? That money supplants rather than supplements state funding. The next big issue for public education is what happens if the Ohio Supreme Court decides, in a case now before it, that school vouchers are constitutional. Listen to the conversation. See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.

    139. Ohio's plan for funding public schools is broken
  4. Aug 31

    135. The U.S. Supreme Court continues to issue stunning decisions

    Today we welcome constitutional law professor Mark Brown to review recent U.S. Supreme Court decisions and their implications for social justice. Brown first discusses the close 5–4 birthright citizenship decision and criticizes the Court’s dissenters for adding an unsupported domicile requirement, while also noting limited historical exceptions for birthright citizenship. Brown next reviews the Court’s decision that allows states to ban transgender girls from girls’ sports and his own concerns about the Court ignoring the factual record in cases like voting rights. Brown argues the Court historically favors the wealthy and powerful, praises Justice Jackson’s dissents on the doctrine of standing, and suggests that restoring the filibuster for confirmation votes could curb radical appointments. Next is a discussion about the Court’s expansion of presidential removal power (the recent cases concerning the Federal Trade Commission and the Federal Reserve), ongoing litigation over a Trump mail-ballot executive order, the Court’s dismantling of the Voting Rights Act protections against racial gerrymandering, possible reforms like multi-member districts, and the Court allowing greater party-candidate fundraising coordination. Justice Roberts may say the Court is doing nothing more than calling balls and strikes, but the Court has gotten into the habit of changing the strike zone. See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.

    135. The U.S. Supreme Court continues to issue stunning decisions
  5. Aug 17

    134. The upheaval with the Trump administration ending temporary protected status for thousands

    We talk with immigration lawyer Emmanuel Olawale about the consequences facing immigrants after the Trump administration abruptly ended the Temporary Protected Status program. TPS was designed to provide temporary protection for people from countries experiencing disaster, conflict or severe instability, but it did not create a direct path to permanent residency or citizenship. The shortcomings of TPS are confronting some 250,000 to 300,000 immigrants in the U.S. whose lawful status has abruptly ended, including about 20,000 to 30,000 Haitians who have lived, worked, built businesses, and raised children in Springfield, Ohio, for years and are now at risk of being deported The discussion highlights the tension between federal immigration policy and the reality of conditions in Haiti, where political instability, gang violence, limited public services, and safety concerns remain severe. As Olawale puts it, TPS is “a temporary solution to a permanent problem,” emphasizing that Congress failed to create a durable legal pathway for long-term TPS holders. The conversation also explores the difference between TPS, asylum, refugee status, and family-based immigration relief. Olawale explains how immigration enforcement is unfolding locally, including ICE reporting requirements, ankle monitoring, expedited immigration court procedures, and pressure on immigration judges. He argues that shifting policies and administrative practices have made immigration law more difficult and unpredictable for attorneys and clients alike. The episode addresses the role of political rhetoric and misinformation in shaping public attitudes toward immigrant communities. The administration’s use of dehumanizing language for immigrants attempts to make harsh enforcement policies easier to justify. The situation in Springfield is an example of how a temporary immigration policy like TPS leaves families vulnerable when political winds change. See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.

    134. The upheaval with the Trump administration ending temporary protected status for thousands
4.7
out of 5
12 Ratings

About

Social justice means applying the law equally to all people. But in practice, that doesn’t always happen. We’re business and trial lawyers with over 60 years experience of practice. Together, we practice law, we seek social justice, and we reveal the conflict between the two. And in this podcast, we bring together guests from a variety of backgrounds to discuss the current issues surrounding social justice and the inequity between these issues and their relation to the legal system. Join with us, so that it’s not Just Us.

You Might Also Like