Mystical Dispute

Carl Chase and Garrett Gardner
  • 4.6 (18)
  • HOBBIES
  • UPDATED WEEKLY

Short form limited Magic: The Gathering debate podcast co-hosted by Carl Chase and Garrett Gardner, who debate cards and quick topics about the latest draft format.

  1. 09/11/2025

    112. Forty Two

    Carl is not done, he is angry, chomping at the bit, and desperate to prove that forty-two cards (or more?!) is the right thing to do. In limited. Where you are allowed to play just forty. So Garrett let him, again. Short form limited Magic: The Gathering debate podcast co-hosted by Carl Chase and Garrett Gardner, who debate cards and quick topics about the latest draft format. Support Mystical Dispute on Patreon (patreon.com/mysticaldispute) and visit our website (mysticaldispute.com). Carl Chase is on Twitch (twitch.tv/twoduckcubed) and Twitter (twitter.com/twoduckcubed), and Garrett Gardner is on Twitch (twitch.tv/ggards) and Twitter (twitter.com/theGGards).

    44 min

  2. 08/27/2025

    111. Intrepid Tenderfoot, Flight-Deck Coordinator and Tapestry Warden

    Carl and Garrett debate the most complicated, complex, intricate cards in the set: mostly vanilla creatures. Yes, Garrett is defending them. Why do you ask? Short form limited Magic: The Gathering debate podcast co-hosted by Carl Chase and Garrett Gardner, who debate cards and quick topics about the latest draft format. Support Mystical Dispute on Patreon (patreon.com/mysticaldispute) and visit our website (mysticaldispute.com). Carl Chase is on Twitch (twitch.tv/twoduckcubed) and Twitter (twitter.com/twoduckcubed), and Garrett Gardner is on Twitch (twitch.tv/ggards) and Twitter (twitter.com/theGGards).

    29 min

  3. 08/21/2025

    110. Plasma Bolt vs. Gravkill

    Carl and Garrett debate a universal exile anything removal spell at instant speed vs. a sorcery speed shock. I bet you wonder who writes these episode summaries huh? Short form limited Magic: The Gathering debate podcast co-hosted by Carl Chase and Garrett Gardner, who debate cards and quick topics about the latest draft format. Support Mystical Dispute on Patreon (patreon.com/mysticaldispute) and visit our website (mysticaldispute.com). Carl Chase is on Twitch (twitch.tv/twoduckcubed) and Twitter (twitter.com/twoduckcubed), and Garrett Gardner is on Twitch (twitch.tv/ggards) and Twitter (twitter.com/theGGards).

    28 min

  4. 08/15/2025

    109. Biosynthic Burst vs. Diplomatic Relations

    Carl and Garrett come back to a classic: combat trick vs. a removal spell. Also, this format is awesome. Short form limited Magic: The Gathering debate podcast co-hosted by Carl Chase and Garrett Gardner, who debate cards and quick topics about the latest draft format. Support Mystical Dispute on Patreon (patreon.com/mysticaldispute) and visit our website (mysticaldispute.com). Carl Chase is on Twitch (twitch.tv/twoduckcubed) and Twitter (twitter.com/twoduckcubed), and Garrett Gardner is on Twitch (twitch.tv/ggards) and Twitter (twitter.com/theGGards).

    25 min

  5. 08/07/2025

    108. Cryogen Relic vs. 2x Cryoshatter

    Carl and Garrett are back in action, this time debating a single blue common vs. TWO copies of a different blue common. How have ya'll been after all this time?! Short form limited Magic: The Gathering debate podcast co-hosted by Carl Chase and Garrett Gardner, who debate cards and quick topics about the latest draft format. Support Mystical Dispute on Patreon (patreon.com/mysticaldispute) and visit our website (mysticaldispute.com). Carl Chase is on Twitch (twitch.tv/twoduckcubed) and Twitter (twitter.com/twoduckcubed), and Garrett Gardner is on Twitch (twitch.tv/ggards) and Twitter (twitter.com/theGGards).

    21 min

  6. 04/29/2024

    107. Life vs. Magic: The Gathering

    Carl and Garrett share some news, explain their recent absence, and debate what is more important - living life, or playing this card game (it's close). Short form limited Magic: The Gathering debate podcast co-hosted by Carl Chase and Garrett Gardner, who debate cards and quick topics about the latest draft format. Support Mystical Dispute on Patreon (patreon.com/mysticaldispute) and visit our website (mysticaldispute.com). Carl Chase is on Twitch (twitch.tv/twoduckcubed) and Twitter (twitter.com/twoduckcubed), and Garrett Gardner is on Twitch (twitch.tv/ggards) and Twitter (twitter.com/theGGards).

    27 min

  7. 12/06/2023

    106. Captain Storm, Cosmium Raider vs. Chupacabra Echo (LCI)

    Carl and Garrett return from a short hiatus to debate the glass cannon higher risk synergy card and the pure value removal creature card. Guess who's on which side. Short form limited Magic: The Gathering debate podcast co-hosted by Carl Chase and Garrett Gardner, who debate cards and quick topics about the latest draft format. Support Mystical Dispute on Patreon (patreon.com/mysticaldispute) and visit our website (mysticaldispute.com). Carl Chase is on Twitch (twitch.tv/twoduckcubed) and Twitter (twitter.com/twoduckcubed), and Garrett Gardner is on Twitch (twitch.tv/ggards) and Twitter (twitter.com/theGGards).

    25 min

  8. 11/08/2023

    105. Lost Caverns of Ixalan Preview Battle: Spyglass Siren (LCI)

    Carl and Garrett debate over how well a, you guess it, 1 mana 1/1 will fare as we decend into the brand new format, The Lost Caverns of Ixalan! Short form limited Magic: The Gathering debate podcast co-hosted by Carl Chase and Garrett Gardner, who debate cards and quick topics about the latest draft format. Support Mystical Dispute on Patreon (patreon.com/mysticaldispute) and visit our website (mysticaldispute.com). Carl Chase is on Twitch (twitch.tv/twoduckcubed) and Twitter (twitter.com/twoduckcubed), and Garrett Gardner is on Twitch (twitch.tv/ggards) and Twitter (twitter.com/theGGards).

    18 min
See All (112)

Ratings & Reviews

4.6
out of 5
18 Ratings

About

Short form limited Magic: The Gathering debate podcast co-hosted by Carl Chase and Garrett Gardner, who debate cards and quick topics about the latest draft format.

Information

  • Creator
    Carl Chase and Garrett Gardner
  • Years Active
    2021 - 2025
  • Episodes
    112
  • Rating
    Clean
  • Copyright
    © Copyright Garrett Gardner 2022
  • Show Website
    Mystical Dispute