Think Twice with Jonathan Tobin

The Internet and mainstream media are inundated with misinformation and superficial hot takes. That’s why you’re not getting the full story. Take another look with JNS Editor-in-chief Jonathan Tobin as he takes deep dives into the most critical stories and controversies impacting the Jewish world with insightful commentary and fascinating interviews. If you want to understand the bigger picture and the context of the issues that really matter, this show is for you. Thanks for listening to Jonathan Tobin's podcast. If you appreciated today’s discussion and want to dive deeper into the issues shaping Israel and the Jewish world, join our community by subscribing to our newsletter. Your engagement keeps our journalism thriving. Your support is crucial. Support us with a donation to ensure we can continue delivering in-depth reporting: Donate Now!

  1. 19h ago

    Antisemitism on college campuses may get worse | Ep. 243

    Is the surge of antisemitism on college campuses going to get worse in the next two years? That’s a question posed by JNS editor-in-chief Jonathan Tobin. He wonders whether a Trump administration that will be distracted and hamstrung by a Congress that will be dominated by Democrats who have opposed the administration’s efforts on this issue will be able to continue its efforts.   He’s joined in this week’s episode of Think Twice by City University of New York Law Professor Jeffrey Lax, a leading critic of the way academia has tolerated and encouraged Jew-hatred. Lax believes that the best way for Jews to fight back against the problem is by taking schools and institutions to court. Discrimination against Jews because they are Zionists is against the law, he explains.   Lax also sounds the alarm about the way New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani is using his power to endanger the Jewish community. He is particularly concerned that his decision to disband the New York City Police Department unit tasked with preventing demonstrations from turning into violent riots will have consequences for Jews who are targeted by the mayor’s ideological antisemitic allies.   He also rejects the idea that moderates will be able to control the faction of the party that belongs to the Democratic Socialists of America or are allied with it. Lax thinks that Mamdani and openly antisemitic Michigan Senator-elect Dr. Abdul El-Sayed, along with Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D-NY), represent the future of the Democratic Party. In 2028, he thinks there’s a good chance the party’s left-wing will dominate the nomination process. Moreover, he believes AOC might well win the Democratic presidential nomination in no small measure because most Americans don’t know much about economics and therefore don’t understand why socialism doesn’t work.   Nevertheless, Lax thinks the red-green alliance of Marxists and Islamists that back the DSA, AOC, Mamdani and El-Sayed will eventually fall out with each other since the latter will never tolerate the former if they gain power.   Lax also denounced Vice President JD Vance’s blaming the GOP’s midterm elections defeat on Israel, which he views as a “flat out lie.”   Listen/Subscribe to weekly episodes on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, YouTube Music, iHeart Radio or wherever you listen to your podcasts.

  2. 5d ago

    How the arguments inside Israel’s ‘War Room’ determined history | Ep. 242

    If you want a better understanding of why the aftermath of Israel’s first election since the Oct. 7, 2023 Hamas-led Palestinian Arab terror attacks on its southern communities is so difficult to unravel, then knowing what happened behind the scenes among the Jewish state’s leaders and military commanders is a good place to start. That’s the conclusion JNS editor-in-chief Jonathan Tobin draws from the new book, In the War Room: The Inside Story of Israel’s Fight Against the Iranian Axis. He’s joined on this week's episode of Think Twice by its authors, The Wall Street Journal’s Elliot Kaufman and The Jerusalem Post’s Yonah Jeremy Bob. The book discusses why a broad cross-section of Israel’s military, intelligence and political leadership failed to anticipate the Hamas attack. But it also details how the Biden administration, despite some rhetorical support for the goal of defeating the terrorists after Oct. 7, almost from the start opposed a war to achieve that end. Though the administration was under enormous pressure from the left-wing of the Democratic Party to prevent the Israeli government from protecting its people, Biden and his staff urged Jerusalem to merely repeat the same failed efforts to restrain Hamas that had been tried before. And they were especially eager to prevent any attacks on Iran and its Hezbollah auxiliaries in Lebanon. The disputes inside Israel’s war room between Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, Defense Minister Yoav Gallant, Israel Defense Forces Chief of Staff Herzl Halevi and the opposition leaders who joined the government after Oct 7 such as former IDF chief of staffs retired generals Benny Gantz and Gadi Eisenkot hinged on whether or not to attack Lebanon before dealing with Gaza as well as how to balance the two war aims of defeating Hamas and returning the hostages. In the end, as the authors note, the argument against Netanyahu’s determination to persist in the conflict to defeat Hamas beyond mid-2024 “didn’t age well.” It was only by doing so that he was able to pivot to defeat Hezbollah in Lebanon, which led to the fall of the Assad regime in Syria and then to partnership with the Trump administration against Iran’s nuclear and missile threats. Still, as both Kaufman and Bob point out, in the aftermath of Oct. 7, Israel went on to win militarily on every front and returned home the hostages. But on the diplomatic front, Israel lost. Whether it can preserve its advantages or grow them in the long run, has yet to be determined, depending largely on whether the Trump administration is able to achieve the ouster of Hamas from power in Gaza and to finish the conflict with Iran. Listen/Subscribe to weekly episodes on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, YouTube Music, iHeart Radio or wherever you listen to your podcasts. Watch new episodes every week by subscribing to the JNS YouTube Channel.

  3. Nov 5

    El-Sayed’s election is a turning point in American history | Ep. 241

    According to JNS editor-in-chief Jonathan Tobin, President Donald Trump and the Republicans weren’t the only big losers in the midterm elections. Supporters of the U.S.-Israel alliance and those who worry about the surge of antisemitism that has swept across the globe over the past three years should, he says, be equally worried about the implications of the Democrats’ midterm victory.   He’s joined in this week’s episode of Think Twice by commentator & author Josh Hammer who said the assertion that the war against Iran was the sole reason for the GOP’s defeat is mistaken. The economy in general, the impact of Trump’s tariffs, corruption and the administration’s focus on things voters don’t care about played just as big a role in the voters’ decisions.   Hammer also believes that it would be a mistake to underestimate the negative impact of the election of anti-Israel and antisemitic leftist candidates to Congress. But he is especially alarmed by the victory of Dr. Abdul El-Sayed in the Michigan Senate race. He called it  “a turning point moment in American history.” What’s important is not that he’s the first Muslim elected to the U.S. Senate.   It is, he says, what he stands for, in terms of a campaign that revolved around antisemitism as well as “who he is surrounded with, what he has said, and what he has failed to say.” Hammer termed his election as the “singular culmination of the Muslim Brotherhood's decades-long effort” to insinuate itself and other Hamas supporters into mainstream politics.   Hammer also asserts that the “biggest loser” of the midterms isn’t Trump but Vice President JD Vance, who clearly intends to run for president in 2028. “His entire pitch is that he wants to be the third term of Trumpism and MAGA. Well, I hate to say it, but as of this past Tuesday evening, MAGA and Trumpism are dead. They are deader than dead. That the coalition is not just in shambles, it is literally dead.”   Hammer believes the Republicans will need someone, unlike Vance, who is not associated with the administration or a conspiracy and hate monger like Tucker Carlson, to come up with a new vision for the country.   Listen/Subscribe to weekly episodes on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, YouTube Music, iHeart Radio or wherever you listen to your podcasts.   Watch new episodes every week by subscribing to the JNS YouTube Channel.

  4. Oct 29

    What will break the Israeli electoral stalemate? | Ep. 240

    Who were the real winners and losers of the Israeli election? On the  day after the voting, JNS editor-in-chief Jonathan Tobin was joined on this week’s episode of Think Twice by JNS Senior contributing editor Ruthie Blum to break down the results and discuss the implications.   According to Blum, the fact that neither Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s coalition partners nor that of the “anyone-but-Bibi” alliance of parties led by former Israel Defense Forces chief of staff, retired Gen. Gadi Eisenkot gained a majority, creating an impasse. But the biggest winners on Oct. 27 were clearly the Arab parties, which appeared to have won a record number of Knesset seats.   Both Tobin and Blum said the pressure from the left and many in the international community for Eisenkot to join forces with the Arab parties in one way or another in order to topple Netanyahu. But allowing parties that are not merely anti-Zionist but which identify with Israel’s enemies which seek its destruction into the cabinet is not merely shocking; it’s a threat to the Jewish state’s security at a time of ongoing war.   Blum said Eisenkot’s call for the IDF and the security services to thwart any efforts of the current caretaker government that is led by Netanyahu to continue the war against Iran and its terror auxiliaries is outrageous. It will also set up a possible conflict with U.S. President Donald Trump, who has made it clear he wants Israel’s government to help him “finish the job” of ending the nuclear threat from Tehran.   While neither Netanyahu or Eisenkot had a clear path to a government, they agreed that the prime minister was in a stronger position and not just because his faction won more seats. All of Eisenkot’s options for breaking the stalemate, whether by deals with the Arabs, a unity government with Netanyahu or one with the haredi parties will damage him politically in the long run. Netanyahu can stand his ground and be ready to try again in new elections early next year if no government is formed and may do better the next time.   The prime minister’s advantage, Blum says, stems from the fact that although it is vilified in the liberal press in Israel and the United States, the Likud Party remains the largest because its positions on security and other issues are more in touch with the center of Israeli public opinion. Listen/Subscribe to weekly episodes on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, YouTube Music, iHeart Radio or wherever you listen to your podcasts.

  5. Oct 22

    Are Jews breaking up with the Democrats? | Ep. 239

    American Jews have been among the most ardent and loyal supporters of the Democratic Party for over a century. But as, JNS editor-in-chief Jonathan Tobin notes, as the party’s intersectional left wing base embraced hatred for Israel and even antisemitism in recent years, the argument for a shift in political loyalties is now being made by some who were closely identified with the Democrats. One such person is famed legal analyst and retired Harvard Law School professor Alan Dershowitz, who joins Tobin on this week’s episode of Think Twice. A prolific author, Dershowitz has written a new book titled, Why I Quit the Dems And So Should You! The confessions of a reluctant Republican. In it, the 63rd book he has published in his career, Dershowitz, 88, documents the reasons why he left the Democrats after 70 years as an ardent and involved supporter of the party and many of its candidates. Dershowitz asserts that his beliefs are unchanged. But the Democratic Party has, he acknowledged, been gradually becoming more illiberal and woke. It is “a systemic problem.”   “I am a liberal, but I'm no longer a liberal Democrat, because I think that's an oxymoron,” Dershowitz says.   “I don't think Democrats are liberals. The reason I basically made the switch was not because [New York City Mayor Zohran] Mamdani got elected or because [Michigan Democratic U.S. Senate candidate Dr. Abdul] El-Syed was nominated, it's because [Senate Minority Leader] Chuck Schumer supported them. It's because the mainstream of the Democratic Party, which is testicularly challenged, wouldn't stand up against the anti-Semites in the Democratic Party. Whereas President Trump did stand up against some of the extremists in the Republican Party. So, for me,” he continued. “The issue is not the extremes; it's how the center deals with the extremes.” When asked about criticism from Democrats that prioritizing Israel and the battle against antisemitism makes Jews “single issue voters,” Dershowitz had a ready reply.   “We should become more single-issue voters. If I were living in Germany in 1932 and I were an environmentalist or a vegetarian or somebody who wanted full employment for Germany, I wouldn't care about those issues. I would care about Adolf Hitler. Seven thousand German Jews voted for Adolf Hitler,” Dershowitz declared. “I think the time has come for single issue voting. Anti Semitism is the most serious danger in the world today of bigotry.”   Dershowitz admitted that he was a “reluctant Republican” because he still agreed with the Democrats on many issues. He also held out the possibility that the Democrats could reject their antisemites as well as noting that the isolationist wing of the Republican Party, led by Vice President JD Vance, whom he says is “not pro-Israel” yet also “not antisemitic” worries him.   The legal authority also said that he had recently reconnected with his friend Larry David after the “Seinfeld” producer and “Curb Your Enthusiasm” star publicly broke with him because Dershowitz had represented President Donald Trump. Now that David has denounced the Democratic Socialists who have hijacked the Democratic Party, the two have, he said, reconciled.   Listen/Subscribe to weekly episodes on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, YouTube Music, iHeart Radio or wherever you listen to your podcasts.   Watch new episodes every week by subscribing to the JNS YouTube Channel.

  6. Oct 15

    Is there a final solution to the Jewish problem? | Ep. 238

    What if all the clever ideas about dealing with antisemitism, including focusing on Holocaust education, are failing? That’s the question posed by JNS editor-in-chief Jonathan Tobin with respect to the unprecedented surge in Jew-hatred. He’s joined in this week’s episode of Think Twice by Dara Horn, author of the seminal 2021 collection of essays, People Love Dead Jews: Reports From a Haunted Present and the new The Solution to the Jewish Problem: A Love Story for the Living. Horn says that since the publication of her People Love Dead Jews, she’s become a magnet for Jews who want to share their stories of how they’ve been impacted by the surge of antisemitism. Because of this, she’s been dubbed by family members as the “Antisemitism Lorax,” a reference to the Dr. Seuss book. Because of this, she’s spent the past few years researching efforts to combat Jew-hatred and come to some firm conclusions. One is that Holocaust education, while important in and of itself, is not curing the world of antisemitism or achieving the goal of many involved with it to teach non-Jews to be nicer to people. To the contrary, since it doesn’t teach about Jewish civilization or about Jew-hatred per se, it does little or nothing to deal with the problem. She also believes that American Jews are wrong to believe that the so-called “golden age” of American Jewry after the Second World War was the result of non-Jews deciding not to be antisemitic because of the Holocaust. Instead, it was created by American Jewish activism which asserted the rights of Jews to be treated as equal partners. The problem was that the implicit deal that Jews sought to make with the non-Jewish world created more trouble in the long run. The “Gentleman’s Agreement,” which was the name of a famous novel and Oscar-winning 1947 film about antisemitism—hinged on the idea that Jews are like everyone else rather than a group whose civilization was always based on their being different. Antisemitism thrives, Horn says, because it is not so much a virus as “lie” that tells people that the Jews are to blame for whatever it is they fear most. That applies to every variety of Jew-hater, including those at Harvard University, where she served on the ill-fated Antisemitism Advisory Group. The only effective answer to it—the “final solution” that she references in the title to her book—is for Jews to stop trying to make others like them and instead concentrate on educating themselves and others about their own heritage. The answer today, she says, is the same that has sustained Jews throughout their history. Listen/Subscribe to weekly episodes on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, YouTube Music, iHeart Radio or wherever you listen to your podcasts. Watch new episodes every week by subscribing to the JNS YouTube Channel.

  7. Oct 8

    Jews were betrayed after Oct. 7 | Ep. 237

    A half century ago, the Soviet Union and its Third World allies passed the infamous “Zionism is racism” resolution at the United Nations. Today, the same propaganda is regurgitated by academics, liberal media and pop culture figures who think they’re enlightened supporters of human rights. According to historian Gil Troy, who joins JNS editor-in-chief Jonathan Tobin on this week’s episode of Think Twice, the reason is the spread of “anti-racist” ideology that spreads antisemitic blood libels about Israel.   Troy, who wrote the definitive study of the struggle against the “Zionism is racism” resolution, sees the spread of toxic left-wing ideas has undermined both Israel’s international standing and that of American Jews. This was evident in what he calls the “triple double cross” of liberals and feminists who betrayed Israel after Oct. 7 by taking the side of the Palestinians who murdered, raped and kidnapped Israelis. What happened should have brought moral clarity about jihadi foes to American views of the conflict but instead it created division between the United States and Israel.   While Troy is worried about the way far-left Israeli-haters are taking over the Democratic Party, he believes figures like Michigan Senate candidate Dr. Abdul El-Sayed is a greater threat to his party than he is to the Jews. The reason is that the shift to the far left is likely to damage Democrats in 2028 if not in 2026.   Nevertheless, Troy says it was far more important for Israel to win on the battlefield after Oct. 7 than to win public relations or diplomatic battles.   Analyzing the upcoming Israeli election, Troy says the divide among citizens of the Jewish state is primarily tribal and causing the two main camps that are supporting Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu on the one hand, and his chief opponent, former Gen. Gadi Eisenkot on the other, to create what may well be a stalemate in the vote. He says it’s unfortunate because there is a broad Zionist consensus on the issues of security and even on the drafting of Haredim. Though many Israelis would like the two main blocs to come together, it’s not clear that either leader can escape the necessity of allying themselves with allies on the right or the left.   Listen/Subscribe to weekly episodes on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, YouTube Music, iHeart Radio or wherever you listen to your podcasts.   Watch new episodes every week by subscribing to the JNS YouTube Channel.

  8. Oct 1

    Ep. 236: Is Jewish unity in a polarized nation possible?

    At a time when most Americans have lost the ability to listen to people with opposing views on political issues, how can a fractious Jewish community that is also split on denominational lines to pull together. That’s the question posed by JNS editor-in-chief Jonathan Tobin. He believes that Jewish disunity has been exacerbated by the capture of the political left—which is still supported by the majority of Jews—by anti-Israel and antisemitic “progressives.” This puts even more pressure on Jewish liberals to conform to fashionable opinion on the left that poses a threat to their community’s interests and safety.   He’s joined in this week’s episode of Think Twice by DePaul University Law Professor Roberta Kwall, author of the new book, Polarized: Why American Jews Are Divided And What To Do About It. She believes that a vital Jewish center can be reconstituted if people realize that the things that unite them are still greater than those that seek to tear them apart.   Part of the problem is that Israel, which was once thought to be a unifying factor is now the greatest source of division with many unaffiliated or liberal Jews no longer supportive of it with a small but well-publicized minority actively opposed to Zionism.   At the core of her effort is a statement of largely anodyne principles that she believes the overwhelming majority of Jews agree on. Among them is support for the right of Israel to exist as a Jewish and democratic state as well as the legitimacy of criticizing its government.   But for Kwall, just as important is the need to re-emphasize education and the importance of tradition to reinforce Jewish identity. In such a context, it will be easier for Jews who disagree on politics or aspects of Israeli policy to listen to each other and find common ground.   Listen/Subscribe to weekly episodes on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, YouTube Music, iHeart Radio or wherever you listen to your podcasts.   Watch new episodes every week by subscribing to the JNS YouTube Channel.

4.8
out of 5
129 Ratings

About

The Internet and mainstream media are inundated with misinformation and superficial hot takes. That’s why you’re not getting the full story. Take another look with JNS Editor-in-chief Jonathan Tobin as he takes deep dives into the most critical stories and controversies impacting the Jewish world with insightful commentary and fascinating interviews. If you want to understand the bigger picture and the context of the issues that really matter, this show is for you. Thanks for listening to Jonathan Tobin's podcast. If you appreciated today’s discussion and want to dive deeper into the issues shaping Israel and the Jewish world, join our community by subscribing to our newsletter. Your engagement keeps our journalism thriving. Your support is crucial. Support us with a donation to ensure we can continue delivering in-depth reporting: Donate Now!

More From JNS

You Might Also Like