Everything Vaguely Paranormal

Shelly Pruitt and Blake Smith

Everything Vaguely Paranormal is a paranormal podcast exploring true stories, dark history, and unexplained phenomena. Each episode dives into hauntings, demons, UFOs, witchcraft, and cryptids, breaking down real encounters, folklore, and the patterns that connect them. We focus on what’s documented, what’s reported, and what still can’t be explained. Blending research with conversation, the show balances eerie storytelling with grounded discussion, making space for both skepticism and belief without forcing an answer. If you’re drawn to ghost stories, supernatural cases, and mysteries that linger long after the episode ends, this is where those stories live. New episodes release every Wednesday.

  1. 1d ago

    The Watseka Wonder: A Spirit Possession Mystery

    Send us Fan Mail Could the Watseka Wonder be evidence of life after death, or was something far stranger unfolding in a small Illinois town? In 1878, thirteen-year-old Lurancy Vennum began exhibiting unusual behavior, experiencing mysterious trances, and claiming to communicate with spirits. But when she reportedly identified herself as Mary Roff, a young woman who had died thirteen years earlier, her story took an extraordinary turn. Lurancy allegedly recalled memories, recognized people, and displayed behaviors that convinced the Roff family their deceased daughter had returned. For months, she lived with Mary's family, leaving witnesses to question whether they were witnessing genuine spirit possession or something science had yet to explain. Known as one of America's most remarkable alleged possession cases, the Watseka Wonder continues to raise questions about consciousness, identity, and the possibility of life after death. Was Mary Roff truly communicating from beyond the grave, or could psychological influences, grief, and suggestion explain what happened?  CONNECT WITH US ON SOCIAL MEDIA: https://linktr.ee/everythingvaguelyparanormal  Don't forget, you can watch us live on Tuesday nights at 8PM CST - U.S. on YouTube and Facebook!   Support the Show: Patreon (Bonus Content) Follow us on Social Media: YouTube Channel Facebook Fan Page Instagram Fan Page X (formerly Twitter) TikTok Fan Page Submit Your Story, Comments, or Questions: theevppod@gmail.com

  2. Oct 21

    Bloody Benders: Kansas Killers

    Send us Fan Mail The Bloody Benders left a trail of death in 1870s Kansas before vanishing. A roadside inn, missing travelers, and claims of spiritualism surround this notorious family. What really happened to the killers who escaped without a trace?  Watch the video version here: https://youtube.com/live/9SKceCdv2tM Don't forget, you can watch us live on Tuesday nights at 8PM CST - U.S. on YouTube and Facebook!   Support the Show: Patreon (Bonus Content) Follow us on Social Media: YouTube Channel Facebook Fan Page Instagram Fan Page X (formerly Twitter) TikTok Fan Page Submit Your Story, Comments, or Questions: theevppod@gmail.com

  3. Oct 14

    UFO Encounters With Police | Marianne Robb & Dave Rich

    Send us Fan Mail What happens when UFO encounters with police challenge what officers can explain? Marianne Robb and Dave Rich explore law enforcement sightings, UAP investigations, paranormal events, and cryptids. Hear why some officers and first responders have stayed silent about the unknown.  Watch the video version here: https://youtube.com/live/WxqKBbEJIVY Don't forget, you can watch us live on Tuesday nights at 8PM CST - U.S. on YouTube and Facebook!   Support the Show: Patreon (Bonus Content) Follow us on Social Media: YouTube Channel Facebook Fan Page Instagram Fan Page X (formerly Twitter) TikTok Fan Page Submit Your Story, Comments, or Questions: theevppod@gmail.com

  4. Oct 7

    Cropsey Urban Legend: The Boogeyman of Staten Island

    Send us Fan Mail The Cropsey Urban Legend was a campfire nightmare, until reality began to resemble it. Staten Island children disappeared, and Andre Rand became linked to a name already feared for years. Where did the folklore end and something terrifyingly real begin? Watch the video version here: https://youtube.com/live/BZY08q19QI0 Don't forget, you can watch us live on Tuesday nights at 8PM CST - U.S. on YouTube and Facebook!   Support the Show: Patreon (Bonus Content) Follow us on Social Media: YouTube Channel Facebook Fan Page Instagram Fan Page X (formerly Twitter) TikTok Fan Page Submit Your Story, Comments, or Questions: theevppod@gmail.com

  5. Sep 30

    Three Identical Strangers: The Darker Story

    Send us Fan Mail Three Identical Strangers found each other by chance, but their separation hid a darker truth. The triplets had unknowingly been part of a secretive nature vs nurture study. We uncover the secrecy, ethical questions, and human cost behind their extraordinary reunion. Watch the video version here: https://youtube.com/live/2wpXnWGsNEM Don't forget, you can watch us live on Tuesday nights at 8PM CST - U.S. on YouTube and Facebook!   Support the Show: Patreon (Bonus Content) Follow us on Social Media: YouTube Channel Facebook Fan Page Instagram Fan Page X (formerly Twitter) TikTok Fan Page Submit Your Story, Comments, or Questions: theevppod@gmail.com

  6. Sep 23

    Brodhead Manor Paranormal Investigation

    Send us Fan Mail Brodhead Manor paranormal investigation takes us back inside Wisconsin's haunted school. Owner Bill Wolter joins us before our September 25–27 public investigation. Hear what we've encountered there before and why this return could be different.  Watch the video version here: https://youtube.com/live/-ntCrgNK51o Don't forget, you can watch us live on Tuesday nights at 8PM CST - U.S. on YouTube and Facebook!   Support the Show: Patreon (Bonus Content) Follow us on Social Media: YouTube Channel Facebook Fan Page Instagram Fan Page X (formerly Twitter) TikTok Fan Page Submit Your Story, Comments, or Questions: theevppod@gmail.com

  7. Sep 16

    Dorothy Kilgallen: The Journalist Who Asked Too Many Questions [Part Two]

    Send us Fan Mail Dorothy Kilgallen Death remains surrounded by questions decades later. We examine her final hours, the official investigation, missing notes, and disputed evidence. Uncover the documented facts and enduring theories behind the Dorothy Kilgallen mystery. Don't forget, you can watch us live on Tuesday nights at 8PM CST - U.S. on YouTube and Facebook!   Support the Show: Patreon (Bonus Content) Follow us on Social Media: YouTube Channel Facebook Fan Page Instagram Fan Page X (formerly Twitter) TikTok Fan Page Submit Your Story, Comments, or Questions: theevppod@gmail.com

  8. Sep 9

    Dorothy Kilgallen: The Journalist Who Asked Too Many Questions [Part One]

    Send us Fan Mail Dorothy Kilgallen became one of America's most respected journalists before becoming a mystery herself. Explore her remarkable career, her growing interest in the Kennedy assassination, and her exclusive access to Jack Ruby. Discover why her search for answers still captivates people decades later.  Watch the video version here: https://youtube.com/live/cpgW4BAnRLs Don't forget, you can watch us live on Tuesday nights at 8PM CST - U.S. on YouTube and Facebook!   Support the Show: Patreon (Bonus Content) Follow us on Social Media: YouTube Channel Facebook Fan Page Instagram Fan Page X (formerly Twitter) TikTok Fan Page Submit Your Story, Comments, or Questions: theevppod@gmail.com

See All (267)

4.5
out of 5
19 Ratings

About

Everything Vaguely Paranormal is a paranormal podcast exploring true stories, dark history, and unexplained phenomena. Each episode dives into hauntings, demons, UFOs, witchcraft, and cryptids, breaking down real encounters, folklore, and the patterns that connect them. We focus on what’s documented, what’s reported, and what still can’t be explained. Blending research with conversation, the show balances eerie storytelling with grounded discussion, making space for both skepticism and belief without forcing an answer. If you’re drawn to ghost stories, supernatural cases, and mysteries that linger long after the episode ends, this is where those stories live. New episodes release every Wednesday.

Information

  • Creator
    Shelly Pruitt and Blake Smith
  • Years Active
    2021 - 2026
  • Episodes
    267
  • Rating
    Explicit
  • Copyright
    © 2026 Everything Vaguely Paranormal
  • Show Website
    Everything Vaguely Paranormal

You Might Also Like