Critical Science

Lyle Burgoon
  • 5.0 (2)
  • MEDICINE
  • UPDATED WEEKLY

Critical Science is focused on a few things I (Dr. Lyle Burgoon) love -- critical thinking (which I don't do enough of at home, ask my family), science, and applied ethics. And ya know what -- even scientists, who are supposed to be trained to be critical thinkers, often mess it up (I'm certainly not perfect). In each episode I try to combine these two passions of mine. Sometimes, we'll explore a topic in the news in a slightly more critical way. Other times we might explore how a lack of critical thought has led to some minor, and sometimes major, problems. But ultimately, I want us to explore critical thinking more deeply. How do we do this critical thinking thing, anyway? What do we need to watch out for? And how does critical thinking align with the scientific method as it's actually practiced by real scientists? And we'll tackle tough subjects like applied ethics challenges and scientific integrity questions. My hope is that through this journey we'll learn and grow into better critical thinkers -- together. Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

  1. 06/04/2024

    Thanks for Listening!

    This is the last episode of Critical Science. It's not goodbye. It's more like, "until we meet again." Thank you for listening! Thank you for watching! It's been a lot of fun. I learned a lot, and I hope you have, too. I also hope you had some fun along the way. This actually ran a LOT longer than I ever expected. I appreciate everyone's support! I fully anticipate creating a new podcast series at some point. I've got some ideas, some things are more concrete than others. Be excellent to each other, and I'll see you all again real soon. Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

    7 min

  2. 05/29/2024

    So-Called Endocrine Disrupting Chemicals Aren't Giving Children Metabolic Syndrome

    Summary In this episode, Dr. Lyle Burgoon discusses a study published in JAMA Network Open that claims a link between prenatal exposure to certain chemicals and metabolic syndrome risk in children. He analyzes the study using the seven tips he discussed in a previous episode and highlights several flaws and limitations in the study design. Dr. Burgoon emphasizes the importance of being skeptical and checking biases when evaluating scientific studies. He criticizes the media, particularly CNN, for sensationalizing and misrepresenting the study's findings, causing unnecessary fear and confusion among the public. Takeaways Be skeptical and evaluate scientific studies based on their scientific merits, regardless of who funded them. Consider the study design and sample size when assessing the reliability and generalizability of the findings. Recognize the limitations and uncertainties in observational studies and the inability to establish causation. Check biases and avoid confirmation bias when interpreting scientific studies. Be critical of media reporting on scientific studies and consider waiting for scientific consensus before drawing conclusions. Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

    27 min

  3. 05/21/2024

    7 Tips for Assessing Science

    I get asked now and then if I have tips to help people spot poorly done science, bad science, or what I prefer to call pseudoscience. Here are 7 tips! If you want to see the infographic, visit our Critical Science website (https://critscipod.com/episode-25-7-tips-for-assessing-science/). Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

    24 min

  4. 03/22/2024

    Benzoyl Peroxide, Benzene, and You

    Summary In this episode, Dr. Lyle discusses benzoyl peroxide and the recent concerns raised by Valashur about the presence of benzene in benzoyl peroxide products. He explains that Valashur has a history of testing products for impurities and notifying the FDA. However, the benzene was only found in products that were exposed to high heat for extended periods, which is not how they are supposed to be stored. Dr. Lyle emphasizes that one molecule of benzene is not toxic and that there are thresholds for toxicity. He also highlights the importance of educating the public about the science and not relying on activist talking points. Takeaways Benzene was found in benzoyl peroxide products that were exposed to high heat for extended periods, which is not how they are supposed to be stored. One molecule of benzene is not toxic, and there are thresholds for toxicity. It is important to educate the public about the science and not rely on activist talking points. Follow the manufacturer's instructions for storing and using benzoyl peroxide products. Chapters 00:00 Introduction to benzoyl peroxide 00:30 Valashur's testing and FDA involvement 01:24 Benzene presence in benzoyl peroxide 03:23 No safe level of benzene exposure 04:06 Toxicity of one molecule of benzene 05:05 Thresholds for toxicity 06:04 Long history of benzoyl peroxide use 06:29 Detection of impurities over time 07:56 Educating the public about thresholds 08:25 Activist talking points 09:23 DNA repair mechanisms 10:24 Xeroderma pigmentosa and DNA damage 11:24 Homeostasis and cell signaling 12:22 Dose-response curves 13:20 Oncotic necrosis and cell death 14:48 Relevance of Valashur's study 19:00 Following manufacturer's instructions 19:53 Take-home messages References: https://ehp.niehs.nih.gov/doi/10.1289/EHP13984 Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

    21 min

  5. 02/15/2024

    Drug Tests Don't Mean What You Think -- Methamphetamine Edition

    Summary In this episode of the Critical Science podcast, Dr. Lyle Burgoon discusses the topic of drug testing, with a focus on methamphetamine testing. He explains the different forms of methamphetamine and how they affect the brain. Dr. Burgoon highlights the presence of levomethamphetamine in over-the-counter products and the potential for false positive methamphetamine tests. He emphasizes the importance of accurately listing all medications, including over-the-counter drugs, when undergoing drug testing. Dr. Burgoon also explores the probability of drug use based on positive test results and the challenges of interpreting drug tests. He concludes by emphasizing the need for due diligence and additional confirmatory tests in the drug testing process. Takeaways Methamphetamine has two forms: levo and dextro, with only the dextro form having psychoactive effects on the brain. Over-the-counter products containing levomethamphetamine can lead to false positive methamphetamine tests. Positive drug tests do not necessarily indicate drug abuse, as there is a high probability of non-users testing positive. Confirmatory tests, such as enantiomer-specific tests, are necessary to accurately determine the presence of methamphetamine. Chapters 00:00 Introduction to Drug Testing 00:28 Different Forms of Methamphetamine 01:53 How Methamphetamine Affects the Brain 03:10 Levomethamphetamine in Over-the-Counter Products 04:07 Ramifications of Positive Methamphetamine Tests 05:59 Forgetting to List Over-the-Counter Drugs 06:26 Drug Testing in Various Settings 07:24 Probability of Drug Use Based on Positive Test 08:20 Bayes' Rule and Prevalence of Drug Users 09:46 Probability of Positive Test for Non-Users 12:37 Performance Characteristics of Drug Tests 13:34 Low Probability of Drug Use Given Positive Test 16:37 High Probability of Non-Users Testing Positive 18:10 Challenges of Drug Testing and Confirmatory Tests 20:27 Enantiomer Specific Test for Methamphetamine 23:21 Additional Steps in Drug Testing Process 25:31 Importance of Due Diligence in Drug Testing 26:01 Positive Test Does Not Indicate Drug Abuse 26:58 Orthogonal Assay for More Accurate Results 27:25 Conclusion and Closing Remarks Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

    28 min

  6. 01/16/2024

    The American Academy of Pediatrics Gets Glyphosate Wrong

    Happy New Year! New Year, New You, right? Well, it wasn't quite in the new year, but the American Academy of Pediatrics may have re-made themselves into a Merchant of Fear. In December 2023, the AAP released a statement that although GMOs themselves are fine, glyphosate (which is commonly associated with GMO crops) is not okay for children. In fact, the AAP says that glyphosate "Recent studies show that glyphosate is present in many foods, especially ultra-processed foods (more information, below). It also shows up in 80% of urine samples taken from people in the U.S.—including kids as young as 6 years. This suggests that most children and adults are consuming foods that may increase their chances of developing cancer." So this creates a confusing dynamic: do I trust the US EPA and the US FDA, or do I trust the AAP? The US Government and the AAP can't both be right. The US Government says that glyphosate does not cause cancer. Yet the AAP says glyphosate may increase the chances of children developing cancer. Who's right here? The science is clear -- the US Government is right, and the AAP is pushing a chemophobic agenda. Find out more in today's podcast! Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

    20 min

  7. 12/01/2023

    Alcohol, Family Law, and a Biomarker Called PETH

    Thanks for your patience while I was away on travel. I spent a couple of weeks in Korea presenting at 2 conferences, including 1 Keynote Address. And somehow one of my kids speaks better Korean than me!?! (It's not hard to speak better Korean than me). Anywho, big few weeks in the toxicology world. The European Commission granted another 10 year approval to glyphosate! I did not have that on my bingo card! The Biden-Harris Administration is looking to replace all of the lead service lines -- that's simply fantastic news! Now, on to more our topic of the day -- phosphatidylethanol or PETH (see why we just call it PETH; I trip over that word and I have a biochemistry background, which means I am trained to say big words like that). Anywho, today's topic is this: PETH and its use in Family Law cases. I've seen it mostly when a parent, in a co-parenting situation, has temporary custody of a child and is not allowed to drink in the presence of the child. I'm going to talk today about why PETH is not the right biomarker to use in these cases. And I want to give a shout-out to the Toxicology Education Foundation (TEF; toxedfoundation.org). Fully disclosure: I'm on the Board and I am the Secretary. Part of the TEF's mission is to educate the public about toxicology in our daily lives. We want to raise the level of scientific literacy in our country. But we can't do it without your help. Please consider donating to TEF -- small dollar donations are always welcome. Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

    25 min

  8. 10/24/2023

    California, Fear, and Red Dye 3

    Well, California has gone full chemophobic on us. Governor Newsom signed an incredibly anti-science bill into law. They have decided that banning chemicals that will not cause cancer at human relevant concentrations in food is the way to go. This is the first step towards building an anti-science, chemophobic society. But I think the thing that irritates me most is that politicians believe they know more about food safety and science than toxicologists. Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

    22 min
See All (27)

Ratings & Reviews

5
out of 5
2 Ratings

About

Critical Science is focused on a few things I (Dr. Lyle Burgoon) love -- critical thinking (which I don't do enough of at home, ask my family), science, and applied ethics. And ya know what -- even scientists, who are supposed to be trained to be critical thinkers, often mess it up (I'm certainly not perfect). In each episode I try to combine these two passions of mine. Sometimes, we'll explore a topic in the news in a slightly more critical way. Other times we might explore how a lack of critical thought has led to some minor, and sometimes major, problems. But ultimately, I want us to explore critical thinking more deeply. How do we do this critical thinking thing, anyway? What do we need to watch out for? And how does critical thinking align with the scientific method as it's actually practiced by real scientists? And we'll tackle tough subjects like applied ethics challenges and scientific integrity questions. My hope is that through this journey we'll learn and grow into better critical thinkers -- together. Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

Information

  • Creator
    Lyle Burgoon
  • Years Active
    2022 - 2024
  • Episodes
    27
  • Rating
    Explicit
  • Copyright
    © Lyle Burgoon
  • Show Website
    Critical Science