Dear Jane

Scott Baker & Marcie Little
  • 4.6 (21)
  • News Commentary
  • Updated Weekly

This podcast brings together pro-life leaders and individuals of all stripes to have meaningful conversations about the issue of life. How do we tackle the massive injustice of abortion while keeping the abortion-minded woman at the forefront of our considerations? How do we hold heartbreak, anger, and compassion close to our hearts to minister to everyone impacted by abortion? How do we work with others with whom we differ ideologically on every other issue except the issue of abortion to promote a culture of life? These are just some of the questions we wrestle with on our Dear Jane podcast. The other side only wants to highlight our differences, but we want to talk with people in the movement about what unites us. Dear Jane focuses on the one thing we can all agree on: the sanctity of every human life. Dear Jane will host the hard conversations, ask the tough questions, and acknowledge our differences while always keeping in mind our shared beliefs. Tune in to listen to heartfelt conversations and learn more about what your place in the pro-life movement may be!

  1. 4d ago

    Who Is Really Ordering the Abortion Pill?

    An abortion pill can be ordered online and mailed across state lines. But what happens when the person ordering it isn’t the woman who takes it? Andrea Trudden, Vice President of Communications and Marketing at Heartbeat International, joins Scott and Marcie to discuss what the organization calls abortion pill poisoning: documented cases in which women have allegedly been given abortion drugs through force, coercion, or deception. Pills crushed into drinks. Orders placed using a woman’s identity. A doctor accused of poisoning his girlfriend. And a father charged with giving abortion drugs to his 17-year-old daughter at 23 weeks pregnant. Andrea also shares the story of Catherine Herring, whose now-ex-husband was convicted after secretly giving her abortion drugs and attempting to do so six more times. Heartbeat International now maintains a public tracker of these cases, documenting each through court records or local news reports. The abortion pill debate usually centers on access. But when these drugs are this easy to obtain, who is really getting them? Watch the full conversation on Dear Jane.

    Who Is Really Ordering the Abortion Pill?

  2. Aug 20

    What’s Changing Gen Z’s Mind on Abortion?

    Gen Z has grown up surrounded by abortion messaging. So why are more young people beginning to question it? And why now? Lydia Taylor Davis, a spokesperson and Social Media Coordinator for Students for Life of America who once identified as pro-choice herself, joins Scott and Marcie to talk about what she is seeing firsthand on college campuses: young men becoming more engaged, young women proving harder to reach, and students reconsidering abortion after encountering arguments they had never heard before. But those conversations come at a cost. Lydia says she wears a bulletproof vest when she speaks on campuses and received threats after Charlie Kirk’s assassination. Students for Life considered canceling its speaking tours. They didn’t. She also discusses what the pro-life movement gets wrong when speaking to women, why graphic abortion imagery can backfire, and why social media may be one of the most important battlegrounds left. All of these facts paint a picture and also raise an important question: what actually changes a person's mind about abortion? Watch the full conversation on Dear Jane. Chapters: 0:44 — Campus Trends on Abortion 2:25 — What’s Changing Gen Z’s Mind? 3:40 — The Gender Divide on Abortion 6:06 — What’s Bringing Men Into the Conversation? 7:11 — “Charlie Was First. We’re Coming for You Next.” 8:44 — Why They Refused to Back Down 10:22 — Who Is Actually Changing Their Mind? 11:53 — How Do You Prepare for the Threats? 13:32 — Is the Pro-Life Argument Really Religious? 15:28 — When Becoming Pro-Life Changes Your Identity 17:59 — What Isn’t Working With Gen Z? 20:11 — Does Victim Imagery Work? 22:06 — How Social Media Shapes Gen Z on Abortion 23:42 — Why We Have to Be Online 24:42 — The Social Media Post That Helped Save a Baby 25:00 — Who Is Gen Z Listening To?

    What’s Changing Gen Z’s Mind on Abortion?

  3. Aug 13

    Are Abortion Restrictions Really Causing Maternal Deaths?

    A waiting period. An ultrasound. A requirement that a physician perform the abortion. A new study grouped measures like these under one category: abortion restrictions and linked states with more restrictions to higher maternal mortality. That sounds alarming. But Dr. Christina Francis, a board-certified OB-GYN and CEO of AAPLOG, raises a basic question: how do these policies actually cause maternal deaths? She joins Scott and Marcie to examine what the headline leaves out. How does requiring an ultrasound increase maternal mortality? Why is giving a woman more time before a major decision treated as a health risk? And why is physician involvement being framed as a restriction? The conversation also turns to abortion-pill complications, including research finding that 83.5% of post-abortion-pill emergency room visits were miscoded as miscarriages and 76% of emergency room visits following the abortion pill were coded as severe. Dr. Francis explains why those findings matter, what could happen as physician-only requirements are removed, and the challenges doctors face when they question the dominant abortion narrative within medicine. Watch the full episode of Dear Jane to get the full conversation. -- 1:15 — When Maternal-Fetal Medicine Chooses a Side 3:27 — Do Abortion Restrictions Cause Maternal Deaths? 5:08 — Is a Waiting Period Really a Health Risk? 6:12 — How Does an Ultrasound Cause Maternal Death? 9:15 — What Actually Causes Maternal Death? 10:19 — 80% of Maternal Deaths Are Preventable 12:49 — When Pregnancy Isn’t the Cause 14:23 — Should Non-Physicians Provide Abortions? 16:20 — The Reality of a D&E Abortion 19:22 — How Safe Is the Abortion Pill? 22:00 — When an Abortion Is Coded as a Miscarriage 23:05 — The Trauma No One Warns Women About 23:50 — What Pro-Life Doctors Risk by Speaking Up 24:45 — 93% of OB-GYNs Don’t Perform Abortions 25:58 — Who Stands With Pro-Life Doctors?

    Are Abortion Restrictions Really Causing Maternal Deaths?

  4. Aug 6

    Is the Abortion Pill in Our Water?

    What begins with the abortion pill does not necessarily end when the abortion is over. Once taken, the abortion drug and biological remnants from the abortion enter a toilet, a sewer system, and eventually a wastewater treatment facility that was never designed to remove every pharmaceutical compound. The chemical is only part of what enters the system. Liberty Counsel Action estimates that 30 to 40 tons of hazardous medical waste, including human remains, are being flushed into American waterways. That makes mifepristone different from the other pharmaceuticals already raising concerns in the water supply. It was developed and FDA-approved to end a life in the womb by blocking progesterone, the hormone needed to sustain a pregnancy. But does that anti-progesterone activity disappear once the drug enters the water system? Issues in Law & Medicine,a study reported anti-progesterone activity in environmental water samples from Austin, Texas; Blacksburg, Virginia; and Carbondale, Illinois. The study does not establish that exposure through drinking water causes infertility, nor does it determine where the anti-progesterone activity originated. But it raises a question that has received remarkably little investigation: what happens after mifepristone enters the water system? They also found that downstream levels were not appreciably lower than upstream levels in any of the three cities. In two, they were higher. The authors concluded that conventional water treatment was not consistently effective at removing the activity they detected.cking progesterone, what happens after it enters the water system?Could environmental exposure be one factor worth investigating when approximately 1 in 6 people of reproductive age worldwide experience infertility during their lifetime?Abigail Forman is a researcher and policy analyst with Liberty Counsel Action and the author of a comprehensive analysis on abortion drugs in America's water supply. She joins Dear Jane to walk through what the abortion industry and federal regulators have largely left unaddressed. Abigail Forman is a researcher and policy analyst with Liberty Counsel Action and the author of a comprehensive analysis on abortion drugs in America's water supply. She joins Dear Jane to walk through the research, explain what she believes the abortion industry and federal regulators have largely left unaddressed, and discuss why these questions deserve closer attention. She also raises a question that stops the conversation cold: if women were required to decide whether to cremate or bury what the abortion pill produces, would more of them think twice? Her argument reaches beyond the pro-life movement. You do not have to be pro-life to care about abortion drugs entering the water supply. And because chemical abortions account for roughly two-thirds of abortions in the United States, Abigail argues that water-contamination regulations could change the abortion landscape almost overnight. the abortion pill now accounts for roughly two0-thirds of abortions in the Uni Visit abortioninourwater.org to learn more about the research and current efforts calling on the EPA to investigate. The comment period closes August 31, 2026. Watch the full episode of Dear Jane.

    Is the Abortion Pill in Our Water?

  5. Jul 30

    Has the Pro-Life Movement Lost Its Focus?

    The pro-life movement is not having one conversation right now. It has several, and they do not always agree with each other. Scott and Marcie discuss the Massachusetts bill that would allow abortion up to birth and the question it raises about messaging: As the movement has shifted its focus toward the mother, has it made a strategic mistake by stepping back from talking about the baby? They discuss fetal pain—what it is, how it shapes the conversation, and why some in the movement have moved away from talking about it. They also examine the California lawsuit in which the state's attorney general is seeking more than $20 million and a permanent gag order against Heartbeat International and Real Options for telling women about Abortion Pill Reversal. Under oath, the state's own expert witness could not say APR is unsafe, could not say it does not work, and could not support the state's claim that the abortion pill is safer than Tylenol. These conversations are shaping the future of the pro-life movement and raising questions it can no longer avoid. Watch the full episode of Dear Jane. -- 0:23 — Abortion Up to Birth 1:49 — Have We Abandoned the Baby? 3:30 — The Fetal Pain Argument 4:16 — The Baby Recoils 5:40 — The Problem With Subjectivism 6:50 — Reorienting Around the Baby 7:54 — What's Your Favorite Type of Abortion? 9:34 — Equal Protection Explained 11:00 — Inside the Movement's Divide 13:14 — Unapologetic About the Goal 14:12 — Is the Movement Making It Worse? 15:00 — Abortion Is Illegal. It's Still Happening. 17:10 — History Doesn't Answer 2026 19:30 — Showing What Abortion Actually Is 20:00 — The California Lawsuit 21:00 — Coercion and the Feminist Silence 21:50 — The Baby Who Almost Wasn't 22:40 — The Witness Who Couldn't Back It Up 23:50 — Population Control on the Stand 24:40 — What If We Just Called It Progesterone? 26:00 — APR Is a Choice 27:00 — Taking Away the Right to Change Your Mind

    Has the Pro-Life Movement Lost Its Focus?

  6. Jul 23

    What If Family Is Being Redefined Without You Knowing?

    The redefinition of the family is not happening all at once. It is happening one sentence at a time, buried inside 80-page bills that most lawmakers never fully read, drafted by legal bodies most people have never heard of, and framed as routine updates to reflect the modern reality of family life. Patience Sunne, Engagement Director at Them Before Us, has been reading those bills. She joins Dear Jane to talk about what is actually in them: the removal of mother and father language from parentage laws, the legalization of surrogacy without a single background check, the quiet allowance of poly parenting slipped into a single line of code, and what any of it means for the child at the center of all of it. Them Before Us recently released the Children's Rights Scorecard, grading all 50 states on how well their laws protect children's rights. You can look up your state. The grades are illuminating. This is not a conversation about politics. It is a conversation about what children need and whether anyone in power is asking. Watch the full episode on Dear Jane.

    What If Family Is Being Redefined Without You Knowing?

  7. Jul 16

    What Finally Made an Abortion Clinic Nurse Walk Away

    She was a nurse. She believed she was providing care and helping women. She had no idea what she was walking into. Naomi Padilla spent four years inside a Tampa abortion clinic where, she says, surgical suites were wiped down with a household cleaner, women were processed like cattle, and the words baby and God weren't allowed to be spoken. A woman who said she wasn't sure was still ushered through the abortion process. A woman who called back, saying she was on the brink of taking her own life, received no emergency intervention. No one called 911. And the number of procedures completed determined whether the staff got pizza or “the good lunch.” When Naomi later met former abortion workers from across the country, she realized her clinic was not an isolated case. More than 700 workers have connected with And Then There Were None, many of whom have described similar experiences. Then one day, a patient offered her $50 just to hear her baby’s heartbeat. Naomi had not heard one in two years. Everything began to change. Today, Naomi is part of And Then There Were None, an organization that helps abortion workers leave the industry and begin healing. She joins Dear Jane to tell the story of what she witnessed, what finally changed her mind, and why she believes her story is only one of many.

    What Finally Made an Abortion Clinic Nurse Walk Away

  8. Jul 9

    The Legal War on Pregnancy Centers, Abortion Pill Reversal, and the Women Behind the Cases

    The New Jersey attorney general created a strike force to investigate pro-life pregnancy centers. One of those centers received a subpoena demanding ten years of private donor records. No complaints had been filed. No fraud had been alleged. The case went all the way to the Supreme Court, which ruled unanimously in the pregnancy center's favor. Twenty-four hours later, the state found a way to keep fighting anyway. That is just one case. In New York and California, attorneys general are trying to silence pregnancy centers for simply telling women that abortion pill reversal exists. In Louisiana, a woman's ex-boyfriend ordered mifepristone online and coerced her to take it. And the drug whose label says one in twenty-five women will end up in the emergency room is now available to anyone with a few minutes and an internet connection. Gabriella McIntyre is an attorney with the Alliance Defending Freedom. She joins Dear Jane to walk through all of it, the cases, the creative tactics, the real stories behind the headlines, and answer the question most people are left with at the end: What can the rest of us actually do about any of this?

    The Legal War on Pregnancy Centers, Abortion Pill Reversal, and the Women Behind the Cases
See All (124)

Trailer

4.6
out of 5
21 Ratings

About

This podcast brings together pro-life leaders and individuals of all stripes to have meaningful conversations about the issue of life. How do we tackle the massive injustice of abortion while keeping the abortion-minded woman at the forefront of our considerations? How do we hold heartbreak, anger, and compassion close to our hearts to minister to everyone impacted by abortion? How do we work with others with whom we differ ideologically on every other issue except the issue of abortion to promote a culture of life? These are just some of the questions we wrestle with on our Dear Jane podcast. The other side only wants to highlight our differences, but we want to talk with people in the movement about what unites us. Dear Jane focuses on the one thing we can all agree on: the sanctity of every human life. Dear Jane will host the hard conversations, ask the tough questions, and acknowledge our differences while always keeping in mind our shared beliefs. Tune in to listen to heartfelt conversations and learn more about what your place in the pro-life movement may be!

Information

  • Creator
    Scott Baker & Marcie Little
  • Years Active
    2022 - 2026
  • Episodes
    124
  • Rating
    Clean
  • Copyright
    © Dear Jane 2022
  • Show Website
    Dear Jane