American court hearing recordings and interviews

Center of Main Interests

Listen to this podcast of American court hearing records and interviews, including oral arguments before the U.S. Supreme Court and the eleven Circuit Courts of Appeals as well as lower federal court hearings.

  1. 3d ago

    Listen to the 11/16 argument to the Court of Appeals re third party releases in the Gol bankruptcy.

    Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode! This is a somewhat surprising appeal in the Brazilian Gol airline bankruptcy filed in the United States, insofar as a majority of the U.S. Supreme Court - including Justices considered liberals and conservatives - expressed in the Purdue Pharma opioid bankruptcy, that third party releases were not appropriate as they shielded parties who did not file for bankruptcy (in the Purdue Pharma case, the company owners, the Sackler family). Supreme Court rulings in bankruptcy cases are typically interpreted broadly. When a party receives a release (protection from being sued) as part of a bankruptcy case (such as a chapter 11 bankruptcy or a chapter 15 bankruptcy effectuating a release from a foreign court), in effect the party is receiving debt discharge globally as a matter of U.S, law without having filed for bankruptcy. This is in contravention of the Bankruptcy Code and its provisions and policies as expressed by the majority of the Supreme Court in Purdue Pharma. This appeal in the Gol bankruptcy concerns so called opt-out mechanisms in bankruptcies (actually the opposite of what opt-out suggests, people or parties that bought their claims doing nothing in response to receiving voluminous court papers, and NOT opting out and therefore being deemed to have consented to third party releases of parties that did not file for bankruptcy), a technique for achieving third party releases that counsel for the appellant argues is not foreclosed by Purdue Pharma,. She makes a few comparisons to contract law (much as a contract is a legally binding agreement people actively enter into) and other arguments that the panel of Judges had questions about. On the other side of the appeal is the winner in the court below, the US government/US Trustee's office, defending the win in this appeal. The government was the winner in the Purdue Pharma bankruptcy. The appeal is before the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit, based in downtown Manhattan, which has jurisdiction over appeals of certain court orders entered in cases including Southern District of New York bankruptcy cases (which can be appealed directly to the Circuit Court or first to District Courts). The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit, based in New Orleans, which has jurisdiction over appeals of certain court orders including appeals springing from Houston bankruptcy cases, also has an appeal pending concerning third party release issues... in the Container Store bankruptcy. Some commentators read Purdue Pharma narrowly and discuss the possibility there will be a circuit split (different rulings by the Second Circuit and Fifth Circuit) on these so called opt-out provisions that some law firms are including in bankruptcies to encourage company owners and other parties to agree to a bankruptcy path to deal with a financial crisis typically caused by the companies having taken on too much debt that was pushed on the companies. A circuit split could lead to another Supreme Court appeal about third party releases. It would be unusual if the Supreme Court takes on two appeals on related bankruptcy issues given the many parties seeking appellate review from the Supreme Court re different areas of law, some of which the Court has not addressed before or recently, but it is possible.

    Listen to the 11/16 argument to the Court of Appeals re third party releases in the Gol bankruptcy.

Ratings & Reviews

About

Listen to this podcast of American court hearing records and interviews, including oral arguments before the U.S. Supreme Court and the eleven Circuit Courts of Appeals as well as lower federal court hearings.