Our Secret Bookshelf

Faith and Jay
  • 4.5 (4)
  • COMEDY FICTION
  • UPDATED BIWEEKLY

Welcome to "Our Secret Bookshelf," a hilarious podcast for curious adults exploring strange, obscure books that have never entered a public library. Each episode uncovers a new tome, from monster mash to erotic sentient beings, guided by our storytelling bibliophile hosts. Whether you are intrigued by the bizarre or love literary oddities, "Our Secret Bookshelf" invites you to explore the extraordinary, where each page reveals a new WTF. Tune in to ignite your morbid curiosity! Follow us on IG @oursecretbookshelf to see what’s coming and vote on possible books.

  1. Forced Into a Vagina (Rerun)

    FEB 6

    Forced Into a Vagina (Rerun)

    **Bringing back a classic from Season 1! (Originally aired Season 1 Episode 2 - February 24th, 2023) Join Faith and Jaylynne as we explore Stacy's vagina. It's a typical love story about a small man who is forced inside a giant woman's vagina and enters a whole new world...of jelly people(??)The Haunted Vagina by Carlton Mellick IIIIf you have any suggestions for books we should read and review in the future, please email OurSecretBookshelf2023@gmail.comPlease Like and Subscribe so you know when future Episodes are released.**WARNING** Spoilers! ** WARNING** Explicit Language **WARNING** Slightly Buzzed Hosts

    38 min

  2. JAN 23

    Tingle in 2026

    Join Faith and Jaylynne go on grand adventures that include dragons, unicorns, and sentient beings. Dungeons, Dragons, and Buckaroos by Chuck Tingle OSB Rating = 1 If you have any suggestions for books we should read and review in the future, please emailOurSecretBookshelf2023@gmail.com Please Like and Subscribe so you know when future Episodes are released. **WARNING** Spoilers! ** WARNING** Explicit Language **WARNING** Slightly Buzzed Hosts OSB Rating Scale** 1 – Mild 2 – Just a Little More 3 – Midrange 4 – Mature 5 – Top of the Spectrum (for genre) (**To learn more about our rating scale, please see Season 1 Episode 24 – Goodbye 2023)

    53 min

  3. JAN 2

    That's a Wrap on Season 3

    Join Faith and Jaylynne as we share our favorites (and not so favorites) of Season 3. If you have any suggestions for books we should read and review in the future, please emailOurSecretBookshelf2023@gmail.com Please Like and Subscribe so you know when future Episodes are released. **WARNING** Spoilers! ** WARNING** Explicit Language **WARNING** Slightly Buzzed Hosts OSB Rating Scale** 1 – Mild 2 – Just a Little More 3 – Midrange 4 – Mature 5 – Top of the Spectrum (for genre) (**To learn more about our rating scale, please see Season 1 Episode 24 – Goodbye 2023)

    42 min

  4. 12/19/2025

    50% Was Pretty Good

    Join Faith and Jaylynne as we hate on half this book. Christmas on Crack by Carlton Mellick III OSB Rating = 5 If you have any suggestions for books we should read and review in the future, please emailOurSecretBookshelf2023@gmail.com Please Like and Subscribe so you know when future Episodes are released. **WARNING** Spoilers! ** WARNING** Explicit Language **WARNING** Slightly Buzzed Hosts OSB Rating Scale** 1 – Mild 2 – Just a Little More 3 – Midrange 4 – Mature 5 – Top of the Spectrum (for genre) (**To learn more about our rating scale, please see Season 1 Episode 24 – Goodbye 2023)

    29 min

  5. 12/05/2025

    Holly Goes to Prison

    Join Faith and Jaylynne as they wonder “what about Chad?!” Frisky by Lauren Biel OSB Rating = 4 If you have any suggestions for books we should read and review in the future, please emailOurSecretBookshelf2023@gmail.com Please Like and Subscribe so you know when future Episodes are released. **WARNING** Spoilers! ** WARNING** Explicit Language **WARNING** Slightly Buzzed Hosts OSB Rating Scale** 1 – Mild 2 – Just a Little More 3 – Midrange 4 – Mature 5 – Top of the Spectrum (for genre) (**To learn more about our rating scale, please see Season 1 Episode 24 – Goodbye 2023)

    41 min

  6. 11/21/2025

    Maybe the Grossest Book Ever

    Join Faith and Jaylynne as they struggle to embrace the cringe of this meaty (gag) story. Basted by Abby Hunter OSB Rating = 5 If you have any suggestions for books we should read and review in the future, please emailOurSecretBookshelf2023@gmail.com Please Like and Subscribe so you know when future Episodes are released. **WARNING** Spoilers! ** WARNING** Explicit Language **WARNING** Slightly Buzzed Hosts OSB Rating Scale** 1 – Mild 2 – Just a Little More 3 – Midrange 4 – Mature 5 – Top of the Spectrum (for genre) (**To learn more about our rating scale, please see Season 1 Episode 24 – Goodbye 2023)

    27 min

  7. 11/07/2025

    One way to break a dry streak

    Join Faith and Jaylynne as they spend time on Etsy searching for crochet penises. Corny by Sabrina Cross OSB Rating = 2 If you have any suggestions for books we should read and review in the future, please emailOurSecretBookshelf2023@gmail.com Please Like and Subscribe so you know when future Episodes are released. **WARNING** Spoilers! ** WARNING** Explicit Language **WARNING** Slightly Buzzed Hosts OSB Rating Scale** 1 – Mild 2 – Just a Little More 3 – Midrange 4 – Mature 5 – Top of the Spectrum (for genre) (**To learn more about our rating scale, please see Season 1 Episode 24 – Goodbye 2023)

    30 min

  8. 10/24/2025

    Just a fun little Halloween story…

    Hallopeen by Holly Wilde Join Faith and Jaylynne as they learn new Halloween Legends…and that they will always make sure all the candy is out of the bowl by midnight. OSB Rating = 3 If you have any suggestions for books we should read and review in the future, please emailOurSecretBookshelf2023@gmail.com Please Like and Subscribe so you know when future Episodes are released. **WARNING** Spoilers! ** WARNING** Explicit Language **WARNING** Slightly Buzzed Hosts OSB Rating Scale** 1 – Mild 2 – Just a Little More 3 – Midrange 4 – Mature 5 – Top of the Spectrum (for genre) (**To learn more about our rating scale, please see Sea son 1 Episode 24 – Goodbye 2023)

    42 min
See All (78)

Trailer

Ratings & Reviews

4.5
out of 5
4 Ratings

About

Welcome to "Our Secret Bookshelf," a hilarious podcast for curious adults exploring strange, obscure books that have never entered a public library. Each episode uncovers a new tome, from monster mash to erotic sentient beings, guided by our storytelling bibliophile hosts. Whether you are intrigued by the bizarre or love literary oddities, "Our Secret Bookshelf" invites you to explore the extraordinary, where each page reveals a new WTF. Tune in to ignite your morbid curiosity! Follow us on IG @oursecretbookshelf to see what’s coming and vote on possible books.

Information

  • Creator
    Faith and Jay
  • Years Active
    2023 - 2026
  • Episodes
    78
  • Rating
    Explicit
  • Copyright
    © Faith and Jay
  • Show Website
    Our Secret Bookshelf