Have you ever realized that you've spent so much time meeting everyone else's expectations that you're no longer sure what you actually want? For Audra Phelps, that realization came while making an apple pie. After spending much of her life in the Mormon Church, Audra made the difficult decision to leave behind the belief system that had shaped her identity, relationships, and understanding of what it meant to be a good wife, mother, and person. Leaving gave her the freedom to make her own choices. But it also meant confronting something she hadn't anticipated: the fear and uncertainty of no longer having someone else tell her what was right. In this episode of The Spiritually Curious Therapist, I sit down with Audra, founder of Mama Audra, to explore what happens when the beliefs and expectations we've built our lives around no longer feel true. Together, we discuss the emotional impact of leaving a high-demand religion, the challenge of rebuilding identity, and the ways guilt, shame, and old conditioning can continue influencing our choices long after we've consciously rejected those beliefs. Audra shares her personal journey of questioning her faith, navigating marriage and motherhood, and learning to recognize emotions she had spent years suppressing. She also tells a powerful story about a Thanksgiving apple pie that revealed just how disconnected she'd become from her own wants and needs. And in one of the most thought-provoking moments of the conversation, Audra reveals something she never expected to grieve after leaving her religion: certainty. In This Episode, We Explore: Identity beyond expectations: Who are we when the roles and beliefs that once defined us no longer fit?The nervous system and uncertainty: Why freedom and choice can feel threatening when we've become accustomed to rigid rules and expectations.Emotional suppression and self-trust: How learning to recognize anger, guilt, grief, and resentment can help us reconnect with ourselves.The apple pie moment: What happens when we realize we've spent years anticipating everyone else's needs without considering our own.Grieving the life unlived: Navigating regret, questioning past choices, and discovering what we want moving forward.Conditioning and self-abandonment: How beliefs about being a good wife, mother, daughter, or person can shape our behavior long after circumstances change.The loss of certainty: Why developing the freedom to choose can also mean learning to tolerate not knowing.A Question to Sit With Audra's story raises a question that extends far beyond religious deconstruction: How much of the life you're living reflects what you genuinely want, and how much reflects what you learned you were supposed to want? Sometimes the first step toward change isn't making a big decision. It's noticing the small, everyday moments when we override our own preferences, feelings, and needs. And getting curious about why. Connect with Audra: Visit Mama Audra to learn more about her work and explore her free masterclass, Five Shifts Every Former Mormon Woman Needs to Make. www.mamaaudra.com IG: https://www.instagram.com/mamaaudraofficial/?hl=en FB: https://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=61571178607920 TT: Mama Audra You-Tube: https://www.youtube.com/@Mama-Audra Linkedin: https://www.linkedin.com/in/audra-phelps-b422786a/ Share what resonated for you Thank you for listening to the Spiritually Curious Therapist Podcast. If you enjoyed this episode, please subscribe, share, and leave a review - it helps us grow and reach more listeners! For our 2027 season, we’re exploring how we stay connected to ourselves while navigating relationships, difficult emotions, and the expectations of others. Our listeners may seem capable and composed while privately struggling with people-pleasing, perfectionism, anxiety, resentment, or persistent pain and symptoms. We’re curious about what helps people acknowledge their feelings, express their needs, and build relationships that have room for them, too. Spiritual curiosity is part of this exploration: questioning who we’ve learned we’re supposed to be, reconnecting with our values and inner experience, and discovering what makes life meaningful. Our conversations bring psychotherapy, nervous system science, spirituality, and lived experience into dialogue. Could your professional or lived experience contribute to this conversation? If so, complete an application to be on the podcast here Until next time. Stay Curious. You can find Jodi Silverman, LCSW at www.therachihealing.com ...