Ask A Priest Live

The Station of the Cross Catholic Media Network

"Ask A Priest Live," because Father knows best! We'll bring you a different priest each weekday at 12pm Eastern time, where you'll be able to participate in a live Q&A on the topics that matter! We'll be joined by priests and canons from the Institute of Christ the King Sovereign Priest, the Priestly Fraternity of Saint Peter, the Franciscan Friars of the Immaculate, and even some Diocesan priests that you may know personally! To ask your question, call 1-877-511-5483 or email us at priests@thestationofthecross.com

  1. 8h ago

    11/20/26 - Fr. Michael Rennier - On-Air Appeal Day Two

    Donate today! www.thestationofthecross.com   Email:  Joe from Elmira, NY I'm a high school athlete, and sports are a huge part of my life. Sometimes tournaments or practices interfere with Sunday Mass, and my coaches expect everyone to participate. Is it wrong to miss Mass for a big game, and how should I handle it if my coach doesn't understand?   Email:  Candice from Rochester, NY If someone cloned a human being in a laboratory, would that cloned person have a soul? Would the Catholic Church recognize that person as fully human, and could they receive Baptism and the other sacraments?   Email: John from Boston I've heard Catholics say that suffering can be offered up to God. What does that actually accomplish? If Jesus already suffered and died for our sins, why would God want us to offer Him our suffering?   @CriticalThought369 ​​Isn't the modern concept of romantic attraction synonymous with perceptive internal lust, due to its irrational undertones?   Aquinas and Augustine say it is present within the ordered marital act more than the modern notion of attraction that has no rational and voluntary basis   shouldn't the internal tendency towards a partner be built on different emotions   EMAIL: Jack from Maryland When I am in the heat of battle with evil (e.g., facing a "big", obvious evil), I am always willing to fight it, and willing to sacrifice myself to beat it. In everyday life, though, I find myself constantly giving in to "little" evils despite my will to defeat evil when faced with "big" ones. How can I prevent this?   Question from Donor: Kaitlin from Ashland, MA ($100) How do you know if God is speaking to you? What do you hear?   YouTube: Elizabeth I'm 16, and I believe in God, but honestly, I find going to Mass pretty boring. My parents make me go every Sunday, but I don't feel like I'm getting anything out of it. What advice do you have for me?   EMAIL: Tom from Arkansas Is any species of dancing (between unmarried couples) allowed by the Church? If we are to never place ourselves in the occasion of sin, should we also not attend dances (even if hosted by a parish), for they can be an occasion for sin? Could arguing against all dancing appear to be Puritan?

  2. 1d ago

    11/19/26 - Fr. John Brancich, FSSP - On-Air Appeal Day One

    Donate now! www.thestationofthecross.com   Email: Mike from New York Can a priest refuse to absolve someone’s sins after hearing their confession?   EMAIL: John A few days ago, I made the first sincere confession of my life. I had been unfaithful to the sacrament of confession since my First Communion. I confessed all the mortal sins I could remember with a sincere heart and tried my very best. However, I forgot to mention a few mortal sins that I only remembered after the confession was over. I feel as though my sins are not forgiven, especially since the confessor only gave me a simple penance. Do I need to confess the sins again in confession, and should I refrain from receiving Communion until I do?   EMAIL: Anonymous from New York At night when I'm lying in bed, my mind will sometimes wander, and I'll have sexual thoughts. I'll catch myself and rebuke those thoughts, but I'm wondering if these are something I should confess?   YouTube: Charlie If a priest commits a serious sin and celebrates Mass without going to Confession, is the Eucharist still valid? Does the priest's spiritual condition have any effect on the sacraments he administers?   @AmongTheWildflowers8​ ​What is the FSSP’s general practice for admitting children and adults with special needs to the Sacraments of Communion and Confirmation? I’ve heard that some FSSP priests won’t allow it?   EMAIL: Tiffany (For Fr. Brancich) I saw Father Brancich's segment a couple of months ago in which he discussed why digital piracy is a sin. Would he then go on to say that there is a moral obligation to make restitution for such piracy? As I understand it, sins against commutative justice require restitution, and it would seem that digital piracy and other violations of copyright would fall under this category. That would also, however, seem to be a very onerous requirement, given the extent to which copyright, licensing, and related laws and agreements are not/have not been respected by significant chunks of the population over these past several decades.   EMAIL: Anonymous I am a 19-year-old, and I am thinking of discerning the priesthood with the FSSP. My dream is to celebrate the Latin Mass, but I struggle with Latin. My question is: Was there any help in the seminary for seminarians who struggled with Latin?   Email: Anonymous I'm a teenage boy, and sometimes I wonder whether God might be calling me to become a priest. But I also want to get married and have a family someday. How can I tell whether I'm actually being called to the priesthood or whether it's just something I've thought about?   @SpoiloftheImmaculate ​​Father can we look forward to death? I sometimes find myself looking forward to it in suffering. Even calling it sweet. I don’t mean it in a suicidal way. I just want to go to heaven already.

  3. 3d ago

    11/17/26 - Fr. Joseph Dalimata, FSSP - How Can a Husband Begin Again After Falling into Mortal Sins?

    Fr. Joseph Dalimata, FSSP, serves as Parochial Vicar at Our Lady of Mount Carmel in Littleton (Denver), Colorado. He was ordained in May of 2021. Click here for more information on Bosco Ministries.  Resources: e-course: https://www.boscoministries.org/the-bosco-way-in-the-household-e-course Sign up for more formational content: https://www.boscoministries.org/join In Today's Show: EMAIL: Anonymous Father, can you speak about how a husband should begin again if he was formerly devout and fell into scruples and mortal sins? I’m having a hard time picking myself back up and leading my family.   EMAIL: Robert from Buffalo, NY I have a son who will be turning 13 next year. While I would love to send him to one of Bosco Ministries camps, they're unfortunately too far away. Would it be acceptable to instead send him to a secular summer camp? The YMCA has a camp in Buffalo that offers canoeing, ziplining, swimming, and other activities that I'm sure he would enjoy. I'm just worried he may pick up things I wouldn’t approve of from the other kids. What are your thoughts?   @josemontes3636 ​​What are some of the challenges and triumphs you have had with Bosco Ministries?   @saulcd2 ​​I would like to learn more about st John boscos teachings. Can you please recommend a book or any writings please? Thank you -Saul from OLMC   EMAIL: Anonymous from Gainesville, Florida I find myself going through the motions every day, not being the man God wants me to be. Instead of working on improving my work, my prayer life, or other aspects of my life, I'll just sit around on my bed or at my desk feeling unmotivated. What would you recommend for a man to become more motivated and have a new lease on life?   EMAIL: Julie from Erie, Pennsylvania Father, at what age do you think it's appropriate for Catholic parents to let their boys go on dates?   EMAIL: Sebastian from Huntington, New York Do Catholic men tend to have a harder time dating than Catholic women? If so, why?   EMAIL: Juan from New York What is Young Life? Can, or rather, SHOULD a young Catholic man be involved in it? I've investigated what I can but see little information on their site. I only get that it is a non-denominational youth outreach to 'evangelize' based on relationship-building. What do non-denominational outreach groups DO with their 'evangelization'?   EMAIL: Renee from Buffalo, NY I've heard many priests on this show recommend a "classical education," but I have no idea what that is. Does this mean lecture-based classes where reading the textbook is normal? Is it more like a book study? Do they do any modern classical books? Do students still get music, art, and sports? Visit the show page at thestationofthecross.com/askapriest to listen live, check out the weekly lineup, listen to podcasts of past episodes, watch live video, find show resources, sign up for our mailing list of upcoming shows, and submit your question for Father!

  4. 3d ago

    11/16/26 - Fr. Christopher Mahar - Is Artificial Intelligence the Final Result of Adam & Eve's Sin?

    Father Christopher Mahar earned a Bachelor of Science in Philosophy from Providence College in 2000 and subsequently completed his Bachelor's degree in Sacred Theology from the Pontifical Gregorian University in Rome in 2003. He was ordained a deacon in St. Peter’s Basilica in Rome in 2003 and a priest in the Diocese of Providence in 2004. He currently serves as Pastor at St. Augustine Church in Providence, Rhode Island.  In Today's Show: EMAIL: Benson from Covington, Kentucky What do you believe is the hardest of the Ten Commandments for most Catholics to follow and why?   EMAIL: Sam from Cornelius, Oregon I have a friend who refuses to go anywhere without their favorite rosary and will refuse to use any other rosary when offered. They believe this rosary is special because it was the one they were given at their First Communion. My question is: when does devotion turn into superstition? It seems as if they are treating this rosary as a good luck charm.     CALLER: Lugboxer: Olean, NY In Jesus' sermon on the Mount he speaks about our righteousness, and how it relates to our ability to get into Heaven.  He is hoping Fr. Mahar can explain that to him so that it is clearer.   EMAIL: Daniel from Batavia, New York Do Catholics believe that teachings and practices do not have to be explicitly or implicitly taught in Scripture alone?   EMAIL: James from Idaho Could AI be the final result of Adam and Eve's original sin? The ultimate knowledge of all good and evil?   EMAIL: Anonymous from Rochester, NY In your opinion, what is the best way to resolve conflict/hurt feelings in a relationship? How do you do it in a Christ-centered way?   @Felix ​​Regarding Noah’s Ark, Genesis 6:19 says two of every animal were to be gathered, but Genesis 7 says seven of clean animals and two of unclean. Which one is correct?   EMAIL: Robert from Massachusetts Why does it seem so much harder for people to be excommunicated now? Several politicians and celebrities support abortion and sinful lifestyles, yet they are welcomed into the church with open arms and even, on some occasions, are celebrated. Why is this the case?   EMAIL: Anonymous from Henrietta, New York Is it ok for Catholics to watch or participate in combat sports like MMA and UFC?   EMAIL: Anonymous from New Mexico A few months ago, a friend of mine admitted to me that he had become a Freemason. This came as a surprise because he frequently attends Mass and receives the Eucharist. This week, he asked if I would like to join, and offered to put me in touch with someone from the lodge. When I declined and told him that Masonry was against the Catholic Church, he defended his decision, saying that being a Catholic and a Mason was not contradictory. What can I say to him to get him to consider leaving the lodge?   EMAIL: Lucille from Chandler, Arizona Proverbs 23:13 points to how physical punishment is acceptable and even sometimes necessary for children. Why then is light physical punishment frowned upon now?   EMAIL: Chris from Madison, Wisconsin Father, in your opinion, how much free time/relaxation is too much free time? How can we determine if we are succumbing to the sin of sloth or not?   EMAIL: Anonymous from Pittsford, New York Do you have any experience with the Mary Undoer of Knots novena? If so, would you say it's effective to help resolve issues without a clear solution? Is it a sin to lie about St Nick to our kids?   EMAIL: Nancy How do I test and grow in my faith when my life is so easy? As someone who's semi-middle class in the United States, I have no real struggles financially. I feel grateful and guilty at the same time. How do I grow in faith when I have no real struggles?   EMAIL: Giovanni from North Carolina What happened to those who died before Our Lord's sacrifice on the cross? Did their souls go to Hell, Purgatory, or some other place? Also, how did final judgment work without the sacrament of reconciliation?   EMAIL: Kevin from Hialeah, Florida Hypothetically, if the government of a country were to ban Catholicism and the celebration of Mass, what are the faithful of this country to do in this scenario?   Visit the show page at thestationofthecross.com/askapriest to listen live, check out the weekly lineup, listen to podcasts of past episodes, watch live video, find show resources, sign up for our mailing list of upcoming shows, and submit your question for Father!

  5. Nov 11

    11/11/26 - Fr. Elias Mary Mills, F.I. - What Are Some Devotions to Christ's Passion?

    Fr. Elias Mary Mills, F.I., served as Rector of the Shrine Church at the Shrine of Our Lady of Guadalupe in Lacrosse, Wisconsin, from 2016 to 2021. He was ordained in May of 2000. In Today's Show: EMAIL: Anonymous I work in hospice, and as a nurse I know of a facility that does not use IV's or nasogastric tubes (sometimes listed as "artificial nutrition and hydration" in literature).   It is Catholic, and all the patients have terminal cancer. When they get so sick they can't eat/drink, the policy is to simply wait for them to die, other than providing basic care (changing them, oxygen, etc.).   Is this in conformity with Church teaching? And as a nurse, would I be responsible for making the determination of what is right and wrong in these situations, or should I leave if I think this is not good?   EMAIL: Debra from Henderson, Nevada If Purgatory is “necessary” for most Catholics to enter Heaven, then where does this leave the work of our Lord Jesus on the cross? Isn't that where Jesus said, "it is finished"?   EMAIL: Tim from New Jersey I was raised Protestant, but I’ve become very disillusioned with that form of Christianity; it seems disingenuous in its current state.   I’ve felt drawn to Catholicism for over a year at this point, and I’m just not sure where to start. Can I just go to Mass, or do I need to do anything prior? The only thing I know is that I can’t take part in the Eucharist yet.   EMAIL: Anonymous from New Hampshire If we commit a mortal sin, do we automatically lose all the merit and grace we have earned, or is it gradual? Is it all restored by the sacrament of reconciliation?   EMAIL: Gerald from Boston, Massachusetts With many churches being sold and turned into mosques, do you think that Catholicism and Christianity as a whole will have a difficult time surviving if this expansion continues?   Message from Caller: Anonymous from Arizona When someone is enlisting in the military, is it morally permissible for them to take all of the vaccines even though some are derived from aborted fetal cells?   @Felix In Matt 3:25 and Luke 11:17, it says "a house divided cannot stand". Then in Matt 10:34 and Luke 12:51 it says "I come to set man against father and daughter against mother". How do we understand these two differences?   @christopherbrunetti5074 ​​What are some of the devotions to the Passion? Does the Seven Sorrows Rosary of Mary count? Caller: Cynthia from Rochester, NY Is the statement OMG considered blasphemy when it is said in a moment of frustration?   EMAIL: Anonymous What are the requirements for the fast before communion? What specific things break it?   EMAIL: Judy from Illinois If someone says that they find spiritual retreats boring, would that be considered a sin? Would that be considered talking badly of God? Visit the show page at thestationofthecross.com/askapriest to listen live, check out the weekly lineup, listen to podcasts of past episodes, watch live video, find show resources, sign up for our mailing list of upcoming shows, and submit your question for Father!

  6. Nov 11

    11/10/26 - Fr. William Rock, FSSP - How Do We Recognize and Reject the "Mark of the Beast"?

    Fr. William Rock, FSSP, serves as Parochial Vicar at St. Stanislaus Catholic Church in Nashua, New Hampshire. He was ordained in October of 2019 and serves as a regular contributor to the FSSP North America Missive Blog. Fr. Rock is also currently contributing to TAN Books “Year of the Latin Mass.”  Fr. Rock’s video contributions can be found on TAN Books YouTube page. In Today's Show: Message from Caller: Brother Knight Scott In the Book of Revelation it says we are going to have a one world currency and a one world government. How as Catholics do we prepare for this "New World Order" and how do we recognize and reject the Mark of the Beast?   EMAIL: Anonymous (FSSP) I have been feeling like leaving my TLM parish because I don’t connect with the priests and feel unwelcome. I know the pastor at another nearby FSSP parish, whose spiritual style may suit me better, but I worry about causing tension or being told I must stay at my current parish. Any advice would be helpful.   EMAIL: Michael My local priests frequently refuse to answer my questions. Could you give me some advice on how best to approach asking a priest a question in person? Also, why do you think some priests are so unwilling to discuss anything?   EMAIL: Anonymous from Riverside, California If two people with SSA were living together but were not in a sexual relationship and were trying to seek help for their tendencies, would they be able to receive communion?   EMAIL: Justin I'm severely allergic to wheat and cannot receive the Eucharist. I have also been concerned with cross-contamination from the chalice. How would you, as a priest, prefer a parishioner handle that? Do you think it would be appropriate to ask for a separate chalice occasionally during low-attendance Masses?   @Felix ​​While a full-on crusade is off the table, what about self-defense or defense of others? Lots of Christians are being attacked in parts of Africa and other places. Should we let the attacks continue?   @surfdude1217 (TLM) ​​Father, what is your reaction to Cardinal Roche's recent statement that "you shouldn't attend TLM exclusively"?   @CriticalThought369 ​Does reading the bible in the living Tradition of the Church include reading the bible with Patristics? Does it include anything else? What is Tradition exactly, is it patristics, councils, papal acts   Caller: Molly from Ontario, Canada Are unmarried couples allowed to hold hands or hug?   EMAIL: Anonymous from Garland, Texas Can a Catholic be in favor of unrestricted free speech when much of that free speech is used to tear down the Catholic Church and blaspheme?   EMAIL: Maria from New Hampshire Would you be able to explain the Heroic Act of Charity Prayer? As one of the souls you help, I would like to thank you for this program from the bottom of my heart.   Caller: Alexander from Bloomington, Illinois - YouTube His grandmother is in the hospital, probably does not have much time left.  He would like to tell her the meaning of the will of God -in short.  Can Fr give him this meaning?   @LizB-Cath ​​How do I talk to someone who uses AI to restore Catholic art? Is it wrong or not? (uses to revise existing paintings)   @Doug_Remeikis ​​Question for father: Would Father Rock respond to the request of the Pope to remove Cardinal Fernandez because of heresy. Thank you.   @BrianBenson-rc9mu Why are some of the Vatican 2 documents written in a way that makes it seem like they enforce doctrines condemned by the Catholic Church?   EMAIL: Anonymous from Buffalo, NY When you bring a sin or sins to confession but you know out of habit or current circumstance that you will likely not immediately stop committing that sin, however your intentions are to rid these sins from your life, is it a valid confession? Visit the show page at thestationofthecross.com/askapriest to listen live, check out the weekly lineup, listen to podcasts of past episodes, watch live video, find show resources, sign up for our mailing list of upcoming shows, and submit your question for Father!

  7. Nov 6

    11/06/26 - Fr. Paul Born - What Makes Catholicism the True Religion Among So Many Others?

    Fr. Paul Born currently serves as the Parochial Vicar at Mary, Queen of Martyrs Parish in Plymouth, Massachusetts. In Today's Show: EMAIL: Michael from Ontario, Canada What makes Catholicism the true religion among so many others? How can we be sure that God isn’t actually just a "coping mechanism," as various atheist “arguments” suggest?   @TeqTony ​​I would like to know Father Born's opinion on the midterm elections, and what Catholics can do about it moving forward.   Message from Caller: Alex from Illinois - YouTube What is the 3rd secret of Fatima?  (He keeps hearing about it, and knows most of the story of Fatima, but he doesn’t know about the 3rd secret)   EMAIL: Anonymous from Chicago How can we determine in today’s day the difference between someone afflicted by a demon and someone who suffers from mental illness?   Caller: Molly from Ontario - YouTube Her boyfriend was raised Catholic, but was never baptized.  He is leaning towards Orthodoxy.  She is trying to discern the future for them with the difference in beliefs and would like Father's input.   @bdeda5 ​​Dad was actively dying, and the priest came in and anointed him. He was out of it on morphine in 2023. By anointing him, were all his sins forgiven?   EMAIL: David from Lincoln, Nebraska If someone prays for someone else to come back to the Church, can it cause God to allow bad things to happen to them? For example, would God allow someone to reach a new low point in an addiction if it meant that afterwards they would come back to the Faith?     Visit the show page at thestationofthecross.com/askapriest to listen live, check out the weekly lineup, listen to podcasts of past episodes, watch live video, find show resources, sign up for our mailing list of upcoming shows, and submit your question for Father!

4.9
out of 5
76 Ratings

About

"Ask A Priest Live," because Father knows best! We'll bring you a different priest each weekday at 12pm Eastern time, where you'll be able to participate in a live Q&A on the topics that matter! We'll be joined by priests and canons from the Institute of Christ the King Sovereign Priest, the Priestly Fraternity of Saint Peter, the Franciscan Friars of the Immaculate, and even some Diocesan priests that you may know personally! To ask your question, call 1-877-511-5483 or email us at priests@thestationofthecross.com

You Might Also Like