You Had Me At Podcast | The Rom-com Review Podcast

Jessica Sterling and Stuart Traynor
  • 5.0 (27)
  • AFTER SHOWS
  • UPDATED WEEKLY

You Had Me At Podcast, where hosts Jess Sterling and Stuart Traynor dive into a different rom-com from each decade, starting in the 1980s and ending in the 2020s. Across ten episodes, they'll explore how love stories have evolved, from mixtapes and love letters to awkward DMs and dating apps. Watch us on YouTube

  1. 5D AGO

    A Lot Like Love - You Had Me At Podcast

    Join Jess Sterling and Stuart Traynor as they continue Season 1 of You Had Me At Podcast with a dive into the 2005 film, A Lot Like Love. They talk Now That's What I Call Music, Jess' boy crush closet, and the early days of the internet! Chapters: 00:00 Intros 07:55 Movie Recap 09:48 Our Thoughts 50:52 You Had Me At… 01:00:00 The Meet-Cute or Meet-Creep Meter 01:05:55 Best in Show(Mance) Score 01:10:38 Next Week's Rom Com Subscribe to You Had Me At Podcast Follow on all social media @youhadmeatpod Watch the video version on YouTube (@youhadmeatpod) Email us at youhadmeatpod@gmail.com Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands Privacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy

    1h 27m

  2. JAN 30

    Easy A - You Had Me At Podcast

    Join Jess Sterling and Stuart Traynor as they continue Season 1 of You Had Me At Podcast with a dive into the 2010 film, Easy A. They talk pocketfuls of sunshine, Amanda Bynes, and whether or not this movie aged well. Chapters: 00:00 Intros 08:00 Movie Recap 10:00 Our Thoughts 47:20 You Had Me At… 49:25 The Meet-Cute or Meet-Creep Meter 51:30 Best in Show(Mance) Score 1:01:05 Next Week's Rom Com Subscribe to You Had Me At Podcast Follow on all social media @youhadmeatpod Watch the video version on YouTube (@youhadmeatpod) Email us at youhadmeatpod@gmail.com Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands Privacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy

    1h 10m

  3. JAN 16

    The Wrong Paris - You Had Me At Podcast

    Join Jess Sterling and Stuart Traynor as they continue Season 1 of You Had Me At Podcast with a dive into the 2025 film, The Wrong Paris. They talk reality dating shows, what stereotype they'd fall into, and debate whether this movie was actually GOOD. Chapters: 00:00 Intros 04:11 Movie Recap 08:40 Our Thoughts 44:24 You Had Me At… 45:59 The Meet-Cute or Meet-Creep Meter 50:55 Best in Show(Mance) Score 56:00 Next Rom Com Pick Subscribe to You Had Me At Podcast Follow on all social media @youhadmeatpod Watch the video version on YouTube (@youhadmeatpod) Email us at youhadmeatpod@gmail.com Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands Privacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy

    1h 7m

  4. JAN 2

    Merv - You Had Me At Podcast

    Join Jess Sterling and Stuart Traynor as they continue Season 1 of You Had Me At Podcast with a dive into the 2025 film, Merv. They talk bad pet parenting, dinosaur t-shirts, and how truly awful this film is. Chapters: 00:00 Intros 05:50 Movie Recap 10:00 Our Thoughts 41:00 You Had Me At… 43:10 The Meet-Cute or Meet-Creep Meter 48:00 Best in Show(Mance) Score 53:00 Next Week's Rom Com Subscribe to You Had Me At Podcast Follow on all social media @youhadmeatpod Watch the video version on YouTube (@youhadmeatpod) Email us at youhadmeatpod@gmail.com Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands Privacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy

    1h 3m

  5. 12/19/2025

    Bridesmaids - You Had Me At Podcast

    Join Jess Sterling and Stuart Traynor as they continue Season 1 of You Had Me At Podcast with a dive into the 2011 film, Bridesmaids. They talk frenemies, the best pizza toppings, and whether or not a cop can have no red flags. Chapters: 00:00 Intros 02:32 Movie Recap 04:42 Our Thoughts 53:40 You Had Me At… 56:30 The Meet-Cute or Meet-Creep Meter 01:02:27 Best in Show(Mance) Score 01:09:42 Next Week's Rom Com Subscribe to You Had Me At Podcast Follow on all social media @youhadmeatpod Watch the video version on YouTube (@youhadmeatpod) Email us at youhadmeatpod@gmail.com Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands Privacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy

    1h 20m

  6. 12/05/2025

    The Holiday - You Had Me At Podcast

    Join Jess Sterling and Stuart Traynor as they continue Season 1 of You Had Me At Podcast with a dive into the 2006 film, The Holiday. They discuss whether they'd rather vacation in a cozy London cottage or a fancy LA mansion, debate what could have been trimmed in this lengthy movie, and obviously do some HORRENDOUS impressions. Chapters: 00:00 Intros 2:55 Movie Recap 05:20 Our Thoughts 52:36 You Had Me At… 59:40 The Meet-Cute or Meet-Creep Meter 01:04:15 Best in Show(Mance) Score 01:07:00 Next Week's Rom Com Subscribe to You Had Me At Podcast Follow on all social media @youhadmeatpod Watch the video version on YouTube (@youhadmeatpod) Email us at youhadmeatpod@gmail.com Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands Privacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy

    1h 18m

  7. 11/21/2025

    10 Things I Hate About You - You Had Me At Podcast

    Join Jess Sterling and Stuart Traynor as they continue Season 1 of You Had Me At Podcast with a dive into the 1999 film, 10 Things I Hate About You. They discuss Heath Ledger's irresistible smirk, whether or not Kat's poem is good, and the impact the paintball scene had on teen Jess. They can't help but quote the film incessantly as they rank the soulmate status of the couploes, rate their overall enjoyment, and talk through the incredible soundtrack. Chapters: 00:00 Intros 07:41 Movie Recap 09:49 Our Thoughts 54:50 You Had Me At… 58:13 The Meet-Cute or Meet-Creep Meter 1:02:13 Best in Show(Mance) Score 1:07:00 Next Week's Rom Com Subscribe to You Had Me At Podcast Follow on all social media @youhadmeatpod Watch the video version on YouTube (@youhadmeatpod) Email us at youhadmeatpod@gmail.com Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands Privacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy

    1h 19m

  8. 11/07/2025

    Say Anything - You Had Me At Podcast

    Join Jess Sterling and Stuart Traynor as they kick off Season 1 of You Had Me At Podcast with a dive into the 1989 classic Say Anything. They revisit Lloyd Dobler’s graduation limbo, Diane Court’s overwhelming expectations, and the now-infamous boombox moment. They talk parental interference, learning to drive stick, uncomfortable breakup etiquette, and whether “Are you here because you need someone or because you need me?” actually lands or just leaves a bad taste. They also discuss Cameron Crowe’s directorial debut, the real-life history between Ione Skye and John Cusack, and how this movie has shaped grand gesture romance for decades. Finally, they rate the meet-cute, decide where this couple sits on the soulmate scale, and score the film in Best in Show(mance). Chapters: 00:00 Intros 03:06 Movie Recap 05:09 Our Thoughts 45:05 You Had Me At… The Meet-Cute or Meet-Creep Meter 52:45 Best in Show(Mance) Score 59:22 Feedback 01:03:20 Next Week's Rom Com Subscribe to You Had Me At Podcast Follow on all social media @youhadmeatpod Watch the video version on YouTube (@youhadmeatpod) Email us at youhadmeatpod@gmail.com Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands Privacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy

    1h 7m
See All (97)

Trailer

5
out of 5
27 Ratings

About

You Had Me At Podcast, where hosts Jess Sterling and Stuart Traynor dive into a different rom-com from each decade, starting in the 1980s and ending in the 2020s. Across ten episodes, they'll explore how love stories have evolved, from mixtapes and love letters to awkward DMs and dating apps. Watch us on YouTube

Information

You Might Also Like