Empty Nesters and True Crime

Susan Haley, Nancy Maier
  • 5.0 (6)
  • TRUE CRIME
  • UPDATED WEEKLY

Welcome to Empty Nesters True Crime podcast, where we explore chilling mysteries and dark secrets. With their nests now empty, Susan and Nancy have more time to uncover the truth and venture into the unknown. Let's step into the shadows together.

  1. 12/06/2024 · BONUS

    Breaking: Susan Smith's Parole Case Draws Backlash—Justice at Risk?

    Join Susan and Nancy as they dive into the latest updates on the controversial Susan Smith parole hearing. In this episode, they discuss the shocking details of Smith's original case, the emotional toll on the families involved, and the public outrage over the possibility of her release. With strong opinions and thought-provoking insights, Susan and Nancy break down the legal implications, explore the societal response, and question whether justice can ever truly be served in such a case. Key Topics Covered: A recap of Susan Smith’s heinous crime and its impact. Updates on the parole process and where the case stands now. Public and legal reactions to the possibility of her release. Moral and ethical questions surrounding parole for infamous offenders. Tune in for a passionate and no-holds-barred conversation about justice, accountability, and the limits of redemption.

    16 min
  2. Secrets in Room 406

    11/24/2024

    Secrets in Room 406

    Christy Bautista, a 31-year-old woman, was tragically killed in Washington, D.C., in March 2023. She was staying at the Ivy City Hotel when she was stabbed multiple times. The suspect arrested and charged in her murder is 43-year-old Darrell D. Rushton from Maryland. Rushton reportedly entered Bautista's hotel room shortly after she checked in. Witnesses heard sounds of distress coming from the room, and police were called. When officers arrived, they found Bautista with fatal injuries and arrested Rushton at the scene. Investigations indicated that the attack was both brutal and unprovoked. The motive remains unclear, but Rushton had a criminal history, raising questions about why he targeted Bautista. Her case has drawn attention to the safety of travelers and the tragic consequences of random acts of violence.

    58 min
  3. Unveiling Lost Identities: The Story of Bobby Whitt and Myoung Hwa Cho

    11/17/2024

    Unveiling Lost Identities: The Story of Bobby Whitt and Myoung Hwa Cho

    This episode unravels the chilling mystery of Robert "Bobby" Adam Whitt and Myoung Hwa Cho, a mother and son whose identities remained unknown for over two decades. Bobby, dubbed "The Boy Under the Billboard," and Myoung, a Jane Doe found along a roadside, were both victims of a brutal series of events in 1998. Through the tireless efforts of investigators and advancements in forensic genealogy, their names—and their tragic fates—were uncovered in 2019. We delve into the heartbreaking details of their lives, the deception that kept their murders hidden, and the journey that led to justice. This is a story of loss, resilience, and the power of never giving up on the forgotten. References https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Murders_of_Bobby_Whitt_and_Myoung_Hwa_Cho https://abc11.com/cold-case-orange-county-robert-adam-whitt-bobby/5853339/ https://abc11.com/cold-case-orange-county-robert-adam-whitt-bobby/5121007/ https://www.wral.com/story/father-charged-in-death-of-boy-whose-remains-were-found-under-mebane-billboard-in-1998/18383618/ https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/cold-case-solved-the-boy-under-the-billboard/id1485570562?i=1000668024875 https://finishedpages.com/the-mystery-of-the-boy-under-the-billboard/

    41 min
  4. A Friend's Betrayal: Justice for Shanquella Robinson

    11/03/2024

    A Friend's Betrayal: Justice for Shanquella Robinson

    On this week’s episode of Empty Nesters and True Crime, Susan brings the shocking story of Shanquella Robinson's tragic and mysterious death to Nancy. Shanquella, a young entrepreneur from North Carolina, traveled to Mexico with friends but never returned home. What initially seemed like an accident took a darker turn with the emergence of chilling video evidence and conflicting stories from her travel companions. Join Susan and Nancy as they explore the timeline, discuss the investigation's twists and turns, and seek answers to questions that remain unsolved. Tune in for a heartbreaking tale of betrayal, injustice, and a family’s fight for the truth. Wikipedia contributors. "Killing of Shanquella Robinson." Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia. Accessed [date]. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Killing_of_Shanquella_Robinson Wikipedia contributors. "Resort town." Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia. Accessed [date]. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Resort_town Wikipedia contributors. "Cabo San Lucas." Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia. Accessed [date]. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cabo_San_Lucas

    56 min
  5. When a Swipe Turns Deadly: Ashley Pegram’s Last Date

    10/13/2024

    When a Swipe Turns Deadly: Ashley Pegram’s Last Date

    Nancy recounts the chilling tale of Ashley Pegram to Susan, warning her about the hidden dangers of online dating. Ashley, an ambitious young woman, met an intriguing man on a dating site, charmed by his wit and perfect profile. However, her quest for love took a sinister turn when the relationship quickly escalated into manipulation, deceit, and eventually led to her tragic murder. The story leaves Susan uneasy, forcing her to reconsider her own online connections and reflect on the risks behind the curated personas people display online. Nancy’s retelling is not just a cautionary tale—it’s a grim reminder that not everything online is as it seems.

    38 min
  6. A Prescription for Evil: Uncovering Dr. Fata's Horrific Fraud

    09/29/2024

    A Prescription for Evil: Uncovering Dr. Fata's Horrific Fraud

    This week on Empty Nesters & True Crime, Susan and Nancy dive into the horrifying case of Dr. Farid Fata, a once-respected oncologist who preyed on his patients in the most unimaginable way. Behind the mask of a trusted doctor, Fata was responsible for misdiagnosing countless patients, subjecting them to unnecessary treatments, and inflicting needless pain—all for personal gain. Join Susan and Nancy as they unravel the details of Fata’s shocking crimes, exploring the impact on his victims and how justice was ultimately served. Paired with the sinister Evil Doctor cocktail, this episode is both chilling and eye-opening. WXYZ Detroit. "Convicted Oakland County Cancer Doctor Farid Fata Files for Compassionate Release." WXYZ.com, March 10, 2022. https://www.wxyz.com/news/convicted-oakland-county-cancer-doctor-farid-fata-files-for-compassionate-release. Wikipedia contributors. "Farid Fata." Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, August 25, 2023. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Farid_Fata. NBC News. "Full Episode: Do No Harm." Dateline, October 2, 2016. https://www.nbcnews.com/dateline/video/full-episode-do-no-harm-605292611904. Baldas, Tresa. "Cancer Doc Farid Fata's Conviction Upheld." The Detroit News, February 7, 2020. https://www.detroitnews.com/story/news/local/oakland-county/2020/02/07/cancer-doc-farid-fata-conviction-upheld/4692724002/.

    34 min
  7. Pamela Hoy - A Shattered Life

    09/22/2024

    Pamela Hoy - A Shattered Life

    In this episode, Susan and Nancy delve into the life and mysterious death of Pamela Mitchell Hoy. Born in 1948, Pam was the beloved eldest of six siblings, a talented athlete, and a passionate dog handler. After marrying Fred Hoy, the couple seemed to have it all, but their story took a tragic turn. In July 1990, after separating from her husband, Pam went missing. Weeks later, her body was found wrapped in a quilt, sparking an investigation that remains unsolved to this day. Was it a case of domestic violence gone too far, or did someone else play a sinister role? Susan and Nancy unravel the timeline, explore the suspects, and discuss the controversial evidence surrounding Pam’s case—including the unsettling circumstances that point fingers at Fred. With no physical evidence and the clock ticking, this is a story of love, betrayal, and a relentless search for justice. Tune in as we explore the heartbreaking case of Pamela Mitchell Hoy and the unanswered question: Who killed Pam? 🎙️ Listen now to Empty Nesters and True Crime! #TrueCrime #PamelaMitchellHoy #UnsolvedMystery sources North Carolina State Bureau of Investigation - Unsolved Homicides: Pamela Mitchell HoyNCSBI - Unsolved Homicides WFMY News 2 - Search Warrant Turns Up Possible Evidence in Hoy CaseWFMY News 2 Cold Brew Crime Podcast - Episode 5: The Murder of Pamela HoyCold Brew Crime on Spotify YouTube - The Unsolved Murder of Pam HoyThe Unsolved Murder of Pam Hoy on YouTube Greensboro News & Record - Scientific Advances May Help Find KillerGreensboro News & Record True Crime All the Time Unsolved Podcast - Episode 102: Pamela Hoy, Jennifer Patterson, Cecil Chacon Jr.True Crime All the Time Unsolved on Apple Podcasts Cold Brew Crime Podcast - Episode 5: The Murder of Pamela Hoy (Duplicate)Cold Brew Crime on Spotify

    32 min
  8. Uncle John's Secret: The Heather Robinson Story

    09/15/2024

    Uncle John's Secret: The Heather Robinson Story

    On this week's episode of Empty Nesters and True Crime, Nancy shares a gripping and heart-wrenching tale with Susan—the story of Heather Robinson and her Uncle John, a man who hid dark secrets beneath the surface of a seemingly normal family life. As Nancy dives into the details, Susan listens intently, knowing the importance of giving a voice to victims whose stories often go untold. Heather Robinson grew up believing her life was as ordinary as any other. Her Uncle John was a constant figure in her childhood, a trusted family member who seemed to always be around, lending a helping hand. But behind his friendly demeanor was a sinister truth. Heather had no idea the man she called Uncle John would later become a central figure in a shocking crime that shattered her world. Nancy takes listeners on a journey through the layers of deception, manipulation, and ultimate betrayal. Uncle John, a man trusted by everyone around him, had a dark past that was carefully hidden for years. When the truth finally came to light, the revelations were almost too horrifying to comprehend. Not only was Heather's life irreparably changed, but the entire community was left in disbelief as the story of her uncle's crimes unfolded. The episode explores how deeply betrayal from within a family can cut, especially when the perpetrator is someone who is supposed to protect, not harm. Nancy passionately narrates the emotional toll Heather’s story took on her, highlighting the resilience of survivors like Heather who, even after such trauma, find the strength to rebuild their lives. Susan, as always, offers insightful commentary on the case, pointing out how crimes like these often leave lasting scars on the survivors and those around them. The two hosts discuss the failings of the systems that should have caught Uncle John's behavior sooner and how easily abusers can hide in plain sight. This episode of Empty Nesters and True Crime serves as both a cautionary tale and a testament to the strength of the human spirit, shedding light on the darkness that can sometimes lurk within the most trusted relationships. Don't miss this intense and emotional story of Heather Robinson and Uncle John, available now on all major podcast platforms. Heavy.com: This article covers the twisted details of Heather Robinson's adoption and John Edward Robinson's crimes. It offers key facts and insights about the case and its lasting impact. Heavy.com Article on Donald Robinson & John Edward Robinson​(Heavy.com) Tales from the Underworld: This article titled Digital Demon: The Story of John Edward Robinson covers John Edward Robinson's gruesome crimes, including his manipulation of the internet to lure victims. It also discusses the dark underpinnings of his relationships, including the adoption of Heather Robinson. Digital Demon: The Story of John Edward Robinson Wikipedia: Wikipedia provides a comprehensive overview of John Edward Robinson’s crimes, including his manipulation of the adoption of Heather Robinson. Wikipedia Article on John Edward Robinson True Crime Stories: I wasn’t able to retrieve a dedicated article from True Crime Stories related to this case. True crime platforms often have similar narratives, but it might be necessary to check their website for a more detailed account. ABC News: ABC News conducted an exclusive interview with Heather Robinson as she learned more about her biological mother and John Robinson's deceit. ABC News Interview with Heather Robinson​(Heavy.com)

    32 min
See All (28)

Ratings & Reviews

5
out of 5
6 Ratings

About

Welcome to Empty Nesters True Crime podcast, where we explore chilling mysteries and dark secrets. With their nests now empty, Susan and Nancy have more time to uncover the truth and venture into the unknown. Let's step into the shadows together.

Information

  • Creator
    Susan Haley, Nancy Maier
  • Years Active
    2K
  • Episodes
    28
  • Rating
    Explicit
  • Copyright
    © Susan Haley, Nancy Maier
  • Show Website
    Empty Nesters and True Crime