Szego Unplugged Podcast

Julie Szego

My eclectic obsessions and musings. Gender identity, identity politics, politics, public education, class, old-school feminism. szegounplugged.substack.com

  1. 22h ago

    Man On a Mission

    On the eve of Remembrance Day — latterly an occasion for vandalising monuments with anti-Israel graffiti — I’m publishing this podcast interview with retired Australian Army Colonel, Michael Scott. Michael’s 32-year military career included deployments to East Timor, Bougainville, Iraq and Afghanistan. From 2019 to 2021 he had a secondment to the United Nations in Jerusalem. In 2023 he was awarded the Conspicuous Service Cross for his outstanding devotion to duty. Most conspicuously from my point of view, since October 7 he’s stepped up like few others have to defend the state of Israel, the Jewish people and democratic values. He’s the author of several books on the subject: the next one, When the Light Must Be Held: Standing Sentinel Against the Gathering Storm, will be released later this year. Michael describes our present moment as an interbellum, an interval before the next war: so there’s nothing hedging or ponderous about this conversation! We discuss the reasons for his grim diagnosis, what Remembrance Day means for him, his assessment of the Australian Defence Force, his experience in the military — including his stint working with the UN in the Middle East — his take on the combustible subject of Ben Roberts-Smith, the decorated war hero accused of war crimes. I vent my frustration about Penny Wong’s response to the Israeli military’s finding that the tragic strike on the World Central Kitchen convoy not be referred to criminal investigators. We talk about the rise of anti-Jewish intimidation, such as the shocking case of the horseback Israel-hater at Bondi. I vent my frustration about the Jewish community’s failure to confront the fascists and Islamists who take to the streets on October 7 to claim it for themselves. And we talk about the 2023 Foundation, the Australian non-profit organisation that Michael established to combat antisemitism by facilitating experiences in Israel. (It’s astonishing the extent to which visiting Israel transforms perspectives on the conflict— hence the strenuous efforts of Israel-haters to cast such tours as sinister). But he offers a note of caution: don’t waste your time trying to reason with the “lemon face” crowd. Cryptic? All is revealed herein. Agree with him or not, Michael is a rare figure of conviction and honour. To buy Michael’s books, visit his website: https://michaelscottcsc.com Michael on LinkedIn – www.linkedin.com/in/mscott-csc For information on his Foundation, visit www.2023foundation.org.au Szego Unplugged is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber. This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit szegounplugged.substack.com/subscribe

  2. Sep 23

    Inside Israel’s protest camp

    Welcome to my first video post. It’s non-stop innovation here at Szego Unplugged: no boo boo this time! Esther Takac is a Melbourne-based filmmaker, author and psychologist, who I first met eons ago when she responded to a column I wrote about the challenges of reading the Book of Genesis to my kids by sending me her beautiful, award-winning book, Genesis: The Book With 70 Pages, a “how-to” manual for introducing the young to the foundational text of our civilisation. No-one could accuse Esther of flinching from weighty and confronting subjects. As a psychologist, she deals with trauma and children across the world, including as a consultant to the Paediatric Department at Hadassah Medical Center in Jerusalem. Trauma, and its transcendence, informs her filmmaking too. First in The Narrow Bridge, a much-lauded documentary, which explores the emerging relationships between Israelis and Palestinians bereaved after losing loved ones to the conflict. (The documentary, widely screened and broadcast internationally will feature at the United Nations film festival next month.) Her latest film, Rising: Voices of Protest and Hope, tracks central figures in Israel’s street protests against the Netanyahu government, the most far-right in the nation’s history. From the mass opposition to the government’s flagged judicial overhaul, to the horrific shock of October 7, to the weekly rallies for the release of hostages in Gaza — the people Esther profiles could write the book on resilience and faith. The film is timely as Israelis go to the polls next month in what’s routinely described as one of the most consequential elections since the establishment of the state. Esther and her subjects believe democracy itself is on the ballot — and I don’t disagree. That said, Esther and I sometimes disagree on matters Israel, which is why I enjoy talking to her so much; she argues non-judgmentally and with an open-mind. Today we discuss trauma and grief, how she navigated an Israel bleeding after October 7, her response to the eruption of Jew-hatred in Australia and her fears and hopes for Israel’s future. And yes, at times we disagree. Rising screens at Classic Cinemas in Elsternwick, Melbourne, on Sunday 27 September at 7.30pm: a panel discussion on Israel’s future will be held afterwards. Tickets and more information:https://events.humanitix.com/rising-special-melbourne-screeningRising Facebook:https://www.facebook.com/RisingDocFilm Click here to watch a trailer. Szego Unplugged is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber. This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit szegounplugged.substack.com/subscribe

  3. Sep 3

    Jason Arday et al

    This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit szegounplugged.substack.com By popular demand, theologian, author and fellow Stacker Paul Tyson returns to this podcast! We chat about the Jason Arday controversy, a defining, and tragic, episode of the DEI era. Since we recorded this conversation the fallout from the scandal continues with Simon & Schuster releasing the former Cambridge professor’s memoir, Great and Unfortunate Things, and an inquest opened into his death. Meanwhile, Nathan Cofnas, the philosopher who first raised allegations of plagiarism against Arday, was suspended by his employer, Ghent University in Belgium, on allegations of “discriminatory conduct”, and UK Green Party leader, Zack Polanski, is calling for curbs on press reporting. Wokeism, alas, is far from dead. If you’re not across this tumultuous story, not to worry: I give a 10 minute-long primer. If you are across it, maybe you want to press the forward button. Paul and I also touch on the sexual orientation and religion questions in the Australian census. And we discuss his new book with the subtle title, Gender Theory is Wrong — endorsed by several rock-star gender-critical philosophers — in which he argues trans ideology is a product of the Enlightenment gone wrong. You can buy Paul’s book from the publisher here. And on Amazon here. Subscribe to his Substack, Gender Critical Philosophical Theology, here. Links relevant to this episode: Tyler Austin Harper’s Why I Quit The Tenure Track: https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/2026/09/elite-academia-leadership-hypocrisy/687969/ Musa al-Gharbi on the Jason Arday scandal: Only part of this podcast is accessible to regular subscribers. The full episode is just for paid subscribers. To become one of them, click below. Szego Unplugged is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.

  4. Jul 29

    The Palestinian Maverick

    For some time now I’ve been keen to speak with Ahmed Fouad Alkhatib, an anti-Hamas Palestinian nationalist and peace advocate who has a scorching critique of the so-called pro-Palestinian movement in the West. This week I finally got my wish; here, Ahmed talks to me at length about his essay Hamas and Its Two Million Hostages, published this week in The Jewish Quarterly. Ahmed’s piece interrogates how the Islamist terror group took root in Gaza, seized power and stayed in power long enough to execute the October 7 invasion of southern Israel. He dissects Hamas’s strategy of brutalising and indoctrinating ordinary Gazans into the cult of martyrdom so that the jihadists could weaponise civilian deaths to inflame world opinion against Israel. To understate matters, the strategy proved spectacularly successful. In the Gaza war, Ahmed himself lost 34 members of his extended family to Israeli airstrikes. His essay is in part memoir — revisiting his childhood in Gaza and the all-too-brief moment of optimism and euphoria in the wake of the 1993 Oslo Peace Accords. We talk about the real Gaza as opposed to the symbolic Gaza that animates what Ahmed calls the “pro-Palestine industrial complex”: about the toxic impact of foreign aid on the strip and about the Al Jazeera’ing (who says it’s not a word!) of media discourse on Israel-Gaza. About why the Western liberal-progressive media finds his an inconvenient voice, and how his views on Jews, Israel and Zionism evolved over the years. His words ought to carry weight here in Australia, given that the Labor Party dumped references to Hamas needing to disarm and play no governing role from its resolution at the weekend's national conference, even though these elements are official Labor government policy. A few clarifications. At one point I ask Ahmed about the Israeli writer Einat Wilf’s claim that she’s only aware of three Palestinians who are prepared to affirm the legitimacy of a sovereign Jewish state between the river and the sea. Actually, she said four people rather than three; and obviously she’s referring to people prepared to publicly accept the legitimacy of Israel — I should have made that clear. For Ahmed’s response, have a listen! At another point I refer to Hasbara: I should have explained that that’s a Hebrew word for Israel’s public diplomacy — and like all things related to Israel it’s assumed a sinister meaning for the political left. Ahmed is a senior fellow at the Atlantic Council, a US foreign policy think-tank based in Washington, DC., where he leads the project Realign for Palestine. To buy a copy of Ahmed’s essay, Hamas and Its Two Million Hostages, follow this link: https://jewishquarterly.com Szego Unplugged is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber. This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit szegounplugged.substack.com/subscribe

  5. Jul 2

    Multicultural Troubles

    Chetna Mahadik is general manager at the Robert Menzies Institute in Melbourne, a fellow stacker and the editor of, and contributor to, a recently published book of essays, Immigration & Multiculturalism: The Past, The Present and The Future. Chetna’s essay, Racism in Australia: Narrative and Reality, tracks her encounters with the country’s sometimes mystifying debates about its national character. As she explains in the piece, Chetna migrated to Australia from India in 2011 with a master’s degree in globalization and media. At the time Melbourne was experiencing a spate of attacks against Indian international students, with student leaders alleging the violence was part of a broader pattern of anti-Indian racism. Chetna decided she’d write about the controversy — but what she found surprised her. We talk about her essay and what she learned about “anti-racism” discourse. We talk about the insights she gained from editing the politically-heterodox essay collection, which explores the evolution of Australian immigration policy from the postwar ethos of “populate or perish” through to the dismantling of the White Australia Policy and the adoption of multiculturalism. We talk about the fraught debate around Muslim immigration to the West, and to Australia after the Bondi Beach massacre, the rise of the populist right and Pauline Hanson’s promotion of “monoculturalism.” A few things of note: On 21 July the Robert Menzies Institute is holding a public conversation on “Conditions for a Successful Immigration Policy” with Coalition Senator Jonno Duniam. You can book tickets here: https://www.robertmenziesinstitute.org.au/event/jonno-duniam-policy-dialogue/ The essay collection, Immigration & Multiculturalism: The Past, The Present and The Future, is available from the publisher here: https://www.connorcourtpublishing.com.au/Immigration-Multiculturalism-The-Past-the-Present-and-the-Future-edited-by-Chetna-Mahadik_p_681.html Or on Amazon: https://www.amazon.com.au/Immigration-Multiculturalism-Past-Present-Future/dp/1923568760 Or on Booktopia. And Chetna’s newsletter, which includes columns first published in the AFR, is here: Szego Unplugged is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber. This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit szegounplugged.substack.com/subscribe

  6. 06/05/2025

    The real John Anderson

    I’ll explain the “accidental” gag soon — first, the important stuff. In this episode I pick the formidable brain of John Anderson, second-in-charge of Oz from 1999 to 2005 and these days a serious player in the world of long-form podcasting. He was an early adopter of the web-based interview, launching his “Conversations” series in 2017 to tackle the big geopolitical and philosophical questions with public intellectuals. As he tells me, he needed some convincing years ago to interview a psychologist he’d never heard of called Jordan Peterson. The rest is history. Anderson’s thirst for answers on how we should live led him to help found the Alliance for Responsible Citizenship, a global organisation that aims to reaffirm Western values. The Alliance staged its inaugural conference in London in October 2023 with a rock star line-up. Back then, with many of us reeling from the outbreak of pro-Hamas sentiment on our streets and university campuses, the centre-right seemed to have the wind at its back. But things have since soured for the political right in parts of Europe, Canada and Australia: I ask Anderson what went wrong. Is it all Donald Trump’s fault? Before he became a heterodox media star, Anderson, a sixth-generation farmer, held several ministries in the Howard Government and was former leader of the National Party — to overseas readers, that’s a rural-based party that together with the Liberal Party comprises Australia’s conservative Coalition. The Coalition marriage broke down momentarily in the aftermath of the Liberals’ historic drubbing in May’s federal election; Anderson was one of several former leaders enlisted as marriage counsellor. Something obviously worked: the parties stitched things up, for how long only time will tell. Anderson airs his frustration with Labor’s election tactics and with what he (rightly) diagnoses as both parties’ desultory policy prescriptions. He also airs concerns about energy, Australia’s vulnerability in global supply chains, mounting government debt, a more aggressive China and the deteriorating mental health of young people in the digital age. And we moan about Donald Trump, a subject I pursued excessively, I reckon. There are many more conversations I’d like to have with Anderson on topics remote from the daily headlines. And now to my blonde moment, which I’ve left uncut in the interests of transparency, and also because it’s sort of funny. Later in our talk I say that before he entered politics Anderson had a brief stint as a reporter on a rural newspaper. I had written this down in my notes and raised it here, proud I’d done my homework. Turns out I was wrong. Anderson never worked as a rural reporter. He thinks I may have been reading about a different John Anderson, a person who, by coincidence, also moved among the Nationals in Canberra. I reckon Anderson would have been a fantastic rural reporter had he ever tried his hand at it, which, of course, he hadn’t. He’s also gracious when others embarrass themselves. I’d intended to read Anderson’s authorised biography before our conversation but an unexpected study trip to Israel (more on that another time) got in the way. The biography, Faith & Duty: The John Anderson Story by Paul Gallagher, charts a life marked by profound tragedy (I won’t go into details here) and extraordinary resilience. Anderson arrives at his Christian faith, and so much else, with great substance. We need more like him. Szego Unplugged is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber. This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit szegounplugged.substack.com/subscribe

About

My eclectic obsessions and musings. Gender identity, identity politics, politics, public education, class, old-school feminism. szegounplugged.substack.com