Crimenelia Street

Sam & Tori
  • 5.0 (1)
  • TRUE CRIME
  • UPDATED BIWEEKLY

Sam and Tori tell the stories of different true crime and paranormal occurrences with a Swiftie-related palette cleanser at the end.

  1. DEC 7

    Ep. 28: Vigilante Shit - Faye Yager and The Children of the Underground

    Send us a text This week we’re getting into some vigilante shit. Faye Yager didn’t trust the courts to protect children—so she built her own underground. Children of the Underground became a secret network for parents fleeing alleged abuse, moving families across state lines and out of sight. Was Yager a hero filling in the gaps of a broken system, or a self-appointed savior who caused more harm than help? We dig into the cases, the fallout, and the legacy of one woman who decided the rules didn’t apply to her. Children of the Underground Docuseries Atlanta Magazine Article on Trials of Faye Yager A&E Article on How Faye Yager Operated Her Network Time Magazine Article - He Found His Girls Main Line Custody Battle Has Day in Court Follow us on Instagram @crimeneliastreet Follow us on TikTok @crimeneliastpodcast Send us an email at crimeneliast@gmail.com Subscribe and Like on YouTube @CrimeneliaStreetPodcast

    54 min

  2. NOV 23

    Ep. 27: You Belong With Me...Or Else. The Story of Jenelle Potter

    Send us a text In a small Tennessee town, one woman’s online life starts to blur with reality — and the results are anything but picture-perfect. Join Crimenelia Street as we scroll through a story of obsession, identity, and the dangerous side of wanting to belong. Because sometimes, even in the quietest towns, not everyone is who they seem.  Sources:  https://law.justia.com/cases/tennessee/court-of-criminal-appeals/2019/e2015-02261-cca-r3-cd.html https://www.the-sun.com/news/11010867/where-marvin-jenelle-barbara-potter-now/ https://www.wate.com/news/mother-daughter-serve-2-life-sentences-in-tenn-facebook-murders/ https://www.spokesman.com/stories/2012/feb/10/facebook-unfriending-leads-murders/ https://lawandcrime.com/crime/matriarch-of-tennessee-family-convicted-of-infamous-facebook-murders-pleads-guilty-after-being-granted-new-trial/ Follow us on Instagram @crimeneliastreet Follow us on TikTok @crimeneliastpodcast Send us an email at crimeneliast@gmail.com Subscribe and Like on YouTube @CrimeneliaStreetPodcast

    51 min

  3. NOV 9

    Ep. 26 PART TWO: I Bet You Think About Me - The Unanswered Case of Robert Wone

    Send us a text In part two of our deep dive into the mysterious murder of Robert Wone, we unpack the details that continue to baffle investigators and true crime followers nearly two decades later. We walk through the autopsy findings, key pieces of the investigation, and both criminal and civil trials that followed. Finally, we explore the many theories about what may have happened inside that Dupont Circle townhouse on the night Robert was killed — and why answers remain just out of reach.  As a palate cleanser we talk about some good the Swiftie community did recently, and some of the things we're looking forward to. Sources - This episode description contains Amazon affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases. Who Kill Robert Wone - Peacock Docuseries Crime Junkie - Murdered: Robert Wone Autopsy Report Interview Footage The Murder of Robert Wone Podcast Follow us on Instagram @crimeneliastreet Follow us on TikTok @crimeneliastpodcast Send us an email at crimeneliast@gmail.com Subscribe and Like on YouTube @CrimeneliaStreetPodcast

    1h 18m

  4. OCT 26

    Ep. 26 PART ONE: I Bet You Think About Me - The Unanswered Case of Robert Wone

    Send us a text On August 2, 2006, attorney Robert Wone arrived at a friend’s townhouse in Washington, D.C. for what should have been an ordinary overnight stay. Instead, it became the last night of his life. In Part One of our coverage, we break down the timeline of Robert’s final hours, the 911 call, and the chilling discovery inside the guest room. With no signs of forced entry, and a strangely pristine crime scene investigators knew almost immediately that something was off. We walk through the interrogation room drama, the shifting statements, and some of the early investigative missteps that left this case with more unanswered questions than answers. Was there truly an intruder—or was the truth hiding in plain sight? Join us as we unpack the night of the murder, the roommates' interviews, and the start of one of D.C.’s most haunting unsolved mysteries. Sources -  Some of the links below may earn us a commission. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you. Who Killed Robert Wone - Peacock Docuseries Autopsy Report Interview Footage Here's How you Scale an 'Impossible' Fence by Juliana Brint The Murder of Robert Wone Podcast Crimejunkie Podcast Episode on Robert Wone Who Murdered Robert Wone Blog Follow us on Instagram @crimeneliastreet Follow us on TikTok @crimeneliastpodcast Send us an email at crimeneliast@gmail.com Subscribe and Like on YouTube @CrimeneliaStreetPodcast

    1h 6m

  5. OCT 12

    Ep. 25: Shadows In My Room-The story of Daniel LaPlante

    Send us a text Daniel LaPlante’s crimes were the ultimate nightmare fuel—stalking, hostage situations, and a violent spree that still haunts Massachusetts. On Crimenelia Street, we unravel how obsession and terror led to one of the most chilling cases in true crime.  Sources: https://www.celticssentinel.com/2021/07/the-elm-street-nightmare.html https://www.newspapers.com/article/the-boston-globe-gustafson-murders/34908982/ https://www.lowellsun.com/2017/03/22/convicted-triple-murderer-daniel-laplante-apologizes-in-bid-for-reduced-sentence/ Picture credits: Hiding Spot diagrams-Steve Bezanson, Tom Lane Follow us on Instagram @crimeneliastreet Follow us on TikTok @crimeneliastpodcast Send us an email at crimeneliast@gmail.com Subscribe and Like on YouTube @CrimeneliaStreetPodcast

    48 min

  6. OCT 7 · BONUS

    BONUS EPISODE: And Baby, That's Show Business For You-Bonus Episode!

    Send us a text Oh hey, hi! Welcome to a bonus episode of Crimenelia Street where Tori and Sam rank the tracks on the album that all the cool kids are listening to, The Life of a Showgirl by Taylor Swift! From the glittering highs of fame to the shadows behind the curtain, we unpack lyrical Easter eggs, sonic throwbacks, and emotional callbacks to every version of Taylor we’ve known before. We hope you like it! Follow us on Instagram @crimeneliastreet Follow us on TikTok @crimeneliastpodcast Send us an email at crimeneliast@gmail.com Subscribe and Like on YouTube @CrimeneliaStreetPodcast

    52 min

  7. SEP 28

    Ep. 24: The Bus Ride from Hell - The Chowchilla Kidnapping

    Send us a text In July 1976, a quiet California town was rocked when a school bus carrying 26 children and their driver vanished. What started as an ordinary summer day spiraled into one of the most brazen and bizarre kidnappings in U.S. history —complete with a buried moving van, ransom demands, and a daring escape that still defies belief. This kidnapping remains the largest mass kidnapping in U.S. history. In this episode, we dig into the meticulous planning, the shocking suspects, and the courage it took for a group of kids to outwit their captors. And because we can’t stay underground forever, we cleanse the palate with some hype over The Life of a Showgirl. Some of the links below are affiliate links, which means we may earn a small commission if you purchase through them at no additional cost to you.  The Chowchilla Kidnapping: Why Me? by Larry Park Chowchilla - 2023 Documentary Follow us on Instagram @crimeneliastreet Follow us on TikTok @crimeneliastpodcast Send us an email at crimeneliast@gmail.com Subscribe and Like on YouTube @CrimeneliaStreetPodcast

    1h 3m

  8. SEP 10

    Ep. 23: An Illicit Affair: The Murder of Tommy Paeyeneers

    Send us a text On Crimenelia Street this week, we peel back the lid on a scandalous true crime you've probably never heard of: the murder of Tommy Paeyeneers. We dive into the torrid affair, the teenage lover, and the explosive moment Tommy answered a knock that would change everything.  Spoiler: Divorce was “not an option,” so somewhere along the line the plot skips straight to murder. We unravel the messy conspiracy, and the verdict that shocked a small town. Plus, because we’re not ruthless (just a little), we wrap things up with a softer Swift-adjacent moment—because sometimes true crime needs a Taylor echo to catch its breath.  Follow us on Instagram @crimeneliastreet Follow us on TikTok @crimeneliastpodcast Send us an email at crimeneliast@gmail.com Subscribe and Like on YouTube @CrimeneliaStreetPodcast

    43 min
See All (35)

About

Sam and Tori tell the stories of different true crime and paranormal occurrences with a Swiftie-related palette cleanser at the end.

Information

  • Creator
    Sam & Tori
  • Years Active
    2024 - 2025
  • Episodes
    35
  • Rating
    Explicit
  • Copyright
    © 2025 Crimenelia Street
  • Show Website
    Crimenelia Street