Carwins v Critics

Joseph Carwin
  • 5.0 (15)
  • MUSIC COMMENTARY
  • UPDATED WEEKLY

Welcome to Carwins v Critics! Join brothers Joseph and James Carwin as they explore a new album each episode, diving into the critical consensus and sharing their personal takes. From classic hits to hidden gems, they break down each track and discuss their opinions—comparing them to the critics’ views along the way. Whether you’re a music enthusiast or just looking for a fresh perspective, we’re here to have fun and enjoy the ride!

  1. 09/15/2025

    28 - Vessel

    In this episode of Carwins v Critics, Joseph and Mason Carwin dive into Vessel by Twenty One Pilots. We break down the album’s unique blend of genres, its vulnerable themes, and the way it set the stage for the band’s rise. Join us as we explore what makes this record such a defining moment in their catalog.

    1h 8m

  2. 09/08/2025

    27 - Weezer (Blue Album)

    Carwins v Critics is back! With James serving in Australia for the next two years, Mason Carwin returns from his mission in Southern California to join Joseph on the show. For our comeback episode, we’re diving into Weezer’s debut, the Blue Album. From its power-pop hooks to its lasting influence, we break down the tracks and talk about why this record continues to resonate.

    1h 5m

  3. 06/25/2025

    26 - The New Abnormal

    In this surprise episode of Carwins v Critics, Joseph and James Carwin sit down one last time before James heads out on his mission to talk about The New Abnormal by The Strokes, a shared favorite. We break down the album’s sleek sound, reflective tone, and why it’s stuck with us. Thanks for listening, and we’ll see what the future holds.

    1h 10m

  4. 04/21/2025

    25 - Pet Sounds

    In this episode of Carwins v Critics, Joseph and James Carwin dive into Pet Sounds by The Beach Boys. We break down the album’s lush arrangements, emotional depth, and lasting legacy in music history. Is this the final episode of the podcast? Who’s to say—but tune in to hear our thoughts on this legendary record and what might be next.

    1 hr

  5. 04/14/2025

    24 - OK Computer

    In this episode of Carwins v Critics, Joseph and James Carwin take on OK Computer by Radiohead. We dive into the album’s haunting atmosphere, abstract lyricism, and forward-thinking production that redefined the boundaries of rock. Join us as we unpack a record that’s as challenging as it is unforgettable.

    1h 5m

  6. 04/07/2025

    23 - Thriller

    In this episode of Carwins v Critics, Joseph and James Carwin dive into Thriller by Michael Jackson. We break down the album’s iconic tracks, massive influence, and the precision behind its genre-blending sound. Join us as we explore one of the most defining records in pop music history.

    51 min

  7. 03/31/2025

    22 - GUTS

    In this episode of Carwins v Critics, Joseph and James Carwin take on GUTS by Olivia Rodrigo. We break down its sharp lyrics, dynamic production, and the evolution of her sound since SOUR. Join us as we explore the highs and lows of one of pop’s biggest albums in recent years.

    1h 2m

  8. 03/24/2025

    21 - Blue

    In this episode of Carwins v Critics, Joseph and James Carwin dive into Blue by Joni Mitchell. From its deeply personal songwriting to its lasting influence, we break down the album’s raw emotion and musical brilliance. Join us as we explore one of the most revered singer-songwriter records of all time.

    52 min
See All (28)

5
out of 5
15 Ratings

About

Welcome to Carwins v Critics! Join brothers Joseph and James Carwin as they explore a new album each episode, diving into the critical consensus and sharing their personal takes. From classic hits to hidden gems, they break down each track and discuss their opinions—comparing them to the critics’ views along the way. Whether you’re a music enthusiast or just looking for a fresh perspective, we’re here to have fun and enjoy the ride!

Information

  • Creator
    Joseph Carwin
  • Years Active
    2024 - 2025
  • Episodes
    28
  • Rating
    Clean
  • Copyright
    © Joseph Carwin
  • Show Website
    Carwins v Critics