Medicare Sales Playbook

Medicare Sales Playbook
  • 5.0 (7)
  • Careers
  • Updated Weekly

The Medicare Sales Playbook is more than just a podcast; it's a mission to transform the way agents approach Medicare sales, focusing on utilizing one's unique talents, embracing hard work, and fostering a sense of community. It's about making a meaningful impact on the lives of seniors while simultaneously achieving professional growth and financial success. Every episode is designed to inspire, educate, and empower agents to not only grow their business but also to discover their 'why' and achieve a fulfilling career. Hosted by the energetic and insightful Dallas Keithley, this podcast stands as a guiding light for insurance agents aiming to elevate their Medicare business, one strategic play at a time. Tune in to join Dallas and his guests on this journey toward becoming a standout agent in the Medicare insurance world.

  1. 4d ago ·  Video

    How to Present Medicare Advantage vs. Medicare Supplement

    How do you present Medicare Advantage and Medicare Supplement options without letting your own preferences make the decision for the client? In this episode of the Medicare Sales Playbook, Dallas and Matt continue their series on presenting Medicare by heading back to the whiteboard and breaking down how they educate clients on their coverage options. They walk through how to explain Medicare Supplements and Medicare Advantage plans side by side, discuss premiums, copays, networks, maximum out-of-pocket costs, prescription coverage, and additional protection—and show how putting the numbers on paper can help clients understand what they're actually choosing. You'll also learn why Dallas and Matt believe the goal shouldn't be to push a client toward one option or the other. Instead, a great Medicare agent gives clients the information, clears up misconceptions, asks the right questions, and helps them arrive at a decision they understand. Plus, they discuss: How to compare Medicare Supplements and Medicare Advantage Why the cheapest Medicare Supplement isn't always the best choice How to use "Medicare math" to make costs easier to understand How to address concerns about Medicare Advantage networks Why maximum out-of-pocket numbers need context How hospital indemnity can fit into the overall conversation Why agents should build a repeatable presentation process How practice can make complicated Medicare conversations feel simple The better you understand your presentation, the easier it becomes for your clients to understand their options. Like, subscribe, and share the Medicare Sales Playbook with another agent who wants to improve their Medicare appointments. Connect With Us: Website: https://medicaresalesplaybook.com/ Instagram: https://instagram.com/themedicaresalesplaybook TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@medicare.sales.pl Facebook: https://facebook.com/medicaresalesplaybook

    How to Present Medicare Advantage vs. Medicare Supplement

  2. Sep 10 ·  Video

    How to Explain Medicare So Clients Actually Understand It

    Knowing Medicare and knowing how to explain Medicare are two very different things. In this episode of the Medicare Sales Playbook, Dallas and Matt continue their series on presenting Medicare by breaking down how to explain Medicare Parts A and B in a way clients can actually understand. The goal isn't to overwhelm clients with terminology, numbers, and coverage details. It's to simplify the conversation, build a strong foundation, uncover the gaps Medicare leaves behind, and help clients understand why additional coverage may matter. You'll hear how Dallas walks through Medicare step by step, how he handles questions and misconceptions, why repetition matters during the presentation, and why being the "simplest person in the room" may be more valuable than trying to sound like the smartest. They also discuss: How to position Medicare as the foundation of the overall conversation Why education helps agents sell themselves—not just a plan How to explain Medicare Part A and Part B simply How to discuss deductibles, coinsurance, and IRMAA Why agents should address rumors and misinformation directly How to uncover Medicare's gaps without using fear Why saying "I don't know, but I'll find out" can build trust How to know when you're truly ready to present Medicare to a client If you can explain Medicare clearly enough that someone else can repeat it back to you, you're on the right track. Learn more about the Medicare Sales Playbook at MedicareSalesPlaybook.com. Connect With Us: Website: https://medicaresalesplaybook.com/ Instagram: https://instagram.com/themedicaresalesplaybook TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@medicare.sales.pl Facebook: https://facebook.com/medicaresalesplaybook

    How to Explain Medicare So Clients Actually Understand It

  3. Sep 3 ·  Video

    How Top Medicare Agents Prepare for Every Appointment

    What happens before you start explaining Medicare may determine whether you ever earn the client's trust. In this episode of the Medicare Sales Playbook, Dallas and Matt break down the preparation, warm-up, and expectation-setting that can make a Medicare appointment feel smoother, more professional, and more productive. From having the right tools ready before you walk through the door to building rapport, eliminating distractions, and establishing the client's goals, they walk through the foundation of a strong Medicare presentation. They cover: What to have ready before every Medicare appointment Why preparation matters for both new clients and reviews How a second screen can improve the client experience Using scopes, cross-sell sheets, flip books, and plan materials Why your mindset before the appointment matters How the "warm-up" starts before you ever knock on the door What to observe when you arrive at a client's home Why listening is one of the most important parts of rapport building How to eliminate distractions before the presentation begins Setting expectations and identifying the client's real goals Using the "10,000-foot view" to determine how much detail a client wants How to introduce the bigger financial picture without losing focus on Medicare Why you need to establish trust and value before asking for referrals or additional business The big takeaway: the Medicare presentation doesn't begin when you start talking about Parts A and B. It begins with preparation, first impressions, rapport, and setting the right expectations. Plus, Dallas and Matt share plenty of stories from appointments that went right—and a few that definitely didn't. Coming next: They'll continue the series by breaking down how to actually educate clients on Medicare and move through the presentation. And don't forget: Medicare Sales Playbook is coming to Philadelphia on September 24th for a live training day. Visit MedicareSalesPlaybook.com for details. Subscribe for more Medicare sales strategies, appointment techniques, cross-selling ideas, and practical training to help you become a more effective Medicare agent. Connect With Us: Website: https://medicaresalesplaybook.com/ Instagram: https://instagram.com/themedicaresalesplaybook TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@medicare.sales.pl Facebook: https://facebook.com/medicaresalesplaybook

    How Top Medicare Agents Prepare for Every Appointment

  4. Aug 27 ·  Video

    How to Get More Medicare Clients Through Relationships & Referrals

    What if you could build a thriving Medicare business without constantly buying leads? In this episode of the Medicare Sales Playbook, Dallas Keithley sits down with Kelsey Hentzen and Don Chapman of the Askins Insurance Team to unpack how they've grown their businesses through relationships, referrals, seminars, and deep involvement in their local communities. Kelsey and Dawn share how they've added roughly 100 clients per year while building a business around serving seniors—not just selling to them. From volunteering at senior centers and participating in community events to asking existing clients for introductions, their strategy starts with one simple question: "How can we help?" You'll also hear how they: Get into senior centers and other community organizations Generate referrals without making the conversation feel awkward Turn community service into long-term relationships Cross-sell naturally by listening to what clients actually need Work seminars together while fairly dividing opportunities Balance growing Medicare businesses with raising families Use mentorship, teamwork, and support to accelerate their success Create opportunities without depending on purchased leads If you're wondering how to get in front of more Medicare prospects without simply spending more money on leads, this episode is packed with practical ideas you can start applying in your own market. The biggest takeaway? Provide value first. Build relationships. Then ask who else you can help. 👍 Like the episode if you found it helpful. 💬 Comment with one strategy you're going to put into action. 🔔 Subscribe to the Medicare Sales Playbook for more practical strategies to grow your Medicare business.

    How to Get More Medicare Clients Through Relationships & Referrals

  5. Aug 20 ·  Video

    What Medicare Agents Should Expect This AEP

    AEP is approaching, and the Medicare market continues to change. In this episode of the Medicare Sales Playbook, Dallas and Matt make their predictions for the upcoming 2027 plan year—and break down what Medicare agents should be preparing for now. From $0 premiums becoming less of a selling point to tighter networks, non-commissionable plans, PDP volatility, and increased disruption across the market, agents may have more complexity to navigate this AEP than ever before. But the opportunity is still there for agents who are prepared. Dallas and Matt discuss why agents need to become better at explaining value and trade-offs, investigating provider networks, cross-selling their Medicare clients, and becoming the knowledgeable, calming voice clients need when the market gets confusing. In this episode: Why $0 premiums may matter less to clients How to sell the total value of a Medicare plan—not just the premium Why non-commissionable plans could become more prevalent The growing importance of cross-selling Why Medicare Advantage networks could become the battleground How PDP volatility could affect Medicare Supplement clients Why disruption creates opportunity for knowledgeable agents How to become the calming voice clients need during AEP The takeaway is simple: study, prepare, tell the truth, and become so valuable to your clients that choosing you is obvious. If you're a Medicare agent preparing for the upcoming AEP, this episode will help you understand what may be coming—and what you can do about it. Be sure to like, comment, and subscribe for more Medicare sales strategies, training, and conversations from the Medicare Sales Playbook. Connect With Us: Website: https://medicaresalesplaybook.com/ Instagram: https://instagram.com/themedicaresalesplaybook TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@medicare.sales.pl Facebook: https://facebook.com/medicaresalesplaybook

    What Medicare Agents Should Expect This AEP

  6. Aug 13 ·  Video

    5 Ways to Grow Your Business Without Chasing New Leads

    Your book of business may be worth more than you realize—you just have to know how to uncover the opportunities already inside it. In this episode of the Medicare Sales Playbook, Dallas and Matt share five practical ways insurance agents can generate new business, strengthen client relationships, and create more consistent activity without constantly chasing brand-new leads. They break down how to: Learn new products and bring fresh opportunities to existing clients Create a newsletter clients will actually read Use referral contests and clearly communicated goals Make cross-selling part of every client interaction Build community through client appreciation events The strategies are simple, but simplicity only works when it is paired with consistent action. Whether you have 10 clients or 1,000, this episode will help you find more reasons to connect, provide more value, and make sure every client understands everything you can do for them. You do not have to implement all five ideas immediately. Choose one, put it into action, and start creating momentum inside the book of business you already have. Learn more about the Medicare Sales Playbook and upcoming Training Days at MedicareSalesPlaybook.com. Connect With Us: Website: https://medicaresalesplaybook.com/ Instagram: https://instagram.com/themedicaresalesplaybook TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@medicare.sales.pl Facebook: https://facebook.com/medicaresalesplaybook

    5 Ways to Grow Your Business Without Chasing New Leads

  7. Aug 6 ·  Video

    How Elite Medicare Agents Prepare for AEP

    AEP success does not begin on October 15—it begins months earlier. In this episode of the Medicare Sales Playbook, Dallas Keithley sits down with Lasting Mark CEO Brian Askins to break down how elite Medicare agents prepare for AEP. Brian shares the systems, routines, client communication strategies, and team structure that have helped him build a successful Medicare business over nearly four decades. You'll learn how to: Begin filling your AEP calendar before October Protect your existing book of business while attracting new clients Contact clients through a strategic series of letters and phone calls Use every Medicare review to uncover future cross-selling opportunities Schedule January, February, and March appointments during AEP Generate referrals by delivering massive value Master enrollment platforms, provider searches, and essential technology Build a disciplined daily routine that protects your energy Prepare your staff and assign clear responsibilities before AEP begins Create a business that produces consistently throughout the entire year AEP is a marathon disguised as a sprint. The agents who win are not simply motivated—they are prepared, disciplined, and supported by a system. Start preparing today, protect your clients, master your process, and make this your best AEP yet. Visit the Medicare Sales Playbook website to learn more about upcoming training days and additional resources. Connect With Us: Website: https://medicaresalesplaybook.com/ Instagram: https://instagram.com/themedicaresalesplaybook TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@medicare.sales.pl Facebook: https://facebook.com/medicaresalesplaybook

    How Elite Medicare Agents Prepare for AEP

  8. Jul 30 ·  Video

    Stop Working Harder—Build a Better Medicare Sales System

    Great Medicare agents do not rely on motivation alone—they build systems that keep producing results even when energy, confidence, and momentum begin to fade. In this episode of the Medicare Sales Playbook, Dallas and Matt break down why your results are often a reflection of the systems behind your business. They discuss what agents should track, how to identify weaknesses in the sales process, why consistent producers operate differently, and how to build a business that does not depend entirely on you. You'll learn how to: Track leads, appointments, sales, closing ratios, and marketing costs Identify which lead sources and sales methods work best for you Build routines that carry you through AEP when motivation disappears Create consistent systems for appointments, referrals, objections, and client follow-up Improve the process behind your production instead of only focusing on the final number Build a Medicare business that can grow without everything running through you Find mentors whose consistency is worth modeling Start improving one part of your business at a time You do not need to reinvent every part of your agency. You need to identify what works, document it, repeat it, and keep refining it. Whether you are a brand-new Medicare agent or already managing hundreds of clients, this episode will help you build a more consistent, efficient, and scalable business. Learn more about Medicare Sales Playbook training, resources, and upcoming events at MedicareSalesPlaybook.com. Subscribe for more practical Medicare sales, marketing, retention, and agency-growth strategies from Dallas and Matt. Connect With Us: Website: https://medicaresalesplaybook.com/ Instagram: https://instagram.com/themedicaresalesplaybook TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@medicare.sales.pl Facebook: https://facebook.com/medicaresalesplaybook

    Stop Working Harder—Build a Better Medicare Sales System
See All (132)

Ratings & Reviews

5
out of 5
7 Ratings

About

The Medicare Sales Playbook is more than just a podcast; it's a mission to transform the way agents approach Medicare sales, focusing on utilizing one's unique talents, embracing hard work, and fostering a sense of community. It's about making a meaningful impact on the lives of seniors while simultaneously achieving professional growth and financial success. Every episode is designed to inspire, educate, and empower agents to not only grow their business but also to discover their 'why' and achieve a fulfilling career. Hosted by the energetic and insightful Dallas Keithley, this podcast stands as a guiding light for insurance agents aiming to elevate their Medicare business, one strategic play at a time. Tune in to join Dallas and his guests on this journey toward becoming a standout agent in the Medicare insurance world.

Information

  • Creator
    Medicare Sales Playbook
  • Years Active
    2024 - 2026
  • Episodes
    132
  • Rating
    Clean
  • Copyright
    © 2024
  • Show Website
    Medicare Sales Playbook

You Might Also Like