Story Deep Dive Podcast

Story Deep Dive

Join editor and USA Today bestselling author Dana Pittman and developmental editor Rachel Arsenault for a weekly deep dive into great novels. storydeepdive.substack.com

  1. 1D AGO

    Episode 60: Realism, Restraint, and Deep Emotional Stakes in Before I Let Go

    Welcome to Story Deep Dive! In this episode, hosts Rachel and Dana wrap up their four-week discussion of Before I Let Go by Kennedy Ryan—not as readers, but as writers. Whether you’re a writer, editor, or storyteller studying romance craft, you’ll gain valuable insights on how to balance heavy themes with joy, how “realistic” character choices can cap emotional highs and lows, and how to use backstory/flashbacks that do double duty instead of feeling like filler. You can also watch the video version of this podcast on YouTube! Estimate Timestamps 0:00 – Welcome Back + Next Book Reveal Rachel and Dana open the episode by setting the tone for the podcast—craft talk, writer-focused insights, and bestie energy. Before closing out their final discussion of Before I Let Go, they reveal next month’s pick: Sin and Magic by K.F. Breene. They share that part of their 2026 reading strategy includes tackling “book twos” to study how sequels escalate stakes, expand worldbuilding, and re-hook readers who already know the characters. 3:10 – Why Book Two Conversations Hit Different They discuss what makes a sequel craft conversation uniquely valuable—especially in a long-running series. Dana explains that Sin and Magic picks up directly after Sin and Chocolate and deepens the romance in a steady slow burn while widening the world, the found-family dynamics, and the scope of the hero’s family conflict (including more about his father). Rachel shares she’s especially excited because mysteries raise her engagement level fast, and she’s eager to analyze how a series sustains romantic payoff across multiple books. 8:15 – Series Craft: Slow Burn Across Multiple Books Rachel and Dana dig into a key craft question: how do you sustain a slow burn with the same couple across a long series without repeating the same “together/not together” cycle? Dana describes the relationship development as “onion layers”—slow, intentional, and more intimate over time because the couple is truly getting to know each other. They note that long-series pacing depends on timeline choices (six books could cover six months or multiple years), and they plan to pay attention to how the author handles this. 12:30 – Quick Recap of Before I Let Go Dana gives a clean summary for listeners: Before I Let Go is a second-chance romance that begins after the marriage is already over. Yasmin and Josiah are divorced but still intertwined through co-parenting and the restaurant they built together. The story isn’t about whether they still love each other—it’s about whether they can heal, face grief, and choose each other again. 14:10 – Big Takeaways: Realism, Grief + Joy, and Layered Storytelling Dana names one of the book’s biggest strengths: it’s a mature, realistic romance with minimal pettiness—an intentional choice that fits the subject matter (grief, depression, family life, therapy). She praises Kennedy Ryan for balancing grief with moments of light—celebrations, family gatherings, and community scenes—so readers don’t stay emotionally submerged for too long. Dana also highlights the book’s layering: themes, relationships, cast, and emotional nuance create a story that grips without relying on big melodrama. 19:20 – The Craft Tension: When Everyone Is Reasonable, Conflict Has a Ceiling Rachel and Dana explain the tradeoff of realism: when characters behave sensibly (and there are no true villains), emotional highs and lows can feel “capped.” Rachel frames it as a pro-and-con: it’s true to life and beautifully mature, but it limits how far conflict can escalate. Dana adds that some tensions resolve quickly, and she argues that it’s okay to let tension live longer so it can create momentum and make standout moments pop. Notable craft takeaway: Great ingredients can still taste “same-ish” without variation—like cooking without salt and pepper. 26:40 – The Missing Engine: Why a Singular External Through-Line Helps They revisit a key structural point: the story could have gained more propulsion with a consistent external plot engine (for example, something sustained tied to the restaurant). Rachel explains that an external through-line doesn’t mean turning the book into suspense or adding drama—it simply gives realistic characters a steady pressure source so escalation happens naturally. Dana notes that without that through-line, plot pressure can feel like “jump starts” that fade, rather than one thread that intensifies over time. 34:10 – Why This Matters More for Emerging Authors They point out a market reality: established authors with a loyal readership can take more pacing risks because readers already trust them. For newer authors, the same choices may be riskier—because readers haven’t yet built that trust and might disengage if the story feels too steady or doesn’t escalate clearly. 37:10 – The Power of Mature Romance: Representation, Hope, and Emotional Truth Dana explains why mature romance can be so powerful and widely resonant: it speaks to readers who want protagonists with real lives—kids, mortgages, businesses, responsibilities, history. She emphasizes that the book offers something deeper than entertainment: it can help readers feel seen, understood, and hopeful—especially women navigating grief, caregiving, or the complexity of loving again after loss. Rachel echoes that the story’s impact transcends identity and circumstance because it taps into honest human experience—periods where life is heavy, where you don’t recognize yourself, and where healing is possible. 44:00 – Backstory That Works: “Double Duty” Memories + Flashbacks Rachel closes with practical craft strategies for handling history between characters. She explains that backstory should appear when it’s relevant to the present scene and must illuminate what’s happening now (not derail the narrative). She stresses specificity—sensory, tangible details that anchor memory—and reminds writers that information alone isn’t enough. Notable quote/idea: “Memories have to do double duty.” They should deepen emotion, reveal character, shift meaning, or increase tension—not just deliver facts. 52:20 – Final Love Letter to Kennedy Ryan + Wrap-Up Dana closes by praising Kennedy Ryan as a master storyteller whose work proves the power of fiction to move people and speak life. Rachel thanks Dana for the pick and encourages listeners to read or listen (and reminds non-romance readers they can skip steamy scenes if they prefer—though the hosts note the intimacy is selective and plot-relevant). They close by inviting reviews, comments, and listener questions. Book Selection Before I Let Go by Kennedy Ryan Their love was supposed to last forever. But when life delivered blow after devastating blow, Yasmen and Josiah Wade found that love alone couldn’t solve or save everything. It couldn’t save their marriage. Yasmen wasn’t prepared for how her life fell apart, but she’s finally starting to find joy again. She and Josiah have found a new rhythm, co-parenting their two kids and running a thriving business together. Yet like magnets, they’re always drawn back to each other, and now they’re beginning to wonder if they’re truly ready to let go of everything they once had. Soon, one stolen kiss leads to another … and then more. It’s hot. It’s illicit. It’s all good—until old wounds reopen. Is it too late for them to find forever? Or could they be even better, the second time around? Where to Find the Book Before I Let Go by Kennedy Ryan is available in several formats. It’s also widely available in libraries and online retailers. Details on his website. Next Episode: In the next episode, Rachel and Dana will kick off their new read: Sin and Magic by K.F. Breene. They’ll explore what changes (and what must escalate) in a book two—especially in a long-running series with a slow-burn romance, expanding worldbuilding, and found-family dynamics. Be sure to tune in! Join the Conversation: Like what you heard? Subscribe, leave a review, and share your thoughts. Follow Story Deep Dive on your favorite podcast platform and on YouTube, and connect with Dana and Rachel to keep the craft conversation going. Connect with Dana and Rachel on storydeepdive.com to keep the conversation going! This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit storydeepdive.substack.com

    1h 13m
  2. FEB 15

    Episode 59: Ensemble Cast, Character Depth, and Emotional Stakes in Before I Let Go

    Welcome to Story Deep Dive! In this episode, Rachel and Dana dive into the cast of characters in Before I Let Go by Kennedy Ryan—breaking down how character design, lived-in history, and community dynamics can carry a story with emotional power. Whether you’re a writer, storyteller, or craft-minded reader, you’ll gain valuable insights on how to build protagonists shaped by grief and recovery, how to write children as real characters (not props), and how to create conflict without villains. You can also watch the video version of this podcast on YouTube! Estimate Timestamps 0:00 – Welcome Back + Episode Focus: Why This Cast Hits So Hard Rachel and Dana introduce the episode’s theme: the character work in Before I Let Go is one of the most moving and structurally important parts of the story. They frame the conversation through a writer’s lens—studying how Kennedy Ryan builds a full ensemble that feels intimate, emotionally resonant, and essential to the story’s momentum. 1:00 – Small Talk: Micro Habits, Creative Play, and Making Space Away From Screens Dana shares a personal creative shift: she’s learning watercolor as a tactile, off-screen hobby that supports brainstorming and creative flow. She talks about how stepping into “beginner energy” helps her get out of her own way—and how intentional she has to be about scheduling non-writing creativity now that writing is her job. Rachel expands on the craft connection: writers often solve story problems faster by stepping away from the desk, letting the brain work in the background while the hands do something physical. Notable moment: the conversation highlights how tactile creativity can support clarity, emotional regulation, and better story thinking—especially when your primary creative passion is also your career. 7:30 – Rachel’s Update: A Tactile Scene-Planning Method (ProWritingAid Workshop) Rachel previews an upcoming ProWritingAid expert workshop where she’ll teach her favorite scene planning method—pen-and-paper, diagram-based, and conflict-forward. She explains how visual planning helps writers find what’s “missing” when a scene feels flat, especially in early drafts or revision, and why working away from the computer can unlock better insight. 10:30 – Book Summary: Second Chance Romance After the Marriage Ends Dana summarizes Before I Let Go as a second chance romance that begins after Yasmin and Josiah’s marriage has already broken. They’re divorced but still bound by co-parenting and their shared restaurant. The heart of the story isn’t whether love exists—it’s whether they’re capable of choosing each other again after grief, avoidance, and emotional fallout. 12:00 – Episode Roadmap: What We’re Studying in the Characters Dana outlines key topics: Yasmin as a portrait of grief, depression, recovery, and maternal guilt Josiah as a powerful alpha with real vulnerability (including therapy and cultural nuance) Deja and Kaseem as children with their own emotional arcs, not background props The supporting cast and Skyland community as a major story engine Rachel adds three craft angles: writing characters with history, handling mental health with care, and building antagonism without villains. 15:00 – Yasmin: Grief, Depression, Identity, and “Almost Being Back” Dana unpacks why Yasmin’s character lands with such force—especially through the lens of cultural context and mental health. She discusses how Kennedy Ryan portrays a successful Black woman whose outer life looks “fine,” while private grief nearly destroys her. The story begins after Yasmin’s lowest point, allowing readers to experience the residue of depression rather than being submerged in the darkest moments—while still feeling how close it remains. Rachel highlights the craft challenge of portraying two truths at once: Yasmin can be dressed up, radiant, and feeling herself—while still carrying the shadow voice of doubt and pain just behind her. They praise how the book makes mental health feel real without sensationalizing it, and how consequences (like the divorce request made at the lowest point) externalize what could otherwise feel intangible. Key insight: this is character work that transcends genre and culture—because grief, regret, and rebuilding identity are human experiences. 25:30 – Josiah: Swagger + Vulnerability, and the Conflict of Two Different Grief Styles Dana breaks down why Josiah is such a strong portrayal of masculinity: he has presence and confidence, but also emotional depth—especially in how he approaches counseling, fatherhood, and grief. The tension between him and Yasmin isn’t about a villain—it’s about mismatch. Yasmin folded inward; Josiah went into motion and “holding it together” mode. Their different coping styles become the antagonistic energy that keeps them locked in a painful tug-of-war. Craft takeaway: when characters’ words and actions say “we’re fine,” but their internal worlds are bleeding, that contradiction can become a powerful engine—especially in emotionally-driven stories. 30:00 – Deja + Kaseem: Kids With Real Arcs (Not Stakes Props) Rachel notes that kids are often used as “low-hanging fruit” to raise stakes or add cuteness—but Before I Let Go does the opposite. Deja and Kaseem are full characters with their own emotional journeys and interpretations of the divorce. Dana talks about what co-parenting looks like from the inside: the residue kids carry, the ways they interpret adult choices with limited lived experience, and how children become mirrors—reflecting both what happened and what was missed. They point out how the book lets us watch the kids process, not just “accept” the HEA. Dana even shouts out Otis (the dog) as part of the story’s lived-in family texture. 35:00 – Craft Study: How Kennedy Ryan Creates Believable Character History Rachel zooms in on a major technique: ultra-specific memory details. Instead of vague “we used to be in love,” the story uses concrete shared experiences (like their early broke days—old car quirks, a cold apartment, bad water pressure) to make history feel real and character-owned. Dana adds why this matters even more in second chance romance: the “falling in love” is mostly behind them, so the past must prove what was real and what’s worth fighting for. They discuss how the book uses flashbacks in a way that avoids info-dumping—each memory ties directly to present conflict, illuminating what was lost and what might be reclaimed. Key takeaway: history should never feel tangential—it should clarify the present and raise the emotional stakes right now. 41:00 – Supporting Cast: New Friendships, Community Care, and Emotional Momentum Rachel points out a brilliant structural choice: Yasmin’s closest girlfriends are newer friends who didn’t know her during the marriage. That gives the story organic space for curiosity, questions, and emotional processing without forced exposition—and it supports Yasmin’s healing by giving her relationships not tied to her “old self.” Dana celebrates the full ensemble: girlfriends who bring joy and pressure, family voices that challenge, therapists who normalize support, and a community that shows up in practical ways (neighbors watching kids, people missing Yasmin, small acts of care). They connect this to a universal fantasy: not “perfect small-town wackiness,” but real community—people who notice, hold you, and help you survive. 48:00 – No Villains: Mature Conflict Built From Human Messiness Rachel highlights one of the episode’s biggest craft points: the story builds antagonism without making anyone evil. Vashti and Mark aren’t cartoon threats—they’re real people looking for love. Deja’s anger isn’t villainy—it’s pain. Even when people clash, the story stays rooted in human complexity. Dana agrees and notes how rare this is—conflict isn’t driven by petty misunderstandings, but by layered grief and fracture at the foundation. That maturity requires strong characterization across the board, and they argue Ryan delivers it. 53:30 – Wrap-Up: Why This Book Is Worth Studying for Character Dana concludes that character work is one of the story’s strongest elements—especially because the cast is large but never feels crowded. Everything feels intimate and intentional. She shares she’s reread the book multiple times and it gets better with each read because the layers reveal themselves. Rachel agrees and previews next week’s editor takeaways episode. Book Selection Before I Let Go by Kennedy Ryan Their love was supposed to last forever. But when life delivered blow after devastating blow, Yasmen and Josiah Wade found that love alone couldn’t solve or save everything. It couldn’t save their marriage. Yasmen wasn’t prepared for how her life fell apart, but she’s finally starting to find joy again. She and Josiah have found a new rhythm, co-parenting their two kids and running a thriving business together. Yet like magnets, they’re always drawn back to each other, and now they’re beginning to wonder if they’re truly ready to let go of everything they once had. Soon, one stolen kiss leads to another … and then more. It’s hot. It’s illicit. It’s all good—until old wounds reopen. Is it too late for them to find forever? Or could they be even better, the second time around? Where to Find the Book Before I Let Go by Kennedy Ryan is available in several formats. It’s also widely available in libraries and online retailers. Details on his website. Next Episode: In the next episode, Rachel and Dana will explore their editor takeaways—big craft lessons from this book, what writers should study closely, and how to apply those insights to your own work. Be sure to tune in! Join the Conversation: Like what you heard? Subscribe, leave a review, and share your thoughts. Follow Story D

    1h 9m
  3. FEB 8

    Episode 58: Healing, Grief, and Second Chances in Before I Let Go

    Welcome to Story Deep Dive! In this episode, Rachel and Dana kick off a three-week craft breakdown of Before I Let Go by Kennedy Ryan—reading as writers, not just readers. Whether you’re a writer, editor, or storyteller, you’ll gain practical insight into how to build deeply realistic characters, sustain romantic tension in a second-chance setup, and weave heavy topics like grief and therapy into a romance without becoming preachy. You can also watch the video version of this podcast on YouTube! Estimate Timestamps 0:00 – Welcome Back + New Series Kickoff Rachel and Dana welcome listeners back and introduce this month’s book: Before I Let Go by Kennedy Ryan. They frame it as a major shift from last month’s pick (Mistborn) and set expectations for a love story with rich emotional layers, cultural grounding, and three weeks of discussion ahead. 1:00 – What’s Happening at Danja Tales (Dana’s Update) Dana shares what’s in motion behind the scenes at Danja Tales: she’s gathering notes for a trilogy draft and revisiting long-standing projects she’s ready to bring back to life. The conversation turns to whether she’ll run another bootcamp—Dana makes it clear she won’t repeat the intense multi-week version again, but she’s considering a tighter plotting-only bootcamp with a clear framework and live demonstration in real time. 10:30 – StoryCypher Update: Sick Week + Academy Hot Seat Win Rachel talks about getting seriously sick at the start of January and how that slowed her momentum—then shifts into a highlight: StoryCypher’s first Act One hot seat session. A student submitted her first act for group review, and Rachel explains how they assessed stakes, clarity of the central story promise, and investment in the protagonist. The biggest win: the student received both actionable notes and emotional confirmation that readers are genuinely excited about her story. 18:30 – Book Overview: What This Romance Is Really About Rachel delivers the core setup: Yasmin and Josiah are divorced, but still intertwined through co-parenting and the restaurant they built together. The story isn’t about whether love exists—it’s about whether they’re capable of choosing each other again after grief, avoidance, and years of history. The episode establishes the emotional spine: therapy, parenting, and unresolved pain pulling them back into orbit. 20:00 – The Big Themes for the Next Three Weeks Dana lays out the discussion pillars they’ll return to throughout the series: African-American romance and cultural grounding Mature, realistic romance (characters who feel knowable, not escapist) A second-chance romance that begins after the marriage ends Grief and therapy as the foundation of the story A realistic HEA that feels earned and hopeful rather than fantastical Rachel adds a key lens: this book is a standout reference for writers who want to craft realistic characters and intimate community casts—especially in contrast to more heightened, quirky, or larger-than-life romance communities. 24:30 – What “African-American Romance” Adds to the Story Dana explains what makes the book culturally grounded beyond “it’s a Black couple”—the story integrates food, family, music, sisterhood, and the lived reality of an upper middle-class Black family building a business and raising kids intentionally. They also touch on how the story handles therapy and mental health in a way that reflects real cultural tension and generational norms without turning the book into a lecture. 29:30 – Mature Realism: Built Lives, Real Stakes, No Villains Rachel and Dana break down why the romance feels “mature”: the characters have already built a whole life—kids, business, stability—and the conflict is what happens when something vital breaks inside that structure. Rachel points out that realism changes everything: there aren’t classic villains here, just people trying to survive life. That choice deepens intimacy and makes the emotional lows hit harder—but also makes the relationships feel more precious and true. 34:00 – Second Chance After Divorce: Risking Love Again They highlight what makes this second-chance story different: the love isn’t missing, but the trust and emotional safety are fractured. Dana points out the emotional weight on both sides—Yasmin initiated the divorce and carries guilt, while Josiah wanted to stay married and had to accept her decision. The central question becomes: can they risk believing again, not just in romance, but in a whole life that includes love? 39:00 – Therapy Done Right (Without the “TED Talk” Effect) Rachel praises how Kennedy Ryan threads therapy into the narrative without using the therapist as a mouthpiece. The therapists feel like real characters—especially Dr. Mosa—rather than devices delivering lessons. Dana agrees, emphasizing that the book never feels preachy, but readers should be prepared for the emotional lows tied to grief and what caused the marriage to collapse. 44:00 – Realistic HEA + Male Vulnerability (Josiah as a Model Romance Hero) They discuss why the HEA works even though the couple already had a marriage that ended: the ending feels hopeful because it’s grounded in growth and tools that prepare them for real life continuing to happen. Rachel calls out how well the book portrays male vulnerability—Josiah is deeply emotional and wounded without becoming weak or losing romantic appeal. Dana adds that his strength shows up in how he loves and shows up for Yasmin and the kids, not in macho posturing. 49:00 – Tropes You’ll Recognize (With a Twist) Rachel points out the fun craft surprise: even with all the realism, familiar romance tropes appear—“let’s get it out of our system,” “no strings attached,” and even a one-bed moment—except they land differently because this couple has history and a shared past. Dana adds forced proximity and notes how Josiah’s emotional unavailability is portrayed as a controlled wall rather than the typical grumpy/jerk archetype. 52:00 – Final Notes: Friendship After Divorce + Children With Real Arcs Dana highlights two additional layers they’ll explore more later: the book introduces the female protagonist for the rest of the series, and Yasmin’s closest friendships are formed after the divorce—an emotional angle that adds depth and recovery. She also praises the children’s arcs (Kaseem and Deja), noting that the kids have distinct emotional journeys shaped by the residual impact of the divorce, even with two actively involved parents. They close by recommending the audiobook, calling it “acted” rather than simply narrated. Book Selection Before I Let Go by Kennedy Ryan Their love was supposed to last forever. But when life delivered blow after devastating blow, Yasmen and Josiah Wade found that love alone couldn’t solve or save everything. It couldn’t save their marriage. Yasmen wasn’t prepared for how her life fell apart, but she’s finally starting to find joy again. She and Josiah have found a new rhythm, co-parenting their two kids and running a thriving business together. Yet like magnets, they’re always drawn back to each other, and now they’re beginning to wonder if they’re truly ready to let go of everything they once had. Soon, one stolen kiss leads to another … and then more. It’s hot. It’s illicit. It’s all good—until old wounds reopen. Is it too late for them to find forever? Or could they be even better, the second time around? Where to Find the Book Before I Let Go by Kennedy Ryan is available in several formats. It’s also widely available in libraries and online retailers. Details on his website. Next Episode: In the next episode, Rachel and Dana will explore the plot of Before I Let Go—breaking down how the story sustains tension when the couple already has history, how the emotional spine drives structure, and what writers can learn from its pacing and progression. Be sure to tune in! Join the Conversation: Like what you heard? Subscribe, leave a review, and share your thoughts. Follow Story Deep Dive on your favorite podcast platform and on YouTube, and connect with Dana and Rachel to keep the craft conversation going. Connect with Dana and Rachel on storydeepdive.com to keep the conversation going! This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit storydeepdive.substack.com

    1h 18m
  4. FEB 1

    Episode 57: Second-Chance Romance, Deep Character Work, and Realistic Stakes in Before I Let Go

    Welcome to Story Deep Dive! In this episode, Rachel and Dana kick off a three-week craft breakdown of Before I Let Go by Kennedy Ryan—reading as writers, not just readers. Whether you’re a writer, editor, or storyteller, you’ll gain practical insight into how to build deeply realistic characters, sustain romantic tension in a second-chance setup, and weave heavy topics like grief and therapy into a romance without becoming preachy. You can also watch the video version of this podcast on YouTube! Estimate Timestamps 0:00 – Welcome Back + New Series Kickoff Rachel and Dana welcome listeners back and introduce this month’s book: Before I Let Go by Kennedy Ryan. They frame it as a major shift from last month’s pick (Mistborn) and set expectations for a love story with rich emotional layers, cultural grounding, and three weeks of discussion ahead. 1:00 – What’s Happening at Danja Tales (Dana’s Update) Dana shares what’s in motion behind the scenes at Danja Tales: she’s gathering notes for a trilogy draft and revisiting long-standing projects she’s ready to bring back to life. The conversation turns to whether she’ll run another bootcamp—Dana makes it clear she won’t repeat the intense multi-week version again, but she’s considering a tighter plotting-only bootcamp with a clear framework and live demonstration in real time. 10:30 – StoryCypher Update: Sick Week + Academy Hot Seat Win Rachel talks about getting seriously sick at the start of January and how that slowed her momentum—then shifts into a highlight: StoryCypher’s first Act One hot seat session. A student submitted her first act for group review, and Rachel explains how they assessed stakes, clarity of the central story promise, and investment in the protagonist. The biggest win: the student received both actionable notes and emotional confirmation that readers are genuinely excited about her story. 18:30 – Book Overview: What This Romance Is Really About Rachel delivers the core setup: Yasmin and Josiah are divorced, but still intertwined through co-parenting and the restaurant they built together. The story isn’t about whether love exists—it’s about whether they’re capable of choosing each other again after grief, avoidance, and years of history. The episode establishes the emotional spine: therapy, parenting, and unresolved pain pulling them back into orbit. 20:00 – The Big Themes for the Next Three Weeks Dana lays out the discussion pillars they’ll return to throughout the series: African-American romance and cultural grounding Mature, realistic romance (characters who feel knowable, not escapist) A second-chance romance that begins after the marriage ends Grief and therapy as the foundation of the story A realistic HEA that feels earned and hopeful rather than fantastical Rachel adds a key lens: this book is a standout reference for writers who want to craft realistic characters and intimate community casts—especially in contrast to more heightened, quirky, or larger-than-life romance communities. 24:30 – What “African-American Romance” Adds to the Story Dana explains what makes the book culturally grounded beyond “it’s a Black couple”—the story integrates food, family, music, sisterhood, and the lived reality of an upper middle-class Black family building a business and raising kids intentionally. They also touch on how the story handles therapy and mental health in a way that reflects real cultural tension and generational norms without turning the book into a lecture. 29:30 – Mature Realism: Built Lives, Real Stakes, No Villains Rachel and Dana break down why the romance feels “mature”: the characters have already built a whole life—kids, business, stability—and the conflict is what happens when something vital breaks inside that structure. Rachel points out that realism changes everything: there aren’t classic villains here, just people trying to survive life. That choice deepens intimacy and makes the emotional lows hit harder—but also makes the relationships feel more precious and true. 34:00 – Second Chance After Divorce: Risking Love Again They highlight what makes this second-chance story different: the love isn’t missing, but the trust and emotional safety are fractured. Dana points out the emotional weight on both sides—Yasmin initiated the divorce and carries guilt, while Josiah wanted to stay married and had to accept her decision. The central question becomes: can they risk believing again, not just in romance, but in a whole life that includes love? 39:00 – Therapy Done Right (Without the “TED Talk” Effect) Rachel praises how Kennedy Ryan threads therapy into the narrative without using the therapist as a mouthpiece. The therapists feel like real characters—especially Dr. Mosa—rather than devices delivering lessons. Dana agrees, emphasizing that the book never feels preachy, but readers should be prepared for the emotional lows tied to grief and what caused the marriage to collapse. 44:00 – Realistic HEA + Male Vulnerability (Josiah as a Model Romance Hero) They discuss why the HEA works even though the couple already had a marriage that ended: the ending feels hopeful because it’s grounded in growth and tools that prepare them for real life continuing to happen. Rachel calls out how well the book portrays male vulnerability—Josiah is deeply emotional and wounded without becoming weak or losing romantic appeal. Dana adds that his strength shows up in how he loves and shows up for Yasmin and the kids, not in macho posturing. 49:00 – Tropes You’ll Recognize (With a Twist) Rachel points out the fun craft surprise: even with all the realism, familiar romance tropes appear—“let’s get it out of our system,” “no strings attached,” and even a one-bed moment—except they land differently because this couple has history and a shared past. Dana adds forced proximity and notes how Josiah’s emotional unavailability is portrayed as a controlled wall rather than the typical grumpy/jerk archetype. 52:00 – Final Notes: Friendship After Divorce + Children With Real Arcs Dana highlights two additional layers they’ll explore more later: the book introduces the female protagonist for the rest of the series, and Yasmin’s closest friendships are formed after the divorce—an emotional angle that adds depth and recovery. She also praises the children’s arcs (Kaseem and Deja), noting that the kids have distinct emotional journeys shaped by the residual impact of the divorce, even with two actively involved parents. They close by recommending the audiobook, calling it “acted” rather than simply narrated. Book Selection Before I Let Go by Kennedy Ryan Their love was supposed to last forever. But when life delivered blow after devastating blow, Yasmen and Josiah Wade found that love alone couldn’t solve or save everything. It couldn’t save their marriage. Yasmen wasn’t prepared for how her life fell apart, but she’s finally starting to find joy again. She and Josiah have found a new rhythm, co-parenting their two kids and running a thriving business together. Yet like magnets, they’re always drawn back to each other, and now they’re beginning to wonder if they’re truly ready to let go of everything they once had. Soon, one stolen kiss leads to another … and then more. It’s hot. It’s illicit. It’s all good—until old wounds reopen. Is it too late for them to find forever? Or could they be even better, the second time around? Where to Find the Book Before I Let Go by Kennedy Ryan is available in several formats. It’s also widely available in libraries and online retailers. Details on his website. Next Episode: In the next episode, Rachel and Dana will explore the plot of Before I Let Go—breaking down how the story sustains tension when the couple already has history, how the emotional spine drives structure, and what writers can learn from its pacing and progression. Be sure to tune in! Join the Conversation: Like what you heard? Subscribe, leave a review, and share your thoughts. Follow Story Deep Dive on your favorite podcast platform and on YouTube, and connect with Dana and Rachel to keep the craft conversation going. Connect with Dana and Rachel on storydeepdive.com to keep the conversation going! This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit storydeepdive.substack.com

    1h 1m
  5. JAN 25

    Episode 56: Core Story, Ensemble Cast, and Transformation in Mistborn

    Welcome to Story Deep Dive! In this episode, Dana Pittman and Rachel Arsenault wrap up their Mistborn month with an editor’s take episode—pulling the biggest craft lessons from their deeper plot and character breakdowns. Whether you’re a writer, reader, or storyteller, you’ll gain valuable insights on plot management through a core story thread, how to make book one of a trilogy feel standalone, and how to maximize your supporting cast to deepen theme and character transformation. You can also watch the video version of this podcast on YouTube! Estimate Timestamps 00:00 – Welcome Back + Framing the “Editor’s Take” Dana and Rachel kick off by welcoming listeners back to Story Deep Dive and naming the challenge of this episode: distilling multiple rich conversations into a handful of usable takeaways. They keep it light with their usual banter—Dana admits she gets “lost in the sauce,” while Rachel’s “meticulous, copious notes” keep the show on track. 03:00 – February Book Announcement: Before I Let Go by Kennedy Ryan Rachel introduces the next month’s pick: Before I Let Go by Kennedy Ryan. She explains why she chose it—both for craft discussion and for broadening the show’s reading list—highlighting Kennedy Ryan’s success as a hybrid author and the cultural depth often present in African-American romance. Rachel flags key elements: second-chance romance, a divorced couple, co-parenting, and a story that leans heavily into internal transformation and emotional weight. She also notes it may be a “love it or hard pass” read depending on how readers connect with its tone and cultural textures. Notable insight: Rachel shares how the book surprised her emotionally—she expected a vacation romance read and ended up ugly crying—underscoring how powerful emotional setup and thematic depth can be when done well. 18:30 – Returning to Mistborn: Why This Episode Can’t Cover Everything They transition back to the main focus: Mistborn’s editor takeaways. Dana emphasizes that the book is too layered to cover fully here, so the goal is to offer “hooks to hang the information on”—frameworks listeners can use in their own writing and for rereading the novel with sharper craft eyes. 20:30 – Quick Book Recap: The Core Premise of Mistborn Rachel delivers a tight summary: Vin is a skaa surviving under the Lord Ruler’s oppression until Kelsier recruits her for a job that’s bigger than theft—a plan to overthrow (and kill) the Lord Ruler. Vin discovers she’s Mistborn and must learn both the magic and the social performance required to move in noble circles—earning a laugh with the line about learning to be Mistborn “and how to wear a dress.” 22:00 – Takeaway #1: Plot Management Through the Core Story Thread Rachel breaks down one of the biggest lessons from Mistborn: complex stories stay readable when anchored to a clear core story thread. She explains how the inciting incident raises a story question and the climax answers it—creating a clean loop readers can follow even when the narrative has many layers. Key craft focus: Inciting incident raises the question: Will Kelsier’s crew succeed in overthrowing the Lord Ruler? The climax answers it—so the reader feels the story delivered what it promised. Subplots (romance, training, espionage, crew dynamics) complicate the core mission rather than drifting away from it. 27:00 – Takeaway #2: How Book One of a Trilogy Still Reads Like a Standalone Rachel and Dana connect plot management to series strategy: Mistborn is book one of a trilogy, but it still satisfies like a standalone because it closes the loop on the core question. They emphasize reader trust—especially for authors without an established audience. Dana adds a key nuance: the book must do two things at once: Resolve the primary promise so the reader feels satisfied. Keep the protagonist compelling enough that the reader wants to stay in her POV for the next book. This becomes a two-pronged litmus test: closure + continued investment. 33:00 – Takeaway #3: Maximize Your Supporting Cast for Depth + Theme They shift into character craft. Rachel explains that the “heist crew” structure creates built-in cast roles—but Sanderson makes the cast feel real by ensuring every character has a distinct relationship to the world’s oppression, a unique voice, and meaningful thematic weight. Dana expands this into a practical craft lens: the supporting cast doesn’t just fill jobs—they become the mechanism through which Vin’s blind spots are exposed. Her growth happens in active moments, under pressure, without stopping the story for explanatory monologues. The ensemble helps the reader see transformation instead of being told it. Bonus moment: a quick appreciation for narrator Michael Kramer and how his performance (especially as Breeze) adds texture to the listening experience. 45:00 – Internal Arc Power Move: Let the Plot Challenge the Wound Rachel highlights a craft concept that ties everything together: internal transformation becomes inevitable when the plot pressures the protagonist’s wound. They discuss how wounds shape perception, trust, and decision-making—and how writers can reverse engineer this relationship depending on whether they start with plot or character. Dana adds a set of guiding questions writers can use: What belief kept them alive once—but hurts them now? Where do they crave connection—but expect betrayal? Who challenges that belief without “fixing” it for them? The shared point: transformation is earned when the story forces the protagonist to confront the lies they adopted as truth—and learn to trust themselves, not just external saviors. 1:02:00 – “Bookmark These” Craft Lessons: Pivots + Worldbuilding Delivery Dana asks Rachel for two final “bookmark” items to study in Mistborn, and Rachel delivers: Act pivots and escalation: study the inciting incident, midpoint, all-is-lost, and climax—and how each one tips the story into the next act without sagging pacing. Worldbuilding execution: at the line-by-line level, watch how Sanderson balances explanation vs. action, avoids info dumps, and paces the reader’s understanding across the book. 1:07:00 – Closing + What’s Next They close out Mistborn month, invite listener recommendations, and tease next week’s episode: they’re jumping genres—from epic fantasy into romance—with the overview of Before I Let Go. Book Selection Once, a hero arose to save the world. He failed. Ever since, the world has been a wasteland of ash and mist controlled by the immortal emperor known as the Lord Ruler. But hope survives. A new uprising is forming, one built around the ultimate caper, the cunning of a brilliant criminal mastermind, and the determination of an unlikely heroine: a street urchin who must learn to master the power of a Mistborn. Where to Find the Book Mistborn by Brandon Sanderson is available in several formats. It’s also widely available in libraries and online retailers. Details on his website. Next Episode: In the next episode, Dana and Rachel will explore the overview of Before I Let Go by Kennedy Ryan, kicking off a new month of discussion centered on second-chance romance, emotional depth, cultural texture, and layered relationship stakes. Be sure to tune in! Join the Conversation: Like what you heard? Subscribe, leave a review, and share your thoughts. Follow Story Deep Dive on your favorite podcast platform and on YouTube, and connect with Dana and Rachel to keep the craft conversation going. Connect with Dana and Rachel on storydeepdive.com to keep the conversation going! This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit storydeepdive.substack.com

    1h 5m
  6. JAN 18

    Episode 55: Characters, Wounds, and Transformation in Mistborn

    Welcome to Story Deep Dive! In this episode, Dana and Rachel dive into the character craft behind Mistborn—with a spotlight on Vin’s internal arc and how an ensemble cast can serve both plot and transformation. Whether you’re a writer, storyteller, or craft-curious reader, you’ll gain valuable insights on how to dramatize a character’s wound through decisions, how to build an earned arc scene-by-scene, and how to use supporting characters as emotional “vitamins” that develop the protagonist over time. You can also watch the video version of this podcast on YouTube! Estimate Timestamps 00:00 – Welcome Back + Episode Focus: Characters in Mistborn Dana and Rachel kick off the episode by setting expectations: this is a craft-driven character discussion, not a full recap. They frame the goal as pulling out practical “gems” writers can apply—especially around internal change and why character design matters across a trilogy. 01:00 – Rachel’s Update: Story Cypher Academy + Brainstorming as a Skill Rachel shares what’s happening inside Story Cypher as a new Academy cohort begins. She highlights the value of guided brainstorming—moving from wide-open possibilities to a narrowed, plottable concept—and how new students benefit from returning Fellows who provide perspective, mentorship, and “I wish I’d done this sooner” wisdom. 05:20 – Dana’s Update: Writing-to-Market Community Energy + YouTube Nerves Dana talks about planning for the year and how a community shifts when writers are actively publishing—craft conversations become marketplace conversations. She also shares her personal stretch goal: posting weekly on YouTube under her name and giving herself permission to teach in her natural style (longer-form, question-driven, less over-edited), even if it feels vulnerable. 14:40 – Book Setup: Vin, Kelsier, and the Heist That Could Change Everything Rachel gives a clean summary of the premise: Vin is a skaa thief surviving under the Lord Ruler’s oppression until Kelsier recruits her for an impossible job. She discovers she’s Mistborn—and the mission isn’t just theft, it’s overthrow. The story blends training, infiltration, and escalating stakes that force Vin to evolve quickly. 16:10 – The Two Big Character Buckets: Vin’s Arc + The Ensemble Cast Rachel lays out the episode roadmap: first, Vin’s internal arc and how Sanderson shows it through choice rather than exposition; second, the secondary characters and why the crew is built so effectively for both this book and the series. 19:30 – Vin’s Wound on the Page: Trust, Betrayal, and Decision-Making Under Pressure Rachel breaks down Vin’s pain point—betrayal and the inability to trust—and how the plot is engineered to challenge it constantly. Rather than having Vin narrate her trauma, the story forces her into micro-decisions: speak up or stay silent, connect or withdraw, risk trust or protect herself. The result is an earned, believable arc because the reader watches her shift scene by scene instead of flipping a switch at the end. Notable craft insight: internal arcs land harder when the wound is demonstrated through behavior, not explained in monologue. 23:30 – Dana’s Lens: “Why This Character, Why Now” + The Act One Invitation Dana highlights how Vin’s survival mindset shapes every interaction—her “requirements to exist” are painfully low at the start. She points out how the story plants possibility early: Vin can keep surviving… or step into something bigger. That “you could be / you could do” invitation is classic Act One fuel, because the reader can see the future self before Vin can. 29:40 – Ensemble Craft: A Big Cast That’s Clean, Purposeful, and Series-Ready Rachel explains why the heist framework makes the large cast feel natural: specialists are required. She also notes the smart pacing choice—most secondary characters remain relatively static in Book 1 so the reader can truly learn them, because later books will ask those characters to carry more weight. Dana expands this into a key takeaway: the crew doesn’t only serve the heist plot—they also serve Vin’s emotional development. Each character brings a different kind of pressure, model, or perspective that pushes her toward who she must become. 33:10 – “Character Vitamins”: Supporting Characters as Tools for Transformation Dana introduces one of the episode’s signature concepts: the supporting cast functions like “vitins”—each member provides something Vin is missing (language, belonging, confidence, trust practice, identity expansion). What starts as “teach me my powers so I can survive” becomes “teach me who I can be.” 41:20 – Elend and the Romantic Thread: A Mirror for Who Vin Is Becoming Dana explains why the romantic subplot matters beyond romance: Elend gives Vin space away from the crew’s structure so the reader can see her emerging personality—sass, softness, curiosity, self-definition. Rachel ties this to the larger arc: through Elend, Vin starts forming her own opinions rather than inheriting them from Kelsier. 46:10 – Series Arc Strategy: Book One Must Create the Protagonist Book Two Requires Rachel shares a practical series-planning principle: at the end of Book 1, the protagonist must become the version of themselves capable of entering Book 2’s escalation. Vin can’t remain the hiding, mistrusting outsider; she must clear that hurdle so the next conflict level is plausible. The internal arc climbs the same way the external stakes climb. 50:20 – Selling the Change: Why “Scene-by-Scene Shifts” Make the Ending Earned Rachel and Dana close the craft discussion by reinforcing the key technique: the transformation is believable because we watch Vin’s thought patterns and decisions evolve under repeated pressure. Dana connects this to try/fail learning—Vin adapts based on outcomes—so her growth feels like a lived process, not a late-story announcement. Book Selection Once, a hero arose to save the world. He failed. Ever since, the world has been a wasteland of ash and mist controlled by the immortal emperor known as the Lord Ruler. But hope survives. A new uprising is forming, one built around the ultimate caper, the cunning of a brilliant criminal mastermind, and the determination of an unlikely heroine: a street urchin who must learn to master the power of a Mistborn. Where to Find the Book Mistborn by Brandon Sanderson is available in several formats. It’s also widely available in libraries and online retailers. Details on his website. Next Episode: In the next episode, Dana and Rachel will explore editor takeaways from Mistborn—pulling craft lessons writers can apply immediately, and zooming out to the big-picture techniques that make the story feel cohesive, powerful, and binge-ready. Be sure to tune in! Join the Conversation: Like what you heard? Subscribe, leave a review, and share your thoughts. Follow Story Deep Dive on your favorite podcast platform and on YouTube, and connect with Dana and Rachel to keep the craft conversation going. Connect with Dana and Rachel on storydeepdive.com to keep the conversation going! This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit storydeepdive.substack.com

    1h 8m
  7. JAN 11

    Episode 54: What Mistborn Teaches Writers About Structure, Stakes, and Series Power

    Welcome to Story Deep Dive! In this episode, Dana and Rachel dive into the plot architecture of Mistborn—without spoiling the big reveals. Whether you’re a fantasy writer, romance writer, or storytelling nerd who loves structure, you’ll walk away with practical insight on plot management, how to make subplots do double duty, and how to write Book 1 of a trilogy that still feels satisfying as a standalone. You can also watch the video version of this podcast on YouTube! Estimate Timestamps 0:00 – Welcome Back + 2026 Reading Kickoff Dana and Rachel open the episode by setting the tone: Story Deep Dive is a craft-forward podcast where they discuss books “as writers,” not just as readers. They introduce their 2026 reading slate and confirm this episode will focus on Mistborn plot—but intentionally “around it” to avoid spoilers. Dana jokes she’s riding shotgun because this is one of Rachel’s primary teaching books. 1:20 – Story Cypher Updates: The Academy + The New Fellows Program Rachel shares what’s happening at Story Cypher: after a successful beta cohort, the Academy is returning with improvements built from last year’s lessons. She also introduces the Fellows Program, an invitation-only community for graduates where they shift from foundational drafting and process to deeper craft skills like dialogue, exposition, and fine-tuning—without trying to master advanced techniques before a draft even exists. Notable insight: The program structure reinforces a key creative principle—separate writer brain and editor brain so each can do its job. 6:00 – Dana Asks Rachel: What Does It Feel Like After the First Cohort? Dana puts Rachel on the spot with a heartfelt question about what it’s like to cross the finish line of the first cohort and step into the next phase. Rachel shares how proud she is of the work—especially building curriculum while simultaneously writing and recording her own full project. She highlights the transformation of writers who’d been stuck for years finally moving forward with completed drafts and a clear plan. Notable quote energy: “I gave absolutely everything I had to that beta run.” 10:30 – Dana’s 2026 Focus: Real-Life Planning, Inner Circle, and Book Club Strategy Dana shares how her current Inner Circle and one-on-one work is being shaped by a powerful retreat realization: writers often “fail” plans because the plan was never built around real life capacity. She explains her lens of identifying whether someone is maintaining, scaling, or building foundations, then creating plans that fit that season. Dana also explains the evolution of her book club selection strategy—balancing “tried and true” craft titles with chart-aware reads that keep conversations fresh and relevant. 14:40 – Why Dana Won’t Overlap Book Club Reading With Personal Reading Rachel catches a pattern: Dana is choosing not to overlap personal reading with book club picks—meaning more reading. Dana explains that because she’s doing deeper “deep dives,” she wants her thinking to remain untainted until she’s fully formed her own conclusions. She describes her mind as a “sponge” and doesn’t want outside opinions filling in her open loops too soon. 18:10 – Mistborn Summary (Spoiler-Light) + Why This Book Rewards Rereads Rachel delivers a clean, non-spoilery summary of the setup: Vin, a skaa thief, is recruited by Kelsier—only to discover her “luck” is something more. The job isn’t just a heist; it’s an attempt to overthrow the Lord Ruler. Dana notes this is her third read and emphasizes that books like Mistborn are the kind you reread when they’re a comp or craft reference because the layering is so dense. 21:00 – Plot Management: The Core Plot Spine + Nested Subplots That Matter Rachel teaches why Mistborn is a “plotter’s dream,” especially for fantasy writers trying to manage multiple threads without the story sprawling. She breaks down the craft move: Identify the inciting incident Ask what story question it raises Ensure the climax answers that question Then build subplots so they influence and are influenced by the core plot She uses Vin’s Mistborn training arc and the romantic subplot with Elend Venture as examples of subplots that don’t distract—they actively complicate the mission and heighten stakes. Key takeaway: When plot threads are properly nested, every scene feels like it matters. 28:30 – Book 1 in a Trilogy: Close the Loop, Crack the Door Dana and Rachel dig into the difference between a trilogy installment and a serial cliffhanger. They emphasize that Book 1 must still feel like a satisfying standalone experience, even while it launches a larger arc. Rachel highlights the danger of ending without answering the core story question—especially in long books—because it can feel antagonistic instead of compelling. Dana adds that trilogies are “advanced mode” because you’re multiplying structure and payoff across three books, which requires clarity about what belongs in Book 1 versus what should carry forward. Key takeaway: Answer the Book 1 question—then let the implications create the momentum for Book 2. 35:10 – Draft Reality: This Level of Tightness Comes From Iteration Rachel offers an important craft reality check: we’re looking at a polished, battle-tested book, and this kind of integration usually emerges across multiple drafts. She explains how early drafts often separate threads into separate scenes, and revision is where writers learn to merge threads so scenes do “double duty.” Dana adds nuance: heavy plotters can get closer on draft one because their plotting functions like a draft, but the core point remains—know your process and give yourself grace. 40:10 – Rules as Guardrails: Hard vs. Soft Magic Systems (and Why It Works Here) Dana introduces her favorite plot-adjacent takeaway: Mistborn is deeply rule-based, and those rules shape everything—magic, class structure, economics, power, and consequences. She contrasts this with stories where rules are vague or the protagonist is an exception to everything, which reduces tension. Rachel ties this to the craft concept of hard vs. soft magic systems. Mistborn is a hallmark of hard magic: clear constraints, consistent rules, and creative problem-solving within boundaries. She also highlights a key technique: Sanderson often shows the magic through plot before explaining it, so explanations land as answers to questions the reader already has—rather than an info dump. Key takeaway: Rules create trust, tension, and payoff, because the reader knows the author isn’t cheating. 47:20 – Build Your World From the Thing That Excites You Most Rachel closes with a practical strategy for fantasy writers (and honestly, any writer building a complex story): start with the element that excites you most and follow the cause-and-effect chain. Ask what that concept would change about governance, economics, warfare, society, and character behavior. Done well, your world “blooms” outward in believable ways and generates plot fuel. Dana agrees, calling this note-taking and mapping process “gold” you’ll return to later—especially when building a trilogy. Book Selection Once, a hero arose to save the world. He failed. Ever since, the world has been a wasteland of ash and mist controlled by the immortal emperor known as the Lord Ruler. But hope survives. A new uprising is forming, one built around the ultimate caper, the cunning of a brilliant criminal mastermind, and the determination of an unlikely heroine: a street urchin who must learn to master the power of a Mistborn. Where to Find the Book Mistborn by Brandon Sanderson is available in several formats. It’s also widely available in libraries and online retailers. Details on his website. Next Episode: In the next episode, Dana and Rachel will explore Mistborn through character—including how relationship dynamics and character growth are woven so tightly into the plot that separating the two is nearly impossible. Be sure to tune in! Join the Conversation: Like what you heard? Subscribe, leave a review, and share your thoughts. Follow Story Deep Dive on your favorite podcast platform and on YouTube, and connect with Dana and Rachel to keep the craft conversation going. Connect with Dana and Rachel on storydeepdive.com to keep the conversation going! This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit storydeepdive.substack.com

    1h 13m
  8. JAN 4

    Episode 53: How to Build an Addictive Trilogy: Plot and Promise in Mistborn

    Welcome to Story Deep Dive! In this first episode of 2026, Dana and Rachel kick off their January book pick—Mistborn by Brandon Sanderson—with a craft-focused overview designed for writers who want to study why a story works, not just enjoy the ride. Whether you’re a fantasy writer, romance writer, or story-obsessed reader, you’ll walk away with insights on four-act structure and escalating stakes, how a “heist frame” can power a rebellion plot, and how to introduce a big ensemble cast without overwhelming your reader. You can also watch the video version of this podcast on YouTube! Estimate Timestamps 00:00 – Welcome Back + New Year Kickoff Dana welcomes listeners back to Story Deep Dive and sets the tone: bookish besties + editors + coaches breaking stories down like writers. They reveal the first pick of the year—Mistborn—and tease that January is always a “go hard” month for the show. 01:10 – Holiday Reads + What They’ve Been Reading Rachel shares her holiday reading recap, including a standout comp read (The Fox Wife) and reflections on noir craft via Devil in a Blue Dress. Dana shares her own reading updates, including Fourth Wing and several nonfiction reads related to YouTube as she ramps up for a busy quarter. 08:30 – Building the 2026 Reading List + “Pearl-Clutching” Banter They talk about finalizing their 2026 reading list, including Dana’s process of sampling books and rejecting picks that don’t meet the “Story Deep Dive” standard. The conversation turns playful when they reference intense books (and Dana’s tolerance levels), joking about easing into wilder picks “maybe in 2027.” 10:35 – Why January Picks Go Hard + Introducing Mistborn Dana and Rachel joke about who should pick January next year, then pivot into why they chose Mistborn as the first study of 2026: it’s big, layered, and packed with craft lessons—especially for writers building plot-heavy stories. 12:05 – Spoiler-Light Summary: What Mistborn Is About Rachel gives a quick, clean setup: Vin, a skaa thief surviving under the Lord Ruler’s brutal empire, is recruited by Kelsier—and discovers her “luck” is something more. The job isn’t just theft… it’s revolution. Notable moment: Rachel jokes that Vin must learn how to be a Mistborn… “and how to wear a dress.” 13:20 – Episode Caveat: What This Overview Will (and Won’t) Cover They set expectations: Mistborn has too much depth to cover in one episode. Rachel notes they will discuss the magic system, but more through the lens of how plot reveals worldbuilding rather than doing a full technical breakdown. 16:10 – Four-Act Structure + The Power of a Core Story Thread Rachel explains why she uses Mistborn as a teaching text for four-act structure: it has a clear central plot question(overthrowing the Lord Ruler) and a clean escalation of stakes across acts. She highlights how subplots and complications feed the core mission instead of distracting from it. Key insight: Strong pacing comes from tracking one central story thread and escalating pressure against it. 19:35 – “Heist-Flavored Rebellion”: What Makes the Plot Feel Fresh Rachel breaks down the innovation: Sanderson uses the heist framework (specialists, roles, planning, execution problems) to drive what is fundamentally a rebellion story. Dana adds that this combination gives readers a familiar “container” for expectations while delivering it in an original way. Key takeaway: Take a classic story engine and “flavor” it with another genre’s structure to create something fresh. 22:10 – Book One in a Trilogy: Deliver on This Book, Earn Book Two They discuss how Mistborn works as a complete story while still setting up the trilogy. Rachel reinforces the principle: the best way to sell book two is to write a strong book one—no bait-and-switch endings, no “read the sequel to get the real payoff.” Key insight: Close the loop on the main promise of this book, then let the ending raise new questions naturally. 25:20 – Ensemble Cast: How to Introduce Many Characters Without Confusing Readers Rachel explains how Sanderson layers character introductions across chapters—adding one or two at a time so readers can anchor names, personalities, and roles. Dana notes the heist structure helps because each character is tied to a job, skillset, and story function, making them easier to remember and more distinct. Key takeaway: Readers remember characters faster when they have multiple anchors: role, personality, relationship to the protagonist, and purpose in the mission. 30:10 – Training Scenes + Worldbuilding That Multitasks Rachel highlights how Mistborn avoids long, repetitive training sequences. Instead, the magic is introduced in layers: overview → action in the story → deeper training later. This keeps worldbuilding scenes from becoming info dumps and ensures they still move plot forward. Key insight: In books, training scenes must multitask—show growth, reveal rules, and advance the story. 34:10 – Vin’s Internal Lens: “Who She Is vs. Who She Can Become” Dana calls out one of the most helpful lenses for writers studying Mistborn: Vin begins as an observer and survivor, and every challenge pressures the gap between her current identity and her potential. Kelsier introduces the possibility early, and the story keeps rubbing that tension until she changes. Key takeaway: Transformation is clearest when the story constantly pressures the distance between “now self” and “future self.” 37:20 – Craft Encouragement: Masterworks Take Time Rachel closes by reminding writers that Mistborn wasn’t Sanderson’s first draft—or his first book. They encourage listeners not to compare their first drafts to a polished, edited masterwork, but to use the episode as inspiration and a roadmap for skill-building over time. About Mistborn Author: Brandon Sanderson Once, a hero arose to save the world. He failed. Ever since, the world has been a wasteland of ash and mist controlled by the immortal emperor known as the Lord Ruler. But hope survives. A new uprising is forming, one built around the ultimate caper, the cunning of a brilliant criminal mastermind, and the determination of an unlikely heroine: a street urchin who must learn to master the power of a Mistborn. Where to Find the Book Mistborn by Brandon Sanderson is available in several formats. It’s also widely available in libraries and online retailers. Details on his website. Next Episode: In the next episode, Dana and Rachel will dive into plot—including how Mistborn maintains momentum through a central story thread, escalates complications across acts, and uses the heist frame to keep the rebellion storyline tight and propulsive. Be sure to tune in! Join the Conversation: Like what you heard? Subscribe, leave a review, and share your thoughts. Follow Story Deep Dive on your favorite podcast platform and connect with Dana and Rachel to keep the discussion going—then grab the book and read along with us as we break down Mistborn over the next three episodes! Connect with Dana and Rachel on storydeepdive.com to keep the conversation going! This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit storydeepdive.substack.com

    1h 6m

Ratings & Reviews

5
out of 5
6 Ratings

About

Join editor and USA Today bestselling author Dana Pittman and developmental editor Rachel Arsenault for a weekly deep dive into great novels. storydeepdive.substack.com