Wickedly Judged

Rebecca Watkins

What if the system meant to protect us is the one that fails us the most? Wickedly Judged is a true crime podcast exposing wrongful convictions, broken justice, and the people whose lives are forever changed by the system. Hosted by Rebecca, the show dives deep into real cases and the human stories behind them — the families, the loved ones, and the empty seats that are never forgotten. Inspired by her husband’s wrongful conviction, Rebecca brings truth, heart, and fearless advocacy to every episode. This is more than a podcast — it’s a mission, a voice for the unheard, and a fight for justice reform.

  1. Nov 11

    For Two Hours, They Were Veterans

    Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode! For Two Hours, They Were Veterans Wickedly Judged | Veterans Day Special 2026 Their circumstances may have changed. Their service never did. On November 10, 2026, something extraordinary happened inside Warren Correctional Institution in Ohio. For two hours, incarcerated veterans gathered to honor their military service, surrounded by the families who love and support them. For those two hours, the focus wasn't on their convictions, sentences, or prison uniforms. It was on the men who once raised their right hands and swore an oath to defend the United States Constitution. In this deeply personal Veterans Day episode of Wickedly Judged, host Rebecca shares her experience attending the ceremony and witnessing the pride, dignity, and camaraderie of veterans who are too often overlooked. But these veterans aren't simply remembering their years of military service. The veterans group at Warren Correctional Institution is actively organizing fundraisers to support organizations that assist fellow veterans, demonstrating that their commitment to helping others continues beyond prison walls. Rebecca also shares personal tributes to the veterans in her own family, including her husband, Johnny Ray Watkins, a U.S. Army veteran currently incarcerated in Ohio; her late father, a U.S. Air Force veteran whom she describes as the greatest man she ever knew; her brother Bill; and her brothers-in-law Craig and John. Special Recognition and Appreciation A heartfelt thank-you to Warden Brian Baker for allowing the Veterans Day ceremony to take place and welcoming the veterans' families to participate in this meaningful occasion. Special appreciation also goes to Lieutenant Godyke, Officer Briggs, and the staff at Warren Correctional Institution who helped organize, facilitate, and participate in the celebration. And to the members of Warren's veterans group: thank you for continuing to serve your fellow veterans through your fundraising and charitable efforts. In This Episode A firsthand account of the November 10 Veterans Day celebration at Warren Correctional Institution.The importance of recognizing military service among incarcerated veterans.How Warren's veterans group is raising funds to help veteran-support organizations.The significance of allowing families to participate in ceremonies honoring their loved ones.Rebecca's personal tribute to her husband, father, brother, and brothers-in-law.Why honoring military service and recognizing accountability are not mutually exclusive.A reminder that veterans deserve dignity, recognition, and appropriate support regardless of their circumstances.A Message Worth Remembering “A prison uniform does not erase the military uniform someone once wore.” This Veterans Day, we honor every man and woman who answered the call to serve, including those whose service is too often forgotten. To all veterans, their families, and those who made the ultimate sacrifice: thank you. Happy Veterans Day from Wickedly Judged. Connect With Wickedly Judged Follow, subscribe, and share this episode to help bring awareness to incarcerated veterans and the importance of recognizing their service. If this episode resonates with you, share it with a veteran, military family, or someone who believes that service and sacrifice deserve to be remembered. Hashtags #WickedlyJudged #VeteransDay2026 #VeteransDay #IncarceratedVeterans #HonorOurVeterans #VeteransSupportingVeterans #MilitaryService #VeteranAdvocacy #USArmy #USAirForce #BeyondPrisonWalls #JusticeAdvocacy #NeverForgotten

    For Two Hours, They Were Veterans
  2. Oct 8

    They Said No. We’re Not Done: Where Johnny’s Case Goes From Here

    Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode! They Said No. We’re Not Done. | Johnny Watkins Case Update On September 29, 2026, the Ohio Supreme Court declined jurisdiction in Johnny Watkins’ case. But what does that actually mean? It does not mean the Court reviewed all of the evidence and determined Johnny’s conviction was sound. It means the Court declined to hear that appeal. And we’re not done. In this solo episode of Wickedly Judged, Rebecca gives an update on Johnny’s case after more than 21 years of incarceration and explains where the fight goes from here. Over the past several years, records obtained through public-records requests have raised serious questions about the investigation and evidence presented in Johnny’s case. Rebecca discusses: • The Ohio Supreme Court’s decision to decline jurisdiction • What that decision does—and does not—mean • Pretrial testimony concerning who possessed the knife • Changing and conflicting witness accounts • Statements concerning the washing of hands and disposal of the knife • Questions raised by witness interrogations • The interrogation of a 16-year-old witness • DNA testing that found no blood on Johnny’s tested shoes or socks • Other clothing that was not tested • Records that surfaced years after the conviction • The importance of the records-request timeline • Ohio Criminal Rule 33 and newly discovered evidence • What “unavoidably prevented” means • What happens next in Johnny’s fight for a new trial Rebecca also talks about the personal side of this fight—being Johnny’s wife while also becoming his advocate and learning to separate emotion from evidence. “I don’t want you to believe Johnny is innocent because I love him. Look at the evidence. Read the documents. Listen to the interrogations. Compare the statements. Ask the same questions I’m asking.” The question now is simple: How can someone discover evidence they were never told existed? The Ohio Supreme Court said no to this appeal. The evidence didn’t disappear. And we’re not done.

    They Said No. We’re Not Done: Where Johnny’s Case Goes From Here
  3. Oct 1

    DNA Excluded Him. He Still Spent 16 Years in Prison| Jeff Deskovic

    Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode! DNA Excluded Him. He Still Spent 16 Years in Prison | Jeff Deskovic DNA evidence excluded Jeffrey Deskovic before trial, yet he was convicted as a teenager and spent 16 years in prison for a crime he did not commit. In this episode of Wickedly Judged, Rebecca talks with Jeff about becoming a suspect at 16, the interrogation that led to his false confession, and how a confession outweighed DNA evidence that excluded him. At 17, Jeff was convicted and sentenced to 15 years to life in an adult maximum-security prison. Jeff shares how faith, studying the law, and learning about other exonerations helped him keep fighting through years of failed appeals. Eventually, the Innocence Project took his case. DNA testing produced a database match identifying the actual perpetrator and helped secure Jeff’s freedom. Jeff then turned his experience into advocacy. He became an attorney and founded the Jeffrey Deskovic Foundation for Justice, using part of his compensation to help others fighting wrongful convictions. IN THIS EPISODE: • Jeff’s interrogation & false confession • DNA evidence that excluded him • Being convicted at 17 • Surviving 16 years in prison • The DNA match that led to his exoneration • Becoming an attorney & advocate • Starting the Deskovic Foundation • Seeking help for wrongful-conviction cases • Why legal guidance matters with new evidence • Non-DNA innocence cases • Post-conviction barriers & reform • Jeff’s support for Pete Wlasiuk • Podcasts, documentaries & public advocacy • Accountability & preventing wrongful convictions • What Jeff would tell his 16-year-old self CONNECT WITH JEFF: Foundation: https://www.deskovicfoundation.org/ Donate: https://www.deskovicfoundation.org/donate Jeff Deskovic: https://www.Deskovic.org/ Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/Deskovic Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/jeffrey.deskovic Foundation Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/thejeffreydeskovicfoundation Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/deskovicfoundation/ LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/jeffreydeskovic/ Innocence Project: https://innocenceproject.org/cases/jeffrey-deskovic/ WICKEDLY JUDGED: Episodes, advocacy & merchandise: https://www.wickedlyjudged.com/ Subscribe to Wickedly Judged and share this episode to help amplify the stories of people fighting wrongful convictions. Join the conversation: What change discussed in this episode could make the biggest difference in preventing wrongful convictions? Content Note: Discussion of sexual violence, murder, wrongful imprisonment & suicidal thoughts. Discussion of disputed cases or evidence reflects the speakers’ accounts and perspectives.

    DNA Excluded Him. He Still Spent 16 Years in Prison| Jeff Deskovic
  4. Sep 24

    The Judge's Oath Podcast Guest interview

    Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode! Rebecca Watkins, founder of Wickedly Judged and president of the Wickedly Judged Justice Activation Project, joins Cheryl Kelmar on The Judge’s Oath Podcast to share the personal fight that sparked her advocacy. Rebecca discusses her husband’s conviction—which she maintains is wrongful—and the years spent reviewing records, seeking answers, and fighting to have his case heard. She explains how that experience grew into a podcast and an organization supporting other families facing similar struggles. Together, Rebecca and Cheryl discuss: • Their questions about the Tyler Robinson case and media coverage surrounding the killing of Charlie Kirk. • The influence of social media on public opinion and fair trials. • Plea-deal pressure, costly legal representation, and barriers to appeals. • Access to case files, missing records, and concerns about withheld evidence. • Judicial accountability and independent review of innocence claims. • Better resources for public defenders, prison education, and rehabilitation. Rebecca also shares how faith sustains her, her plans for advocacy education, and her book project, Wickedly Judged: Buried Evidence. Learn more, get involved, or support the work: https://www.wickedlyjudged.com Original interview: The Judge’s Oath Podcast, Episode 006, hosted by Cheryl Kelmar and published by PodCast by Kelmar Publishing LLC. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Zm3Aat-WLTQ This episode includes personal experiences, opinions, and disputed allegations expressed by the speakers.

    The Judge's Oath Podcast Guest interview
  5. Sep 17

    Heather Wlasiuk: The Woman Behind the Fight for Pete

    Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode! Heather Wlasiuk: The Woman Behind the Fight for Pete In this special episode of Wickedly Judged, we sit down with Heather Wlasiuk for a conversation focused on her perspective, her advocacy, and what it means to stand beside someone while fighting a conviction that has already spanned more than two decades. Throughout our coverage of the Peter Wlasiuk case, we have examined a complicated legal history: three trials, two overturned convictions, disputed evidence, questions surrounding Patricia Wlasiuk's diary, and a third conviction that continues to keep Pete incarcerated. But court opinions and evidence only tell part of the story. Behind every wrongful-conviction claim are families and loved ones who live with the consequences of the criminal justice system every single day. In this interview, the focus turns to Heather. We hear from the woman who continues to advocate for Pete, stand beside him, and push for people to look beyond the conviction and examine the questions surrounding his case. Heather shares her perspective on the fight for Pete, what she has experienced while advocating for him, and why she refuses to allow his case to simply be forgotten. This conversation also highlights something that can easily get lost when discussing trials, appeals, evidence, and court decisions: the human cost of incarceration extends far beyond the person sitting in the prison cell. Families serve this time too. They make the phone calls. They research the case. They attend visits. They advocate. They answer questions. They face criticism. And sometimes, they spend years trying to convince someone—anyone—to take another look. Pete's case has already been through three trials and two reversals. For Heather, however, those numbers represent something much more personal. They represent years of fighting, waiting, hoping, and refusing to give up. At Wickedly Judged, we believe it is important to hear directly from the people living these cases—not only attorneys, investigators, and experts, but the families standing beside those who maintain their innocence. This is Heather's opportunity to tell that side of the story. Listen to her perspective. Examine the case. Ask the questions. Then decide for yourself. The Peter Wlasiuk case continues. And so does Heather's fight for answers.

    Heather Wlasiuk: The Woman Behind the Fight for Pete
  6. Sep 10

    Pete & Heather Wlasiuk: Questions Remain — Part 4

    Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode! Pete & Heather Wlasiuk: Questions Remain — Part 4 Was justice served in the Peter Wlasiuk case—or are we still missing part of the truth? In Part 4 of our continuing interview with Pete and Heather Wlasiuk, we go deeper into a case that has now been questioned and litigated for more than two decades. Patricia Wlasiuk died in April 2002 after Pete's truck entered Guilford Lake in New York. Prosecutors ultimately alleged that Pete killed Patricia and staged the scene to look like an accident. Pete has maintained his innocence throughout his incarceration. But the history of this case is anything but simple. Pete has been tried three times for the same murder. His first conviction was reversed after the appellate court concluded that the cumulative effect of numerous errors deprived him of a fair trial. His second conviction was also reversed, this time after the court found that Pete had received ineffective assistance of counsel. During the second trial, Patricia's diary became particularly significant. Information from diary entries previously ruled inadmissible appeared in a police evidence log given to the jury. When jurors asked whether they could consider those entries as evidence, defense counsel failed to request a limiting instruction. The appellate decision records that less than ten minutes later, the jury reached its verdict. Jurors subsequently reported that the diary entries caused some of them to change their votes to guilty. Pete was tried a third time in 2012 and again convicted of second-degree murder. That conviction was later affirmed. In Part 4 Pete and Heather continue discussing: The evidence and circumstances they believe deserve another examinationPete's perspective from inside the caseQuestions surrounding the investigation and prosecutionThe significance of errors identified during his previous trialsThe continuing effort to challenge Pete's convictionWhat it means to fight for innocence after decades of incarcerationHeather's advocacy and determination to keep Pete's case from being forgottenThe human cost behind years of appeals, court decisions, and legal battlesThree trials. Two convictions overturned. More than two decades of incarceration. And questions that Pete and Heather say still have not been answered. At Wickedly Judged, we believe a verdict should never prevent us from examining the evidence, the investigation, and the process that produced it. Listen to Pete and Heather. Look at the documented history of this case. Ask the difficult questions. Then decide for yourself. Was justice served in the Peter Wlasiuk case—or are we still missing part of the truth?

    Pete & Heather Wlasiuk: Questions Remain — Part 4
  7. Sep 3

    Pete & Heather Wlasiuk: The Fight for the Truth Continues — Part 3

    Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode! Pete & Heather Wlasiuk: The Fight for the Truth Continues — Part 3 In Part 3 of our conversation with Pete and Heather Wlasiuk, we continue digging into the questions surrounding Pete's conviction and what they believe has been overlooked, misunderstood, or misrepresented throughout the case. Patricia Wlasiuk died in April 2002 after a vehicle entered Guilford Lake in New York. Prosecutors alleged that Pete murdered Patricia and staged the scene to appear accidental. Pete has maintained his innocence for more than two decades. This case has already resulted in three trials and two overturned convictions, but Pete and Heather's fight did not end with the third verdict. In this episode, the conversation moves beyond simply asking what happened that night. We look at how the case was investigated, how evidence was interpreted, what was presented to juries, and the enormous difficulty of challenging a conviction once the criminal justice system has decided who it believes is responsible. Pete and Heather also discuss the human side of this fight—the years that cannot be returned, the effect incarceration has had on their family, and what it takes to continue advocating when the legal battle has lasted for decades. In This Episode We discuss: Pete's perspective on the investigation and prosecutionEvidence and circumstances Pete believes support his innocenceQuestions surrounding the state's theory of the caseThe way evidence and investigative conclusions were presentedThe continuing significance of Pete's previous overturned convictionsThe challenges of fighting a conviction from inside prisonHeather's advocacy and determination to keep Pete's case visibleThe personal cost of more than two decades of incarcerationWhy Pete and Heather continue fighting for another examination of the caseThree trials. Two overturned convictions. More than twenty years behind bars. For Pete and Heather, this case is not simply part of the past. It is a fight that continues every day. At Wickedly Judged, we believe cases like Pete's deserve more than a surface-level examination. We look at the evidence, the inconsistencies, the court record, and the questions that remain after the verdict. We aren't asking you to blindly accept anyone's version of events. Listen. Examine the evidence. Ask the questions. Then decide for yourself. Was justice truly served in the Peter Wlasiuk case—or are there still answers waiting to be uncovered?

    Pete & Heather Wlasiuk: The Fight for the Truth Continues — Part 3
  8. Aug 27

    The Peter Wlasiuk Case: Pete and Heather Continue Their Story

    Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode! The Peter Wlasiuk Case: Pete and Heather Continue Their Story In this continuation of our interview, Pete and Heather Wlasiuk discuss the case that has kept Pete incarcerated for more than two decades and the continuing fight to challenge his conviction. Patricia Wlasiuk died after a vehicle entered Guilford Lake in New York in April 2002. Prosecutors alleged that Pete murdered Patricia and staged the scene to resemble an accident. Pete has consistently maintained his innocence. His case has involved three trials and two overturned convictions, yet many of the questions surrounding the investigation and the evidence remain unresolved. During this conversation, Pete and Heather offer a personal perspective on the case, the years of litigation, and the impact that Pete’s incarceration has had on their lives and family. They also discuss the difficulty of continuing to fight a conviction after the courts have repeatedly revisited the case. Questions surrounding Patricia’s diary remain central to the history of Pete’s prosecution. Portions of the diary were introduced during the first trial, but the conviction was later overturned after an appellate court found that prejudicial and inadmissible material had reached the jury. Diary information resurfaced during the second trial through a police evidence log. A juror later explained that the information influenced deliberations and helped persuade jurors who had initially been unwilling to convict. Pete’s second conviction was also overturned. Pete was tried for a third time in 2012 and convicted of second-degree murder. In This Episode We continue examining: Pete’s account of the case and his convictionHeather’s efforts to advocate for PeteThe personal consequences of more than two decades of incarcerationThe three trials and two overturned convictionsPatricia’s diary and its influence on the proceedingsQuestions about how evidence was documented and presentedThe difference between police interpretations and forensic findingsThe ongoing legal and public fight for answersWhy Pete and Heather continue to maintain that he was wrongfully convictedPete’s case raises difficult questions about the reliability of a verdict when evidence has been improperly admitted, misunderstood, or presented in a way that may give it more authority than it deserves. How many times should a person have to be tried before the public begins asking whether the process itself has become part of the problem? At Wickedly Judged, we examine the evidence, the disputed facts, and the voices of those directly affected. We do not ask you to accept one version of the story without question. We ask you to listen, examine the record, and decide for yourself. Was justice served in the Peter Wlasiuk case—or has the full truth still not been heard?

    The Peter Wlasiuk Case: Pete and Heather Continue Their Story
4.2
out of 5
5 Ratings

About

What if the system meant to protect us is the one that fails us the most? Wickedly Judged is a true crime podcast exposing wrongful convictions, broken justice, and the people whose lives are forever changed by the system. Hosted by Rebecca, the show dives deep into real cases and the human stories behind them — the families, the loved ones, and the empty seats that are never forgotten. Inspired by her husband’s wrongful conviction, Rebecca brings truth, heart, and fearless advocacy to every episode. This is more than a podcast — it’s a mission, a voice for the unheard, and a fight for justice reform.