Guilty or Great: Movies on Trial

Guilty or Great
  • 5.0 (6)
  • FILM REVIEWS

Where a courtroom gimmick meets the parking lot after a late night movie at the theater... Join our current roster of judges [Abe, Austin, JC, Jordan, Michael, and Tyler] as they discuss what they're watching, current movie news at the time of recording, and make sure stick around for the main show of 'Movies on Trial' where 3 judges will present their defendants with a discussion to be had for each movie, followed by the next 3 judges presenting their defendants.

  1. (2.2) The 1st Annual 'Guilty or Great' Swaggies

    FEB 10

    (2.2) The 1st Annual 'Guilty or Great' Swaggies

    Our very own award show brought to you by the refreshing taste of Breathable Air(TM) and honoring the namesake of the valiant heroism of one Bob Lee Swagger from Antoine Fuqua's seminal actioner, "Shooter".

    46 min

  2. JAN 28

    (2.1) The 2026 Virtual Sundance Preview

    A few of our judges are back and ready to discuss our most desired flicks of the Sundance Film Festival when we gather together at the end of the month to screen a ton of upcoming movies from new filmmakers, established artists, and hopefully some big surprises throughout! What movie are you most looking forward to out of the 2026 Sundance Film Festival???

    1h 3m

  3. JAN 8

    (1.31) Guilty or Great Presents: The 2025 Swaggy Nominees

    Our year in review for 2025 is still cooking behind-the-scenes, so enjoy us playing "Oscars dress-up" with our own award show, the Guilty or Great: Swaggy* Awards. The main awards will arrive in a week's time, so catch up with all of the nominees before then... *yes we named the awards after 'Shooter'

    54 min

  4. 12/31/2025

    (1.30) Wake Up Dead Man; Christy; A Big Bold Beautiful Journey

    Rian Johnson’s newest whodunnit, a stab at some awards recognition from Sydney Sweeney with an unconventional role for her to bring to life, and a fantastical story of colliding paths and memories starring two gorgeous stars in Margot Robbie and Colin Farrell. These are the last 3 movies for the year, so stick around to see if they’re Guilty…or Great!

    1h 26m

  5. 12/25/2025

    (1.29) The Greatest Christmas Movies of All Time

    Cookies and milk by the fireplace, uncanny & baffling CGI in TWO Robert Zemeckis movies, and "Looney Tunes" levels of violence that would *for sure* kill anyone in reality but they just brush it off and limp to the next trap set by an 8-year-old. What, pray tell, do these all have in common? CHRISTMAS. And that’s exactly what we’re ranking…all of our favorite Christmas movies.

    1h 23m

  6. 12/18/2025

    (1.28) Boys Go to Jupiter; Jay Kelly; Sorry, Baby

    **Spoilers for all movies listed in the episode title** *Content warning and discussion surrounding 'Sorry, Baby'* An animated movie begging for late-night showings on Adult Swim with a sort of bleu-cheese sensibility to its humor; a proposed heavy hitter for awards' season from one of the most critically acclaimed directors working today starring one of the last, true movie stars; and an indie, breakout-debut from Sundance making waves all these months later with a powerful and potent story from a new talent pulling triple duty in the production. Join us as we find out if these movies are Guilty...or Great!

    1 hr

  7. 12/09/2025

    (1.27) Seven Brides for Seven Brothers; Fast Five; All the President's Men

    ***Spoiler warning for the films listed in the episode title*** An old-Hollywood musical covered in Technicolor and questionable morals, the 5th film in one of the most BRO franchises the world has ever seen, and a procedural thriller Rosetta stone that capped off a way of government & a way of making movies. Joins ua and tune in to find out if these films are found Guilty...or Great!

    1h 35m

  8. 11/26/2025

    (1.26) Ad Astra; Annie Hall; Frankenstein (‘25)

    ***Spoiler warning for the films inthe episode title*** *Content Warning 49:15 – 50:25: a brief explanation on Woody Allen’s controversies* An overlooked space odyssey, an AFI Top 100 and Best Picture winner, and new spin to a story we all know even if we haven’t read the source material or seen the films. Join us to see if these are Guilty…or Great!

    1h 30m
See All (33)

Ratings & Reviews

5
out of 5
6 Ratings

About

Where a courtroom gimmick meets the parking lot after a late night movie at the theater... Join our current roster of judges [Abe, Austin, JC, Jordan, Michael, and Tyler] as they discuss what they're watching, current movie news at the time of recording, and make sure stick around for the main show of 'Movies on Trial' where 3 judges will present their defendants with a discussion to be had for each movie, followed by the next 3 judges presenting their defendants.

Information