If We Had The Pencil

Sean Green & Matt Jackson
  • 5.0 (2)
  • WRESTLING
  • UPDATED WEEKLY

Two military vets look at WWE and try to predict the storylines using any information they can get on.

  1. 2D AGO

    20260310 Commentary STFU

    Congratulations to Reece our 100th Subscriber!!!!!! Thank You!!!! This episode covers WWE's recent storylines, social mediastrategies, and key matches leading up to WrestleMania, including insights on star power, character development, and booking decisions. In this episode, hosts analyze recent wrestling events, focusing on Penta's emotional IC titlewin, the evolving character of Danhausen, and strategic insights into upcoming WrestleMania matches. They also critique CM Punk's promos and discuss the complex dynamics of Roman Reigns' character and the Bloodline storyline.

    1h 35m

  2. MAR 4

    20260303 WWE Elimination Chamber Recap

    In this episode, Sean and Matt discuss the latest happenings in WWE, focusing on SmackDown and the Elimination Chamber. They analyze character developments, highlight standout performances, and critique match pacing. The conversation also touches on the state of the women's division and the tag team scene, as well as expectations for upcoming events, particularly the WrestleMania build-up. In this episode, Sean and Matt review the 2026 Men's Elimination Chamber match, discussing the performances of various wrestlers, including Cody Rhodes and Seth Rollins. They analyze the highlights from Raw, including the emotional victory of Penta and the dynamics of the ongoing storylines. The conversation also touches on the match between Gunther and Dragon Lee, the promo battle between CM Punk and Roman Reigns, and the excitement surrounding WrestleMania season.

    1h 14m
  3. 20260224 WWE goes meh Elimination Chamber Preview

    FEB 25

    20260224 WWE goes meh Elimination Chamber Preview

    In this episode, Sean and Matt discuss the latest happenings in WWE, including the weather, their personal lives, and the wrestling week overview. They delve into the issues surrounding babyface characters like Cody Rhodes and Drew McIntyre, the identity crisis of the MFTs, and the character development of the Wyatt Six. The conversation also touches on Nia Jax's promo, the open challenge for WrestleMania, injury angles, and the underwhelming promo from CM Punk. The hosts express their frustrations and hopes for the future of wrestling, particularly regarding character development and storytelling. In this episode, the hosts discuss the upcoming Elimination Chamber event, sharing their predictions for various matches, including the women's and men's chamber matches. They express frustrations with recent WWE programming, particularly the go-home show leading into the pay-per-view. The emotional moments surrounding AJ Styles' Hall of Fame induction and the Undertaker's surprise appearance are highlighted. The conversation also touches on commercial breaks, injuries, and the need for WWE to shake things up to keep fans engaged.

    1h 57m
  4. 20260217 WWE Whats in the box

    FEB 18

    20260217 WWE Whats in the box

    In this episode, Sean and Matt discuss a variety of topics ranging from their weekend experiences to the latest happenings in WWE. They delve into the excitement surrounding Daytona weekend, the evolution of young talent in wrestling, and the dynamics of various wrestlers, including Nia Jax and Lash Legend. The conversation also touches on the anticipation for upcoming matches, concerns about the US title's involvement in tournaments, and the need for character development among wrestlers. The hosts share their thoughts on LA Knight's impressive promo work and the entertaining Valentine's Day segment featuring Judgment Day. Finally, they express their mixed feelings about Cody Rhodes' current storyline and the overall direction of WWE. In this episode, the hosts delve into various wrestling topics, including speculations about WrestleMania, theories on Chris Jericho's potential return, and predictions for the Elimination Chamber matches. They analyze CM Punk's recent promos, discuss Finn Balor's title reign, and the impact of AJ Lee on the women's division. The conversation also covers match dynamics in a triple threat scenario and reviews the performance of J-Von Evans against Gunther, culminating in insights about the road to WrestleMania and the surprises that may lie ahead.

    1h 47m
  5. 20260210 The Calm Before the Storm

    FEB 11

    20260210 The Calm Before the Storm

    In this episode, Sean and Matt reflect on the recent Super Bowl and the Olympics, transitioning into a discussion about wrestling. They analyze the dynamics between Cody Rhodes and Drew McIntyre, emphasizing Drew's leadership role and the importance of storytelling in wrestling. The conversation also highlights emerging talents like Trick Williams and the evolution of women's wrestling, particularly with characters like Chelsea Green. As they discuss the build-up to WrestleMania and the significance of the Elimination Chamber matches, they note the contrasting promo styles of Drew and Cody. The episode concludes with reflections on the energy of Raw and the overall quality of SmackDown. In this episode, Sean and Matt discuss the pacing of a recent wrestling show, highlighting the crowd's engagement and the emotional moments, particularly Becky Lynch's meltdown. They analyze the dynamics of tag teams, the drama surrounding Liv Morgan and Dominic Mysterio, and the future of Judgment Day. The conversation also touches on Rhea Ripley's performance, Finn Balor's interview with CM Punk, and the rising costs of attending WrestleMania, emphasizing the need for WWE to focus on storytelling to maintain fan interest.

    1h 52m
  6. 20260203 WWE Royal Rumble Festivus Edition

    FEB 4

    20260203 WWE Royal Rumble Festivus Edition

    In this episode, Sean and Matt discuss the recent WWE SmackDown and Royal Rumble events, highlighting the weather's impact on their mood, the storytelling in wrestling, and the performances of various wrestlers. They analyze the matches, focusing on the women's Royal Rumble and the men's Royal Rumble, discussing the outcomes and potential storylines moving forward. The conversation emphasizes the importance of character development and audience reactions in wrestling. In this episode, Matt and Sean delve into the recent WWE Royal Rumble and the subsequent Monday Night Raw, discussing their thoughts on the outcomes, character developments, and the implications for WrestleMania. They reflect on the booking decisions made by WWE, the return of the Bella Twins, and the exciting promo battle between CM Punk and Roman Reigns. The conversation highlights the importance of character consistency and the need for engaging storylines as they look ahead to future events.

    1h 26m
  7. 20260127 WWE IWHTP Declares for the Royal Rumble

    JAN 28

    20260127 WWE IWHTP Declares for the Royal Rumble

    In this episode, Sean and Matt dive into the latest happenings in WWE, covering SmackDown highlights, character developments, and the impact of factions. They discuss Drew McIntyre's heel turn, the dynamics of the women's tag team division, and the implications of AJ Styles' potential retirement. The conversation also touches on Gunther's controversial persona as a career killer and the overall storytelling approach in WWE, culminating in a debate about the effectiveness of character development in wrestling. In this episode, the hosts delve into the intricacies of wrestling character development, the significance of losses, and the dynamics within factions like Judgment Day. They discuss the upcoming Royal Rumble, predictions for matches, and the potential returns of iconic wrestlers. The conversation highlights the importance of storytelling in wrestling and how it impacts audience engagement.

    1h 48m

  8. JAN 21

    20260120 WWE When keeping it real goes bad

    In this episode of the We Had the Pencil podcast, hosts Sean and Matt dive into a lively discussion about recent events in the NFL and wrestling, particularly focusing on the upcoming Royal Rumble. Sean shares his experience of coping with his team's loss in the NFL playoffs, leading to a humorous recount of a 'NASCAR cleanse' he and his daughter undertook. The conversation shifts to wrestling, where they analyze the current WWE landscape, including the potential outcomes of the Royal Rumble and the implications of various storylines, particularly surrounding Sammy Zane and Drew McIntyre. They also touch on the use of AI in content creation and the challenges of maintaining authenticity in the age of technology. In this episode, Sean and Matt dive deep into the latest happenings in the wrestling world, focusing on the recent tournament and character developments. They express their frustrations with the lack of compelling storytelling in the tournament, particularly criticizing the predictable outcomes and missed opportunities for character arcs. The conversation shifts to Gunther's recent matches, where they discuss his portrayal and the potential for future storylines involving other wrestlers like AJ Styles and Jade. They also analyze the dynamics of the women's division, particularly the roles of Becky Lynch, Maxine Dupree, and Natalya, speculating on potential character turns and match outcomes. The episode wraps up with predictions for upcoming matches, emphasizing the importance of character development and storytelling in wrestling.

    1h 31m
See All (51)

Ratings & Reviews

5
out of 5
2 Ratings

About

Two military vets look at WWE and try to predict the storylines using any information they can get on.

Information

  • Creator
    Sean Green & Matt Jackson
  • Years Active
    2025 - 2026
  • Episodes
    51
  • Rating
    Explicit
  • Copyright
    © Sean Green & Matt Jackson
  • Show Website
    If We Had The Pencil