Jury of Your Peers

JYP Productions

Jury of Your Peers is the podcast where the internet’s most chaotic dilemmas meet the court of public opinion. Each week, hosts Erick, Paddy, and Darrien dive into the wildest stories from the AITA subreddit, serving as your unofficial jury. No drama is too petty, no post too outrageous. Who was right, who was wrong, and who just needs to log off. Come for the hot takes, stay for the heated debates.

  1. 2d ago

    Jury of Your Peers Ep. 48 - Alaskan Shoreline

    Could one trivia answer destroy your entire friend group? This week on Jury of Your Peers, Darrien, Bello, and Paddy tackle two outrageous Reddit stories that spark some of the funniest debates yet. First, the boys put a heated pub trivia controversy on trial after one teammate knowingly keeps the winning answer to herself—costing the group first place. Was it justified revenge against an arrogant team captain, or did she throw everyone under the bus just to make a point? Then, things shift to the workplace as the guys unpack a bizarre office dress-code dilemma. When a young woman is told she doesn't look "polished enough" despite dressing professionally, the conversation turns into a hilarious—and surprisingly real—discussion about office politics, tattoos, hairstyles, and outdated workplace expectations. Along the way, the boys share stories from Milwaukee's World Series chaos, Halloween costume planning, trivia-night disasters, and why some workplace rules deserve to stay in the past. One lost trivia question. One awkward office showdown. And plenty of unfiltered opinions. Listen to Jury of Your Peers on Spotify and Apple Podcasts, and watch the full episode on YouTube! Like, subscribe, hit the notification bell, and follow us on TikTok and Instagram for more comedy clips, Reddit stories, and behind-the-scenes moments. Got a wild story that deserves a verdict? Send it in and let the Jury decide. #JuryOfYourPeers #AlaskanShoreline #RedditStories #ComedyPodcast #AmITheAsshole #AITAH #PubTrivia #OfficeDrama #WorkplaceHumor #FunnyPodcast #YouTubePodcast #Milwaukee

  2. Oct 26

    Jury of Your Peers Ep. 47 - Hummus Party

    What would you do if you thought your teenage son was having fun in his bedroom, only to discover he was actually eating hummus? This week on Jury of Your Peers, Darrien, Bello, and Paddy dive into one of Reddit’s most legendary stories: a mom who mistakes the sounds coming from her son’s room for something VERY different, leading to an unexpected hummus discovery, an even wilder update, and a whole lot of questions. But the party doesn’t stop at hummus! The boys debate awkward conversations, questionable reputations in the friend group, outrageous group chat behavior, and why people feel the need to bring up your personal business in public. Plus, the guys revisit some of the internet’s most unforgettable stories and discuss athletes whose off-field controversies make headlines for all the wrong reasons. Who’s the a*****e in the original story? Is the hummus excuse actually believable? And how does a simple snack turn into one of Reddit’s most infamous tales? Tune in for ridiculous Reddit stories, unfiltered opinions, and the kind of comedy conversation that only Jury of Your Peers can deliver. Listen to Jury of Your Peers on Spotify and Apple Podcasts, and watch the full episode on YouTube! Like, subscribe, leave a review, and follow us on TikTok and Instagram for more clips and behind-the-scenes content. Have a wild story of your own? Send it our way! #JuryOfYourPeers #HummusParty #RedditStories #ComedyPodcast #FunnyRedditStories #AmITheAsshole #AITAH #RedditPodcast #FunnyPodcast #PodcastComedy

  3. Oct 19

    JYP Deliberation Room Ep. 21 - We React to Our Cooking Video

    Darrien, Bello, and Paddy react to their first-ever Blind, Deaf, and Mute Cooking Challenge, breaking down the hilarious mishaps, questionable communication, and kitchen disasters that unfolded when they attempted to cook a cake hear the guys discuss their first experience creating real-life YouTube content, what they learned from the process, and what's next for JYP as they gear up for more IRL challenges and comedy content. Haven't watched the original cooking challenge? Head over to YouTube and watch the chaos unfold for yourself! Like, subscribe, and join Darrien, Bello, and Paddy for more comedy, ridiculous challenges, behind-the-scenes stories, and unfiltered conversations. Listen to Jury of Your Peers on your favorite podcast platform!

  4. Oct 12

    Jury of your Peers Ep. 46 - Unironically Listening

    The boys are back! Darrien, Bello, and Paddy are bringing another round of unfiltered opinions, questionable takes, and hilarious Reddit drama to Jury of Your Peers. This week, the guys tackle two wild “Am I the A*****e?” stories that put friendships, relationships, and wedding etiquette on trial. First, is someone wrong for refusing to spend an entire weekend with their husband's retired friends, drinking and talking about sports? The guys debate relationship compromises, friendship loyalty, and whether sometimes you just need to suck it up for your significant other. Then, a listener-submitted story takes a much more serious turn. After losing her father, one woman finds herself overwhelmed with grief at her best friend's wedding. Was she wrong for leaving early, or was the bride completely out of line for expecting her to stay? The guys deliver their verdict on a story involving friendship, grief, wedding drama, and some serious red flags. Plus, the boys discuss the struggles of adult life, share some questionable personal stories and wrap things up with some heated college football rivalry talk. - Listen to Jury of Your Peers on Spotify and Apple Podcasts, and watch the full episode on YouTube! - Like, subscribe, hit the notification bell, and follow us on TikTok and Instagram for more comedy, Reddit stories, and brutally honest takes. - Have an “Am I the A*****e?” story of your own? Send it our way and let the Jury decide!

  5. Oct 5

    Jury of Your Peers Ep. 45 - Three Dudes

    The Jury has officially been called into session—and this time, the boys have a first-ever listener-submitted story to judge! Darrien, Bello, and Paddy kick things off with a heated debate over theater etiquette, singing during live performances, and whether a parent should tell their excited 10-year-old to stop singing along during Hamilton. Is the theater a place to freely enjoy the show, or does everyone else’s experience come first? The Jury delivers a unanimous verdict. Then things get MUCH messier with a wedding dilemma. A listener is planning a small destination wedding and wants to exclude one particularly difficult member of his fiancée’s friend group. She’s allegedly dramatic, rude, attention-seeking, and a professional chaos generator—but leaving her off the guest list could create serious problems within the friend group. Is he protecting his wedding day, or overstepping when it comes to his fiancée’s friendships? With Darrien, Bello, and Paddy landing on different sides of the wedding debate, this one gets surprisingly close. Boundaries, friendships, wedding guest lists, relationship compromises, and the age-old question of whether you should invite someone you absolutely cannot stand all go under the Jury’s microscope.

  6. Sep 28

    JYP Deliberation Room Ep. 20 - Cup Catastrophe

    The boys are back in the Deliberation Room, and this week’s conversation goes absolutely everywhere. Darrien, Bello, and Paddy dive into the state of U.S. golf, the Presidents Cup, Ryder Cup rivalries, and why American golfers seem to struggle when the pressure turns international. Plus, the guys debate what could bring some serious energy back to the U.S. Ryder Cup team. From there, things take a hard turn into college football, LSU and SEC drama, Lane Kiffin, and the never-ending battle over which conference reigns supreme. Then it’s time for one of the most important debates of the spooky season: Are haunted houses actually fun? Bello shares a childhood haunted-house story that went horribly wrong, the guys discuss Halloween traditions, terrifying attractions, roller coasters, scary movies, and why some people apparently enjoy paying money to be scared half to death. And somehow, we also end up talking about Taylor Swift superfans, Disney adults, Universal Studios, Hagrid’s motorcycle, college football fandom, and some dangerously close encounters with toddlers.

  7. Sep 21

    Jury of your Peers Ep. 44 - Toddler Food

    The Jury is back, and this week’s cases are somehow even more ridiculous than the title suggests. Darrien, Bello, and Paddy dive into a wild collection of Am I the A*****e? (AITA) Reddit stories, friendship drama, questionable decisions, and one heated debate that may permanently divide the Jury: bone-in vs. boneless wings. What happens when you offer to pay for the appetizers and one of your friends orders an extra $35 worth of food without asking? Is calling someone out justified, or did the situation go way too far? The guys break down the entire argument, including the infamous “toddler food” debate, who actually crossed the line, and whether boneless wings deserve the disrespect they receive. The episode also tackles complicated family dynamics, difficult relationships, and the kinds of everyday situations that somehow turn into full-blown Reddit AITA arguments.

  8. Sep 14

    Jury of Your Peers Ep. 43 - Gonner Anthem

    Darrien, Bello, and Paddy are back with another round of Reddit’s wildest “Am I the A*****e?” stories, and this episode gets heated fast. First up: Hubby loses it on a walk after a teenager allegedly blows through a stop sign. Is the husband justified for confronting a bad driver, or did he take things WAY too far? The jury dives into road rage, reckless driving, protecting your partner, and why some people take being “right” a little too seriously. Then we get into a dating dilemma: Is it wrong to reject someone because you were their second choice? A woman at a coffee shop turns down a guy after he asks her coworker for her number first. Was it a justified rejection, or did pride and ego get in the way of a potential relationship? As always, Darrien, Bello, and Paddy break down both sides before delivering their verdicts. Expect relationship advice, dating drama, Reddit AITA stories, controversial opinions, comedy, and plenty of arguments along the way.

See All (70)

Ratings & Reviews

5
out of 5
6 Ratings

About

Jury of Your Peers is the podcast where the internet’s most chaotic dilemmas meet the court of public opinion. Each week, hosts Erick, Paddy, and Darrien dive into the wildest stories from the AITA subreddit, serving as your unofficial jury. No drama is too petty, no post too outrageous. Who was right, who was wrong, and who just needs to log off. Come for the hot takes, stay for the heated debates.

Information

  • Creator
    JYP Productions
  • Years Active
    2025 - 2026
  • Episodes
    70
  • Rating
    Explicit
  • Copyright
    © Copyright 2025 All rights reserved.
  • Show Website
    Jury of Your Peers