Mormon to Muse

Kristin Martineau

You didn't lose your faith. You found out something true — and now you're figuring out who you are on the other side. Mormon to Muse is a podcast for women navigating life after the Mormon church — the faith transition grief nobody prepares you for, the identity loss that comes with leaving a high-control religious system, and the slow, honest work of reclaiming yourself. Each week I explore what it means to find yourself again after the Mormon church — through creative practice, life coaching tools, and the kind of honest conversation you can't have at Sunday dinner If you've spent years being everything for everyone else and you're only now starting to wonder who you actually are — you're in exactly the right place. Start with: "You Were Never Just a Calling."

  1. 4d ago

    "I Could Never Do That": Untangling Nature, Story, and Belief Post-Mormonism

    "I'm just not creative." "I could never do that." "I'm not the kind of person who finishes things." You've said one of these — or something close to it — so many times it stopped sounding like an opinion. It started sounding like a fact. It isn't one. In this episode, Kristin breaks down the difference between a circumstance (provable, measurable, true regardless of who's looking) and a limiting belief (a thought you've repeated until it felt like biology). She explains why your brain keeps finding evidence to confirm what you already believe about yourself, why this pattern runs especially deep for anyone raised in a high-control religious structure, and exactly how to start testing the beliefs that are quietly running your life. In this episode: What separates a fact from a belief — and why your brain can't tell the difference on its own Why growing up in a high-demand religious system trains you to accept assigned identities instead of testing them Four questions to figure out whether a belief is truly yours, or something you inherited A real coaching example: how one client dismantled "I never finish anything" by finding the evidence she'd been ignoring The one-word shift ("yet") that gets you out of black-and-white thinking Why separating the belief from your identity — "I've been telling myself I'm not creative" vs. "I'm not creative" — changes what's possible One small experiment to try this week that gives your brain new evidence to work with

  2. Jul 12

    The B- Version Is the One That Counts: Overcoming Perfectionism After High-Control Systems

    Are You a Perfectionist? Here's Why That's Not the Compliment You Think It Is Perfectionism gets worn like a badge of honor. I used to wear mine that way too. But underneath the polished exterior, perfectionism isn't a high standard — it's an impossible one. In this episode, I break down what perfectionism actually is, why your brain defaults to it, and the practical antidote I use to get my own imperfect work out into the world. I talk about the myth of "perfect" itself — how even our own definitions of it are nebulous, how one person's perfect manuscript is another person's rough draft. I get into how Mormon culture trains this particular flavor of perfectionism from childhood, where testimony meetings only make room for certainty and struggle is only allowed in past tense. And I talk about how the wider culture backs this up — rewarding the finished book, not the drafts; the overnight success, not the seven invisible years before it. I share what perfectionism actually looked like in my daily life — the schedule I built for myself with a checklist so long that missing one item gave me permission to abandon the whole day. I walk through the small, sneaky ways perfectionism shows up for most of us: buying the supplies and never starting, quitting a new skill the second it gets hard, treating rest as something to be earned instead of allowed. Then I get into what actually works. I talk about Brooke Castillo's concept of B- work — the idea that done imperfectly beats undone every time — and why creative practice is the best low-stakes place to build the muscle of showing up messy. I share why I've had to get comfortable being cringe, why the loudest critics are rarely the people who've actually walked the path themselves, and a practical exercise for taking the sting out of other people's judgment. If this episode resonates, I made something for you. My Reclamation Sketchbook is a free 7-day guided art journal — one creative prompt a day, no experience or talent required. It's the easiest place I know to practice doing something imperfectly on purpose.   Articles Referenced in this episode: https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/the-discomfort-zone/202408/overcoming-perfectionism https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC4562912/

  3. Jul 5

    7 Things I Wish I Knew During Deconstruction

    Faith deconstruction isn't a clean process. You're rebuilding a self while still going to work, parenting, managing a marriage and a household. There's no roadmap for it — you're improvising for the first time in a life that used to hand you all the answers. In this episode, I'm walking through the things I got wrong along the way. Not to give you one more thing to get right, but so you can spot the patterns faster than I did. What I cover: Not being able to sit with uncertainty. After decades inside a system that had all the answers, uncertainty feels intolerable. I talk about the pull to replace one authority with another — wellness culture, politics, self-help, even coaching — and why developing a tolerance for not knowing is what actually makes you free. Making decisions from reaction. Anger is what gets you out the door. It's not where you want to make your future decisions from. I unpack the difference between total rejection of the old system and actually deciding for yourself what you think — because doing the opposite of what you were told is still letting the old system set the terms. All-or-nothing thinking. Mormonism trains this hard — good or bad, worthy or unworthy, no in between. I talk about how that binary doesn't disappear when you leave, it just switches teams. The nuance is harder to hold, but a self built on binary categories is just as brittle as the one you left. Not telling my family sooner. I sat on this for years, partly to protect them and partly to protect myself. I get honest about what that silence actually communicated, and why there's no universal right timeline here — just your own judgment about your specific people. Assuming my kids' experience matched mine. I projected my own reckoning onto my three kids, who each had a completely different relationship to the church depending on their age when we left. I talk about what I missed and why staying curious about their experience mattered more than narrating mine to them. Staying in my head. The information binge — podcasts, documentaries, historical records — is a necessary stage, but it can also become a way to avoid the grief underneath it. I talk about what finally got me out of my head and into my body, including how painting became part of my process. Expecting a linear timeline. Healing isn't a straight line, it's a spiral. I still get hit with grief or anger I don't expect. I talk about why that's normal and not a sign you're doing it wrong. Closing thought: Nothing is wrong with you. Things haven't gone wrong. Setting out on this journey at all is the brave part — the mess is just what it looks like from the inside. Download the Reclamation Sketchbook HERE

  4. Jun 28

    Making Peace with the Human Void: Why That Empty Feeling Isn't a Problem to Fix

    There's a particular kind of longing that shows up even when my life is good. Nothing is wrong. Nothing is happening. And still — something feels missing. A low hum of restlessness, the sense that I forgot something, that there's supposed to be more. This is the human void, and every healthy person carries it. Even small children. In this episode, I walk through how different traditions have tried to explain that empty place inside us — and what happens when we stop trying to fill it. Buddhism names it dukkha, the dissatisfaction that shadows even good experiences because we know they won't last, and asks us to observe it without resistance. Camus called it the Absurd: the collision between our hunger for meaning and a universe that stays silent. His answer wasn't despair or invented comfort, but absurd freedom — living defiantly, fully, and authentically anyway. Mormonism offered its own framing: the void as homesickness for heavenly parents, a memory of wholeness we can't quite recall. Comforting, in a way — it gives the feeling a direction and a meaning. But that's not how I experienced it. For me, the void registered as something is wrong with me. I'm not repenting enough. I don't have the spirit. I'm probably the only one who feels this way. The emptiness became evidence of personal failure, and the failure became shame. The coaching lens reframes all of it. The void is the lower brain doing its survival job — scanning for threat, reading emotional discomfort as danger, driving us toward the candy aisle, the phone, the drink, the busyness, anything to make the bad feeling stop. But here's the misfire: in modern life, feeling bad is almost never a survival emergency. The feeling itself was never dangerous. What hurts us and the people around us is what we do to escape it. So how do we solve the void? We don't. I make the case that the relief isn't in fixing the emptiness but in understanding it's universal, normal, maybe even purposeful — the engine that pushes us to grow, make, and reach. I close with the practices that help me: naming the void, stopping the search for the thing that will finally fix me, releasing the people I love from the impossible job of filling it, getting comfortable with ambiguity, and paying attention to the ordinary moments when — singing along to a light show in a language that isn't mine, watching my kids light up at a boatful of monkeys, lying in a quiet house with everyone home and safe — everything, right now, is okay. I was taught the missing feeling meant something had gone wrong. It never did. It just meant I was alive. In this episode: What the human void is and why every healthy person has one How Buddhism (dukkha), Camus (the Absurd), and Mormon doctrine each explain the empty place inside us Why the void often registered as shame inside a high-control religious framework The lower brain's survival wiring and why it misreads emotional discomfort as danger Why the feeling itself is never the threat — the escape behaviors are Practical ways to live in response to the void instead of burying it The role of presence and ordinary moments of "everything is okay right now" A note: this episode discusses the universal experience of emptiness and restlessness, which is distinct from clinical depression or other conditions that deserve professional support. If the emptiness you feel is persistent, heavy, or interfering with your life, please reach out to a qualified professional.

  5. Jun 21

    The Number One Mistake I See Women Who Leave The Church and How to Fix It

    You know you don't have to do what everyone else wants anymore. So why is it still so hard to figure out what you want? If you left the Mormon church and you're still second-guessing every decision, still scanning for the "right" answer, still feeling like a stranger in your own life — this episode is for you. Here's the thing I see more than anything else in women who leave: you're trying to find yourself using the same map that buried you in the first place. You want to get somewhere new, but you're still navigating with the old tools. In this episode I'm handing you a new map. Not one that tells you where to go — one that helps you get wherever you decide to go. I get into: Why your intuition isn't gone — it's buried — and what that actually means What intuition really is (it's a skill, not a mystical gift, and not the Holy Ghost) How conditioning taught you to outsource your own authority, suppress your feelings, and measure yourself by performance The number one mistake I see: trying to access your intuition through the old frameworks you were handed Why feelings make a terrible tool for measuring objective truth — and what they're actually for How the church taught you that good feeling = true and bad feeling = wrong, and why that broke your relationship with your own knowing Why a bad feeling is information, never a verdict on your character The MUSE map I built from the roadblocks I see most in women rebuilding after the church This isn't about trading one rulebook for another. It's about learning to hear yourself — maybe for the first time — and trusting yourself enough to decide what comes next. Don't miss Intuition Hour: How to Get to Know Yourself. I'm teaching this class live this Thursday June 25th 11:00 am MST. Save your spot HERE. You'll learn exactly how to get in touch with your own intuition so you can live a confident, fun, big life that's authentic to you.

5
out of 5
10 Ratings

About

You didn't lose your faith. You found out something true — and now you're figuring out who you are on the other side. Mormon to Muse is a podcast for women navigating life after the Mormon church — the faith transition grief nobody prepares you for, the identity loss that comes with leaving a high-control religious system, and the slow, honest work of reclaiming yourself. Each week I explore what it means to find yourself again after the Mormon church — through creative practice, life coaching tools, and the kind of honest conversation you can't have at Sunday dinner If you've spent years being everything for everyone else and you're only now starting to wonder who you actually are — you're in exactly the right place. Start with: "You Were Never Just a Calling."

You Might Also Like